臺灣高等法院臺中分院刑事-TCHM,102,重上更(一),7,20140529,1

臺灣高等法院臺中分院刑事判決 102年度重上更(一)字第7號
上 訴 人 臺灣臺中地方法院檢察署檢察官
上 訴 人
即 被 告 許哲彥
選任辯護人 蘇靜怡律師
林照明律師
羅豐胤律師
上 訴 人
即 被 告 葉奕匡
選任辯護人 林松虎律師
吳淑芬律師
上列上訴人等因被告等違反貪污治罪條例等案件，不服臺灣臺中地方法院97年度訴字第3018、3951號中華民國98年12月17日第一審判決（起訴案號：臺灣臺中地方法院檢察署97年度偵字第10922號；
追加起訴案號：97年度偵字第19766號），提起上訴，本院判決後，經最高法院第一次發回更審，本院判決如下：

主 文

原判決關於戊○○、壬○○部分均撤銷。

戊○○共同依法令服務於國家所屬機關而具有法定職務權限之公務員，對於職務上之行為，收受不正利益，處有期徒刑柒年拾月，褫奪公權陸年；

又共同依法令服務於國家所屬機關而具有法定職務權限之公務員，對於職務上之行為，收受不正利益，處有期徒刑柒年拾月，褫奪公權陸年。

應執行有期徒刑玖年陸月，褫奪公權陸年。

壬○○共同依法令服務於國家所屬機關而具有法定職務權限之公務員，對於職務上之行為，收受不正利益，處有期徒刑叁年陸月，褫奪公權肆年：又共同依法令服務於國家所屬機關而具有法定職務權限之公務員，對於職務上之行為，收受不正利益，處有期徒刑叁年陸月，褫奪公權肆年。

應執行有期徒刑肆年陸月，褫奪公權肆年。

犯罪事實

一、戊○○原為經濟部水利署第三河川局簡任第十一職等局長，任職期間自民國95年5 月2 日至98年1 月5 日，在職期間工作項目為負責綜理局務（60% ）、關於水利工程建設暨水資源基本資料之建立轄內主要河川管理策劃、研議改進、報告及建議（30% ）、其他臨時交辦事項(10%) 。

壬○○原係經濟部水利署工程事務組簡任第十職等副組長，自96年3 月22日派任該職迄今，在職期間工作項目為襄理組長綜理組務（50% ）、審核工程招標、驗收、變更設計、展延工期等案件（30% ）、其他臨時交辦事務（20% ）。

均係依法令服務於國家所屬機關而具有法定職務權限之公務員。

其等身為國家中央機關簡任第十一職等、第十職等之首長層級機關公務員或主管，自均應廉潔自持，謹言慎行，恪遵職責。

二、川順營造股份有限公司（下稱川順公司）於96年5 月間起承攬經濟部水利署（下稱水利署）及經濟部水利署第三河川局（下稱第三河川局）所發包、監督及管理之下列二項工程：㈠96年間水利署主辦興建「大甲溪砂石運輸便道工程第三標（25K ＋400 ～32K ＋745 ）」（下稱便道工程）。

便道工程委託「台灣世曦工程顧問股份有限公司」（前稱中華工程顧問工程司，下稱世曦公司）負責設計、監造業務，由水利署授權由第三河川局辦理發包，發包後由第三河川局負責施工期間之工務行政管理業務。

便道工程於96年6 月5 日開標，預算金額新臺幣（下同）1 億7333萬6951元，由川順公司以1 億2350萬元得標，因低於底價1 億5500萬元之百分之80，依規定須繳交差額保證金50萬元後決標。

便道工程主要在大甲溪河床興建便道以供砂石車行駛，而便道與大甲溪河床相接之堤岸部分，原先設計以「甲種機編蛇籠」（另一種施工法為箱型石籠）保護該便道以免遭水流沖毀。

又第三河川局依預算金額將工程分為三類，第一類為水利署指定工程或預算金額5 千萬元以上之工程，第二類為預算金額3 千萬元以上5 千萬元以下之工程，第三類為預算金額3 千萬元以下之工程，故上開便道工程為第一類工程。

嗣因該便道工程所在大甲溪流域環境變更及工期如期完工之考量，水利署乃授權由第三河川局就該工程之變更設計、工期展延等事項同意局部調整（惟變更設計預算書審核及工程驗收並未在授權範圍），比照第二類工程辦理，施工法並改為箱型石籠。

川順公司得標後於96年6 月機具進場至該工程施作地點，該便道工程自開工迄竣工完成複驗間之各項工程等事務進行事項之時程，詳如附表一所示。

㈡頭汴坑一江橋上游崩塌段至內城橋河段防災減災工程（下稱減災工程）係水利署主辦、發包，而由第三河川局設計及監造，工程發包後由第三河川局負責施工期間工務行政管理業務。

減災工程於96年5 月31日開標，亦是由川順公司以1 億4960萬元得標，為前述第一類工程。

該減災工程於96年6 月20日自開工迄本案偵查起訴間之各項工程等事務進行事項之時程，詳如附表二所示。

三、川順公司於96年、97年間所承攬進行之工程，僅有上開便道工程與減災工程。

戴沼澤是川順公司之實際負責人，負責川順公司承攬、施作便道工程與減災工程之經營事務，而廉裕隆為川順公司之經理及該公司承攬便道工程之工地負責人、戴泱丞為川順公司副總經理及該公司承攬減災工程之工地負責人。

戴沼澤、廉裕隆及戴泱丞三人，為使川順公司承攬施作便道工程、減災工程二項工程，其中之便道工程能夠順利變更施工方法、通過該工程施工期間颱風災損費用之查驗與請款，暨與減災工程工程施工方法之調整順利完成程序，以及該2 項工程於施工期間由水利署或第三河川局各項工程包括申請估驗款與迄竣工後之各種驗收請款快速估算核撥階段性工程款，不受各該監督職務行使職權之水利署及第三河川局公務員職務上之刁難，均明知戊○○及壬○○2 人對川順公司所承攬之前上述2 項工程在其等之職務上均在上開職權行使範疇，遂基於不違反戊○○及壬○○職務之範圍加以行賄之分別2 次犯意，對戊○○及壬○○提供喝花酒及對戊○○提供性服務等不正利益。

而戊○○及壬○○竟於川順公司承攬上開便道工程及減災工程施工期間，藉職務上對於便道及減災工程有工務行政管理與監督之職權，且第三河川局就便道工程之變更設計、工期展延等事項亦獲水利署授權局部調整之權限。

而因其職務上行為是否行使妥適及時程上是否予以川順公司合法範圍內之便利，對川順公司影響鉅大，竟基於共同對於職務上之行為，收受不正利益之犯意聯絡，多次向川順公司之負責人戴沼澤、或川順公司經理及該公司承攬便道工程工地負責人廉裕隆、或川順公司副總經理及該公司承攬減災工程工地負責人戴泱丞，以如附表三備註欄所載之方式，即或由戊○○指示「九龍理容KTV 」之工作人員直接向川順公司報請帳款；

或直接由戊○○於電話中要求廉裕隆前來「九龍理容KTV 」或「楓之林理容KTV 」到場後，或由廉裕隆直接支付帳款，或先簽帳再由前揭理容KTV 向川順公司請帳；

或由戊○○直接應戴沼澤或廉裕隆之邀約，前往「九龍理容KTV 」、「楓之林理容KTV 」接受招待後，逕行離開由戴沼澤簽付帳款等方式；

另壬○○則或係以於「麗登理容KTV 」、「香格里拉理容KTV 」消費後，逕於電話中要求廉裕隆支付帳款；

或係直接接受川順公司之邀前往「九龍理容KTV 」消費後逕行離開之方式，要求川順公司給付其等前往有女陪侍之酒店飲宴，並由酒店小姐陪侍唱歌喝酒（俗稱「喝花酒」）之不正利益；

戊○○並於97年1 月7 日前往酒店喝花酒後，更進而接受性招待而與該酒店之陪侍小姐陳瑤寰前往臺中市某汽車旅館進行性交之不正利益一次。

戊○○前往喝花酒之地點及消費金額計算方式等明細，詳如附表三所載。

壬○○前往喝花酒之地點及消費金額計算方式等明細，則詳如附表四所載。

戊○○及壬○○其以此方法對於職務上行為要求進而收受川順公司所給付之不正利益，其前往酒店喝花酒之時間、金額、費用支付方式等如下：㈠戊○○部分：⒈96年8 月15日下午3 時30分許，開始在「九龍理容KTV 」有女 陪侍之酒店喝花酒，消費金額1 萬6 千元，由戊○○簽立一張「許董」本票，該酒店幹部徐玉玲（花名：秀秀）擔任連保人；

該筆消費由川順公司96年9 月25日「轉帳傳票」項下支付。

（詳如附表三，編號1 ）⒉96年9 月6 日下午3 時15分許，開始在「九龍理容KTV 」有女陪侍之酒店喝花酒，消費金額因由川順公司經理廉裕隆以現金支付，消費金額不詳。

（詳如附表三，編號2 ）⒊96年9 月14日下午3 時15分許，開始在「九龍理容KTV 」有女陪侍之酒店喝花酒，消費金額1 萬2 千1 百元、2 千2 百元共計1 萬4 千3 百元，由川順公司96年10月25日「轉帳傳票」項下支付。

（詳如附表三，編號3 ）⒋96年9 月18日下午7 時許，開始在「九龍理容KTV 」 301包廂有女陪侍之酒店喝花酒，消費金額因由川順公司負責人戴沼澤以現金支付，消費金額不詳。

（詳如附表三，編號4 ）⒌96年10月2 日下午4 時30分許，開始在「九龍理容KTV 」有女陪侍之酒店喝花酒，消費金額1 萬6 千5 百50元，由戊○○簽立本票，徐玉玲擔任連保人；

該筆消費載於川順公司96年11月25日「轉帳傳票」項下支付。

（詳如附表三，編號5 ）⒍96年10月4 日下午4 時30分許，開始在「九龍理容KTV 」有女陪侍之酒店喝花酒，消費金額2 萬2 千6 百元，由川順公司經理廉裕隆簽立本票；

該筆消費由川順公司96年11月25日「轉帳傳票」項下支付。

（詳如附表三，編號6 ）⒎96年10月5 日下午7 時許，開始在「九龍理容KTV 」有女陪侍之酒店喝花酒，消費金額1 萬6 百50元，由戊○○簽立本票，徐玉玲擔任連保人，再由川順公司96年11月25日「轉帳傳票」項下支付。

（詳如附表三，編號7 ）⒏96年10月11日下午4 時許，開始在「九龍理容KTV 」有女陪侍之酒店喝花酒，消費金額2 萬8 百元，由一同前往之戊○○女友陳玉瑛代戊○○簽立一張本票，徐玉玲擔任連保人，再由川順公司96年11月25日「轉帳傳票」項下支付。

（詳如附表三，編號8 ）⒐96年10月17日下午3 時許，開始在「九龍理容KTV 」有女陪侍之酒店喝花酒，消費金額4 萬9 千5 百50元，由川順公司經理廉裕隆簽立本票，再由川順公司96年11月25日「轉帳傳票」項下支付。

（詳如附表三，編號9 ）⒑96年10月31日下午4 時許，與林榮紹等人開始在「九龍理容KTV 」有女陪侍之酒店喝花酒，消費金額1 萬6 千5 百50元，由川順公司經理廉裕隆簽立本票，再由川順公司96年11月25日「轉帳傳票」項下支付。

（詳如附表三，編號10）⒒96年11月28日下午6 時許，開始在「九龍理容KTV 」有女陪侍之酒店喝花酒，消費金額1 萬6 千元，由川順公司經理廉裕隆簽立本票，再由川順公司96年11月25日「轉帳傳票」項下支付。

（詳如附表三，編號11）⒓96年12月17日下午4 時30分許，與林榮紹等人開始在「九龍理容KTV 」107 包廂有女陪侍之酒店喝花酒，消費金額1 萬7 千6 百50元，由川順公司總經理戴泱丞簽立本票，再由川順公司96年12月25日「轉帳傳票」項下支付。

（詳如附表三，編號12）⒔97年1 月7 日下午不詳時間，開始在「九龍理容KTV 」有女陪侍之酒店喝花酒，戊○○當晚喝完喝酒後並將九龍理容KTV 店編號第105 號女侍小姐陳瑤寰帶出場，至臺中市某汽車旅館，接受該女侍之性服務。

本次消費金額計8 萬4 百50元，由川順公司負責人戴沼澤簽立本票，再由川順公司於97年2 月25日「轉帳傳票」項下，開立97年4 月25日到期票號JT0000000 支票，面額八萬四百五十元支付。

（詳如附表三，編號13）⒕97年2 月12日下午4 時15許，與壬○○等人開始在「九龍理容KTV 」有女陪侍之酒店喝花酒，戊○○當天晚上8 時17分許，並將「楓之林理容KTV 」編號第66號女侍楊雅惠帶出場至臺中市冶遊，本次消費金額計1 萬7 千1 百50元、6 千元合計2 萬3 千1 百50元，由川順公司經理廉裕隆簽立本票，再由川順公司97年3 月25日「轉帳傳票」項下支付。

（詳如附表三，編號14）⒖97年3 月3 日下午4 時30分許，與林榮紹等人開始在「楓之林理容KTV 」酒店喝花酒，消費金額4 萬1 千8 百50元，由川順公司經理廉裕隆簽立本票，再由川順公司97年4月25日「傳票清單」項下支付。

（詳如附表三，編號15）⒗97年3 月14日下午4 時50分許，與林榮紹等人開始在「楓之林理容KTV 」酒店喝花酒，消費金額1 萬3 千2 百元，由劉禎忠先行代戴沼澤簽帳於楓之林理容KTV 董事謝翠芬應收帳款下，再由川順公司支付。

（詳如附表三，編號16）㈡壬○○部分：⒈96年10月8 日下午3 時許，與林榮紹等人開始在「麗登理容KTV 」有女陪侍酒店喝花酒，消費金額1 萬4 千3 百50元，消費當日以電話要求川順公司經理廉裕隆支付（即要求不正利益），由廉裕隆事後簽認帳款，該筆消費再由川順公司97年3 月25日「轉帳傳票」項下支付。

（詳如附表四，編號1 ）⒉97年1 月16日下午2 時30分許，與林榮紹等人開始在「香格里拉理容KTV （改名前為金拿獎理容KTV ）」有女陪侍酒店喝花酒，消費金額9 千1 百元，由川順公司經理廉裕隆簽立本票，再由川順公司97年4 月25日「轉帳傳票」項下，開立97年4 月25日到期支票，票號JT0000000 支付。

（詳如附表五，編號2 ）⒊97年2 月12日下午4 時15分許，與戊○○等人開始在「九龍理容KTV 」之有女陪侍酒店喝花酒，喝花酒之消費金額共計1 萬7 千1 百50元；

而當日一同前往喝花酒之戊○○於當天晚上8 時17分許，並將「楓之林理容KTV 」編號第66號女侍楊雅惠帶出場，帶出場之費用則為6 千元（有關戊○○將楊雅惠待出場之費用，尚難認係屬壬○○所收受之不正利益）。

本次消費金額計1 萬7 千1 百50元、6 千元共計，合計2 萬3 千1 百50元，由川順公司經理廉裕隆簽立本票，再由川順公司97年3 月25日「轉帳傳票」項下支付。

（詳如附表四，編號3 ）⒋97年3 月25日下午2 時30分許，與林榮紹等人開始在「香格里拉理容KTV 」有女陪侍酒店喝花酒，消費金額7 千1百元，由川順公司經理廉裕隆簽帳，再由川順公司97年4月25日「傳票清單」項下，開立97年6 月25日到期支票，票號JT0000000 支票支付。

（提起公訴檢察官誤將壬○○此部分之行為事實，記載在起訴書第19頁，第18行至24行，本院整理詳如附表四，編號4 ）

四、戊○○及壬○○於川順公司承攬、施做上開便道工程與減災工程期間，分因該2 工程之原因，而收受上開不正利益，且先後不違背其等職務，給予川順公司便利，在其等職務行使範圍內，依戴沼澤之要求，戊○○配合辦理：⑴便道工程之變更設計改採箱型石籠施工法。

⑵便道工程施工期間遇聖帕颱風、柯羅莎颱風而工程發生災損，戊○○協助及配合災損之估驗與請款手續，兩次風災經川順公司提報分別由第三河川局以修正預算方式及籌措財源在水資源作業基金支應。

⑶川順公司就減災工程鋼柵石籠之施作位置與原設計圖不符，配合川順公司辦理會勘而依現況施作；

另壬○○則於相關會勘紀錄簽稿陳核過程中未刻意予以刁難，以便工程順利進行。

使川順公司所承攬之前開便道工程順利辦理變更設計改採箱型石籠施工、便道工程施工期間遇聖帕颱風、柯羅莎颱風而工程發生災損之順利估驗與請款、減災工程施作期間之鋼柵石籠順利依現況施作，而踐履因收受不正利益之職務上對價行為、減災工程中得依據現況施作而免拆除重作鋼柵石籠之合法利益。

進而使得川順公司於便道工程得以改採箱型石籠施工法、合法順利取得便道工程施工期間之聖帕颱風災損工程款1711萬2764元及柯羅莎颱風災損工程款1,412 萬4,661 元、減災工程中得依據現況施作而免拆除重作鋼柵石籠之合法利益。

五、案經臺灣臺中地方法院檢察署檢察官指揮法務調查局臺中市調查站偵辦並執行通訊監察及搜索後，移送臺灣臺中地方法院檢察署檢察官偵查起訴。

理 由

一、審判範圍部分：㈠本案被告戊○○等14人前經臺灣臺中地方法院檢察署檢察官起訴及追加起訴後，經臺灣臺中地方法院以97年度訴字第3018、3951號判決，就被告戊○○、壬○○及林榮紹均判決有對於職務上之行為收受不正利益罪，另同案被告彭壽奇等人均為無罪；

經檢察官對該臺灣臺中地方法院判決全部聲明不服提起上訴，及經被告戊○○、壬○○及林榮紹均提起上訴後，經本院前審以99年度上訴字第974 號、第975 號就被告戊○○、壬○○及林榮紹部分均撤銷，仍對戊○○為有罪部分，另對被告壬○○、林榮紹則改判處無罪；

另其餘經臺灣臺中地方法院判處無罪之同案被告彭壽奇等人，則駁回上訴，均維持原審無罪之判決。

嗣經檢察官就被告戊○○及壬○○部分再提起上訴，且被告戊○○同亦提起上訴，最高法院以102 年度臺上字第958 號刑事判決就被告戊○○及壬○○均撤銷發回本院，是本案之審理範圍，僅限於原審判決中有關被告戊○○及壬○○部分。

㈡至同案被告林榮紹、彭壽奇、徐崧清、甲○○、癸○○、廉裕隆、戴沼澤、戴泱丞、紀駿富、戴沼銘、李國忠、鄭年雅無罪部分，因於本院前審99年度上訴字第974 號、第975 號判決後，檢察官並未提起上訴，故此部分均已確定，附此敘明。

二、證據能力部分：㈠關於通訊監察錄音及譯文內容：⒈按有事實足認被告或犯罪嫌疑人所犯為最輕本刑為3 年以上有期徒刑之罪，並危害國家安全或社會秩序情節重大，而有相當理由可信其通訊內容與本案有關，且不能或難以其他方法蒐集或調查證據者，得發通訊監察書；

前項通訊監察書，偵查中由檢察官依司法警察機關聲請或依職權核發，審判中由法官依職權核發，95年5 月30日修正通訊保障及監察法第5條第1項第1款、第2項定有明文。

⒉本案所作為證據使用之通訊監察錄音及譯文，均係經法務部調查局臺中市調查站（下稱臺中市調查站）之司法警察官提出聲請核發，而由臺灣臺中地方法院檢察署檢察官（通訊保障及監察法第5條第1項第1款、第2項施行前）或臺灣臺中地方法院法官依法核發通訊監察書所載電話實施通訊監察，有臺灣臺中地方法院檢察署96年度中檢輝毅監（續）字第000237號、96年度中檢輝毅監（續）字第 000249 號、96年度中檢輝毅監（續）字第000276號、96年度中檢輝毅監（續）字第000298號、96年度中檢輝毅監（續）字第000335號、96年度中檢輝毅監（續）字第000396號、96年度中檢輝毅監（續）字第000395號、96年度中檢輝毅監（續）字第000441號、96年度中檢輝毅監（續）字第000442號、96年度中檢輝毅監（續）字第000486號、96年度中檢輝毅監（續）字第000485號、96年度中檢輝毅監（續）字第000538號、96年度中檢輝毅監（續）字第000539號、96年度中檢輝毅監（續）字第000576號、96年度中檢輝毅監（續）字第000577號，原審97年度聲監字第000022號、97年度聲監字第000028號、97年度聲監字第000028號、97年度聲監字第000217號、97年度聲監續字第000116號通訊監察書、通訊監察書電話附表影本在卷可稽（原審卷甲卷內）。

而本件核發通訊監察書之案由為偵辦違反貪污治罪條例，屬最輕本刑為3 年以上有期徒刑或貪污治罪條例第11條第1項之罪，足信被告2 人所為確實危害社會秩序情節重大，犯罪手法又有不能或難以其他方法蒐集或調查，而有相當理由可信通訊內容與本案有關，堪認本件偵查人員實施通訊監察之偵查作為合於法定程序。

⒊臺中市調查站所製作之本件通訊監察譯文（附在原審97年度訴字第3018號卷甲卷，譯文本），其中譯文括號內之文字內容雖不免摻雜偵辦人員之個人加註解讀而可疑有失真之虞，應無證據能力。

然其餘譯文之文字，均經原審於98年3 月13日勘驗該實施通訊監察期間之監聽錄音光碟，並於法庭內播放核對確認聲音與譯文內容，並作成勘驗筆錄（見原審97年度訴字第3018號卷七，第37至267 頁），其過程使受通訊監察之人確認聲音與內容，並給予被告及辯護人以充分辯明之機會，均與前述臺中市調查站所製作之本件通訊監察譯文除括號內調查員所註記之文字外，均無不同，自得以原審勘驗筆錄之監察譯文（逐字譯文內容詳如附件所示）及臺中市調查站所製作之本件監聽譯文（見原審法院甲卷）作為證據使用。

此外，本院復查無其他不法之情狀，依上開說明，本件上開通訊監察譯文除監聽人員自行以括號所加註之文字無證據能力外，其餘譯文內容均有證據能力。

至被告戊○○之辯護人雖曾認就以下所引用2007年9 月6 日17時37分16秒及2008年3 月3 日13時59分19秒廉裕隆與戴沼澤間之通訊監察譯文，係廉裕隆與戴沼澤間之對話，因無從證明廉裕隆與戴沼澤對話後，是否曾有人將對話內容傳達給被告戊○○，故就前揭2 通電話之通訊監察譯文，認係屬被告戊○○以外之人於審判外之陳述等語，惟查，前揭通訊監察譯文依照上開說明既係屬依法聲請監聽後，依照電磁紀錄記載後，由公務人員所製作，並經原審勘驗屬實，參照上開說明，即已足認定有證據能力。

辯護人上開所指，尚屬證據證明力之問題，併此敘明。

㈡被告戊○○、壬○○以外之人於審判外之陳述部分：⒈被告戊○○、壬○○以外之第三人（包括證人、鑑定人、告訴人、被害人及共同被告等），在臺中市調查站由調查員之司法警察（官）詢問時所為之陳述，性質上屬於傳聞證據。

而本件既已有其他證據之該第三人在檢察官訊問時之陳述或於原審、本院前審審理時以證人身分之證述可資替代，並非屬證明被告戊○○、壬○○犯罪事實存否所必要，被告戊○○、壬○○及其等選任辯護人又就部分證人之調查站筆錄表示不同意作為證據，依法均無證據能力。

⒉按被告以外之人於偵查中向檢察官所為之陳述，除顯有不可信之情況者外，得為證據，刑事訴訟法第159條之1第2項定有明文。

偵查中對被告以外之人（包括證人、鑑定人、告訴人、被害人及共同被告等）所為之偵查筆錄，或被告以外之人向檢察官所提之書面陳述，性質上均屬傳聞證據。

惟現階段刑事訴訟法規定檢察官代表國家偵查犯罪、實施公訴，依法其有訊問被告、證人及鑑定人之權，證人、鑑定人且須具結，而實務運作時，檢察官偵查中向被告以外之人所取得之陳述，原則上均能遵守法律規定，不致違法取供，其可信度極高，職是，被告以外之人前於偵查中已具結而為證述，除反對該項供述得具有證據能力之一方，已釋明「顯有不可信之情況」之理由外，不宜以該證人未能於審判中接受他造之反對詰問為由，即遽指該證人於偵查中之陳述不具證據能力。

又詰問權係指訴訟上當事人有在審判庭輪流盤問證人，以求發現真實，辨明供述證據真偽之權利，現行刑事訴訟法對於詰問制度之設計，以同法第166條以下規定之交互詰問為實踐，屬於人證調查證據程式之一環；

與證據能力係指符合法律所規定之證據適格，而得成為證明犯罪事實存在與否之證據資格，性質上並非相同。

偵查中檢察官為蒐集被告犯罪證據，訊問證人旨在確認被告嫌疑之有無及內容，與審判期日透過當事人之攻防，調查人證以認定事實之性質及目的，尚屬有別。

偵查中訊問證人，法無明文必須傳喚被告使之得以在場，刑事訴訟法第248條第1項前段雖規定：「如被告在場者，被告得親自詰問」，事實上亦難期被告必有於偵查中行使詰問權之機會。

此項未經被告詰問之被告以外之人於偵查中向檢察官所為之陳述，依刑事訴訟法第159條之1第2項規定，原則上屬於法律規定為有證據能力之傳聞證據，於例外顯有不可信之情況，始否定其得為證據。

經查：證人劉禎忠、乙○○、趙培善、林傳茂、王莉婷、許慶祥、戴美玲、張淑惠、徐玉玲、陳瑤寰、陳秀月、李幼綢、宮子晴、陳玉瑛、謝翠芬、鄧秋蘭、陳俞容、楊雅惠、張敬廉、高遐齡、楊青長、乙○○、廖嘉安、楊偉甫、宋伯永、周世杰、張政茂、江文助、林秀玲、黃天生、曾財益、張榮傑、楊昭璿、吳水城、辛○○、鄭文亮、己○○、羅仕政於偵查中向檢察官所為之陳述，及共同被告壬○○、林榮紹、甲○○、癸○○、戴沼澤、廉裕隆、戴沼銘、鄭年雅、紀駿富、彭壽奇、徐崧清於偵查中以證人地位向檢察官所為之陳述，均經檢察官告以具結之義務及偽證之處罰，且經具結而擔保其等證述之真實性，復無證據顯示係遭受強暴、脅迫、詐欺、利誘等外力干擾情形，或在影響其等心理狀況致妨礙其自由陳述等顯不可信之情況下所為。

另被告戊○○、壬○○及其辯護人對於上開證人之陳述有疑義者，並曾聲請欲進行交互詰問者，亦已於原審及本院前審審判時聲請傳喚到庭而為交互詰問，已保障被告戊○○、壬○○之對質詰問權。

是上開證人於偵查中業經具結之陳述，自有證據能力。

㈢關於臺中市調查站蒐證錄影帶及照片部分：臺中市調查站之調查員蒐證被告戊○○進出酒店行為，乃是由檢察官指揮偵辦，係為偵查本件貪污犯罪之公益目的，偵查手段合於必要性，且未逾越相當程度，尚無嚴重侵害被告之人格自律權之虞因此取得之資料自得作為證據。

而被告戊○○及其辯護人亦未主張該偵查作為取得之資料無證據能力，故上開蒐證錄影內容及照片均有證據能力。

㈣復按「除前三條之情形外，下列文書亦得為證據：一、除顯有不可信之情況外，公務員職務上製作之紀錄文書、證明文書。

二、除顯有不可信之情況外，從事業務之人於業務上或通常業務過程所須製作之紀錄文書、證明文書。

三、除前二款之情形外，其他於可信之特別情況下所製作之文書。」

刑事訴訟法第159條之4 定有明文。

此乃因公務員職務上製作之紀錄文書或證明文書，係公務員依職權所為，與其責任、信譽攸關，若有錯誤、虛偽，公務員可能因此擔負刑事及行政責任，且該等文書經常處於可能受公開檢查之狀態，其正確性及真實之保障極高；

另從事業務之人在業務上或通常業務過程製作之上開文書，因係於通常業務上不間斷而規律之記載，記錄時亦無預見日後將作為證據之偽造動機，其虛偽之可能性較小，且如讓製作者以口頭方式在法庭上再重述過去之事實或數據，實際上有其困難，二者具有一定程度之不可代替性，是除非有顯不可信之情況外，上開公務文書或業務文書應均具有證據能力。

查本案檢察官查扣之書證與物證（97年度大型保管字第165 號、97年度保管字第5331號扣押物品清單），乃臺中市調查站之調查員依據原審核發之97年度聲搜字第2072號搜索票依法搜索扣押而合法所取得（見原審甲卷）；

而原審依職權調取之書證或被告提出調查之書證，俱屬公文書如水利署或第三河川局之函稿、行政規章、命令等；

或從事業務之人於業務上所製作之紀錄文書如帳冊、施工日報表、監工日報表或報表，或係以電腦之作業予以記錄如支出傳票等，係就客觀上所發生之事實予以整理記錄，其誤差之機會極少，且記錄當時並未慮及可能會作為訴訟證物，其作假之機會甚微，再者被告戊○○、壬○○及其辯護人均未爭執該等文書之證據能力，即同意有證據能力，故上開書證與物證，均有證據能力。

三、認定犯罪事實所憑之證據及理由：訊據被告戊○○對於伊前係任職經濟部水利署第三河川局局長，且就伊所執掌之業務，及伊曾於附表三所示之時間及地點消費後，未曾支付費用，而由川順公司之人員代為支付費用等情坦承在卷，另被告壬○○則對於伊前係任職經濟部水利署工程事務組簡任第十職等副組長，且就伊所執掌之業務，及伊曾於附表四所示之時間及地點消費用，未曾支付費用，而由川順公司之人員代為支付相關費用等情坦承在案。

惟被告戊○○及壬○○均矢口否認有何前述違反貪污治罪條例之犯行，被告戊○○、壬○○之辯解及其等選任辯護人辯護稱：⑴被告戊○○部分：①水利署就便道工程預算書及驗收等事項並未授權予第三河川局，水利署仍保有審核之權，且變更設計預算書之金額係由世曦公司編寫，再由第三河川局轉呈水利署核准；

且工程若有變更設計之必要，在完成變更設計程序前，承包商經監造單位及業主同意，即非不得依所同意之變更設計先行施工，再行補辦變更設計之核准程序，此乃工程界之慣例，且本件便道工程有於96年年底完成之壓力，縱使在尚未完成變更設計程序前即先行施工，亦僅屬變更設計程序上之瑕疵，對被告戊○○應無可視為違背職務之行為可言。

②減災工程係由水利署主辦、發包，可否變更設計、變更設計預算書係水利署之權限，故便道工程之變更設計預算、驗收及減災工程之變更設計，並非被告戊○○職務上行為。

③被告戊○○與戴沼澤、廉裕隆等人於多年前即已熟識，時有聚會往來，於便道工程、減災工程施工期間，被告戊○○與戴沼澤等人前往KTV 酒店消費之費用，或係朋友間互相宴請、或係各自負擔，與被告戊○○在第三河川局所負責的事情沒有對價關係，被告戊○○並未接受任何不正利益。

且川順公司先後共16次招待被告戊○○喝花酒之時間，係在96年8 月15日起至97年3 月14日止，亦即第1 次之日期係96年8 月15日。

而有關於便道工程變更設計即96年8 月13日經水利署核准之前，川順公司並未招待被告戊○○至酒店喝花酒，更可見如謂被告戊○○係同意川順公司變更設計改以箱型石籠施工，而接受川順公司招待喝花酒之不正當利益，顯與實情不符。

④證人彭壽奇於偵查中明確證述水理分析報告係世曦公司庚○○主動向其請教便道工程水理演算，且係由庚○○製作，彭壽奇僅從中指導，亦即事實上應係由世曦公司監造，被告戊○○在過程中僅是負責一般行政程序發文工作，未曾以第三河川局局長身分要求指示彭壽奇做水理分析報告。

⑵被告壬○○部分：①便道工程中之工務行政處理，即包括「進度、管控、品質、勞安、環保」等是授權第三河川局處理，被告壬○○為水利署工程事務組副組長，就便道工程之驗收工作而言，被告壬○○僅係指派工程事務組第一科之人員進行驗收，但被告壬○○對於便道工程之驗收進行，實無任何決定驗收結果之權限，僅係會勘紀錄送審會經過被告壬○○之層級。

②減災工程之變更設計程序，需經執行機關第三河川局先報請水利署至現場會勘，經水利署派員到現場履勘，認確有變更設計之必要，經會勘人員製作「工程變更設計會勘記錄」，提出簽呈經署內各單位簽核同意，始為核准。

被告壬○○1 人之肯決，並無法對於變更設計之核准造成影響。

③被告壬○○與證人戴沼澤之彼此宴請，屬彼此互有餽請禮尚往來之交誼行為。

被告壬○○雖曾接受戴沼澤付帳之消費餐飲，亦有多次類似消費則係由被告壬○○自行支付。

倘證人即川順公司之負責人戴沼澤、廉裕隆確係本於行賄之意思，為求被告壬○○於其職務範圍內踐履川順公司特定行為，何以川順公司僅係偶爾支付被告壬○○之消費，惟被告壬○○仍須就己其餘之消費自行負擔。

應可認被告壬○○接受川順公司支付喝花酒款項之消費，並非給予對價之職務上行為。

經查：㈠被告戊○○及壬○○均為刑法第10條第2項第1款所稱依法令服務於國家所屬機關而具有法定職務權限之公務員：⒈被告戊○○係經濟部水利署第三河川局簡任第十一職等局長，任職期間自95年5 月2 日至98年1 月5 日，在職期間其工作項目為負責綜理局務（60% ）、關於水利工程建設暨水資源基本資料之建立轄內主要河川管理策劃、研議改進、報告及建議（30% ）、其他臨時交辦事項(10%) ，有經濟部水利署第三河川局97年10月14日，以水三廉字第00000000000 號函復原審之經濟部95年4 月26日經人字第00000000000 號令、經濟部水利署第三河川局職務說明書所載職稱為局長之工作項目1 份附於原審卷（原審97年度訴字第3018號卷三，第199 至202 頁、第204 頁）可稽。

⒉被告壬○○係經濟部水利署工程事務組簡任第十職等副組長，自96年3 月22日派任該職迄今，在職期間工作項目為襄理組長綜理組務（50% ）、審核工程招標、驗收、變更設計、展延工期等案件（30% ）、其他臨時交辦事務（20% ）等情，有經濟部水利署97年10月9 日，以經水人字第00000000000 號函復原審之經濟部96年3 月22日經人字第00000000000 號令（原審97年度訴字第3018號卷二，第224 至228 頁）、經濟部水利署第三河川局職務說明書職務編號A650020 所載職稱為副組長之工作項目1 紙（同上卷，第227 頁）可證。

⒊綜上顯示，被告戊○○及壬○○2 人，俱為公務人員任用法上之簡任公務員，並具有法定職務之職權，乃刑法第10條第2項第1款所列依據法令從事公務之人員，甚為明確，至堪認定。

㈡認定被告戊○○有要求，進而收受川順公司給付如附表三所示在有女陪侍之酒店消費及性交不正利益之證據及理由；

及被告壬○○有要求，進而收受川順公司給付如附表四所示在有女陪侍之酒店消費之不正利益之證據及理由；

⒈被告戊○○有前往如附表三所示之酒店消費，且未支付過消費款項，而該等酒店乃有女陪侍之高消費，為社會上俗稱喝花酒之場所，相關證據資料整理如下：⑴證人徐玉玲於偵查中證稱：「（九龍理容KTV 擔任何職？）董事。」

、「（你們消費方式？）每小時1100元，外場1200元，結帳方式是現金或是月結，月結是月底結帳，月初收帳，寄帳單到客戶的公司請款。」

、「（與戊○○如何認識？）我以前的友人蔡河清介紹的，．．我是到九龍以後才有碰到他兩三次，我是96年5 月過後到九龍，他都是跟一位陳玉瑛的女性朋友去，我知道的是他跟那位小姐去那裡唱歌，陳玉瑛去那裡喝酒。」

（97年度偵字第10922 號卷第51頁）、「我在九龍酒店擔任幹部，平時的綽號為秀秀。

九龍酒店均是以號碼（如：1 號或3 號或210 號）稱呼坐檯小姐，並不直接稱呼本名或綽號，該代號是由坐檯小姐自行選擇。

96年5 月間我本人調任至九龍酒店擔任幹部起，戊○○前來九龍酒店或和其他友人前來消費時，約有八成會主動找我安排包廂、小姐及喝酒等消費事宜，另外約有二成會找其他幹部廖怡君（本名：張淑惠）負責安排包廂、小姐及喝酒等消費事宜。

戊○○至九龍酒店消費主要服務幹部有徐玉玲及張淑惠。」

（見偵卷五，第121 背面至第122 頁）等語。

⑵證人周世杰於偵查中證稱：「戊○○找我到九龍理容KTV都會叫我找幹部秀秀，我到現場後，也都是由秀秀帶我進去包廂，招呼我們。

我與戊○○等人通常稱呼九龍理容KTV 為阿九」等語（見偵卷八，第219 背面）。

⑶證人張淑惠於偵查中證稱：「（在何處工作？）『九龍理容KTV 』，我是副總。」

、「化名『廖怡君』」、「（上開人等分別於何時間至店內消費？）戊○○去過約4 、5次以上，他有跟另一位陳小姐一起去，陳小姐叫『阿音』（音同），時間約是96年12月至97年1 月間。」

、「（提示96年12月19日17時55分廉裕隆與張淑惠之通訊監察譯文，談話內容為何？）是劉禎忠消費的帳，他欠了一筆3 萬元，劉禎忠交代我說由川順營造股份有限公司的戴經理付這筆錢，．．．我問．．帳為什麼跑到川順營造股份有限公司去，且由秀秀幫我收，我覺得很奇怪，我跟陳小姐即陳玉瑛有認識，所以如果我收不到這筆錢，我跟廉裕隆說我會跟戊○○說，因為我知道他們都認識，而陳小姐與戊○○是男女朋友，川順營造股份有限公司的人比較尊重戊○○，所以我覺得這樣講對廉裕隆比較有壓力。」

等語（97年度偵字第10922 號卷2 第150 、150-1 頁）。

⑷證人陳瑤寰於偵查中證稱：「（是否有在九龍KTV 服務？）有，．．我是做公關佳麗，就是坐檯小姐，陪客人唱歌，我的編號是105 號。」

、「（97年1 月7 日你有無開車載戊○○回家？）有。」

、「（經過情形？）當時是晚上7 、8 時，有10幾個人來，．．戊○○有去，他來喝酒、唱歌，唱了2 、3 個小時之後，我送戊○○回家，他有買出場，一個小時1200元，我不知道是何人付的錢，．．買我出場是買到凌晨4 時，印象中我們有去汽車旅館，我們去汽車旅館有發生性行為，他的生殖器有進入我的生殖器，還沒有超過凌晨0 時，我就送他回家了，我是送他到文心路家樂福，凌晨0 時20分許，我回到九龍KTV ，我就打電話給徐玉玲，告訴他我已安全將戊○○送回去，徐玉玲還問我『妹妹有處理嗎？』，我稱有。」

、「（錢是何人出的？）我不知道，帶出場1 個小時1200元，從晚上10點至凌晨4 時要付7200元。」

等語（97年度偵字第10922 號卷1 第45頁正反面）；

於原審審理時證稱：「（在調查站跟檢察官做筆錄的時候，有沒有受到任何強暴、脅迫，或任何不法的方式？）沒有。」

、「（所有調查筆錄跟偵訊筆錄，你有沒有看過再簽名？）有。」

、「（筆錄是不是都按照你的陳述來記載？）是。」

、「（〈提示97年偵查卷1672號卷1 第38頁〉在筆錄中調查站裡頭問到說在97年1 月7 號，戊○○是不是有把你帶出場和算費用多少，向何人收取費用，你說有的，許大哥有帶我出場及發生性行為，你看一下你有這樣的陳述？）對。」

、「（許大哥指誰？）局長戊○○。」

、「（戊○○當天就性行為，有沒有支付任 何的費用？）沒有。」

、「（買你下班要不要花錢？）要。」

等語（原審97年度訴字第3018號卷第69、70頁）。

⑸證人戴美玲於偵查中證稱：「經濟部水利署第三河川局長戊○○是我在九龍理容KTV 上班時認識的客人，當時是戊○○與朋友前往九龍理容KTV 消費時點我坐檯，因此才認識戊○○。」

、「我在九龍理容KTV 服務期間編號為『230 號』。」

、「戊○○到『九龍理容KTV 』消費時，都會和其他朋友（我均不知道姓名，但是看到人應該會認識），由於我們小姐並不直接與客人結算消費金額，而是由幹部來處理，戊○○至『九龍理容KTV 』消費時所負責的幹部為花名『秀秀』的董事，所以有關戊○○至『九龍理容KTV 』消費付款之事應該問『秀秀』才清楚，至於消費後是由何人付帳我並不十分清楚，但是在戊○○前來消費時，我並沒有看過戊○○自己付帳的情形。」

、「96年10月1 日戊○○前來『九龍理容KTV 』捧我的場，實際消費金額若干我無法確記，因為當天是我返回『九龍理容KTV 』的第1 天，所以戊○○可能是用『買全場』的方式捧我的場（即1,200 元乘以8 小時，總金額為9,600 元），所以消費金額約1 萬餘元，因為戊○○擔任河川局的局長，每次來『九龍理容KTV 』消費均係由同來之友人付帳，我從未看過他付帳，所以該次消費係由何人所付帳我並不確定。」

等語。

（見97年度偵字第10922 號卷五，第26至27頁、29頁）⑹證人陳玉瑛於偵查中證稱：「（戊○○帶你出席理容KTV應酬，是何人買單？）我們都是提早離席，我不知是誰買單，我沒看過戊○○買單或簽單。」

、「（97年3 月13日，你有無跟戊○○去九龍理容KTV 消費？）有。

時間是下午接近晚上，後來我跟戊○○先走。」

、「（97年3 月14日有無去楓之林理容KTV ？）有，．．後來我約下午5 時許我先到楓之林，戊○○約6 時許到，後來戴沼澤及劉禎忠、林榮紹陸續到達，我們唱歌唱了一晚，我跟戊○○先走。」

、「（當天〈即3 月14日〉誰買單，我跟戊○○先走，誰買單我不知道。」

等語（偵卷1 第159 、160 頁）；

於原審審理時證稱：「（之前是不是有到調查站還有檢察官這邊製作過二次的筆錄？）有。」

、「（在製作筆錄的過程中，調查員或檢察官有沒有對你施強暴、脅迫或任何不法的方法製作筆錄？）沒有。」

、「（筆錄你有沒有看過之後再簽名？）有。」

、「（筆錄的記載是不是按照你的陳述來記載？）對。」

、「（你有沒有跟戊○○一起到九龍KTV 去消費過？）有。」

、「（你跟他去的時候，你沒有看過他買單？）對。」

、「（你跟他去的時候，都是誰買單？）應該是他的朋友。」

、「（你在調查站裡頭講到說你曾經聽戊○○講過他到理容KTV 消費的時候，都是川順公司的戴沼澤交代員工阿隆就是廉裕隆直接刷卡或由川順公司支付這些費用，有沒有講過這些話？）有。」

、「（戊○○在什麼樣的場合跟你講過這些話，時間、地點？）他本人來的時候，我有聽到、有看過。」

、「（誰付帳？）包商。」

、「（包商是誰？我現在問你是川順公司，剛剛很清楚的是提到川順？）我知道。」

、「（如果你在場的話，是不是你算是他帶去的伴，然後他有沒有除了你自己當他的伴以外，他自己還點小姐，陪他坐檯？）我不曉得，到後來帶很多小姐陪他坐。」

、「（你在場是不是算是陪他？）對。」

、「（他會不會另外叫小姐陪他？）大部分是我叫的。」

等語。

（見原審97年度訴字第3018號卷六第223 至226 頁）⑺證人王莉婷於偵查中證稱：「川順公司董事長戴沼澤及經理廉裕隆有時會招待第三河川局官員戊○○、林榮紹、周科長及彭壽奇等人前往九龍KTV 唱歌宴飲，我曾經應邀參與數次。」

、「（前述前往九龍等理容KTV 唱歌宴飲，是誰負責出錢買單？）戴沼澤如果有去，都是由戴沼澤出錢買單。」

（97年度偵字第10922 號卷1 第92頁）。

⑻2007年12月19日17時24分17秒，證人張淑惠與廉裕隆通訊監察錄音及譯文內容，並經該2 證人於偵查中證稱係二人對話無訛：①張淑惠表示「對。

應該是，因為我前面就跟『長仔』（指第三河川局局長戊○○）講說這個『帳』『處理好了』，『長仔』應該是要處理後面這個，我在想『他』『怎樣都會把這個後續這3 萬多交給你處理』，你懂我的意思嗎。」

及「不過今天『秀秀』（指九龍理容KTV 幹部徐玉玲）跟我講的意思是說，你「表哥」是當著『長仔』（指局長戊○○）跟『忠哥』面前答應攬下這筆帳。」

，證明戊○○至九龍酒店接受川順公司招待。

②廉裕隆表示「對，其實如果對『公司』（指川順營造公司）的話，對公司啦，也沒有那個什麼1 個月2 個月啦，就是1 次就OK了啦。」

及「所以『他們』（指局長戊○○等人）後來2 個自己去，我就沒有去，因為我們平平都在那裡，所以他們2 個，他們先過去，本來我們也要過去，後來我就說，啊，後來我就腳痛我就不大想去，『有再打』（指戊○○若有打電話）我就過去，沒再打我就不要了，喔，結果沒再打我就沒有了，我一直記得說那1 天喔，後來又說沒有，啊，可能因為『他』（指局長戊○○）覺得說都、都、都叫我，不好意思的樣子，所以那次才給『忠哥』，這樣你知道嗎。」

可見被告戊○○至九龍酒店消費並未曾自己付款，而有接受川順公司招待之事實。

（見原審甲卷監聽譯文，及附件所示、同上偵查卷3 ，第136 至140 頁）③2007年12月19日17時55分25秒，證人張淑惠與廉裕隆通訊監察錄音及譯文內容，並經該2 名證人於偵查中證稱係2人對話無訛：張淑惠表示「我跟你講，我跟你講，我現在問你就是說，我本來確定這幾天之內我可以處理掉，怎麼這個帳到最後『秀秀』來跟我講，這個帳要推到你們公司，那問我願不願意等，我當然表面好，我等呀，就這樣子而已，不然我相信我自己找『長仔』（指局長許哲彥），我可以處理掉呀，你相不相信。」

及「我現在就是要脫離『你們那很複雜的環境』」。

廉裕隆表示「沒有啦，沒有啦，我跟你講這種儘量，不要在，不要在講。」

及「我就說不要常常在電話中講這個，你不知道。」

顯見被告戊○○確有至九龍酒店接受川順公司招待。

（見原審甲卷監聽譯文，及附件所示、97年度偵字第10922 號卷3 ，第140 至141頁）⑼鄭年雅於偵查中證稱：「我接到該九龍等酒店業者按月寄來之數張簽帳單時，為避免該費用集中提列在同一個工程上，會將該等酒店消費款項，大概平均提列在本公司目前施工中之『大甲溪砂石運輸便道工程第三標』及『頭汴坑溪一江橋上游崩塌地至內城橋河段防災減災工程』2 項工程上。」

、「97年1 月間川順公司承包工程業務僅有『大甲溪砂石運輸便道工程第三標』及『頭汴坑溪一江橋上游崩塌地至內城橋河段防災減災工程』2 項工程，沒有施作其他工程。」

等語（97年度偵字第10922 號卷3 第101 頁正反面）。

⒉被告戊○○前往如附表三所示之各次酒店消費，未曾支付過消費款項，而係由川順公司所支付，相關證據資料整理如下：⑴被告戊○○坦承有前往附表三所示各次之酒店喝花酒之消費，並由酒店小姐陳瑤寰提供一次性服務之事實在卷。

至被告戊○○供稱附表三酒店消費部分，有用現金支付不詳金額部分為其所支付一節，不僅與當次消費之酒店幹部及服務小姐所供述：未曾見被告戊○○任何消費款項等語不符，亦與以下所查之事證不符，尚難採信。

⑵關於被告戊○○確實有於96年8 月15日，在「九龍理容KTV 」有女陪侍之酒店喝花酒，消費金額1 萬6 千元，並指示徐玉玲將該次消費本票，向川順公司報請帳款，由川順公司支付，而收受川順公司給付不正利益（詳如附表三，編號1 ），證據如次：①證人張榮傑於偵查中證稱：「我確實曾於96年8 月15日載水利署河川勘測隊正工程師周世杰及同事『小乖』楊昭璿至『理容KTV 』（當時我並不知道該理容KTV 名稱，事後才知道是九龍）等三河局局長戊○○，因當日我當司機載周世杰、三河局的同事綽號『小乖』楊昭璿前往『九龍理容KTV 』，周世杰在車上用我的行動電話打給戊○○，要約戊○○到該『九龍理容KTV 』，後我載周世杰到『九龍理容KTV 』等局長戊○○，當時周世杰已經喝醉，我與『小乖』楊昭璿便將周世杰扶進『九龍理容KTV 』包廂內等局長戊○○，局長戊○○約在晚上6 、7 時到『九龍理容KTV 』，我便與局長戊○○到包廂內聊天，包廂內有2 至3 名女服務生坐檯陪酒，但我並未喝酒。」

、「是周世杰約局長戊○○前往『九龍理容當天的KTV 』，當天的飲宴目的為何我並不清楚，後來我與『小乖』楊昭璿先行離開，離開時包廂內除了周世杰、局長戊○○及2 至3 位服務女子外，並無其他外人，至於離開後有無其他外人來，我並不清楚。」

、「當天在『九龍理容KTV 』消費花費多少錢及由何人付帳，因我先行離開，所以並不清楚。」

等語（見偵卷十，第22至24頁）。

②證人楊昭璿於偵查中證稱：「該0000000000是我同事張榮傑所使用之行動電話，與戊○○對話之女子『小乖』是我本人無誤，『老闆』是戊○○無誤。」

、「就我記憶所及，我於96年8 月15日晚上（詳細時間，我已記不得了），張榮傑向我表示，戊○○有事找他，要我陪他過去，我表示同意，故由張榮傑開車載我，抵達後才知道是有女陪侍之酒店（我僅至該酒店1 次），但我忘記店名是否為『九龍理容KTV 』；

我有跟隨張榮傑進入包廂內向局長戊○○致意，並在場坐了一些時間，後來我因不喜歡該場所，故向張榮傑要求離開，並先行至包廂外等候，我與張榮傑離開時間即是該通電話晚上20時左右，因為我與張榮傑係自行偷偷離開，因而才打該電話向局長戊○○徵求他同意先行離開，戊○○也示意讓我先離開回家休息。

監聽電話內容，確為我與張榮傑先行離開酒店後，由張榮傑撥電話給戊○○，並由我與戊○○對話之通話內容。」

、「我與張榮傑赴『九龍理容KTV 』找戊○○，我僅進包廂向戊○○致意，並坐了一會；

我僅知道包廂內有小姐坐檯，但不知道有幾個，亦記不清楚在場另有那些人。」

、「如前述，我與張榮傑確有依戊○○之要求至一家酒店與戊○○會面，我有看到包廂內坐檯小姐，至於有那些人在包廂內，我已記不得了，詳細情形要問戊○○及張榮傑才清楚。」

、「我因不喜歡該場所，所以與張榮傑先行離開，離開後，因覺得不好意思，故以張榮傑行動電話打電話給戊○○，向戊○○表示抱歉。」

、「當天我與張榮傑先離開，故不知道在『九龍理容KTV 』之消費若干、由何人付帳等情形。」

等語（見偵卷十，第10至12頁）。

③證人陳玉瑛於偵查中證稱：「當天是戊○○自己開車到我位於臺中市逢甲路的居所來載我，並前往九龍理容KTV 消費；

我記得當時是在二樓的包廂，包廂內除了我和戊○○之外，還有張榮傑、周哥（周世杰）、小乖等人在場，戊○○那天找幹部秀秀（徐玉玲）安排大約4 、5 位坐檯小姐坐檯，消費時間約3 個鐘頭以上（詳細消費時間我已記不清楚）。

席間，因小乖與我拼酒，彼此間有一點衝突，張榮傑就將小乖帶離包廂，事後他們兩人也沒有再回來。

消費完畢後，戊○○就叫秀秀前來處理買單，戊○○只向秀秀示意，並沒有付帳，秀秀就知道如何處理。」

等語（見偵卷五，第100 頁）。

④人徐玉玲於偵查中證稱：「該張96年8 月15日簽帳本票應是戊○○於96年8 月15日在九龍酒店消費後，並由我註記『許董』簽帳本票，再將該張簽帳本票寄給川順公司向戴沼澤及廉裕隆請款，事後川順公司依慣例合併數筆九龍酒店帳款後，以公司支票付帳。」

等語（見偵卷五，第186 頁）。

⑤通訊監聽資料內容：（見原審甲卷譯文本，第1 至3 頁）2007年8 月15日16時30分47秒，某女與戊○○通訊監察錄 音及譯文，通話中戊○○背景有KTV 歌唱聲。

以及2007 年8 月15日16時47分15秒，林秀春與戊○○通訊監察錄音及譯文，及2007年8 月15日16時52分15秒，戊○○與女兒通訊監察錄音及譯文，及2007年8 月15日16時53分04秒，周世杰與戊○○通訊監察錄音及譯文，通話中戊○○基地台位置均在九龍酒店。

2007年8 月15日20時8 分50秒，張榮傑、楊昭璿與戊○○通訊監察錄音及譯文內要旨，並經該三人於偵查中證稱係其間之對話無訛。

而通話中，張榮傑向被告戊○○表示「我榮傑，你等一下，『小乖』（第三河川局楊昭璿）說很抱歉要跟你說一下。」

，楊昭璿嗣則表示「老闆。」

、「因為我被拖出去了我。」

及「對不起喔。」

等語，其等顯係為本日於九龍酒店包廂內先行離去之事向被告戊○○道歉。

被告戊○○則表示「沒關係，你回家休息。」

等語，上開內容經核與證人張榮傑、楊昭璿前開於偵查中之證述相符，顯見被告戊○○當日確有前往九龍酒店消費無訛。

⑥扣押物編號25-2之秀秀帳冊，該帳冊資料記載：96年 8月15日內載「許董」及「16000 」（見本案扣押物「秀秀帳冊」，偵卷五第137 頁），以及扣押物編號21-1之川順公司96年交際費傳票，傳票內容為：川順公司96年9 月25日「轉帳傳票」，內載「便餐費」、「九龍名店」、「8/15」及「16,000」。

九龍酒店「本票」，內載「壹萬陸仟」、「16000 」、「許董」、連保人「秀」及「96年8 月15日」。

以及扣押物編號壹-5：傳票清單，清單內容為：川順公司96年9 月25日「轉帳傳票」，內載「便餐費」、「九龍名店」、「8/15」及「16,000」（見偵卷五，第154 、156 頁）。

足認本次被告戊○○至九龍酒店喝花酒之費用，係由川順公司招待及支付。

⑦被告戊○○亦坦承當日有前往九龍理容KTV 消費，且佐以上述之證據資料，顯見被告戊○○於本日至九龍理容KTV 酒店喝花酒後，係由徐玉玲將本次消費向川順公司報請帳款，由川順公司支付，被告戊○○乃係接受川順公司招待喝花酒，而收受川順公司給付之不正利益，至堪認定之。

⑶被告戊○○確實有於96年9 月6 日，在「九龍理容KTV 」有女陪侍之酒店喝花酒，且由被告戊○○電請廉裕隆前來招待，消費金額由川順公司經理廉裕隆以現金支付，而收受川順公司給付不正利益（詳如附表三，編號2 ），證據如次：①證人張淑惠於偵查中證稱：「（96年9 月6 日17時30分）該通電話是廉裕隆與我之對話，0000000000是我所使用之行動電話，我向廉裕隆提到有看到『局長』，是因為我在九龍理容KTV 有看到戊○○在店裡飲宴，至於是在包廂或大廳，及與何人在一起，我已不記得。」

、「前述我向廉裕隆提及有看到『局長』（戊○○），是戊○○於96年9 月6 日由陳玉瑛陪同至九龍理容KTV105包廂飲宴，陳玉瑛並要我至105 包廂作陪，我進入包廂後看到在場者除戊○○、陳玉瑛及徐玉玲（秀秀）外，尚有一名男子（已忘記其姓名及職稱），之後我與廉裕隆聯繫通話後，廉裕隆即前來九龍理容KTV105包廂，與戊○○、陳玉瑛及該名男子一同飲酒唱歌。」

等語（見偵卷五，第60頁）。

②證人陳玉瑛於偵查中證稱：「當天我先行帶兩個女性朋友前往九龍理容KTV ，戊○○事後有隨同前往，該次消費金額我不清楚，如我前述，結帳時，他都是請幹部秀秀過來處理代為簽帳，戊○○並沒有付款。」

等語（見偵卷五，第101 、102 頁）。

③2007年9 月6 日15時15分25秒陳玉瑛與戊○○通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第4 至5 頁），並經該2人於偵查中證稱係其等2人對話無訛：陳玉瑛表示「你要忙到幾點。」

、「比較晚，這樣我跟你講，我可以先去嗎。」

及「先去呀。」

等語，顯示陳玉瑛將先行前往九龍理容KTV 。

戊○○表示「去哪裡，『阿九』那裡」、「隨便你啦，隨便你啦。」

及「不要緊，你就去，反正我可以就去，我會叫人那個。」

證人陳玉瑛於偵查中證稱：「戊○○所說的『那個』，就是表示他會叫其他人來買單的意思。」

等語（見偵卷五，第101 頁）。

④2007年9 月6 日17時31分57秒至17時33分24秒，戊○○與廉裕隆通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第5 至7 頁），並經該二人於偵查中證稱係二人對話無訛：戊○○持用陳玉瑛行動電話與廉裕隆通聯，戊○○表示「喔，好，這樣我知道。

沒有啦，我在，我在那個，本來要叫你過來那個，輕鬆一下啦。」

、「『阿九』。」

及「OK，喔。」

。

廉裕隆表示「喔，好呀，好呀，我要下山了，我要下山了。」

及「好好好」。

⑤2007年9 月6 日17時37分16秒廉裕隆與戴沼澤通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第7 至8 頁），並經該2人於偵查中證稱係其等2人對話無訛：廉裕隆表示「『老闆』（指戊○○）在『阿九』，剛才有打給我。」

及「說叫我過去，我過去，那些我再跟他講一下。」

等語，足見廉裕隆係向戴沼澤報告戊○○在九龍理容KTV ，並將前往；

且擬於該九龍理容KTV 與被告戊○○討論事情。

廉裕隆表示「我現在就看土地啦，啊，會勘，他剛才有在問那個，那個，那個災害的啦，我說那就根本還沒出去到那裡。」

、「我說那個，我現在說那個，那個『副座』（指第三河川局副局長林傳茂）的問題啦，還那個『逕行施工』那個啦。」

等語，可見其間在談論第三河川局人員辦理颱風災損之公文尚未通過之事。

戴沼澤表示「看怎麼樣，看怎樣喔，叫他說，若『世曦』那個你跟他說一說喔，明天他可能『長仔』（指戊○○）還是那個喔，跟『世曦』叫他們過來溝通一下，和他們直接叫起來說不要在那裡寫那些有的沒有的，這樣，這樣就都沒有事情。」

等語。

觀諸前揭文義，此部分應係戴沼澤交代廉裕隆要求被告戊○○讓本便道工程監造設計單位世曦公司及第三河川局副局長林傳茂等人對未經正式函文變更設計即先行施工、認列災損等事宜不要簽註任何意見。

⑥2007年9 月6 日17時38分48秒，林秀春與戊○○通訊監察錄音及譯文，顯示戊○○基地台位置於九龍理容 KTV。

及2007年9 月6 日19時45分38秒，廉裕隆與張淑惠通訊監察錄音及譯文，顯示廉裕隆基地台位置於九龍理容KTV 。

（見原審甲卷，譯文本第8 至10頁），又2007年9 月6 日19時45分51秒，廉裕隆與張淑惠通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第10頁），廉裕隆表示「你在『105 』（指九龍酒店105 包廂）。」

、「我在你後面。」

及「我在門口。」

顯見廉裕隆當有到九龍酒店與被告戊○○一同喝花酒。

⑦證人徐玉玲於偵查中證稱：「九龍酒店確實有105 包廂，依照我本人及張淑惠名下之應收帳款帳冊內均無記載該次戊○○與廉裕隆之簽帳記錄，因戊○○或廉裕隆從未曾以信用卡刷卡方式付帳，且陳玉瑛不會支付該筆帳，所以應該是由戊○○或廉裕隆以現金方式付帳。」

等語（見偵卷五，第187 頁），可見本日消費款項係以現金支付，而被告戊○○既未曾支付九龍理容KTV 之費用，應即是由川順公司經理廉裕隆所支付，至堪認定。

⑧綜上證據資料顯示，且被告戊○○亦坦承當日有前往該酒店消費，顯見被告戊○○於該日至九龍理容KTV 酒店，乃係由被告戊○○電請廉裕隆前來招待喝花酒，消費金額由川順公司經理廉裕隆以現金支付，而收受川順公司給付之不正利益。

⑷被告戊○○確實曾於96年9 月14日，應戴沼澤之邀，在「九龍理容KTV 」有女陪侍之酒店喝花酒，消費金額1 萬2千1 百元、2 千2 百元共計1 萬4 千3 百元，由川順公司本便道工程96年10月25日「轉帳傳票」項下支付，而收受川順公司給付不正利益（詳如附表三，編號 3），證據如次：①證人張淑惠於偵查中證稱：「96年9 月14日當天是我的生日，當晚我與客人游志英、甘耀國等人在外慶生，後來我打電話給廉裕隆，問廉裕隆是否還在九龍理容KTV包廂飲酒，廉裕隆告訴我尚在包廂內與『長仔』（戊○○）、大舅（戴沼澤）等人飲酒，廉裕隆為了避嫌，叫我不要進來九龍理容KTV 作陪，所以我回到九龍理容KTV 後，並未進入包廂，與戊○○、戴沼澤、廉裕隆等人見面。

因為廉裕隆不想讓人家知道我是他女朋友。」

等語（見偵卷五，第60、61頁）②2007年9 月14日16時50分51秒，戊○○與陳玉瑛通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第15至18頁），並經該2 人於偵查中證稱係其等2人對話無訛：被告戊○○當時所使用之行動電話基地台，位置在九龍理容KTV 酒店。

陳玉瑛表示「你那裡很吵耶。」

、「為什麼那裡很吵。

」及「都是女孩子的聲音耶。」

，戊○○表示「沒有啦，現在他們在『阿九』（指九龍理容KTV ）這裡啦。」

陳玉瑛表示「你在那裡喔。」

戊○○表示「對啦」「你要不要過來」，可見當時被告戊○○確係在九龍理容KTV 酒店。

③2007年9 月14日16時56分45秒，陳玉瑛與戊○○通訊監察錄音及譯文，及同日17時13分36秒、17時16分42秒，戊○○與水利署人員通訊監察錄音及譯文，被告戊○○之行動電話基地台位置均位在九龍理容KTV 酒店，可見被告戊○○當時在九龍理容KTV 酒店。

④2007年9 月14日17時21分17秒，鄧秋蘭與戴沼澤通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第18至20頁），並經戴沼澤於偵查中證稱係二人對話無訛：戴沼澤行動電話之基地台位置在九龍理容KTV 酒店。

戴沼澤表示「我現在在，我現在也是在你們這個什麼，『九龍』（指九龍理容KTV ）耶。」

，可證戴沼澤亦在九龍理容KTV 酒店內與被告戊○○一同喝花酒。

⑤2007年9 月14日17時36分52秒，廉裕隆與配偶通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第20至21頁）：廉裕隆行動電話之基地台位置在九龍理容KTV 酒店。

廉裕隆表示「在，在『吃飯喝酒唱歌的地方』。」

「台中呀。」

「你怎麼知道，應該是不會醉啦。」

及「不是我愛喝。」

，可證廉裕隆係與戴沼澤、被告戊○○在九龍理容KTV 酒店喝花酒。

⑥扣押物編號25-2之秀秀帳冊，帳冊內96年9 月14日內載「川順」、「12100 」及「川順」、「2200」（見扣押之秀秀帳冊，偵卷五第138 頁）；

及扣押物編號21-1之川順公司96年交際費傳票，其上記載：川順公司96年10月25日「轉帳傳票」，內載「便餐費」、「九龍名店」、「9/14廉經理12,100」、「9/14（續）2,200 」及「應付票據九龍名店JZ000000000/12/25 」。

九龍酒店「本票」2 紙，分別內載「貳仟貳佰」、「2200」、「許董（川順）續」、連保人「秀」、「96年9 月14日」；

及內載「壹萬貳仟壹佰」、「12100 」、「廉裕隆」、「川順」、連保人「秀」、「96年9 月14日」（見偵卷五，第157 至159 頁）。

並有扣押物編號壹-3之傳票清單，其上載有：川順公司96年10月25日「轉帳傳票」，內載「便餐費」、「九龍名店」、「9/14廉經理12,100」、「9/14（續）2,200 」及「應付票據九龍名店JT0030574 ，96/12/25」。

⑦證人徐玉玲證述要旨：「該2 張簽帳本票確實為廉裕隆及戊○○於96年9 月14日在九龍酒店消費及簽帳之相關本票，該2 張本票我也依慣例寄給川順公司請款，依該張傳票顯示，事後川順公司以支票付款給九龍酒店，至於該張2,200 元本票中註記有『許董（川順）續』，是指當日戊○○與廉裕隆再追加繼續消費1 個小時，從續單本票金額2,200 元可知，當日戊○○與廉裕隆共點了2 名坐檯小姐延長消費1 小時，因每名小姐檯費每小時1,100 元，帶出場是以每小時1,200 元計算。」

等語（見偵卷五，第187 頁）。

⑧綜上所述證據資料顯示，且被告戊○○亦坦承當日有前往該酒店消費，顯見被告戊○○於本日確實係應戴沼澤之邀至九龍理容KTV 酒店接受川順公司招待喝花酒，而收受川順公司給付之不正利益，至堪認定之。

⑸被告戊○○確實曾於96年9 月18日，應戴沼澤之邀，在「九龍理容KTV 」301 包廂有女陪侍之酒店喝花酒，消費金額由川順公司負責人戴沼澤以現金支付，消費金額不詳，而收受川順公司給付之不正利益（詳如附表三，編號4 ），證據如次：①2007年9 月18日19時10分03秒，徐玉玲與戊○○通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第32頁），並經該2人於偵查中證稱係其等2人對話無訛：被告戊○○行動電話基地台位置在九龍理容KTV 酒店。

徐玉玲表示「我幫你拿雨傘嗎。」

及「我知道呀，就你有帶雨傘嗎。」

，可見徐玉玲欲至九龍理容KTV 大門為被告戊○○撐傘，迎接被告戊○○。

戊○○表示「我這個車子不能不能停你們前面啦。」

足見被告戊○○確實有前往九龍理容KTV 。

②2007年9 月18日19時26分46秒，廉裕隆與王莉婷通訊監察錄音及譯文（見原審甲卷，譯文本第32至33頁），並經該2人於偵查中證稱係其等2人對話無訛：王莉婷背景有KTV 歌唱聲。

廉裕隆表示「你在上面。」

及「你在樓上嗎。」

王莉婷表示「對啦，『301 』（指九龍理容KTV 編號301 包廂）」。

廉裕隆表示「我在，這樣我沒有要上去了，我在旁邊而已，要走再打電話給我就好。」

及「我在旁邊而已。」

廉裕隆當時所持行動電話之基地台位置於九龍酒店。

可證廉裕隆已到達九龍理容KTV 。

③2007年9 月18日19時26分33秒，戴沼澤通訊監察短訊譯文其持有通話之行動電話基地台位置在九龍理容KTV 酒店。

（見原審甲卷，譯文本第32頁）及同日19時29分42秒，廉裕隆與某男通訊監察錄音及譯文其所持有通話之行動電話基地台位置在九龍理容KTV 酒店。

（見原審甲卷，譯文本第33頁）④2007年9 月18日19時56分42秒，廉裕隆配偶與廉裕隆通訊監察錄音及譯文（見原審甲卷，譯文本第33至34頁）內容：廉裕隆所持行動電話基地台位置於九龍酒店。

廉裕隆表示「還沒，我在等『大舅』（指戴沼澤）。」

及「他去唱歌，我在等他啦，等他要載他。」

可證明戴沼澤係與被告戊○○在九龍理容KTV 酒店喝花酒。

⑤證人徐玉玲於偵查中證稱：「依照所提示的通訊監察譯文來看，96年9 月18日當天下午戊○○確實有前來與廉裕隆、王莉婷等人在九龍酒店301 包廂內飲酒作樂，如果我本人及張淑惠名下之應收帳款帳冊內均無記載廉裕隆或戊○○之簽帳記錄，應是當日由戊○○或廉裕隆在現場以現金方式支付，至於詳細是由何人付帳，所花費金額為何，我已忘記，必須查看九龍酒店當日301 包廂之消費明細才清楚。」

（見偵卷五，第188 頁），可證本日消費以現金支付，而被告戊○○既未曾在酒店內支付九龍理容KTV 酒店消費之金額，業如前述，可見當日喝花酒之金額係由川順公司所支付。

⑥綜上所述證據資料顯示，且被告戊○○亦坦承當日有前往該酒店消費，顯見被告戊○○於本日有應戴沼澤之邀，前往九龍理容KTV 酒店接受川順公司招待喝花酒，而收受川順公司給付之不正利益，至堪認定之。

⑹被告戊○○確實有於96年10月2 日，前往「九龍理容KTV」有女陪侍之酒店喝花酒後，消費金額16,550元後，即將帳款交由徐玉玲處理，徐玉玲再依照慣例事後要求廉裕隆補簽帳，再由川順公司於96年11月25日「轉帳傳票」項下支付（詳如附表三，編號5 ），證據如次：①證人陳玉瑛於偵查中證稱：「當天是戊○○載我到九龍理容KTV 消費，後來是因為戊○○的太太催他回家，我們大約將近21時左右就離去，離去時，戊○○一樣沒有付款，照樣由秀秀處理。」

等語（見偵卷五，第104 頁）。

②2007年10月2 日20時54分23秒，被告戊○○配偶與戊○○通訊監察錄音及譯文，當時被告戊○○所使用行動電話基地台在九龍理容KTV 店。

（見原審甲卷，譯文本譯文本第40頁）③扣押物編號25-2之秀秀帳冊，該帳冊記載：96年10月2日內載「許」及「16550 」（見偵卷五，第139 頁），以及扣押物編號21-1之川順公司96年交際費傳票，內有川順公司96年11月25日「轉帳傳票」，內載「便餐費」、「九龍名店」、「10/2」及「16,550」，併同10月4日、10月5 日、10月11日、10月17日及10月31日之九龍酒店帳款開立97年1 月25日到期票號JT0000000 支票13萬6700元。

九龍酒店「本票」，內載「壹萬陸仟伍佰伍拾元」、「16550 」、「廉裕隆10/4」、「許」、連保人「秀」及「96年10月2 日」（見偵卷五，第160 、161 頁）。

可見96年10月2 日被告戊○○至九龍理容KTV消費之金額係由川順公司所支付。

④證人徐玉玲於偵查中證稱：「依照該張本票及應收帳款帳冊紀錄，該張本票是戊○○與廉裕隆於10月2 日當天一起在九龍酒店內消費，如前述戊○○及廉裕隆告訴我，他們因為平均分擔帳款關係，所以我必須將該本票再拿給廉裕隆簽名確認，同時也利於我依照戊○○或廉裕隆指示，可將該本票直接寄給川順公司請款，再由戊○○與廉裕隆均分該筆帳款。」

等語（見偵卷五，第189頁），而被告戊○○既未曾支付酒店消費款項，堪認上開費用均係由川順公司支付。

⑤綜上所述證據資料顯示，且被告戊○○亦坦承當日有前往該酒店消費，顯見被告戊○○前往九龍理容KTV 酒店後，即將帳款交由徐玉玲處理，徐玉玲再要求廉裕隆補簽帳，由川順公司付款招待喝花酒，而收受川順公司給付之不正利益，至堪認定之。

⑺被告戊○○確實曾於96年10月4 日，與廉裕隆共同前往「九龍理容KTV 」有女陪侍之酒店喝花酒，消費金額22,600元後，由川順公司支付（詳如附表三，編號6 ），相關證據資料整理如下：①證人陳玉瑛於偵查中證稱：「我記得當天戊○○及川順公司董事長戴沼澤等一行人在谷關用餐，戊○○要我先去九龍理容KTV 等他，戊○○要我先去九龍理容KTV 等他，後來戊○○一行人約在16時30分左右到場；

當時除戊○○及我之外，尚有綽號水哥之男子，川順公司的廉裕隆及一位身材瘦高的離職員工。

當天戊○○等人先離開，但是離開前有交代秀秀處理這筆消費帳務，我和女性友人就繼續在樓下按摩後才離開。

至於該筆帳是由何人支付買單，我不清楚，這要問秀秀才知道。」

等語（見偵卷五，第102 頁）。

②證人張淑惠於偵查中證稱：「該通電話我是告訴廉裕隆，陳玉瑛（1 號）於下午1 點左右打電話給我，說廉裕隆與戊○○在山上喝酒，陳玉瑛並在電話中表示將於當天下午3 點多前來九龍理容KTV 喝酒唱歌。

陳玉瑛於當天下午3 點多與1 位女性朋友前來九龍理容KTV ，我負責引導陳玉瑛及其友人進入包廂，並帶4 位小姐進入包廂坐檯後即離去，該包廂交由徐玉玲（秀秀）擔任主桌幹部，而廉裕隆向我表示，他等一下就會下山。」

等語（見偵卷五，第62頁）。

③2007年10月4 日13時15分0 秒及15時19分24秒，陳玉瑛與戊○○通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第45至47頁），並經該2 人於偵查中證稱係其等2 人對話無訛：陳玉瑛表示「我那個，我2 點半就在『阿九』（即九龍理容KTV ）了喔。」

。

戊○○表示「但是我沒那麼早下去啦。」

陳玉瑛表示「不要緊，我就等你就對了。」

戊○○表示「我要過去，還是。」

及「我還在路上。」

陳玉瑛表示「當然。」

及「等你。」

顯見被告戊○○確有於96年10月4 日下午前往九龍理容KTV 。

④2007年10月4 日15時29分39秒，廉裕隆與張淑惠通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第45至47頁），並經該2 人於偵查中證稱係其等2 人對話無訛：張淑惠表示「『1 號』（指戊○○女友陳玉瑛）呀，他1 點多的時候打電話說你，說『長仔』（指局長戊○○）跟你在山上喝酒。」

廉裕隆表示「有呀。」

張淑惠表示「沒有，好，那就這樣，剛到呀，『他』（指陳玉瑛）1 點多的時候說他3 點會到呀。」

及「因為他嗆要把我灌醉，我不要進去，他帶1 個女孩來，叫4 個女孩。

」廉裕隆表示「我還在山上，可能等一下下去吧。」

，顯見廉裕隆與被告戊○○確有前往九龍理容KTV 酒店。

⑤2007年10月4 日16時29分59秒，戊○○與陳玉瑛通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第48頁），並經該二人於偵查中證稱係二人對話無訛：由上開通訊顯示被告戊○○所持用之行動電話基地台位置於九龍理容KTV 。

被告戊○○表示「幾號房。」

陳玉瑛表示「我叫人去帶你。」

足見被告戊○○確有於96年10月4 日下午前往九龍理容KTV 。

⑥2007年10月4 日16時36分29秒，戴沼澤與戊○○通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第48頁），並經該二人於偵查中證稱係二人對話無訛：被告戊○○表示「在『阿九』（指「九龍理容KTV 」）。」

，可證戴沼澤亦知悉被告戊○○於該日確有在九龍理容KTV 喝花酒。

⑦扣押物編號25-2之秀秀帳冊，帳冊記載：96年10月4 日內載「廉裕隆」及「22600 」（見偵卷五，第139 頁），以及扣押物編號21-1之川順公司96年交際費傳票，內載：川順公司96年11月25日「轉帳傳票」，內載「便餐費」、「九龍名店」、「10/4」及「22,600」，併同10月2 日、10月5 日、10月11日、10月17日及10月31日之九龍酒店帳款開立97年1 月25日到期票號JT0000000 支票13萬6700元。

並有九龍酒店「本票」，內載「貳萬貳仟陸佰」、「22600 」、「廉裕隆10/4」、連保人「秀」及「96年10月4 日」（見偵卷五，第160 、162 頁）。

可見被告戊○○於本日至九龍理容KTV 酒店係接受川順公司招待，至為明確。

⑧綜上證據資料顯示，且被告戊○○亦坦承當日有前往該酒店消費，顯見被告戊○○於本日與廉裕隆共同前往九龍理容KTV 酒店喝花酒後，係由川順公司招待喝花酒，而收受川順公司給付之不正利益無訛。

⑻被告戊○○確實有於96年10月5 日，在九龍理容KTV 有女陪侍之酒店喝花酒，消費金額10,650元後，指示徐玉玲代為簽帳，再由徐玉玲事後向當日未到場之廉裕隆要求補簽帳，再由川順公司支付該帳款（詳如附表三，編號7 ），證據如次：①扣押物編號25-2之秀秀帳冊，帳冊記載有：96年10月 5日內載「許」及「10650 」（見偵卷五，第139 頁），以及扣押物編號21-1之川順公司96年交際費傳票，內載：川順公司96年11月25日「轉帳傳票」，內載「便餐費」、「九龍名店」、「10/5」及「10,650」，併同10月2 日、10月4 日、10月11日、10月17日及10月31日之九龍酒店帳款開立97年1 月25日到期票號JT0000000 支票13萬6700元。

並有九龍酒店「本票」，內載「壹萬╳仟陸佰伍拾」、「10650 」、「廉裕隆10/31 」、「許」、「英」、連保人「秀」及「96年10月5 日」（見偵卷五，第160 、163 頁）。

可見被告戊○○於該日至九龍酒店係接受川順公司招待，至為明確。

②證人徐玉玲於偵查中證稱：「該張96年10月5 日金額10,650元之簽帳本票，確實為戊○○偕同女友陳玉瑛前來九龍酒店消費10,650元，因此我在本票上註記『英』等字跡。

該張96年10月5 日金額10,650元之簽帳本票，我確實在96年10月31日廉裕隆前來九龍酒店消費時，再交給廉裕隆補簽認該筆帳款，以利於向川順公司申請付款，另外我再拿該張本票給廉裕隆簽帳確認，是指廉裕隆當日有前來與戊○○一起消費，我依照廉裕隆及戊○○之前的指示將該簽帳本票寄給川順公司進行請款。」

等語（見偵卷五，第190 頁），而被告戊○○既未曾支付酒店消費款，可見被告戊○○於本日至九龍理容KTV 酒店係接受川順公司招待，至為明確。

③綜上證據資料顯示，且被告戊○○亦坦承當日有前往該酒店消費，顯見被告戊○○於該日至九龍理容KTV 酒店後並未付款，即由徐玉玲依照慣例要求廉裕隆補簽帳後，由川順公司招待喝花酒，而收受川順公司給付之不正利益無疑，至堪認定之。

⑼被告戊○○確實曾於96年10月11日，在「九龍理容KTV 」有女陪侍之酒店喝花酒，消費金額為20,800元後，指示徐玉玲代為簽帳，再由徐玉玲事後向當日未到場之廉裕隆要求補簽帳，再由川順公司96年11月25日「轉帳傳票」項下支付（詳如附表三，編號8 ），證據如次：①證人陳玉瑛於偵查中證稱：「當天戊○○有帶我去九龍理容KTV 消費，後來有帶一位小姐轉到楓之林理容KTV續攤；

由於那位小姐酒醉，且戊○○因老婆在催而先行離去，我與該名小姐及其他女性朋友繼續在楓之林理容KTV 唱歌。

因為該小姐已經超過出場時間，我請徐玉玲補3 個小時的出場費，由於該筆費用是由戊○○負責的，所以徐玉玲就於翌日打電話給戊○○，以確認是否准予補這3 小時出場費。」

等語（見偵卷五，第103 頁）。

②2007年10月11日20時11分53秒，被告戊○○配偶與戊○○通訊監察錄音及譯文（見原審甲卷，譯文本第62頁），顯示被告戊○○當時持用之行動電話基地台在九龍理容KTV 酒店，且可證明證人陳玉瑛上開證述非虛。

③2007年10月12日12時14分50秒，徐玉玲與戊○○通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第62至63頁），並經該2 人於偵查中證稱係其等2 人對話無訛：徐玉玲表示「昨天『阿瑛』（指戊○○女友陳玉瑛）說要再把他朋友『補3 小時』啦。」

、「『阿瑛』啦。」

及「說要再把他朋友『補3 小時』啦，要嗎。」

；

戊○○表示「呵呵呵呵呵，呵呵，好啦，好啦。」

對照陳玉瑛上開證詞，足見被告戊○○確有於96年10月11日在九龍理容KTV 消費。

④證人徐玉玲於偵查中證稱：「戊○○與陳玉瑛在96年10月11日在九龍酒店消費，並點陳玉瑛在九龍酒店上班的朋友坐檯陪酒唱歌，當日戊○○先行離開，且已經與我結算該日帳款，但陳玉瑛再向我要求繼續延後3 小時點陳玉瑛的朋友坐檯喝酒，因此我於隔日向戊○○報告此情，並經戊○○同意在戊○○的名下列入應收帳款。」

（見偵卷五，第191 頁）。

⑤扣押物編號25-2之秀秀帳冊，帳冊上記載：96年10月11日內載「許」、「3600」及「許」、「20800 」（見偵卷五，第139 頁），以及扣押物編號21-1之川順公司96年交際費傳票，內載有：川順公司96年11月25日「轉帳傳票」，內載「便餐費」、「九龍名店」、「10/11 」及「20,800」，併同10月2 日、10月4 日、10月5 日、10月17日及10月31日之九龍酒店帳款開立97年1 月25日到期票號JT0000000 支票13萬6700元。

並有九龍酒店「本票」，內載「貳萬╳仟捌佰」、「20800 」、「廉裕隆10/31 」、「英」、連保人「秀」及「96年10月11日」（見偵卷五，第160 、164 頁）。

可見被告戊○○於該日至九龍酒店係接受川順公司招待，至為明確。

⑥綜上證據資料顯示，且被告戊○○亦坦承當日有前往該酒店消費，顯見被告戊○○於該日至九龍理容KTV 酒店後並未付款，即由徐玉玲依照慣例要求廉裕隆補簽帳後，由川順公司招待喝花酒，而收受川順公司給付之不正利益無訛，自應認定之。

⑽被告戊○○確實曾於96年10月17日，與戴沼澤、廉裕隆共同前往「九龍理容KTV 」有女陪侍之酒店喝花酒，消費金額49,550元，由川順公司經理廉裕隆簽立本票，再由川順公司96年11月25日「轉帳傳票」項下支付（詳如附表三，編號9 ），相關證據資料整理如下：①2007年10月17日17時10分18秒，戴美玲與戊○○通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第72至73頁），並經該2 人於偵查中證稱係其等2 人對話無訛：戴美玲表示「我跟你講你現在在我們『公司』（指九龍酒店）對不對，那我打去跟那個。」

、「哪是，姐姐打電話說你有喝酒了。」

、「那我等一下，我打電話去跟那個客人講說我不要過去，我等一下弄一弄過去『公司』了。」

可見被告戊○○已在九龍理容KTV 酒店內喝花酒。

②2007年10月17日17時38分29秒，廉裕隆、戊○○與彭壽奇通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第72至73頁），並經該三人於偵查中證稱係其間對話無訛：所持用之行動電話基地台位置在九龍酒店附近。

戊○○持用廉裕隆行動電話與彭壽奇通聯，足見被告戊○○與廉裕隆均在九龍理容KTV 酒店。

戊○○表示「你們下午去哪裡爽快。」

、「現在要來上班 喔，對呀。」

及「來呀，過來呀。」

，邀彭壽奇前來九龍酒店接受招待。

彭壽奇表示「『九』（指九龍酒店）。」

（詢問是否於九龍酒店。

）戊○○表示「對呀。」

彭壽奇表示「好好好好。」

③2007年10月17日18時15分25秒，戴沼澤與廉裕隆通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第74至75頁），並經該2 人於偵查中證稱係其等2 人對話無訛：廉裕隆持用之行動電話基地台位置於九龍理容KTV 酒店。

廉裕隆現場有KTV 歌唱聲。

可見廉裕隆仍在九龍理容KTV酒店。

戴沼澤詢問「還沒結束。」

廉裕隆表示「還沒。」

表示仍在九龍理容 KTV酒店招待戊○○。

戴沼澤表示「你不要喝太多，明天你就直接到工地去，我 叫『阿如』（音譯，戴沼澤女友王莉婷）載過去就好了。」

④2007年10月17日18時16分21秒，廉裕隆與配偶通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第75頁），並經廉裕隆於偵查中證稱係其間對話無訛：廉裕隆基地台位置仍在九龍酒店。

廉裕隆表示「沒有啦，還在KTV 喔。」

及「喔，從（下午）3 點多喝到現在。」

可見當日從15時許即開始在九龍理容KTV 酒店招待戊○○，且仍繼續招待。

⑤2007年10月17日21時53分47秒，廉裕隆配偶與廉裕隆通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第78頁），並經廉裕隆於偵查中證稱係其間對話無訛：廉裕隆基地台位置於九龍酒店。

其配偶表示「你還在『那裡』（指九龍酒店）喔。」

廉裕隆表示「嗯。」

可見廉裕隆仍在九龍理容KTV 酒店招待被告戊○○。

⑥扣押物編號25-2之秀秀帳冊，帳冊記載：96年10月17日內載「廉裕隆」及「49550 」（如附表九所示扣押物，並見同上偵卷五，第133 至149 頁，第139 頁背面），以及扣押物編號21-1之川順公司96年交際費傳票，其上載有：川順公司96年11月25日「轉帳傳票」，內載「便餐費」、「九龍名店」、「10/17 」及「49,550」，併同10月2 日、10月4 日、10月5 日、10月11日及10月31日之九龍酒店帳款開立97年1 月25日到期票號JT0030581 支票13萬6700元。

並有九龍酒店「本票」，內載「正確＄49550 」、「廉裕隆10/17 」、連保人「秀」及「96年10月17日」。

（見偵卷五，第160 、165 頁）。

可見被告戊○○於該日至九龍酒店係接受川順公司招待，至為明確。

⑦證人徐玉玲於偵查中證稱：「該筆49,550元之帳款確實是廉裕隆在96年10月17日當日前往九龍酒店消費並於當日簽帳之簽帳本票，我同樣寄該張簽帳本票給川順公司進行請款，並且由川順公司以支票付帳。」

等語（見偵卷五，第192 頁）。

⑧綜上證據資料顯示，且被告戊○○亦坦承當日有前往該酒店消費，顯見被告戊○○於本日與戴沼澤及廉裕隆至九龍理容KTV 酒店乃係接受川順公司招待喝花酒，而收受川順公司給付之不正利益無訛，自應認定之。

(11)被告戊○○確實有於96年10月31日，與廉裕隆一同前往「九龍理容KTV 」有女陪侍之酒店喝花酒，消費金額16,550元，由川順公司經理廉裕隆簽立本票，再由川順公司96年11月25日「轉帳傳票」項下支付（詳如附表三，編號10），證據如次：①證人張淑惠於偵查中證稱：「96年10月31日我下班返家後打電話關心廉裕隆狀況，並問是否需要我去接他，當時廉裕隆仍在九龍理容KTV 飲酒，要我不用去接他。」

等語（見偵卷五，第63頁）②2007年10月31日14時37分24秒，戊○○與廉裕隆通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第80頁），並經該2人於偵查中證稱係其等2人對話無訛：戊○○表示「你現在在『旱溪』（指天祥街招待所）還是 。」

、「『老林仔』他們人過去了嗎。」

「喔。

你現在在『旱溪』啦喔。」

所指「旱溪」應係指川順公司天祥招待所，另「老林仔」則係指被告林榮紹。

廉裕隆表示「現在要過去，差不多要到了，再5 分鐘就到了。」

③2007年10月31日15時27分48秒，林榮紹與戊○○通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第80至81頁），並經該2 人於偵查中證稱係其等2 人對話無訛：戊○○持用之行動電話基地台位置在川順公司旱溪天祥街招待所。

林榮紹表示「我，你把我放在這裡，給我『亂亂游』（台語音譯、指找不到人）呀。」

、「你要來嗎，你要來嗎，你講1 句，這樣而已。」

戊○○表示「交代他們要給你弄好，什麼『亂亂游』。

」④2007年10月31日16時15分50秒，戴沼澤與林榮紹通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第81至82頁），並經該2人於偵查中證稱係其等2人對話無訛：戴沼澤表示「『阿九』（指邀去九龍酒店）呀。」

、「叫他，他們要去『九仔他家』（指九龍酒店）啦。」

、「你就彎回來就好了啊，他們那邊結束了吧。」

及「『阿九』那裡啊，你車子你若是會開，就開來天祥街，載你去這樣比較好啦。」

林榮紹表示「沒有啦，我要回去處理一下。」

⑤2007年10月31日17時12分14秒，林榮紹與廉裕隆通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第83至84頁），並經該2人於偵查中證稱係其等2人對話無訛：林榮紹表示「現在『老闆』（指戊○○）是要怎麼樣。

」、「老闆還在天祥街（指川順公司旱溪天祥街招待所）嘛，我要回去了，現在你要叫我去哪裡。」

廉裕隆表示「還在那裡，還在那裡。」

⑥2007年10月31日17時16分12秒，戴沼澤、戊○○與林榮紹通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第84至85頁），並經該3 人於偵查中證稱係其等間對話無訛：戊○○持用戴沼澤行動電話與林榮紹通聯。

證明被告戊○○與戴沼澤同於川順公司旱溪天祥街招待所。

戴沼澤表示「你跟『長仔』講，『長仔』跟你講。」

並將行動電話交予戊○○。

（證明「長仔」係戊○○。

）林榮紹稱呼戊○○為「老闆，老闆。」

（證明「老闆」係戊○○。

）林榮紹表示「喂，『你們』在打麻將，我就不過去了，我直接回去。」

、「沒有啦，『你們』在打麻將，因為時間的問題，我跟『阿隆』（指廉裕隆）說，我就回來了，我不去啦喔。」

、「隨便講講，你們現在你們在打麻將。」

及「你們就打麻將就好了。」

林榮紹表示「我現在快來，本來要去『九龍』（指九龍酒店）那裡，我再10分鐘就到『九龍』了，但我現在改變路線。」

、「人生喔，經濟第2 啦，女人第1 啦，講實在我本來我說要去『那裡』（指九龍酒店），我衝很快，很多那個我就叫人代理。」

、「要去『九仔』（指九龍酒店）那裡嘛。」

及「你何時會到，我現在就快回到家了，何時會到。」

林榮紹表示將前往九龍理容KTV酒店。

戊○○表示「好啦，好啦，我會到啦。」

及「我就說我會到，你等一下啦，我正在認真賺錢，我會到。」

被告戊○○允諾將前往九龍理容KTV 酒店。

⑦2007年10月31日17時31分4 秒，廉裕隆與林榮紹通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第86頁），並經該2人於偵查中證稱係其等2人對話無訛：廉裕隆表示「人過去了耶。」

、「嗯，『老闆』（指戊○○）呀。」

、「『老闆』過去了。

（指局長戊○○）」、「差不多快到了。」

、「嗯，我也要過去啦。」

及「好呀，好呀，就差不多，在路上了啦，頂多，至多5分鐘就到了。」

告訴林榮紹說戊○○即將到達九龍理容KTV 酒店。

廉裕隆表示「喔，你等一下會過去嘛。」

林榮紹表示「我沒有，我沒有『開間』（指於九龍酒店開 包廂）啦，因為我還沒到啦，我還沒到啦。」

及「會，我現在剛好到哪裡你知道嗎，松竹路的什麼地方這樣而已。」

林榮紹允諾並已前往九龍理容KTV 。

⑧扣押物編號21-1之川順公司96年交際費傳票，其上記載：川順公司96年11月25日「轉帳傳票」，內載「便餐費」、「九龍名店」、「10/31 」及「16,550」，併同10月2 日、10月4 日、10月5 日、10月11日及10月17日之九龍酒店帳款，開立97年1 月25日到期票號 JT0000000支票13萬6700元。

並有九龍酒店「本票」，內載「壹萬陸仟伍佰伍拾」、「16550 」、「廉裕隆10/31 」、連保人「秀」及「96年10月31日」。

（見偵卷五，第160、166 頁）。

可見被告戊○○、林榮紹於該日至九龍酒店係接受川順公司招待，至為明確。

⑨證人徐玉玲於偵查中證稱：「該筆16,550元之帳款，確實是廉裕隆在96年10月31日當日前往九龍酒店消費並於當日簽帳之簽帳本票，我同樣寄該張簽帳本票給川順公司進行請款，並且由川順公司以支票付帳。」

等語（見偵卷五，第193 頁）。

⑩綜上所述證據資料顯示，且被告戊○○亦坦承當日有前往該酒店消費，顯見被告戊○○於本日與廉裕隆至九龍理容KTV 酒店，乃係接受川順公司招待喝花酒，而收受川順公司給付之不正利益無誤。

(12)被告戊○○確實曾於96年11月28日，電洽廉裕隆要求前往「九龍理容KTV 」招待後，即前往「九龍理容KTV 」有女陪侍之酒店喝花酒，消費金額16,000元，由川順公司經理廉裕隆簽立本票，再由川順公司96年11月25日「轉帳傳票」項下支付（詳如附表三，編號11），證據資料整理如下：①證人王莉婷於偵查中證稱：「96年11月29日上午9 時51分許，我打電話給川順公司的廉裕隆，向他詢問三河局局長戊○○是否在11月28日沒有找戴沼澤，而直接找廉裕隆外出飲酒作樂，廉裕隆向我表示確實如此，因此才會有『喝酒人家不用找舅舅，阿孫出馬就可以了』的說法，其中舅舅即是指戴沼澤，阿孫即是指廉裕隆。」

等語（見偵卷卷1 ，第92至93頁）。

②證人陳玉瑛於偵查中證稱：「當天戊○○帶我去九龍理容KTV 消費，遇到警察臨檢，KTV 的幹部就將戊○○帶到二樓密室躲藏，我打電話表示關心，最後一通電話『狀況解除』，是我通知戊○○，警察臨檢已經結束。

當天消費起先是戊○○的同學顏教授，後來戊○○請廉裕隆到場作陪；

當天因為後來遇到臨檢，當警察走後，我們就隨即離開，由廉裕隆負責支付帳務。」

等語（見偵卷五，第103 頁）。

③證人張淑惠於偵查中證稱：該通電話是我在九龍理容KTV 打給廉裕隆的，因為廉裕隆告訴我將前來店裡飲酒唱歌，我主動詢問是否需安排小姐，廉裕隆原本不準備叫小姐，但我向他表示叫兩個就好，廉裕隆才同意由我安排兩位小姐坐檯，當日由我擔任主桌幹部，我安排戊○○等人在1 樓包廂飲酒唱歌。」

、「我當時擔任主桌幹部，在現場並未看到戊○○飲酒跳舞，且當時座位之安排係戊○○與陳玉瑛併坐，廉裕隆及顏沛華各與1 名小姐併坐。」

、「該筆帳款係由廉裕隆先行簽帳，我再於96年12月初（約12月5 日前）將該筆帳單寄達川順公司請款，川順公司約於12月25日郵寄1 紙票期兩個月之支票至公司，金額共計16000 元，因此該筆帳目已結清。

」等語（見偵卷五，第64、65頁）；

於原審審理時證稱：「（是不是有一次也就是在96年11月28號晚上大概 9點多，戊○○、廉裕隆、陳玉瑛等人到九龍KTV 消費，遇到警察臨檢，戊○○跑到二樓躲避臨檢？）有。」

、「（那一天96年11月28日就是被警察臨檢的那一次消費款項，你是不是記載在你的怡君帳冊裡面？記載為『廉裕隆收入16000 元』？〈提示扣押物編號25-3怡君帳冊〉）（點頭）有。」

、「（這一次的16000 元的消費款項，你是不是在96年12月初，你用郵寄帳單到川順公司，川順公司在96年12月25日郵寄支票給你，你再交給公司？）對。」

等語（97年度訴字第3018號卷六，第221頁反面、222 頁）。

雖證人張淑惠於偵查中另證稱：「戊○○本人並未消費，且自行攜伴（陳玉瑛）前來店內，所以其本人無須支付費用。」

、「我當時擔任主桌幹部，在現場並未看到戊○○飲酒跳舞．且當時座位之安排係戊○○與陳玉瑛併坐，廉裕隆及顏沛華各與1 名小姐併坐。」

等語（偵卷五，第64、65頁），惟依該日通訊監察譯文顯示，該次飲宴係被告戊○○為招待其同學顏沛華，而找來廉裕隆，而被告戊○○在遇警方臨檢前有2 個多小時以上之時間，其是否如證人張淑惠所言並未飲酒，尚屬有疑，且該次飲宴本應由被告戊○○付款，卻找來廉裕隆並由廉裕隆簽帳及由川順公司付款，其仍有收受不正利益無誤。

④2007年11月28日17時59分11秒，戊○○與廉裕隆通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第94頁），並經該2人於偵查中證稱係其等2人對話無訛：廉裕隆稱戊○○「長仔。」

可見「長仔」係被告戊○○。

戊○○表示「呀，來『阿九』（指九龍理容KTV ）怎麼樣。」

及「我再差不多5 分鐘到。」

要約廉裕隆九龍理容KTV 酒店。

廉裕隆表示「喔，好呀，好呀，這樣我等一下，好。」

⑤2007年11月28日18時28分01秒，張淑惠與廉裕隆通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第94至95頁），並經該2人於偵查中證稱係其等2人對話無訛：張淑惠表示「要跟你排小姐嗎。」

、「這樣就好嗎。」

及「2 個就好嗎。」

即安排2 名坐檯小姐。

⑥2007年11月28日20時25分14秒，戴沼澤與廉裕隆通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第95頁），並經該2人於偵查中證稱係其等對話無訛：廉裕隆現場有KTV歌唱聲。

廉裕隆表示「還沒，在『阿九』（指九龍理容KTV ）」證明其在九龍理容KTV 酒店。

戴沼澤表示「和『許仔』（指第三河川局局長戊○○）他們去。」

詢問廉裕隆是否陪同被告戊○○等人。

裕隆表示「嗯嗯嗯，『老闆』（指戊○○），嗯。」

⑦2007年11月28日21時34分45秒、21時35分38秒、21時40分34秒，陳玉瑛與戊○○通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第95至96頁），並經該2 人於偵查中證稱係其等對話無訛：戊○○基地台位置於九龍酒店。

陳玉瑛表示「你還OK嘛喔。」

戊○○表示「嗯嗯。」

表示陳玉瑛詢問因警察臨檢而躲藏之被告戊○○狀況如何。

陳玉瑛表示「你還OK嗎。」

戊○○表示「嗯嗯。」

陳玉瑛表示「你在哪裡。」

戊○○表示「在2 樓。」

顯示被告戊○○在九龍理容KTV2樓處所躲避警方臨檢。

陳玉瑛表示「狀況解除，狀況解除。」

戊○○表示「OK，好，我下來。」

表示警方臨檢之狀況解除，被告戊○○可從九龍理容KTV2樓下樓。

⑧扣押物編號21-1之川順公司96年交際費傳票，其上記載：川順公司96年12月25日「轉帳傳票」，內載「便餐費」、「九龍名店」、「11/28 便餐費」及「16,000」，開立97年2 月25日到期支票，票號：JT0000000 。

並有九龍酒店「本票」，內載「壹萬陸仟」、「16000 」、「廉裕隆11/28 」、及「96年11月28日」、「九龍名店消費請款單」內載「川順先生」、「消費日96年11月28日」、「金額16000 」等，張淑惠於備註欄署名「廖怡君」，以及扣押物編號25-3之怡君帳冊，帳冊記載：96年11月28日內載「廉裕隆」及「16000 」（見偵卷五，第48頁）。

可見被告戊○○於該日至九龍酒店係接受川順公司招待，至屬明確。

⑨綜上證據資料顯示，且被告戊○○亦坦承當日有前往該酒店消費，顯見被告戊○○於該日至九龍理容KTV 酒店，乃係電請廉裕隆要求招待，亦即係接受川順公司招待喝花酒，而收受川順公司給付之不正利益無誤，足以認定之。

(13)被告戊○○確實曾於96年12月17日，應廉裕隆之邀約，前往「九龍理容KTV 」107 包廂有女陪侍之酒店喝花酒，消費金額17,650元，由川順公司總經理戴泱丞簽立本票，再由川順公司96年12月25日「轉帳傳票」項下支付（詳如附表三，編號12），證據如次：①證人張淑惠於偵查中稱：「我是在公司打給廉裕隆，向其表示戊○○與『忠哥』（劉禎忠）等人在九龍理容KTV 飲宴，當日係由徐玉玲（秀秀）擔任主桌幹部負責結帳處理單子。」

等語（見偵卷五，第65頁）②2007年12月17日15時30分28秒，王莉婷與廉裕隆通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第99至100 頁），並經該2 人於偵查中證稱係其等對話無訛：廉裕隆表示「在『九龍』（指九龍理容KTV ）。」

王莉婷表示「『阿忠』（指幀衡公司劉禎忠）他們在這邊嗎，不然怎麼電話一直打。」

廉裕隆表示「對呀。」

③2007年12月17日16時54分51秒，戴沼澤與廉裕隆通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第101 至102頁），並經該2人於偵查中證稱係其等對話無訛：戴沼澤表示「嗯，啊，那個『長仔他們』（指局長戊○○等人）有都來『那裡』（指九龍理容KTV ）嗎。」

廉裕隆表示「剛才到。」

證明被告戊○○等人已抵達九龍理容KTV 酒店。

④2007年12月17日18時52分17秒，張淑惠與廉裕隆通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第104 至 106頁），並經該2人於偵查中證稱係其等對話無訛：廉裕隆所持用行動電話基地台位置仍在九龍酒店。

廉裕隆通話中背景有KTV歌唱聲。

（證明仍在九龍酒店。

）張淑惠表示「他今天就給『秀秀』（指九龍理容KTV 徐玉玲）去處理這張單子。」

及「對呀，我想你們都做『秀秀』的。」

證明本（17）日由酒店幹部徐玉玲安排女侍招待被告戊○○等人。

廉裕隆表示「對呀，應該今天也『秀秀』啦。」

證明由徐玉玲安排女侍。

張淑惠表示「我等一下打聲招呼，我跟『長仔』（指戊○○）打聲招呼啦。」

證明被告戊○○在九龍理容KTV 酒店。

⑤扣押物編號21-2之川順公司97年交際費傳票，其上記載：川順公司97年1 月25日「轉帳傳票」，內載「便餐費」、「九龍名店」、「12/17 」及「17,650」，併同12月5 日之九龍酒店帳款開立97年3 月25日到期票號JT0030599 支票2 萬9650元。

並有九龍酒店「本票」，內載「壹萬柒仟陸佰伍拾」、「17650 」、「戴泱丞」、連保人「秀」及「96年12月17日」（見偵卷3 ，第77至79頁）。

可見被告戊○○於本日至九龍理容KTV 係接受川順公司招待，至為明確。

⑥證人鄭年雅於偵查中證稱：「我收到該2 張本票簽帳單後，看96年12月5 日及96年12月17日之簽帳本票簽署有『戴泱丞』，我同樣拿該2 張九龍酒店寄來之本票簽單給我先生戴泱丞確認是否有此2 筆簽帳，經我先生戴泱丞確認後，即將該2 張合計消費29,650元憑證交給會計人員登帳製作轉帳傳票。」

、「川順公司同樣是開立2個月票期之支票，面額29,650元，票號JT0000000 、97年3 月25日到期支票支付予九龍酒店。」

等語（見97年度偵字第10922 號卷3 ，第103 頁）。

⑦綜上證據資料顯示，且被告戊○○亦坦承當日有前往該酒店消費，顯見被告戊○○於該日應廉裕隆之邀約前往九龍理容KTV 酒店，乃係接受川順公司招待喝花酒，而收受川順公司給付之不正利益明確，已可認定之。

(14)被告戊○○確實有於97年1 月7 日，應戴沼澤之邀約，由廉裕隆陪同在「九龍理容KTV 」有女陪侍之酒店喝花酒，戊○○當晚喝完喝酒後並將九龍理容KTV 店編號第105 號女侍小姐陳瑤寰帶出場，至臺中市某汽車旅館，接受該女侍之性服務，消費金額計80,450元，由川順公司負責人戴沼澤簽立本票，再由川順公司於97年2 月25日「轉帳傳票」項下，並開立97年4 月25日到期票號JT0000000 支票，面額80,450元支付（詳如附表三，編號13），證據如次：①證人張淑惠於偵查中證稱：「該通聯譯文確實是我本人與陳玉瑛的對話內容，該段對話是我與陳玉瑛聊到關於徐玉玲一直固定擔任戊○○來店消費時的主桌幹部的內容，因為戊○○於1 月7 日前來九龍理容KTV 時，是由我接待上樓的，但是因為戊○○等人平時都是固定找徐玉玲擔任主桌幹部，所以當時我只能算是在大廳接待戊○○等人上樓，至於戊○○等人這一酒攤仍然是由徐玉玲擔任主桌幹部，負責安排坐檯小姐，業績也仍然固定屬於徐玉玲的業績。」

等語（見偵卷2 ，第109 頁）②證人戴沼澤於偵查中證稱：「當日該通電話是我與戊○○的通話，主要意思是戊○○告訴我第七河川局人員前來找戊○○，戊○○要我前往九龍酒店，當日我有依戊○○要求前往九龍酒店。」

等語（見偵卷二，第83頁）③2008年1 月7 日14時40分39秒，戊○○與戴沼澤通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第119 頁），並經該2人於偵查中證稱係其等2人對話無訛：戊○○表示「現在和『第七』（指第七河川局）的兄弟要去『阿九』（指九龍理容KTV ）。」

戴沼澤表示「喔，好呀，好呀，好。」

及「好。」

④2008年1 月7 日14時46分11秒，戊○○與周世杰通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第119 頁），並經該2人於偵查中證稱係其等2人對話無訛：周世杰表示「載，載太太回來。」

戊○○表示「好，回去後，『阿九』（指九龍理容KTV）。」

及「回去後，『阿九』啦。」

，邀周世杰前來九龍理容KTV 酒店。

周世杰表示「好好好好。」

⑤2008年1 月7 日16時6 分51秒、16時11分17秒，陳玉瑛與戊○○通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第120 至121 頁），並經該2 人於偵查中證稱係其等對話無訛：戊○○持用行動電話之基地台位均在九龍酒店。

戊○○表示「現在我屏東的朋友上來，在『阿九』（指九龍理容KTV ）。」

陳玉瑛行動電話短訊表示「怡君那裡有一張3 」。

⑥2008年1 月7 日16時12分38秒，陳玉瑛與張淑惠通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第121 至125頁），並經該2人於偵查中證稱係其等2人對話無訛：張淑惠持用之行動電話基地台位置於九龍酒店。

陳玉瑛表示「你有在『大哥』（指第三河川局局長戊○○）那個包廂嗎」，詢問張淑惠是否在被告戊○○所在之九龍理容KTV 酒店包廂。

張淑惠表示「『他們』（指戊○○等人）在『315』（指九龍理容KTV 『315 』包廂）。」

。

及「我帶上去的。」

證明被告戊○○於九龍理容KTV 酒店編號315 包廂。

陳玉瑛表示「，，他說他屏東的朋友來，在『那邊』（指九龍理容KTV ），．．」及「．．他就講說，他都跑去哪裡，我都打給你，你都不開機，我現在喔，我在那個『阿九』（指九龍理容KTV ），我朋友屏東上來啦，上來，我就帶來這，．．」轉述被告戊○○在九龍理容KTV 酒店。

陳玉瑛表示「今天是『秀秀的桌』（指召女飲酒作樂之消費算徐玉玲的業績）嗎」，張淑惠表示「嗯。」

證明本日由酒店幹部徐玉玲安排酒店小酒陪侍被告戊○○等。

⑦2008年1 月7 日16時13分25秒，戴沼澤與戊○○通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第125 至126頁），並經該二人於偵查中證稱係對話無訛：戊○○持用之行動電話基地台位置在九龍理容KTV 酒店。

戴沼澤表示「不然，我要過去嗎。」

詢問其是否須到九龍理容KTV 酒店。

戊○○表示「都可以呀，來呀。」

及「來呀，大家朋友在這裡。」

要求戴沼澤前來。

⑧2008年1 月7 日18時48分58秒、18時49分27秒，戴沼澤與王莉婷通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第128 頁），並經該2 人於偵查中證稱係其等對話無訛：戴沼澤持用之行動電話基地台位置在九龍酒店。

戴沼澤行動電話通話中背景有KTV 歌唱聲，證明戴沼澤在九龍理容KTV 酒店與被告戊○○一同喝花酒。

）⑨2008年1 月7 日19時23分42秒，戴泱丞與徐玉玲通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第128 至129頁），並經該2人於偵查中證稱係對話無訛：徐玉玲持用之行動電話基地台位置在九龍酒店。

戴泱丞表示「現在在『公司』（指九龍理容KTV）喔。」

詢 問徐玉玲是否於九龍理容KTV 酒店。

徐玉玲表示「對呀。」

徐玉玲表示「…你趕快過來，你趕快過來，但是『你爸』（指戴沼澤）在這裡。」

證明戴沼澤於九龍理容KTV 。

戴泱丞表示「今天過去那裡喔。」

詢問戴沼澤等人是否於 九龍理容KTV 酒店。

徐玉玲表示「對呀，對呀。」

戴泱丞表示「『他們』不就過去沒多久。」

徐玉玲表示「喔，很久了啦。」

「『他』（指戊○○）跟』第七的』（指第七河川局）。」

⑩2008年1 月7 日19時25分14秒至20時39分20秒戴沼澤有通話通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第129 至130 頁）：戴沼澤持用之行動電話之基地台位置均在九龍酒店。

⑪2008年1 月8 日0 時20分13秒，陳瑤寰與徐玉玲通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第131 至132頁），並經該2人於偵查中證稱係其等對話無訛：陳瑤寰表示「那個，那個『局長』剛才，對不對。」

證明陳瑤寰與被告戊○○出場之事實。

徐玉玲表示「妹妹，有『處理』吧。」

及「有沒有『處理』。」

詢問陳瑤寰有無為被告戊○○提供性服務。

陳瑤寰表示「有呀」及「『他』還問我說買到幾點，我說 4點嘛，對不對。」

證明被告戊○○接受川順公司購買酒店女侍陳瑤寰出場鐘點提供性服務；

且該出場鐘點費應非被告戊○○付費，否則其應無不知究竟買幾個鐘點之可能。

⑫證人陳瑤寰於偵查中證述意旨：通訊監察內容是我與徐玉玲董事的對話，1 月7 日晚上（詳細時間已忘記）徐玉玲要我駕駛徐玉玲的休旅車（車號不清楚）送許大哥（指被告戊○○）回家，在場的人（姓名不清楚）付錢買我出場，從1 月7 日晚上10時買至1 月8 日的凌晨4時，許大哥在坐上車後，我依照『許大哥』吩咐，載『許大哥』前往台中市汽車旅館（名稱地點我記不清楚）休息，休息結束後，約在1 月7 日晚上11時30分左右，我按照『許大哥』的吩咐再將『許大哥』載至台中市文心路上的『家樂福』門口後，『許大哥』即下車離去，在1 月8 日凌晨0 時20分，我返回九龍理容KTV 後，我以自己的行動電話0000000000打給董事徐玉玲，告訴徐玉玲我已將『許大哥』安全送返，電話內容中徐玉玲問我：「妹妹，『有處理』啊？」是指『許大哥』帶我出場後有無發生性行為，我答稱：「有呀。」

及「有的，『許大哥』有帶我出場及發生性行為，『許大哥』並未支付任何費用，依照公司的算法，價碼為出場每小時1200元，從1 月7 日晚上10時開始至1 月8 日凌晨4 時計算，許大哥應支付7200元」等語。

可見本（7 、8 ）日戊○○有赴九龍理容KTV 接受川順公司之酒店飲宴及性招待。

⑬扣押物編號21-2之川順公司97年交際費傳票，其上記載：川順公司97年2 月25日「轉帳傳票」，內載「便餐費」、「九龍名店」、「1/7 」及「80,450」，開立97年4 月25日到期票號JT0000000 支票8 萬450 元。

並有九龍酒店「本票」，內載「捌萬零仟肆佰伍拾」、「80450 」、「戴沼澤」、連保人「秀」及「97年1 月7 日」（見偵卷3 ，第80至81頁）。

可見被告戊○○於該日至九龍酒店係接受川順公司招待喝花酒及性交服務之不正利益，至為明確。

⑭證人鄭年雅於偵查中證稱：「我收到該張本票簽帳單後，看97年1 月7 日之簽帳本票簽署有『戴沼澤』，我同樣拿該張九龍酒店寄來之本票簽單給我公公戴沼澤確認是否有此筆簽帳，經我公公戴沼澤確認後，即將該張消費80,450元憑證交給會計人員登帳製作轉帳傳票。」

、「川順公司同樣是開立2 個月票期之支票，面額80,450元，票號JT0000000 、97年4 月25日到期支票支付予九龍酒店。」

、「依照帳冊資料顯示，該等支票是以戴沼澤於合作金庫銀行中港分行支票帳戶，帳號208325開立支付。」

等語（見97年度偵字第10922 號卷3 ，第104頁）。

⑮證人徐玉玲於偵查中證稱：「（為何97年1 月7 日流水帳紀錄收到戴沼澤現金79350 元與川順公司傳票上支出80450 元不符？）酒錢為1100元，如果用我幹部的現金價買，就是這個價錢，然後我會先幫客人代墊買酒，然後等他請款票寄來，我再給公司，然後公司會幫我扣掉1100元我代墊的酒錢，所以流水帳與川順公司的內帳才有1100元之差距。」

等語（97年度偵字第10922 號卷3第55頁）。

⑯綜上所述之證據資料，且被告戊○○亦坦承當日有前往該酒店消費及前往汽車旅館與酒店小姐發生性交，顯見被告戊○○於該日乃係應戴沼澤之邀約，於廉裕隆陪同下，由川順公司招待喝花酒及性服務，而收受川順公司給付之不正利益，實屬明確，至堪認定之。

(15)被告戊○○確實有於97年2 月12日，應川順公司之邀約，與壬○○等人在「九龍理容KTV 」有女陪侍之酒店喝花酒，戊○○當天晚上8 時17分許，並單獨將「楓之林理容KTV 」編號第66號女侍楊雅惠買出場，本次消費金額計17,150元、6,000 元，合計23,150元，由川順公司經理廉裕隆簽立本票，再由川順公司97年3 月25日「轉帳傳票」項下支付（詳如附表三，編號14），證據如次：①證人周世杰於偵查中證稱：「97年2 月12日當天我不是應戊○○就是應壬○○之邀才到九龍理容KTV 。

．．壬○○有打電話告訴我他們已經到了九龍理容KTV ，所以我才會再次打電話給徐玉玲確認。」

、「我先前打電話問徐玉玲壬○○到九龍理容KTV 了沒有，徐玉玲打電話跟我回報壬○○已經到九龍理容KTV ，並由徐玉玲接待到編號121 包廂。

因為我當天在川順公司旱溪天祥街之組合木屋附近，所以就近搭乘阿隆（廉裕隆）的車子前往九龍理容KTV ，但為什麼我會坐他的車子，我記不清楚。」

、「壬○○已經在九龍理容KTV ，他用徐玉玲的電話打給我，壬○○表示說我遲到了，所以壬○○用粗話消遣我，我就回他說再5 分鐘就到了。」

、「我先到九龍理容KTV 編號121 包廂，故我向戊○○表示已經抵達，我在121 包廂裡面大多跟戊○○、壬○○聊天。

．．我先行離開，我亦沒有支付相關的消費費用，至於何人買單，我不清楚。」

等語（見偵卷八，第236 、237頁）。

②2008年2 月12日14時07分25秒，戊○○與楊雅惠通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第167 至168頁），並經該2人於偵查中證稱係其等2人對話無訛：戊○○表示「我說你現在有沒有空呀，要不要過來喝酒呀。」

及「那你不要，你就算我的，你就直接過來就好了。」

顯示被告電召楓之林理容KTV 編號66號小姐楊雅惠出場坐檯。

楊雅惠「喔，你會不會把我灌醉，哈哈哈。

啊，不行，不行，對，我記得了，你，每次坐你旁邊只要朋友敬你，我都要拿起來喝，乾杯，乾杯，．．」證明楊雅惠曾為被告戊○○坐檯。

③2008年2 月12日14時19分07秒，楊雅惠與戊○○通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第168 至169頁），並經該2人於偵查中證稱係其等對話無訛：戊○○表示「可不可以過來。」

顯示被告戊○○再次電召楊雅惠出場至川順營造旱溪天祥街招待所坐檯。

楊雅惠表示「可以呀。」

戊○○表示「那個旱溪東路和天祥街交叉口。」

及「旱溪西路，旱溪西路。」

顯示被告戊○○告知川順營造旱溪天祥街招待所位置。

④2008年2 月12日14時51分55秒，楊雅惠與戊○○通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第170 頁），並經該2人於偵查中證稱係其等對話無訛：戊○○基地台位置於川順營造旱溪天祥街招待所。

楊雅惠表示「到天祥街了。」

戊○○表示「看到你車子了，等一下，等一下。」

證明被告戊○○於川順公司招待所，且楊雅惠已到達。

⑤2008年2 月12日16時6 分37秒，周世杰與徐玉玲通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第172 至 173頁），並經該2人於偵查中證稱係其等對話無訛：徐玉玲基地台位置於九龍酒店。

周世杰表示「對啦，『他們』到了沒。」

、「他們跟我講他們在『那裡』（指九龍理容KTV ），他們講他們在那裡，好啦，我們現在要過去啦。」

及「剛才說，『葉仔』（指水利署工程事務組副組長壬○○）他們說都過去了。」

顯示周世杰詢問壬○○等人是否抵達九龍理容KTV 酒店。

徐玉玲表示「還沒有耶。」

及「好啦，不然他們若到了我，我再打給你好嗎。」

⑥2008年2 月12日16時14分34秒，徐玉玲與周世杰通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第173 頁），並經該2人於偵查中證稱係其等對話無訛：徐玉玲基地台位置於九龍理容KTV酒店。

徐玉玲表示「『人』（指水利署壬○○等人）到了喔。

」周世杰表示「我坐『阿隆』（指廉裕隆）的車子，現在要出發，嗯。」

顯示周世杰乘坐廉裕隆座車前往九龍理容KTV 酒店。

徐玉玲表示「嗯，『121 』（指九龍理容KTV 編號121包廂）。

⑦2008年2 月12日16時15分53秒，徐玉玲、壬○○與周世杰通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第173 至174 頁），並經該3 人於偵查中證稱係其等間對話無訛：徐玉玲、壬○○持用之行動電話基地台位置均在九龍酒店。

壬○○持用徐玉玲行動電話與周世杰通聯。

周世杰表示「再5分鐘啦，我剛又被。」

⑧2008年2 月12日16時16分39秒，周世杰與戊○○通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第174 至 175頁），並經該2人於偵查中證稱係其等對話無訛：戊○○持用之行動電基地台位置在於九龍酒店。

戊○○表示「我到了，怎麼。」

證明被告戊○○已抵達九龍理容KTV 酒店。

周世杰表示「你到『阿九』（指九龍理容KTV）那裡。」

顯示周世杰再次詢問被告戊○○是否已抵達九龍理容KTV 。

戊○○表示「對呀，怎麼。」

證明被告戊○○已抵達九龍理容KTV 。

戊○○表示「啊，到了，你，幾號，那個了嗎。」

顯示被告戊○○詢問至九龍理容KTV 何包廂。

周世杰表示「『121 』（指九龍理容KTV 編號121 包廂）。」

及「『121 』、『121 』」。

戊○○表示「OK，OK，好好好好。」

戊○○表示「我就停。」

顯示被告戊○○在停車。

且有關於被告戊○○於前揭時間正在停車之情，並有調查員拍攝被告戊○○在停車之蒐證照片可證。

⑨2008年2 月12日16時40分3 秒至18時57分46秒數通證人廉裕隆之通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第176 至180 頁），並經該人廉裕隆於偵查中證稱係對話無訛如下：廉裕隆持用之行動電話基地台位置均在九龍理容KTV 酒店，通話背景有有女侍KTV 歌唱聲。

廉裕隆也表示「喔，在唱歌，沒那麼早。」

證明廉裕隆亦在九龍理容KTV 。

⑩2008年2 月12日20時17分45秒，楊雅惠與戊○○通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第180 至 181頁），並經該二人於偵查中證稱係其等對話無訛：楊雅惠表示「你在哪裡呀。」

戊○○表示「我在前面呀。」

、「不是呀，你剛才下車往前走就是呀。」

、「不是呀，你可能走錯邊吧，來來來。」

、「有啦，你可能走錯邊了啦。」

及「沒有，你自己走錯邊了吧。」

證明被告戊○○偕楓之林理容 KTV編號66號小姐楊雅惠出場。

楊雅惠表示「喔，喔喔喔喔。」

及「喔，我看到。」

證明戊○○偕楓之林理容KTV 編號66號小姐楊雅惠出場。

⑪2008年2 月12日20時35分49秒，徐玉玲與廉裕隆通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第181 至182頁），並經該二人於偵查中證稱係其等對話無訛：徐玉玲表示「抱歉，我跟你報告一下，『老闆』（指局長戊○○）又要把那個小姐買到1 點啦。」

、「1 點，再補4 鐘點。」

、「8 ，9 ，10，11，12。」

及「9 ，10，11，12，1 點，5 個小時喔，8 點到1 點。」

顯示徐玉玲向廉裕隆反應被告戊○○延長女侍楊雅惠出場時間5 個鐘點。

）廉裕隆表示「好啦，有遇到他可能會再跟我講啦。」

顯示廉裕隆允諾支付酒店小姐女侍出場費。

徐玉玲表示「嗯，這樣，這樣我先幫你補起來，改天有來你再補簽就好，好嗎。」

要求廉裕隆改日再補簽帳。

廉裕隆表示「好呀，好呀。」

顯示廉裕隆允諾簽帳。

⑫2008年2 月12日20時40分27秒，徐玉玲與戊○○通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第183 頁），並經該2人於偵查中證稱係其等對話無訛：徐玉玲表示「嗯，她後面的有補了。

（指廉裕隆已允諾為戊○○支付女侍出場費用）」、「嗯，我有跟『阿隆』（指廉裕隆）講。」

及「嗯，補到1 點，喔。」

證明戊○○透過徐玉玲要求廉裕隆支付女侍出場費用。

戊○○表示「喔，這樣喔。」

、「OK，好，好，我知道。」

及「我知道，我知道，我知道。」

證明戊○○透過徐玉玲要求廉裕隆支付女侍出場費用之不正利益。

⑬2008年2 月12日21時9 分15秒，楊雅惠與戊○○通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第184 頁），並經該2人於偵查中證稱係其等對話無訛：楊雅惠表示「喂，你開回到家裡了嗎。」

戊○○表示「我到家了，到家了。」

證明被告戊○○偕楓之林理容KTV 編號66號小姐楊雅惠出場至不詳地點後，被告戊○○返家。

⑭證人楊雅惠於偵查中證稱：「我曾經在麗都理容KTV 及金錢豹擔任坐檯小姐，於96年12月15日轉任至臺中市惠中路『楓之林理容KTV 』擔任坐檯小姐迄今，我的代號為『66號』，負責陪客人喝酒、唱歌。」

、「我認識戊○○，我皆稱呼他為許大哥。」

、「約於97年1 、2 月間，戊○○至『楓之林理容KTV 』消費，經由『楓之林理容KTV 』公關主任、綽號『淑萍』安排我坐檯而認識戊○○，我與戊○○並無私交，到目前為止我曾經坐戊○○檯約4 次，其中包括戊○○1 次帶我出場前往『九龍理容KTV 』消費。」

、「97年2 月12日20時17分以我本人持用之0000-000000 撥打戊○○持用之0000-000000 ，戊○○約於97年2 月12日15時左右與4 、5 個朋友（何人我不清楚）前來『楓之林理容KTV 』消費，由我坐檯服務，約於18時左右戊○○與其友人帶我出場，先赴朝富路上的大肥鵝現炒店吃晚餐後，再赴『九龍理容KTV 』消費，至當晚約20時左右，戊○○與我先行離開。」

等語（見偵卷五，第117 、118 頁），可見被告戊○○當日有偕「楓之林理容KTV 」編號66號小姐楊雅惠出場無疑。

⑮扣押物編號A-11-1之帳冊資料，其上記載：1.川順公司「沖帳碼資料表」內載97年2 月12日有「17,150」元及「6,000 」元消費，共計23,150元，其中6000元即係戊○○偕出侍出場之費用5 小時，每小時1200元，「沖帳碼資料表」內載另載戴泱丞於97年2 月28日至九龍酒店之消費6000元，川順公司於97年3 月25日併上述 23150元及6000元，開立2 萬9150元支票。

而徐玉玲於川順公司97年3 月25日「支票收訖簽回單」中簽名並蓋「九龍名店」店章，徐玉玲收到川順公司以合庫- 中港票號J00000000 支票支付之酒款2 萬9150元，（其中6000元為97年2 月28日戴泱丞之消費），97年5 月25日支票到期，（見97年度偵字第10922 號卷3 ，第92至95頁、第152 頁），以及扣押物編號21-2：川順公司97年交際費傳票，其上記載川順公司97年3 月25日「轉帳傳票」，內載「便餐費」、「九龍名店」、「2/12廉裕隆」、「17,150」及「6,000 」，併同97年2 月28日之消費，開立97年5 月25日到期支票，票號：JT0000000 。

並有九龍酒店「本票」2 紙，內載「壹萬柒仟壹佰伍拾元整」、「17150 」、「廉裕隆2/12」、「川順」、「連保人秀」及「97年2 月12日」；

「陸仟元整」、「6000」、「川順楓補66至1 點」及「97年2 月12日」。

「九龍名店消費請款單」內載「川順先生」、「消費日97年2 月12日」、「金額17150 」及「金額6000」等，徐玉玲於備註欄署名「秀秀」（見偵卷五，第168 至171 頁）。

可見被告戊○○於該日所喝花酒及與酒店小姐楊雅惠出場費用，均係接受川順公司招待之不正利益，至屬明確。

⑯證人徐玉玲於偵查中證稱：「該2 張簽帳本票是廉裕隆在97年2 月12日在九龍酒店消費之簽帳本票，其中本票金額6,000 元上特別註記『川順、楓補66至1 點』是指當天廉裕隆有叫楓之林酒店66號小姐到九龍酒店坐檯陪酒唱歌，當日我先與廉裕隆結第1 筆帳17,150元，其後因故再替楓之林酒店66號小姐買5 個小時的出場鐘點，每小時1,200 元，因此我再列記此筆6,000 元費用，前述2 筆帳款有關66號小姐到九龍酒店坐檯陪酒之時數再加計5 小時出場鐘點費用，事後我會向九龍酒店的關係企業楓之林酒店謝總經理對帳。」

（見偵卷五，第 193頁）；

「（97年2 月12日廉裕隆簽帳9950元是與何人前往消費？）廉裕隆本人，如果我記得沒有錯，戊○○也有一同前往。」

、「（當天20時35分你與廉裕隆的通聯譯文稱『抱歉我跟你報告一下，老闆又要把那個小姐買到一點了』，是何意思？）當天戊○○帶．．出場，本來一開始是要買到三個鐘點，但是小姐後來回報跟我講說戊○○要再繼續買他的鐘點，繼續買到凌晨一點，所以我打電話跟廉裕隆講，因為廉裕隆跟我說當日的帳，由廉裕隆處理。」

、「（買到隔日的凌晨一點還要補多少錢？）總共多5 個小時6 千元。」

、「（事後你通聯譯文中你跟戊○○稱大哥，他後面的有補了，我有跟阿隆講，是何意思？）就是我跟戊○○說，我有跟廉裕隆講。」

等語（97年度偵字第10922 號卷3 第53、54頁）。

⑰綜上證據資料，且被告戊○○亦坦承當日有前往該酒店消費，是被告戊○○於上開時地，確有應川順公司之邀約，接受川順公司招待喝花酒，而收受川順公司給付之不正利益，實屬明確，至堪認定之。

(16)被告戊○○確實有於97年3 月3 日，應廉裕隆之邀，在「楓之林理容KTV 」酒店喝花酒，消費金額41,850元，由川順公司經理廉裕隆簽立本票，再由川順公司97年 4月25日「傳票清單」項下支付（詳如附表三，編號15），證據如次：①證人周世杰於偵查中證稱：「97年3 月3 日我有和戊○○、林榮紹、廉裕隆前往楓之林理容KTV ，詳細情形為：廉裕隆於97年3 月3 日到水利署洽公，透過戊○○或林榮紹邀我去有女陪侍的KTV 唱歌（記不清楚是戊○○或林榮紹邀我的），．．我跟廉裕隆也不熟，我不會直接打電話給廉裕隆，我打這通電話給廉裕隆不是我自己的意思要打的，因為我不是主客，我更不會拿主意決定要去楓之林理容KTV ，也不會自己拿主意打給廉裕隆。

」、「我只是應戊○○之邀前往的陪客，另因我患有僵直性脊椎炎不能久坐，故我先行離開，我亦沒有支付相關的消費費用，至於何人買單，我不清楚。」

、「因為我不是主客，廉裕隆不會是要請我，想當然爾，廉裕隆不是要請戊○○就是要請林榮紹，我記不清楚是誰指示我打該通電話，我接到林榮紹或戊○○的邀約之後，便與林榮紹從水利署搭車前往楓之林理容KTV ，我確實忘記是誰要我打這通電話。」

、「我與林榮紹、廉裕隆已於楓之林理容KTV ，因戊○○尚未抵達，我打電話給戊○○是要告訴他我與林榮紹、廉裕隆已經在楓之林理容KTV 。」

、「我確定戊○○當天有到楓之林理容KTV 參與該場邀宴。」

（見偵卷八，第238 、239 頁）。

②2008年3 月3 日13時24分25秒，戊○○與林榮紹通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第189 頁），並經該2人於偵查中證稱係其等對話無訛：林榮紹表示「我在『小仙屋』（音譯）。」

表示林榮紹在小仙屋餐廳。

戊○○表示「這樣喔，你若結束時叫『阿隆』（指廉裕隆）來我這裡一下。」

顯示廉裕隆亦在小仙屋餐廳。

③2008年3 月3 日13時58分32秒，戊○○與戴沼澤通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第190 頁），並經該2人於偵查中證稱係對話無訛：戊○○表示「那個，叫『阿隆』（指廉裕隆）過來一下好嗎。」

及「不是，不是，不是，嗯，嗯，你叫他過來，我跟他講。」

顯示被告戊○○要求戴沼澤指派廉裕隆前來。

戴沼澤表示「好，好。」

④2008年3 月3 日13時59分19秒，戴沼澤與廉裕隆通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第190 至191頁），並經該二人於偵查中證稱係對話無訛：戴沼澤表示「你載『林榮紹』去，他們『水政組』（指水利署水利行政組）要解決這種問題，要講給『局長』（指戊○○）聽，叫你去解釋，你和『林榮紹』過去，你說叫他們。」

及「他在那裡等呀。」

，亦即戴沼澤於電話中指示廉裕隆前往被告戊○○所在，及要求戴沼澤被告戊○○解決問題。

廉裕隆表示「喔。」

⑤2008年3 月3 日14時24分11秒，戴沼澤與廉裕隆通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第191 至 192頁），並經該2人於偵查中證稱係其等對話無訛：廉裕隆表示「剛出發一下子，我剛才有．．，還在那裡啦。」

及「還在那裡，我現在載『科長』（指林榮紹）要過去。」

顯示廉裕隆載送林榮紹前往被告戊○○所在。

戴沼澤表示「對呀，看要做什麼，你要跟我講一下。」

⑥2008年3 月3 日15時58分13秒，周世杰與戊○○通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第194 頁），並經該2人於偵查中證稱係其等對話無訛：周世杰表示「我在『高速公路下』（指楓之林理容 KTV）啦。」

提醒被告戊○○是在至楓之林酒店接受川順公司招待。

戊○○表示「OK，我知道，我知道。」

⑦2008年3 月3 日17時57分40秒至17時59分52秒間，戊○○通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第195 至196 頁）顯示戊○○所持用之行動電話基地台位置均在楓之林酒店。

⑧2008年3 月3 日16時46分38秒至18時12分17秒間，廉裕隆通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第195 至197 頁）顯示廉裕隆所持用之行動電話基地台位置均在楓之林酒店。

⑨2008年3 月3 日18時11分05秒，廉裕隆配偶與廉裕隆通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第191 至192 頁），並經廉裕隆於偵查中證稱係對話無訛：廉裕隆持用之行動電話基地台位置於楓之林酒店。

廉裕隆表示「在唱歌。」

證明其仍在楓之林酒店。

妻表示「在台中喔。」

詢問是否在台中酒店唱歌。

廉裕隆表示「對呀。」

、及「喔，下午就到現在。」

證明下午起即開始招待不正利益。

妻表示「下午到現在，還沒要走嗎。」

詢問是否將結束。

廉裕隆表示「半個下午啦。」

、「半個下午啦。」

及「喔，愈來愈大群。」

證明已於楓之林酒店招待數名公務員半個下午。

妻表示「愈來愈大群，你就錢趕快付一付，趕快走就好了。」

要廉裕隆支付酒店消費後離開回家。

廉裕隆表示「不是我說要走就要走。」

⑩2008年3 月3 日20時57分32秒，廉裕隆與張淑惠通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第199 至 202頁），並經該2人於偵查中證稱係其等對話無訛：廉裕隆表示「對呀，沒人跟你通報嗎。」

及「沒有，啊， 『那個』（指楓之林理容KTV 幹部綽號『淑萍』）說跟你多好，都騙你的。」

證明本日由楓之林酒店幹部淑萍（本名陳俞容）接待、安排女侍。

張淑惠表示「『那個』是哪一個呀。」

及「我姊，『淑萍』嗎。」

證明本日由楓之林酒店幹部淑萍（本名陳俞容）接待、安排女侍。

張淑惠表示「你在『楓之林』（指楓之林理容KTV ）喝酒喔。」

詢問廉裕隆是否於楓之林酒店喝酒。

廉裕隆表示「對呀，『那個』說跟你很好。」

⑪證人陳俞容於偵查中證稱：「我在95年4 月間開始到台中市惠中路『楓之林理容KTV 』工作，擔任公關主任迄今。」

、「陳玉瑛打電話給我說有一個叫戊○○的人要來，叫我負責打理，他們是5 、6 個人來，何人出錢的我不清楚。」

等語（見偵卷1 ，第116 頁）。

⑫扣押物編號一之楓之林日記帳，其上記載謝翠芬應收帳本於97年3 月3 日記載「廉裕隆」、「41850 」及「轉鄧」，證明川順公司支付本（3 ）日楓之林酒店飲宴費用。

以及扣押物編號壹-3之傳票清單，其上記載：川順公司97年4 月25日「傳票清單」，內載「3/3 便餐費」、「楓之林」、「41,850」，及「應付票據」、「楓之林JZ000000000/06/25」，開立97年6 月25日到期支票，票號JT0000000 。

可見被告戊○○於該日喝花酒費用，係接受川順公司招待之不正利益，即為明確。

⑬綜上證據資料，且被告戊○○亦坦承當日有前往該酒店消費，是其確有受廉裕隆之邀，而收受川順公司給付喝花酒之不正利益，實屬明確，至堪認定之。

(17)被告戊○○確實曾於97年3 月14日，應戴沼澤之邀在「楓之林理容KTV 」酒店喝花酒，消費金額13,200元，由劉禎忠先行代戴沼澤簽帳於楓之林理容KTV 董事謝翠芬應收帳款下，再由川順公司支付（詳如附表三，編號16），證據資料整理如下：①證人陳玉瑛於偵查中證稱：「（97年3 月14日有無去楓之林理容KTV ？）有，當天是我先打電話給楓之林理容KTV 的淑萍，因為戊○○的同學顏沛華要去楓之林，我打電話給淑萍先按排一個小姐給顏沛華先接待他，後來我約下午5 時許，我先到達楓之林，戊○○約6 時許到，後來戴沼澤及劉禎忠、林榮紹陸續到達，我們唱歌唱了一晚，我跟戊○○先走，因為戊○○的老婆打電話來催他回家。」

等語（見偵卷1 ，第160 頁）。

②2008年3 月14日16時52分06秒，陳玉瑛與戊○○通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第237 至238頁），並經該2人於偵查中證稱係其等對話無訛：戊○○持用之行動電話基地台位置在川順公司旱溪天祥街招待所。

戊○○表示「那個，那個現在我們『顏同學』（指顏沛華）要過去喔。」

及「他現在要過去，可能差不多10分鐘左右喔。」

顯示顏沛華將前往楓之林理容KTV 。

陳玉瑛表示「就到『那邊』（指楓之林理容KTV ）了。

」、「你說『那裡』（指楓之林理容KTV ），我已經給他弄1 個OK了。」

表示陳玉瑛已交代楓之林酒店安排女侍陪顏沛華。

戊○○表示「你就給他排好就好呀。」

及「你去跟他排好啦。」

指示陳玉瑛安排酒店小姐陪侍。

陳玉瑛表示「我知道，我知道啦。」

及「OK，好好，我安排，好。」

③2008年3 月14日16時55分45秒，陳玉瑛與戊○○通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第238 頁），並經該2 人於偵查中證稱係其等對話無訛：陳玉瑛表示「你跟『顏大哥』（指顏沛華）喔，打電話跟他講，說他到的時候找1 個『淑萍』）。」

「『淑萍阿母』，你跟他講一下，啊，因為我差不多半個鐘頭才會到。」

、「說叫他找『淑萍』喔。」

及「我應該『發落』（台語，指安排女侍），都『發落』。」

顯示陳玉瑛已依被告戊○○之指示，交代楓之林酒店幹部淑萍（本名陳俞容）安排女侍陪酒飲宴。

④2008年3 月14日16時56分38秒、17時15分50秒，戊○○與顏沛華通訊監察錄音及譯文譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第239 頁），並經戊○○於偵查中證稱係其間對話無訛：戊○○表示「找1 個幹部叫『淑萍』（音譯）」及「幹部 叫「淑萍」，喔，他會幫你安排好。」

顏沛華表示「同學，我已經到了。」

戊○○表示「我後面跟著過去。」

顯示被告戊○○隨後亦前往楓之林理容KTV 。

⑤2008年3 月14日17時55分29秒，戴沼澤與劉禎忠通訊監察錄音及譯文：戴沼澤表示「我想要，現在不要說，是你來『楓仔』（楓之林理容KTV ）一下啦。」

邀約劉禎忠同往楓之林理容KTV 與被告戊○○喝花酒。

劉禎忠表示「好，『楓仔』嗎。」

及「好，好，好。」

（允諾）⑥2008年3 月14日18時33分45秒，戴沼澤與配偶通訊監察錄音及譯文內容並經戴沼澤於偵查中證稱係對話無訛（見原審甲卷，譯文本第242 頁以下）：戴沼澤表示「我和，晚上喔，和『長仔』（指戊○○）他們那些會出來，出來吃飯一下喔。」

證明與被告戊○○與戴沼澤聚會。

⑦2008年3 月14日18時50分01秒，戴沼澤與廉裕隆通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第243 至 244頁），並經該2人於偵查中證稱係其等對話無訛：戴沼澤持用之行動電話基地台位置在楓之林理容KTV 酒店 。

戴沼澤背景有KTV歌唱聲、女侍聲。

戴沼澤表示「還是你要，看要過來『楓』（指楓之林理容KTV ）一下，不然他們不知道要到什麼時候，我要回去了。」

，證明被告戊○○仍在楓之林酒店接受招待，戴沼澤要廉裕隆先來接他回去。

⑧2008年3 月14日20時25分28秒，戴沼澤與劉禎忠通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見原審甲卷，譯文本第246 至 248頁），並經該2人於偵查中證稱係其等對話無訛：劉禎忠背景有KTV歌唱聲，證明於於楓之林酒店內。

戴沼澤表示「我在外面啦，你來外面聽，電話拿出來外面聽，我跟你講。」

劉禎忠表示「你在哪裡，我現在走出來了。」

戴沼澤表示「不是啦，你那個，現在就是他們『連教授』（指連惠邦）他們要進來啦喔。」

、「啊，那些『女孩』（指楓之林理容KTV 女侍）就是你不要花啦，那就叫人來花的，你知道嗎。」

、「你現在退1 局啦，好嗎，喔。」

及「那一局我們自己處理啦，啊，那局讓他們去處理啦，不然『那些』（指連惠邦等人）又進來，從中午就去了，就2 個就，對否。」

顯示戴沼澤表示本日酒店消費由其付款，證明本日戊○○係收受戴沼澤給付酒店消費之不正利益。

⑨臺中市調查站於97年3 月14日在該酒店之蒐證照片，照片顯示：⑴戊○○公務座車9063-SG 停放於惠中路市政北七路口。

⑵戊○○步出楓之林酒店。

⑶戴沼澤步出楓之林酒店，廉裕隆到場接戴沼澤。

（見97年度聲搜字第14號第17至19頁、第20至21頁背面）⑩證人劉禎忠於偵查中證稱：「我未曾主動邀約戊○○、林榮紹、周世杰至有女陪侍之酒店飲宴，戊○○、林榮紹經常至川順公司找戴沼澤，其等人用餐吃飯時戴沼澤亦會找我陪同，用餐完後偶而會至有女陪侍之酒店飲宴，因此我亦陪同前往。

．．97年3 月14日晚上7 點是戴沼澤主動打電話要我至臺中市楓之林理容KTV ，說要找我喝酒，約20分鐘之後我就到了，當時我事先不知尚有何人在場，經我與戴沼澤碰面後才知現場尚有戊○○、林榮紹及戊○○之顏姓友人（詳細名字不清楚）及另1名楓之林理容KTV 編號1 號之女子（真實姓名我並不清楚）。

我們在酒店唱歌、喝酒，喝到晚上11時許離開。

期間林榮紹、戴沼澤分別先行離去，戴沼澤離去後不久主動打電話給我，叫我處理一下買單的事情，最後我去買單，戊○○就說他要處理，結果沒有繳，因為我、戊○○和酒店都很熟，結果我們都沒有繳錢就離開了，二個星期之後，他們的小姐就打電話給我，叫我去繳錢，我也一直沒有去繳。」

、「（當天消費多少？）1 萬 3千多元。」

、「97年3 月14日當天，雖然戊○○不讓我支付，但戊○○當天亦無支付該款項，但經2 個星期後，楓之林理容KTV 的小姐打電話向我表示，該次約1 萬餘元的款項尚未處理，我才知道戊○○、戴沼澤等並未支付該筆費用。」

、「97年3 月14日當天我有刷了2 萬多元的帳，但這是我97年1 月間我去消費一筆2 萬多元的帳。」

、「（提示扣押物編號一：楓之林日記帳乙冊，．．該帳冊記載『3/14劉禎忠13200 』是否即為你前述與戊○○等人於97年3 月14日在楓之林理容KTV 之消費款項？）是的。」

等語（見偵卷一第103 、104 頁）。

⑪扣押物編號一之楓之林日記帳，其上記載：謝翠芬應收帳本於97年3 月14日記載「劉禎忠」及「13200 」。

可證劉禎忠係代川順公司簽帳本（3 ）日楓之林酒店飲宴費用。

（見偵卷一，第94頁）⑫綜上證據資料，且被告戊○○亦坦承當日有前往該酒店消費，故被告戊○○應戴沼澤之邀接受川順公司招待喝花酒，而收受川順公司給付之不正利益，至為明確，堪以認定之。

㈢認定被告壬○○有要求，進而收受川順公司給付如附表四所示在有女陪侍之酒店消費之不正利益之證據及理由：⒈被告壬○○確實有於96年10月8 日，與周世杰在「麗登理容KTV 」酒店喝花酒，消費金額14,350元，消費當日透過李幼綢以電話要求川順公司經理廉裕隆支付，由廉裕隆事後簽認帳款，該筆消費再由川順公司97年3 月25日「轉帳傳票」支付等情，業據證人李幼綢於偵查中證稱：我認識壬○○，也是由川順公司戴沼澤招待來店消費而認識，壬○○大部分是由川順公司戴沼澤或廉裕隆陪同來店消費，花費是由川順公司支付，壬○○只有於96年10月間與水利署周科長一起前來麗登理容KTV 店消費，花費的帳款壬○○交待我向川順公司請款。

96年10月間壬○○與周世杰來麗登理容KTV 消費，花費大約1 萬餘元，因壬○○不願自己簽帳，是我幫忙簽帳背書，事後再向川順公司請款。

只有1 次於96年10月間與壬○○一起來消費，壬○○交待我向川順公司請款。

我確信96年10月8 日當天周世杰及壬○○有在麗登理容KTV 消費。

我通知川順公司廉裕隆來店裡，目的是處理當天消費的帳款，但廉裕隆告訴我他人在谷關，無法前來。

廉裕隆因無法親自來店裡處理，但壬○○指示我當天的消費約1 萬餘元仍然向川順公司請款，我在公司要求結帳時，曾與廉裕隆聯絡，要將帳單寄到川順公司請款，但廉裕隆表示他並沒有到場，不清楚壬○○等人消費的情形，我等了很久都沒有消息，所以我自己先墊付1 萬餘元跟公司結帳，但我不甘心自行吸收該筆帳款，所以到了97年3 月間，我再度向廉裕隆請款，廉裕隆雖然不高興，但最後我有將簽帳單寄到川順公司，川順公司也有將該筆帳款14,350元以現金透過廉裕隆交給我。

（提示扣押物編號21-2，川順公司97年交際費傳票）該傳票上所附之本票是麗登理容KTV 客人簽帳所使用之本票，因在店裡消費的公務員都不會自己簽名，所以沒有客人的簽名，廉裕隆也信賴我，所以雖然沒有客人簽名，因消費當時我有先打電話跟廉裕隆知會，所以他還是有付款給我。

至於傳票上記載是『應付票據』，可能因我當時已經離開麗登理容KTV ，不方便提示票據，最後是廉裕隆交付現金給我的等語（見偵卷九，第199 至202 頁）；

及於原審審理時證稱：「（林榮紹與戴沼澤或廉裕隆到店內消費的時候，由誰支付這些款項？）那時候用寄單的。」

、「（最後是誰付錢？帳單寄給誰？）寄給川順。」

、「（壬○○曾經單獨到店內消費過嗎？）沒有。」

、「（有跟廉裕隆或戴沼澤到店內嗎？）有。」

、「（怎麼支付這些款項？）寄單給川順。」

、「（你有沒有印象戊○○或者是林榮紹、壬○○到店裡，而沒有廉裕隆或戴沼澤一起到店內消費的這種情形？）有一次他們喝酒醉，大家看喝酒醉，在那裡不好談。」

、「（他們是誰？）就是壬○○、周世杰，只有看到他們二個，然後我是聽他們說林榮紹沒有進店裡就走了。」

、「（你看一下這個筆錄，壬○○只有在96年10月間跟水利署周世杰一起前來麗登理容KTV 消費，花費的帳款，壬○○交代我向川順請款？）對。」

、「（所以是壬○○交代你向川順請款？）對。」

、「（因為壬○○不願自己簽帳，是否幫忙簽帳背書，事後再向川順請款？）對。」

、「（接下來，在中間那裡，你認識水利署科長周世杰，這一段開始，你說只有一次於96年10月間跟壬○○一起來消費，如前述，壬○○交代我向川順請款？）對。」

、「（請問你到底是壬○○要你去向川順請款，還是林榮紹要求你去跟川順請款？）那時候是壬○○，因為林榮紹沒有進來公司就走了。」

、「（所謂沒有進來公司的意思，你講清楚一點？）就是說林榮紹沒有進來就走了，我沒有見到他的人。」

、「（你沒有見到他的人？）對。」

、「（哪一個人？）林榮紹，那一天沒有看到他。」

、「（你既然沒有看到林榮紹，你怎麼知道林榮紹也有去？）因為他們有說。」

、「（他們怎麼說？誰說的？）壬○○跟周世杰說林榮紹先走了。」

、「（所以說你是聽他們二位說的？）對。」

、「（你自己沒有親眼看到？）我沒有看到。」

、「（當天的消費，到底是誰叫你去跟廉裕隆請款的？）壬○○跟周世杰。」

、「（那有包括壬○○，他是怎麼跟你說的？）他本來要叫我叫廉裕隆來，但是他們沒空，然後到最後他們就說你把帳單寄過去就好，他們有跟廉裕隆說。」

、「（那你在打給廉裕隆的電話中，你怎麼完全都沒有提到壬○○？）因為我找壬○○跟周世杰都一樣，他們二個一起來的。」

、「（當天壬○○有沒有請你打電話給廉裕隆，然後跟他說請他過來付錢？）對，他們二人都有。」

等語屬實，並有2007年10月8 日17時28分21秒，李幼綢與廉裕隆通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見偵卷九，第189 頁）可稽，且扣押物編號21-2之川順公司97年交際費傳票，其上記載：川順公司97年3 月25日轉帳傳票內載「麗登名店」、「96/10/8 便餐費」及「14,350」。

並有麗登酒店簽帳本票內載「壹萬肆仟參佰伍拾元整」、「14350 」及「發票日中華民國96年10月8 日」（見偵卷九，第195 、196 頁），而被告壬○○亦坦承當日有前往該酒店消費，顯見本（8 ）日，係被告壬○○與周世杰在該酒店喝花酒，被告林榮紹則未到場，且消費款項係由川順公司所支付無訛。

⒉被告壬○○確實有於97年1 月16日，在「香格里拉（原名金拿獎）理容KTV 」酒店喝花酒，期間要求陳秀月電洽廉裕隆支付本次消費金額帳款經應允後，該次喝花酒之消費金額9 千1 百元，由川順公司經理廉裕隆簽立本票，再由川順公司97年4 月25日「轉帳傳票」項下支付等情，業據證人陳秀月於偵查中證稱：是在店內認識壬○○的，97年1 月間壬○○曾到店中消費，壬○○曾借用我的電話打給廉裕隆，他們後來也叫我接聽，說帳單放著他會派人來跟我結等語明確（見偵卷1 ，第106 、108 頁），核與證人林榮紹於偵查中供稱：97年1 月16日中午我、壬○○及第三河川局人員與川順公司總經理戴永恭等在台中市向上路『鶴園餐廳』聚餐，由川順公司買單，聚餐席間壬○○要到金拿獎視聽歌唱坊飲酒作樂，所以餐後大家就一起到金拿獎視聽歌唱坊飲酒作樂，並叫來小姐坐台陪酒，當天最後是川順公司廉裕隆簽帳付款的等語（見偵卷4 ，第83頁）相符，並有2008年1 月16日14時25分54秒，林榮紹、陳秀月與廉裕隆通訊監察錄音及譯文內容、2008年1 月16日14時29分16秒，壬○○與戴沼澤通訊監察錄音及譯文內容、2008年1 月16日14時32分54秒，陳秀月與廉裕隆通訊監察錄音及譯文內容、2008年1 月16日14時47分32秒，廉裕隆與壬○○通訊監察錄音及譯文內容、2008年1 月16日14時55分01秒，廉裕隆與陳秀月通訊監察錄音及譯文內容、2008年1 月16日16時8 分10秒，林榮紹與廉裕隆通訊監察錄音及譯文內容、2008年1 月16日16時36分58秒，林榮紹與廉裕隆通訊監察錄音及譯文內容、2008年1 月16日17時49分48秒，戴沼澤與廉裕隆通訊監察錄音及譯文內容在卷可按（見原審甲卷，譯文本第154 至164 頁）。

且扣押物編號16-17 之川順公司96年8 月至97年3 月傳票清單，其上記載：「97年1 月14日支出寶麗晶理容KTV 費用。

97年1 月14日支出九龍理容KTV 費用。」

（見偵卷4 ，第75至76頁），以及扣押物編號21-2之川順公司97年交際費傳票，其上記載：「便餐費」、「金拿獎」、「1/16便餐」及「9,100 」，併同1 月3 日之消費開立97年4 月25日到期支票，票號：JT0000000 。

並有金拿獎簽帳本票內載「金拿獎」、「商業本票存根」、「玖仟壹佰元整」、「9100」、「廉裕隆元/16 」及「97年1 月16日」（見偵卷4 ，第72至74頁）。

可見本日被告壬○○、林榮紹至該酒店喝花酒之消費款項，係由川順公司所支付招待無疑。

⒊被告壬○○確實有於97年2 月12日，在「九龍理容KTV 」有女陪侍之酒店與被告戊○○及周世杰等人接受廉裕隆招待喝花酒，消費金額計17,150元，均由川順公司經理廉裕隆簽立本票，再由川順公司97年3 月25日「轉帳傳票」項下支付等情，業據證人周世杰於偵查中證稱：「97年2 月12日當天我不是應戊○○就是應壬○○之邀才到九龍理容KTV 。

壬○○有打電話告訴我他們已經到了九龍理容KTV，所以我才會再次打電話給徐玉玲確認。

我先前打電話問徐玉玲壬○○到九龍理容KTV 了沒有，徐玉玲打電話跟我回報壬○○已經到九龍理容KTV ，並由徐玉玲接待到編號121 包廂。

因為我當天在川順公司旱溪天祥街之組合木屋附近，所以就近搭乘阿隆（廉裕隆）的車子前往九龍理容KTV ，但為什麼我會坐他的車子，我記不清楚。

壬○○已經在九龍理容KTV ，他用徐玉玲的電話打給我，壬○○表示說我遲到了，所以壬○○用粗話消遣我，我就回他說再5 分鐘就到了。

我先到九龍理容KTV 編號121 包廂，故我向戊○○表示已經抵達，我在121 包廂裡面大多跟戊○○、壬○○聊天。

我先行離開，我亦沒有支付相關的消費費用，至於何人買單，我不清楚。」

等語屬實（見偵卷八，第236 、237 頁），並有2008年2 月12日16時6 分37秒，周世杰與徐玉玲通訊監察錄音及譯文內容、2008年2 月12日16時14分34秒，徐玉玲與周世杰通訊監察錄音及譯文內容、2008年2 月12日16時15分53秒，徐玉玲、壬○○與周世杰通訊監察錄音及譯文內容在卷可參（見原審甲卷，譯文本第172 至174 頁）。

且扣押物編號A-11-1之帳冊資料，其上記載：川順公司「沖帳碼資料表」內載97年2 月12日有「17,150」元及「6,000 」元消費，共計23,150元，其中6000元即係戊○○偕女侍出場之費用5 小時，每小時1200元，「沖帳碼資料表」內載戴泱丞於97年2 月28日至九龍酒店之消費6000元，川順公司於97年3 月25日併上述23150 元及6000元，開立2 萬9150元支票。

而徐玉玲於川順公司97年3 月25日「支票收訖簽回單」中簽名並蓋「九龍名店」店章，徐玉玲收到川順公司以合庫- 中港票號J10000000 支票支付之酒款2 萬9150元，（其中6000元為97年2 月28日戴泱丞之消費），97年5 月25日支票到期，（見97年度偵字第10922 號卷3 ，第92至95頁、第152 頁），以及扣押物編號21-2：川順公司97年交際費傳票，其上記載川順公司97年3 月25日「轉帳傳票」，內載「便餐費」、「九龍名店」、「2/12廉裕隆」、「17,150」及「6,000 」，併同97年2 月28日之消費，開立97年5 月25日到期支票，票號：JT0000000 。

並有九龍酒店「本票」2 紙，內載「壹萬柒仟壹佰伍拾元整」、「17150 」、「廉裕隆2/12」、「川順」、「連保人秀」及「97年2 月12日」；

「陸仟元整」、「6000」、「川順楓補66至1 點」及「97年2 月12日」。

「九龍名店消費請款單」內載「川順先生」、「消費日97年2 月12日」、「金額17150 」及「金額6000」等，徐玉玲於備註欄署名「秀秀」（見偵卷五，第168 至171 頁）。

可見被告壬○○與同案被告戊○○於本日至該酒店喝花酒，而接受川順公司招待喝花酒。

⒋被告壬○○確實有於97年3 月25日，去電廉裕隆要求招待本次消費帳款經應允後，該次在「香格里拉（原名金拿獎）理容KTV 」酒店喝花酒，消費金額7,100 元，由川順公司經理廉裕隆簽帳，再由川順公司97年4 月25日「傳票清單」項下支付等情，業據證人陳秀月於偵查中證稱：97年3 月底，壬○○到店裡消費，又曾借用我的電話打給廉裕隆，廉裕隆表示帳單放著他會派人來跟我結等語屬實（見偵卷1 ，第108 頁），並有2008年3 月25日14時34分18秒，壬○○、林榮紹與廉裕隆通訊監察錄音及譯文內容、2008年3 月25日16時38分37秒，壬○○與廉裕隆通訊監察錄音及譯文內容、2008年3 月25日16時49分36秒，廉裕隆與陳秀月通訊監察錄音及譯文內容、2008年3 月25日17時17分46秒，林榮紹與廉裕隆通訊監察錄音及譯文內容可按（見原審甲卷，譯文本第255 至259 頁），且被告壬○○於偵查中亦自承：「該通電話我主要是邀請廉裕隆一起來香格里拉理容KTV 喝酒，當天我大約是下午2 點半左右與林榮紹一起前往該酒店，由『阿華』出面接待並安排小姐坐檯陪侍飲酒，由於我當天喝醉，所以不記得何時離開該酒店。」

、「該通電話我主要是再次催促廉裕隆一起來香格里拉理容KTV 喝酒。」

、「我是打電話給廉裕隆，拜託廉裕隆轉告川順公司董事長戴沼澤支付當天酒店帳款。」

、「我確曾打電話拜託廉裕隆轉告川順公司董事長戴沼澤支付97年3 月25日當天在香格里拉理容KTV 飲酒帳款。」

等語明確（見偵卷十，第232 頁正反面）。

另扣押物編號壹-3之傳票清單，其上記載：97年4 月25日傳票清單內載「便餐費」、「3/25便餐」、「金拿獎」及「7,100 」，併同3 月17日之消費開立97年6 月25日到期支票，票號：JT0000000 。

可見被告壬○○於本日至該酒店喝花酒費用，係接受川順公司之招待。

㈣至證人戴沼澤、廉裕隆於原審審理時雖陳述：是因被告戊○○及壬○○曾經招待其等前往酒店消費，互有付款情事，故上開時地前往酒店消費為其等之支出，乃請客之性質，係屬雙方社交往來等云云，被告戊○○及壬○○亦同為如此辯解，被告壬○○另辯稱：伊亦曾於其他時間曾前往酒店消費係自己付帳，本案確實係友人間互相招待云云。

然查：就被告戊○○接受招待之前情中，多有證人戴沼澤、廉裕隆等人並未陪同前往，抑或先行離開之情形，此實與友人間同歡後輪流互相款項招待之情有異；

且就附表三編號11部分，該次飲宴實際上係招待被告戊○○之同學顏沛華，倘被告戊○○與證人戴沼澤、廉裕隆間僅係友人間輪流招待，亦無由證人戴沼澤、廉裕隆代為支付該筆帳款之理；

況就附表三編號16該次飲宴行為，依照前揭證據資料所載，於證人戴沼澤與劉禎忠之通訊監察譯文中，證人戴沼澤曾指示證人劉禎忠，因被告戊○○等人自中午起即開始在楓之林理容KTV 內飲宴，故要求證人劉禎忠毋庸全部代為結帳，蓋倘證人戴沼澤等人確係基於友人情誼，心甘情願招待被告戊○○前往消費，焉需對證人劉禎忠為如此之交待；

另就被告壬○○部分，被告壬○○於附表四編號1 之消費中，依照前揭證人李幼稠之證述內容可知，不僅先行墊付款項之證人李幼綢，抑或最終支付帳款之廉裕隆，均非主動及極有意願支付被告壬○○該次酒店喝花酒消費之款項，且就附表四編號4 部分，依照被告壬○○與證人廉裕隆於97年3 月25日下午4 時38分37之通訊監察譯文資料所述，被告壬○○於電話中明確詢問證人廉裕隆是否曾向「老董」報告，可以幫忙處理此攤，更可見被告壬○○係主動直接要求證人廉裕隆招待，而非雙方基於情誼互有往來之情。

況被告戊○○及壬○○均係公務員，而有女陪侍之理容KTV 消費非低，而依照目前卷存證據，亦無被告戊○○及壬○○曾經於相關場所設宴招待川順公司人員之證據資料，更可見一般公務員實無此能力在此有女陪侍之理容KTV 招待他人並以此做為社交往來。

況證人戴沼澤、廉裕隆所支付附表三、四所示之消費款項，完全係由川順公司所給付，並非由其等個人所支付，更可見川順公司之人員即證人戴沼澤、廉裕隆前揭支付帳款之行為，應係與川順公司之業務有關，而非基於證人戴沼澤及廉裕隆之個人情誼。

故證人戴沼澤、廉裕隆前揭陳述，應係屬卸責之詞，顯無可採。

至證人徐玉玲於原審審理中證稱：被告戊○○事後「應該是」有付款給戴沼澤或廉裕隆乙情，並非其親自見聞之事實而屬個人臆測之詞，時無可採。

而被告壬○○雖曾提出96年5 月22日、96年8 月22日及96年10月22日之中國信託信用卡帳單影本（分見原審卷二第98頁至第100 頁，第155 頁至第157 頁，原審卷三第35頁、第36頁），惟查，被告壬○○所提出之前揭帳單資料，均非本院認定被告壬○○接受招待之日期；

被告壬○○本身是否曾另有前往酒店消費及如何支付帳款，實與被告壬○○於本案中數次主動要求證人戴沼澤、廉裕隆代為支付帳款之情無關，併此敘明。

從而，本案關於川順公司曾支付被告戊○○及壬○○前往附表三、四所示理容KTV消費款項等情，事證明確，被告戊○○及壬○○前揭辯稱係友人間互相款宴招待等情，本院均不予採信。

㈤本院認定上開不正利益與戊○○及壬○○之職務具有關聯性，其等職務上之行為具有對價關係，證據及理由如下：⒈按對於職務上行為收受賄賂或不正利益罪，只須其職務上的行為與受授賄賂或不正利益間，在主觀上均認為彼此具有對價關係存在即可，不以客觀上是否確有對價關係為必要（最高法院78年臺上字第1959號參照）。

對於職務上行為收受賄賂或不正利益罪，祗須所收受的金錢或財物或不正利益與職務有相當對價關係，即已成立。

而要求或收受不正利益之與職務上對價關係之存在，不以雙方明示為必要，只要雙方已默認或默許收受不正利益之公務員一方，於收受後在其職務上即會履行一定之職務應為行為即可，不以授受雙方未曾言明收受不正利益之公務員一方在職務上應為之行為內容為何，即謂與職務無關而無對價關係。

在所謂職務上行為，只須在法定規定上，具有一般性的職務而為不正利益對價的具體對象為已；

並無須於要求、期約、交付不正利益之時言明應提供之職務行為內容可能情形為必要。

又所謂不正利益，指賄賂以外足以供人需要或滿足人慾望之一切有形或無形之利益而言（最高法院21年上字第369 號判例參照），而不正利益不以經濟上之利益為限。

又按貪污治罪條例第5條第1項第3款對於職務上之行為收受賄賂罪，須他人有行求賄賂之意思，而公務員於其職務範圍內，有允諾踐履賄求對象之特定行為，且所收受之金錢、財物或不正利益與其職務上之行為有相當對價關係，始足當之。

若他人所交付之財物並非基於行賄意思，其物即非賄賂，苟非關於允諾為職務上行為之報酬，亦不得謂為賄賂。

又是否具有相當對價關係，應就職務行為之內容、交付者與收受者之關係、賄賂之種類、價額、贈與之時間等客觀情形加以審酌，如公務員就其職務範圍內，允諾踐履賄求對象之特定行為，雙方相互之間具有對價關係，縱假借餽贈、酬謝、諮詢顧問費或政治獻金等各種名義之變相給付，亦難謂與職務無關而無對價關係，且究係事前抑或事後給付，以及該公務員事後是否確已踐履該項職務上之特定行為，俱非所問（最高法院98年度臺上字第5370號判決意旨參照）。

本案係被告戊○○及壬○○要求進而收受川順公司提供在有女陪侍之酒店飲宴作樂，乃社會上俗稱喝花酒，其中被告戊○○並有收受酒店小姐所提供之性服務，堪認係屬「不正利益」之範疇無疑，縱使對方以社交名義提供公務員在有女陪侍之酒店飲宴作樂，亦無礙本院認定為不正利益，合先敘明。

⒉被告戊○○及壬○○對本件川順公司承作上述便道工程、減災工程於其職務上有監督管理之責，已如上所述。

而本件便道工程、減災工程均由水利署及第三河川局所主辦之工程。

被告2 人亦認識其等之職務之行使即為該二項工程之進行，是被告2 人職務上之行為與該案項工程具有職務上之直接關聯性，至為明確，已可認定之。

被告2 人其等供述內容如下：⑴被告戊○○於偵查中供述要旨：我擔任第三河川局局長，負責之業務職掌是轄區為大安溪、大甲溪及烏溪水系之河規劃、治理及管理事項相關業務。

本件便道工程是第三河川局確於96年5 月31日發包前述便道工程，與減災工程都是一同由第三河川局負責工務行政管理，我在該2 項工程中負責督導之職務。

⑵被告壬○○於偵查中供述要旨：擔任水利署工程事務組副組長所負責之業務主要為輔佐組長辦理組務，本組分為四科，一科負責工程發包，二科負責進度管控，三科負責工程品質，四科負責工程勞安及環保，其中工程發包部分是指署內工程金額達5,000 萬以上之第一類工程，由署內自行發包之工程，其他工作項目則包括署內所有下屬單位，如第一至第十等10個河川局及北、中、南等3 個水資源局等。

便道工程是第三河川局發包。

該二工程發包後之進度管控、工程品質、工程勞安及環保，由我襄佐組長負責該二工程所有業務。

工程施工期間，有施工查核是部會組成施工查核小組定期或不定期作查核，督導是由執行單位對發包工程依一定比例赴現場作工程督導，工程估驗是廠商要請款時，請執行單位之工務所作估驗，由於我負責本署之工程督導之行程安排，所以該便道工程本署曾派員作不定期督導，便道工程本署曾於96年9 月28日，指派四科科長林榮紹（即同案被告林榮紹）率四個科承辦人員赴現場進行督導，詳細督導情形有督導紀錄。

減災工程於97年1月初，印象中該工程曾要求變更設計，本署並派員赴現場會勘，但該變更設計內容非單純以「鋼柵」位置施作錯誤而變更設計，所以我不清楚該工程是否有「鋼柵」位置施作錯誤之情形。

前述減災工程若有「鋼柵」位置施作錯誤之情形，廠商會行文並附圖報請第三河川局變更設計，第三河川局同樣行文並附圖報請本署會勘，本署會依情形決定是否會勘，會勘時除由本組外，另會請本署河川海岸組及原設計單位會同會勘，會勘後由一科承辦人製作會勘紀錄，該會勘紀錄包括會勘人員共同討論之結論，先上呈本組組長室，經由簡任工程司、「我本人」、組長後，再上呈總工程司室，期間「我本人」若針對變更設計有疑義，我會找承辦人來詢問，若有問題我也會直接簽註意見退回予承辦人再處理，但變更設計最終是由總工程司室決定是否同意變更設計。

⑶證人即水利署工程事務組組長宋伯永證稱：便道工程金額超過查核金額，但因時間緊迫，所以最後授權第三河川局辦理發包，辦理變更設計權責亦授權第三河川局，所以增減工程經費，由第三河川局報文經工程事務組第1 科簽會水利署河川海岸組（設計單位）。

另減災工程是由工程事務組辦理發包、訂約，但契約由第三河川局執行，並由水利署工程事務組督導，我是組長係綜理工程事務組業務，但公文如係第二層決行由我或副組長壬○○或簡任正工程司廖秋雄決行。

減災工程之設計、監造均由第三河川局負責辦理，該二工程均由川順公司得標施作。

便道工程施工期間，水利署有派員定期督導，是由本署工程事務組第二科承辦人、科長（即同案被告林榮紹）或副組長（即被告壬○○）不定期前往對工程進度及品質等進行督導。

⑷況依照前揭理由欄之通訊監察譯文內容所載，川順公司之戴沼澤、廉裕隆於接獲來電要求支付被告戊○○及壬○○於理容KTV 內飲宴款項時，屢有不耐之語氣，倘被告戊○○及壬○○對於本件川順公司所承作之上述便道工程、減災工程於其等職務上，毫無監督管理之責，證人戴沼澤及廉裕隆等人焉有屢屢代為支付金額非低之飲宴及性交易款項。

此外，依據「經濟部水利署工程督導作業要點」所規定，該署為確保工程施工品質、勞工安全、環境保護與施工進度，以達到預期之執行績效，訂定本督導作業要點，以為督導工程施工，特設督導小組。

被告壬○○為該督導小組之成員，而本件川順公司所承攬之上述便道工程、減災工程均為被告壬○○所執行督導職務範圍，至為明確。

被告壬○○固辯稱伊僅係指派人員進行驗收，及於會勘紀錄送審時會經過伊之層級，伊並無任何決定驗收結果之權限，且伊1 人之肯決，並無法對於變更設計之核准造成影響，進而辯稱伊之職務與本件便道工程、減災工程毫無關聯性云云，然依照前揭說明，自屬卸責之詞，顯不可採。

⒊再參酌被告戊○○前往附表三所示理容KTY 喝花酒消費及其中1 次由該酒店小姐提供性服務之時間，及被告壬○○前往附表四所示理容KTV 喝花酒消費之時間，經逐一與附表一所示便道工程時程表、附表二所示減災工程時程表查對後，發現俱與川順公司承攬便道工程、減災工程施作期間中重要之變更設計或管理、勘驗、查核、估驗請款日之當日或前後相關連，詳情如下【查對表】。

由該「查對表」所顯示，川順公司願意招待給付被告戊○○、壬○○前往附表三、四所示理容KTV 消費之不正利益間，與該公司承作便道工程、減災工程之間，展現高度之緊密配合關係之情，亦可認定。

【查對表】┌──────┬───────────────┬──────────────┐│時間 │便道工程或減災工程進行事項 │被告前往喝花酒消費之酒店名 ││ │ │稱明細等 │├──────┼───────────────┼──────────────┤│96年8月13日 │水利署以經水工字第00000000000 │1.即附表三編號1 ││ │號函送第三河川局表示，大甲溪砂│⑴96年8 月15日被告戊○○前往││ │石運輸便道工程第三標（25K十400│ 九龍理容KTV 酒店喝花酒。

││ │-32 K 十745)因工期緊迫，部分工│⑵消費金額1 萬6 千元。

戊○○││ │務處理程序（如變更設計、工期展│ 簽立一張「許董」本票，徐玉││ │延等)，請同意局部調整，授權貴 │ 玲擔任連保人；

再由川順公司││ │局核辦。

│ 96年9 月25日「轉帳傳票」項││ │ │ 下支付。

│├──────┼───────────────┤ ││96年8月14日 │㈠第三河川局以水管三字第096500│ ││ │ 84110 號函川順公司、世曦公司│ │ │ │ 本便道工程30K 十500 至32K 十│ │ │ │ 745 停工，俟變更設計程序完成│ │ │ │ 核定後再行復工。

│ │ │ │㈡戊○○、戴沼澤、廉裕隆電話通│ ││ │ 話中，戊○○表示: 水理不會啦│ ││ │ ，不是有人幫你做，不會喔、這│ ││ │ 樣，這樣我來指導了。

│ │├──────┼───────────────┼──────────────┤│96年8月27日 │戊○○以電話告知川順公司戴沼澤│ 1.即附表三編號2 ││ │有關便道工程已向水利署楊副署長│⑴96年9 月6 日被告戊○○前往│ │ │報告改用三層箱型石籠施工，楊副│ 九龍理容KTV 酒店喝花酒。

│ │ │署長並不反對。

│⑵本次消費金額不詳，由廉裕隆│ ├──────┼───────────────┤ 以現金支付。

││96年8月30日 │由曾財益擔任便道工程第一次變更│ ││ │設計會勘。

│ │├──────┼───────────────┤ ││96年9月10日 │上述變更設計會勘紀錄及變更設計│ ││ │原則經局長戊○○核定。

│ │├──────┼───────────────┼──────────────┤│96年9月12日 │就本便道工程25K十400至32K十745│1.即附表三編號3 ││ │，由第三局曾財益主持進行聖帕颱│⑴96年9 月14日被告戊○○前往││ │風災損會勘日。

│ 九龍理容KTV 酒店喝花酒， │├──────┼───────────────┤⑵本次消費金額1 萬2 千1 百元││96年9月18日 │第三河川局，以水三管字第096020│ 、2 千2 百元，共計：1 萬4 ││ │13850 號函同意本便道工程之調整│ 千3 百元，於川順公司本便道││ │斷面與線型修正原則案，先行施作│ 工程96年10月25日「轉帳傳票││ │。

│ 」項下支付。

│├──────┼───────────────┤2.即附表三編號4 ││96年9月27日 │第三河川局將聖帕颱風所造成之災│⑴96年9 月18日被告戊○○前往││ │害損失及修復經費1711萬2764元函│ 九龍理容KTV 酒店喝花酒。

││ │報水利署核定籌措經費財源。

│⑵本次消費金額不詳，由戴沼澤││ │ │ 以現金支付。

│├──────┼───────────────┼──────────────┤│96年10月4日 │柯羅莎颱風發布警報。

│1.即附表三編號5 │├──────┼───────────────┤⑴96年10月2 日被告戊○○前往││96年10月5日 │第三河川局指派正工程司林秀玲擔│ 九龍理容KTV 酒店喝花酒。

││ │任颱風前便道工程進行查核。

│⑵本次消費金額1 萬6 千5 百50│├──────┼───────────────┤ 元，由被告戊○○簽立本票，││96年10月11日│世曦公司本日發函檢送便道工程第│ 徐玉玲擔任連保人；

該筆消費││ │1次變更設計預算書至第三河川局 │ 載於川順公司96年11月25日「││ │，再由第三河川局函轉水利署核定│ 轉帳傳票」項下支付。

││ │。

│2.即附表三編號6 ││ │ │⑴96年10月4 日被告戊○○前往│├──────┼───────────────┤ 九龍理容KTV 酒店喝花酒。

││96年10月15日│國營會會同川順公司戴沼澤、紀駿│⑵本次消費金額2 萬2 千6 百元││ │富、廉裕隆，世曦公司、水利署林│ ，由廉裕隆簽立本票；

該筆消││ │榮紹、江文助，第三河川局副局長│ 費載於川順公司96年11月25日││ │林傳茂、癸○○查核大甲溪砂石運│ 「轉帳傳票」項下支付。

││ │輸便道工程 │3.即附表三編號7 │├──────┼───────────────┤⑴96年10月5 日被告戊○○前往││96年10月18日│就本便道工程之25K十400至30K十 │ 九龍理容KTV 酒店喝花酒。

││ │500 ，由第三局趙培善主持進行第│⑵本次消費金額1 萬6 百50元，││ │二次工程變更設計會勘日。

│ 由被告戊○○簽本票，徐玉玲│├──────┼───────────────┤ 擔任連保人，再由於川順公司││96年10月22日│1.水利署函復第三河川局有關聖帕│ 96年11月25日「轉帳傳票」項││ │ 颱風所造成之損失及修復經費17│ 下支付。

││ │ 11萬餘元再第三標工程內支應。

│4.即附表三編號8 ││ │ 第三河川局於96年11月23日發函│⑴96年10月11日被告戊○○前往││ │ 水利署請將本次損經費損壞應重│ 九龍理容KTV 酒店喝花酒。

││ │ 作之部分之經費1400萬餘元併入│⑵本次消費金額2 萬8 百元，由││ │ 第1次變更設計預算書內。

│ 陳玉瑛代被告戊○○簽本票，││ │2.川順公司開始施作30K起之箱型 │ 徐玉玲擔任連保人，再由於川││ │ 石籠。

│ 順公司96年11月25日「轉帳傳││ │ │ 票」項下支付。

││ │ │5.即附表三編號9 ││ │ │⑴96年10月17日被告戊○○前往││ │ │ 九龍理容KTV 酒店喝花酒。

││ │ │⑵本次消費金額4 萬9 千5 百50││ │ │ 元，由廉裕隆簽本票，再於川││ │ │ 順公司96年11月25日「轉帳傳││ │ │ 票」項下支付。

││ │ │6.即附表四編號1 ││ │ │⑴96年10月8 日被告壬○○等人││ │ │ 前往麗登理容KTV 酒店喝花酒││ │ │ 。

││ │ │⑵本次消費金額1 萬4 千3 百50││ │ │ 元，廉裕隆事後簽認，於川順││ │ │ 公司97年3 月月25日轉帳傳票││ │ │ 」項下支付。

││ │ │ │├──────┼───────────────┼──────────────┤│96年10月24日│川順公司提報柯羅莎颱風災損報告│1.即附表三編號10 ││ │與世曦公司，經世曦公司提報災損│⑴96年10月31日被告戊○○前往││ │慨算1400萬餘元與第三河川局審核│ 九龍理容KTV 酒店喝花酒。

││ │。

│⑵本次消費金額1 萬6 千5 百50││ │ │ 元，由廉裕隆簽本票，再於川│├──────┼───────────────┤ 順公司96年11月25日「轉帳傳││96年10月31日│就本便道工程25K十400至32K十745│ 票」項下支付。

││ │，由第三局曾財益主持進行柯羅莎│ ││ │颱風災損會勘日。

│ │├──────┼───────────────┤ ││96年10月31日│便道工程第一期工程估驗請款日。

│ │├──────┼───────────────┤ ││96年11月1日 │水利署函復第三河川局第一次變更│ ││ │設計之經費3027萬9845元核准在水│ ││ │資源作業基金下支應。

│ │├──────┼───────────────┤ ││96年11月2日 │第三河川局核定第二次便道工程設│ ││ │計變更紀錄、設計原則及經費預算│ ││ │。

並於96年11月19日函轉水利署審│ ││ │核。

│ ││ ├───────────────┤ ││ │減災工程第二次變更設計會勘日。

│ │├──────┼───────────────┼──────────────┤ ││96年11月19日│第三河川局函報水利署有關柯羅莎│1.即附表三編號11 ││ │颱風災損數量及補助川順公司經費│⑴96年11月28日被告戊○○前往││ │慨算1412萬核定，請求籌措財源。

│ 九龍理容KTV 酒店喝花酒。

││ │水利署於96年12月12日核定在水資│⑵本次消費金額1 萬6 千元，由││ │源作業基金下支應。

│ 廉裕隆簽本票，再於川順公司│├──────┼───────────────┤ 96年12月25日「轉帳傳票」項││96年11月30日│便道工程第二期估驗請款日。

│ 下支付。

│├──────┼───────────────┤ ││96年12月4日 │就本便道工程之26K十450至26K十 │ ││ │700 ，由第三局趙培善主持進行工│ ││ │程變更設計會勘日。

│ │├──────┼───────────────┼──────────────┤│96年12月6日 │就本便道工程之25K十400至32K十 │1.即附表三編號12 ││ │745 ，由第三局曾財益主持進行工│⑴96年12月17日被告戊○○、被││ │程變更設計會勘日。

│ 告林榮紹等人前往九龍理容KT│├──────┼───────────────┤ V 酒店喝花酒。

││ │水利署發函第三河川局本便道工程│⑵本次消費金額1 萬7 千6 百50││96 年12月7日│第1次變更設計預算書核准成立， │ 元，由戴泱丞簽本票，再於川││ │此後川順公司即可據以請領變更施│ 順公司96年12月25日「轉帳傳││ │作石籠之災損及已施作之款項。

│ 票」項下支付。

│├──────┼───────────────┤ ││96年12月11日│便道工程原契約所規定之完工日。

│ │├──────┼───────────────┤ ││96年12月14日│第三河川局函復世曦公司便道工程│ ││ │第二次設計變更經費889萬5735元 │ ││ │經水利署核定。

│ │├──────┼───────────────┤ ││96年12月15日│便道工程第三期估驗請款日。

│ │├──────┼───────────────┼──────────────┤│96年12月22日│減災工程開始施作減災工程之左岸│1.即附表三編號13 ││ │基腳 │⑴97年1 月7 日被告戊○○前往│├──────┼───────────────┤ 九龍理容KTV 酒店喝花酒。

被││97年1 月3 日│減災工程開始施作鋼柵石籠 │ 告戊○○並與該酒店編號105 ││ │ │ 號小姐陳瑤寰買出場至台中市││ │ │ 某汽車旅館，由該小姐進行性││ │ │ 服務。

││ │ │⑵本次消費金額8 萬4 百50元，│├──────┼───────────────┤ 由戴沼澤簽本票，再於川順公││96年12月28日│就本便道工程25K十400至32K十745│ 司97年2 月25日「轉帳傳票」││ │，由第三局趙培善主持進行工程變│ 項下支付。

││ │更設計會勘日。

│ │├──────┼───────────────┤ ││96年12月28日│便道工程須支付工程款500萬元支 │ ││ │票須戊○○蓋章，許戊○○以電話│ ││ │交代第三河川局會計主任逕向局長│ ││ │室工友取印自蓋即可。

│ │├──────┼───────────────┤ ││96年12月31日│便道工程展延完工日並為川順公司│ ││ │陳報第三河川局完工日。

│ │├──────┼───────────────┤ ││97年1月7日 │減災工程第三次變更設計會勘日。

│ │├──────┼───────────────┤ ││97年1月8日 │戴沼澤與世曦公司張敬廉電話通話│ ││ │，詢問有關本便道工程受颱風損害│ ││ │請求第三河川局補償金額之公文是│ ││ │否已函送第三河川局進度情形？ │ │├──────┼───────────────┼──────────────┤│97年1月11日 │減災工程先行查驗日查驗鋼柵石籠│1.即附表四編號2 │├──────┼───────────────┤⑴97年1 月16日被告壬○○等人││97年1月17日 │減災工程先行查驗日查驗鋼柵石籠│ 前往香格里拉理容KTV 酒喝花│├──────┼───────────────┤ 酒。

││97年1月30日 │減災工程同意展期至97年11月18 │⑵本次消費金額9 千1 百元，由││ │竣工。

│ 廉裕隆簽本票，再於川順公司││ │ │ 97年4 月25日「轉帳傳票」項││ │ │ 下支付。

│├──────┼───────────────┼──────────────┤│97年2月4日 │1.水利署發函第三河川局核准第二│1.即附表三編號14 ││ │ 次變更設計工程預算書成立。

│ 及附表四編號3 ││ │2.便道工程完工辦理初驗日。

│⑴97年2 月12日被告戊○○及被│├──────┼───────────────┤ 告壬○○等人前往九龍理容KT││97年2月14日 │水署發函第三河川局同意97年1月7│ V 酒店喝花酒。

被告戊○○為││ │日減災工程變更設計會勘紀錄。

│ 該酒店編號第66號小姐楊雅惠││ │（水利署97年2月14日經水工字第 │ 買出場外遊。

││ │ 00000000000號函） │⑵本次消費金額1 萬7 千1 百50││ │ 此函簽呈中被告壬○○有會簽 │ 元、6 千元，共計：2 萬3 千││ │ │ 1 百50元，由廉裕隆簽本票，││ │ │ 再於川順公司97年3 月25日「│├──────┼───────────────┤ 轉帳傳票」項下支付。

││97年2月22日 │便道工程完工辦理初驗紀錄製作。

│ │├──────┼───────────────┼──────────────┤│97年3月5、6 │便道工程完工辦理複驗日。

│1.即附表三編號15 ││日 │ │⑴97年3 月3 日被告戊○○等人│├──────┼───────────────┤ 前往楓之林理容KTV 酒喝花酒││97年3月12日 │減災工程第四次變更設計會勘日。

│ 。

││ │ │⑵本次消費金額4 萬1 千8 百50││ │ │ 元，由廉裕隆簽本票，再於川││ │ │ 順公司97年4 月25日「轉帳傳││ │ │ 票」項下支付。

│├──────┼───────────────┼──────────────┤│97年3月14日 │戴沼澤聯繫戴沼銘、廉裕隆、許哲│1.即附表三編號16 ││ │彥、林榮紹、彭壽奇、羅仕政至川│⑴97年3 月3 日被告戊○○等人││ │順公司天祥街招待所會商本減災工│ 前往楓之林理容KTV 酒喝花酒││ │程施工錯誤解決方式。

│ 。

││ │ │⑵本次消費金額1 萬3 千2 百元││ │ │ ，由劉禎忠代戴沼澤簽帳於楓││ │ │ 之林理容KTV董事謝翠芬應收 ││ │ │ 帳款下，再於川順公司支付。

│├──────┼───────────────┼──────────────┤│97年3月17日 │便道工程第四期估驗請款日。

│1.即附表四編號4 ││ │ │⑴97年3 月25日被告壬○○等人││ │ │ 前往香格里拉理容KTV 酒喝花││ │ │ 酒。

││ │ │⑵本次消費金額7 千1 百元，由││ │ │ 廉裕隆簽帳，再於川順公司97││ │ │ 年4 月25日「轉帳傳票」項下││ │ │ 支付。

│├──────┼───────────────┤ ││97年3月24日 │便道工程第五期估驗請款日。

│ │├──────┼───────────────┤ ││97年3月28日 │減災工程，川順公司函請第三河川│ ││ │局准許篩取塊石施作蛇籠及石龍之│ ││ │用。

│ │└──────┴───────────────┴──────────────┘⒋被告戊○○及壬○○2 人於收受上開川順公司不正利益後，有如下之其等職務上相呼應川順公司本件二項工程遂行之行為，證據理由如下：⑴按貪污治罪條例所稱「職務上之行為」，係指公務員在其職務權責範圍內所應為或得為之行為。

亦即指其權限範圍內之事項，而不違背其義務責任者而言。

反之，若在其職權範圍內，不應為而為之，或應為而不為，或不正當為之，而與其職務上之義務責任有所違背者，則應屬同條例第4條第1項第5款所謂之「違背職務之行為」。

因此，若公務員受賄之原因，係為其職務上應為或得為之行為者，則受賄人應成立同條例第5條第1項第3款之「對於職務上之行為收受賄賂或其他不正利益罪」。

反之，若受賄之原因，係為其職務上所不應為，或應為而不為，或以不正當方式為之，而違背其職責者，則應成立同條例第4條第1項第5款之「對於違背職務之行為收受賄賂或其他不正利益罪」，兩者之要件迥不相同。

⑵就被告戊○○部分：①關於便道工程變更設計改採箱型石籠施工部分：證人癸○○於偵查中證稱：「川順公司於96年6 月28日提出『施工斷面建議變更建議書』，建議以方籠排列方式辦理施工斷面，川順公司於提出前，曾於川順公司旱溪工務所及本工程工地工務所作兩次討論（非正式會議，兩次討論之詳細時間我忘記了），其在川順公司旱溪工務所討論時，參加人員計有：局長戊○○（主持人）、我、川順公司戴沼澤及土木技師。」

、「我於受命承辦本工程後，約於96年7 月17日前3 天，局長戊○○要求我函文上級水利署，本便道雖屬第一類，但因本便道工程工期緊迫，要求水利署除變更設計預算書審查及驗收外，其他均比照第二類工程辦理，亦即本便道工程除變更設計預算書審查及驗收外，其他事項授權局長戊○○審核。」

、「（你既是本便道工程之承辦人，川順公司於96年7 月3 日即變更以箱型石籠施工，你是否知悉？）我知道川順公司已用箱型石籠施作，在向水利署授權、變更設計都是局長的意思，我只是被告知要這麼辦而已，因為還未開工，局長就有說要變更為箱型石籠，戊○○是在天祥工務所跟我說的。」

、「川順公司於96年6 月28日提出『施工斷面建議變更建議書』後，我即簽辦本便道工程變更施工法為箱型石籠工法之簽呈，並於簽呈內簽註經局長同意後先行施工之意見，．．經局長戊○○同意核可後，我即函文通知川順公司同意變更施工法為箱型石籠工法。」

、「我於簽呈內簽註經局長同意後先行施工之意見，係我個人之見解。」

、「96年7 月12日辦理之工程會勘前，本局局長戊○○早已知悉蛇籠變更為箱型石籠之計劃，且知悉變更後將大幅增加預算；

戊○○並支持蛇籠變更為箱型石籠之計劃，因此在會勘前即要我及本局管理課副工程司曾財益支持該案，我與曾財益才會在會勘時支持變更為箱型石籠工法之計劃，在會勘前，台灣世曦公司向本局局長戊○○口頭報告，本便道工程變更為箱型石籠工法，增加之預算低於契約金額百分之五十，而局長戊○○早已同意變更後增加之預算金額。」

、「不管是授權、變更設計這都是局長告訴我的，我只是補辦公文程序。」

、「本便道工程，川順公司實際上於得標開工後，即變更工法以箱型石籠施工，我等承辦人係依局長戊○○指示，辦理會勘等變更設計之相關程序及簽辦公文，因此前於96年7 月12日及後續辦理會勘及相關簽辦公文均是依局長戊○○指示辦理，以期能讓川順公司在承作本工程能達成變更設計之目的，川順公司戴沼澤於本工程開工前，即與局長戊○○談妥，本便道工程要變更設計為箱型石籠工法，至於川順公司與局長戊○○如何協商，我不清楚。

我於承接本案後、開工前某日下午（時間我已忘記了），局長戊○○要我至川順公司旱溪工務所，於川順公司旱溪工務所向我說明前述本便道工程要變更設計為箱型石籠工法，且說明已與川順公司談妥，要我在承辦過程中配合承包商川順公司及設計監造之台灣世曦公司辦理相關變更設計之會勘及簽辦相關公文作業，因戊○○係我直屬長官及技術層面等因素，我在無法反對下而同意配合，因此在承辦該工程期間，均依戊○○指示，配合辦理會勘及簽辦相關公文。

當時在場人員有我、戊○○、川順公司戴沼澤及該公司土木技師許慶祥等5 、6 人，我到場時，川順公司戴沼澤與局長戊○○即已談妥本便道工程要變更設計為箱型石籠工法，我到場後已在討論箱型石籠排列問題。」

、「本便道工程，川順公司在開工前，即與戊○○談妥要變更設計，且開工後即以箱型石籠工法施作（整個工程除少部分河道較寬部分仍採蛇籠工法，其餘均採箱型石籠工法），故96年7 月12日及96年10月18日等多次辦理會勘，其目的係在配合川順公司及台灣世曦公司辦理本便道工程變更設計之流程，以讓川順公司開工即已變更以箱型石籠工法施作之事實合法化，因此川順公司一開始即是低價搶標本便道工程，並且有把握在局長戊○○主導下完成變更設計程序，因此開工後，即以箱型石籠工法施作，並未依原設計工法施工，且事後，也如川順公司原計劃完成變更設計程序，且順利完工。」

、「能未依正常程序等水利署同意後完成變更設計再施工，該部分局長戊○○一直有把握能讓水利署同意，．．事實上也證明局長戊○○真的有辦法能讓水利署同意。」

、「我是因為局長已經答應川順公司變更石籠之施工法，但該工法之變更，並沒有事先與設計單位台灣世曦公司討論，因此當戴沼澤告知台灣世曦要變更設計時，張敬廉十分苦惱，．．在川順戴沼澤要求及局長戊○○指示下，由我召集該次會勘。

」、「96年6 月25日之開工前協調會時，我依局長與川順戴沼澤之協議，同意變更為石籠之施工法，因此在該協調會中，我即代表業主同意該變更設計為石籠之施工法。」

、「由於局長已與川順戴沼澤商議好同意變更，我在辦好變更設計前，不可能同意川順公司先行施工，應是該公司有局長之承諾而有恃無恐。」

、「本案因是局長自己與承包商之協議變更，因此並沒有依照正常變更流程先由設計單位估算數量及增加之工程費，也沒有知會水利署會計部門，當時台灣世曦曾提醒增加之工程費不可超過合約金額之一半，以免違法，但局長曾表示本合約是依實作數量計價，箱型石籠本來在合約內就有設計，增加數量並不是新增項目及新增單價，不會有採購法50% 之問題，因此要台灣世曦不必考慮。」

、「局長叫我去談沒有講那麼明白，他跟我講蛇籠要變更為箱型石籠，我去時已經在談箱籠排列的方法了，就是同意了才談這些，如果不同意就不用談了。」

、「該川順公司建議書所附擬變更施工斷面圖之箱型石籠排列工圖，確實是我於97年5 月23日的調查筆錄中所說，約於96年6 月15日合約開工日前，局長戊○○與川順公司戴沼澤在天祥街工務所內已談妥之變更設計為箱型石籠之排列圖，在該次局長戊○○指示我到川順公司天祥街與戊○○、戴沼澤等人見面，局長戊○○除了與戴沼澤已談妥變更設計為箱型石籠之施工草圖外，他就已經講到箱型石籠的排列方式，所以當然有同意本便道工程合約中蛇籠變更改為箱型石籠施作，並沒有明確的指示我依照此方向配合川順公司所提建議將蛇籠變更為箱型石籠施工，但是把我叫去就說要做箱型石籠，也就是叫我把蛇籠變更為箱型石籠，辦理後續變更設計程序，也因為局長戊○○該指示，我才會在不久後即96年6 月25日應川順公司戴沼澤、廉裕隆要求下召開開工前協調會議，目的在於啟動將蛇籠改變為箱型石籠之變更設計程序。」

、「本便道工程合約開工日為96年6 月15日，但川順公司一直未依規定進場開工，經前述局長戊○○找我到川順公司天祥街與戴沼澤、許慶祥等人見面，並指示我配合辦理後續變更設計。

」等語明確（97年度偵字第10922 號卷二第31至35頁、38頁、41頁、42頁、47頁；

卷六第167 、168 頁）；

於原審審理時具結證稱：「局長到工務所指示變更蛇籠設計的事，我接受了。」

、「（本案開工之前，是否有奉局長戊○○指示，到川順公司天祥街工務所與戴沼澤碰面討論本件工程變更設計為箱型石籠的施工方法？）有。」

、「（在場的有誰？）我及戴沼澤、戊○○、川順營造的技師許慶祥這些人肯定有，其他人我現在記不清楚了。」

、「（討論何事？）96年6 月15日要開工，但實際上沒有開工，我也抽空去現場一、二趟，我得到訊息，因為川順營造施工前要測量、放樣，測量結果發現河道狹窄，水流湍急，如果按照原設計蛇籠來做的話，將窒礙難行，因為蛇籠坡度較緩，而且占水道面積較多，使得河道洪水面積縮小。

我接到川順廉裕隆打電話給我，我當天到時，他們都已經在場了，就已經決定要箱型石籠的施工方法，當時我到時，他們正在繪畫箱型石籠的排列方式。」

、「（96年6 月25號開工前協調會有提到說工法要從甲種機編蛇籠變更為箱型石籠這件事是誰提出來的，當場是誰提出來的？）因為在6 月25號開工協調會之前大概一、兩天，就在旱溪工務所就討論過這個事了，那時候局長就告訴我了，就說我當時有提到。」

、「（你剛才提到說在開工前的某一天，局長有跟你指示在川順公司的旱溪工務所跟你指示說要變更工法，那你能不能講一下實際是哪一天，開工前的哪一天？）是在開工協調會的前一、二天。」

等語明確（原審97年度訴字第3018號卷五，第316 頁反面、317 頁；

同上案號卷六，第46頁、47頁反面）。

而癸○○為本件便道工程之承辦人，則其對於受命辦理 該工程變更設計之經過，自當知之甚詳，是其證詞應屬可信。

而依證人癸○○上開證詞可知，被告戊○○對於便道工程之變更設計一事著力甚深，且與川順公司戴沼澤已有協議，並指示癸○○配合川順公司辦理變更設計，非僅單純依下屬上呈之公文審核批示或行政指導而已。

另癸○○於96年6 月28日檢呈開工前協調會會議紀錄，被告戊○○則批示：「一、會議紀錄如擬。

二、如以箱型籠施作，不需外加掛坡蛇籠。」

被告戊○○復於調查站製作筆錄時供稱：「，．．在簽呈的附圖中，有將箱型籠與掛坡蛇籠同時施作的示意圖，所以我才提醒如施工箱型籠就不需要外加掛坡蛇籠。」

、「在此（96年7 月18日）之前我已向署長口頭報告本案之時效壓力，請求將本案比照第二類工程授權給三河局辦理，以爭取施工時效。」

等語，益見證人癸○○之上開證述內容為可採。

至證人癸○○於本院審理時雖改證稱：其在調查站及偵訊時之說法有失偏頗，有關其證稱川順公司有把握在被告戊○○主導下完成變更設計程序，都是其在忐忑情況下所為之猜測之詞，其在原審時就已經證稱其在偵查中所述證詞與事實有所出入等語（詳見本院卷二第151 頁至第154 頁），惟查，本案相關工程均係在96、97年間，證人癸○○於偵訊時較接近工程施工日期所為之證述，顯較證人癸○○於原審及本院審理證述時記憶為清晰；

且證人癸○○於偵查時所為之證述，核與前揭96年6 月28日檢呈開工前協調會會議紀錄中被告戊○○之批示及被告戊○○於調查站之陳述相吻，益徵證人癸○○事後翻異之詞，應係屬迴護被告戊○○之詞，不足採信。

至辯護人雖辯稱被告戊○○接受川順公司之時間點係在96年8 月15日起至97年3 月14日止，亦即第1 次之日期係在96年8 月15日，而便道工程變更設計在96年8 月13日經水利署核准之前，川順公司並無招待被告戊○○喝花酒之情，從而難認被告戊○○係同意川順公司變更設計改以箱型石籠施工，而接受川順公司招待喝花酒之不正當利益等語。

惟按按貪污治罪條例第5條第1項第3款對於職務上之行為收受賄賂罪，須他人有行求賄賂之意思，而公務員於其職務範圍內，有允諾踐履賄求對象之特定行為，且所收受之金錢、財物或不正利益與其職務上之行為有相當對價關係，始足當之。

又是否具有相當對價關係，應就職務行為之內容、交付者與收受者之關係、賄賂之種類、價額、贈與之時間等客觀情形加以審酌，如公務員就其職務範圍內，允諾踐履賄求對價之特定行為，雙方相互之間具有對價關係，縱假借餽贈、酬謝、諮詢顧問費或政治獻金等各種名義之變相給付，亦難謂與職務無關而無對價關係，且究係事前抑或事後給付，以及該公務員事後是否確已踐履該項職務上之特定行為，俱非所問；

否則，該公務員收受餽贈、酬謝、諮詢顧問費等，固有悖官箴，仍不能遽論以對於職務上之行為收受賄賂罪（最高法院70年臺上字第1186號判例、98年度臺上字第5370號判決參照）。

故被告戊○○縱係於便道工程變更設計後，始接受川順公司之招待，亦無礙於被告戊○○接受前揭喝花酒不當利益與職務行為間有無對價關係之認定，併此敘明。

②被告戊○○應有協助川順公司施作便道工程變更設計中之水理分析：2007年8 月3 日12時58分56秒，戴沼澤與戊○○通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見偵卷二，第194 頁），並經該2 人於偵查中證稱係其等對話無訛：「（戴）：幫我看一些可能行政，我有時候喔，那個，那個 ，那個他們昨天送那個有那個，好像有那個『要 變比較窄那個部份』，副座好像有簽還要『水理 』。

（許）：那不用啦，那不用『水理』，只有做1 段就好， 那反正他寫那樣，但是最後目的是做車道啦。

（戴）：呀。

（許）：那做車道而已。

（戴）：做車道，現在就是說，若低一點來做雙車道，你 看看。

（許）：不好，不好，不好。

（戴）：你做那麼高做車道。

（許）：不是做那麼高，就照原來的高度做車道就好，因 為你不行不行做像台8線那麼高。

（戴）：沒有啦，還差很多。

（許）：你就，你上回跟我講比台 8線還低，這樣這樣就 避免。

（戴）：還一些他簽的意見，我是說你若真的有時間差不 多1 個多小時走一趟，我跟你跟工那邊聯繫一些 事情，跟你報告一下，會不會忙。

（許）：不會，還好啦，不然這樣喔，我現在在吃飯嘛喔 ，我吃完是不是叫『阿隆』還是什麼人來載我。

（戴）：好呀，好呀，好。」

2007年8 月3 日14時16分32秒，戴沼澤與戊○○通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見偵卷4 ，第155 頁），並經該2 人於偵查中證稱係對話無訛：a.戊○○表示「你現在是一定要工地，還是針對那個『文』的問題。」

應係詢問是否確為解決水理分析之問題。

b.戴沼澤表示「沒有啦，來事務所就好啦，來工務所這裡跟我們指導一下。」

c.戊○○表示「好，這樣我知道意思，我知道意思。」

）被告戊○○於調查站接受詢問時供承：「該0000000000行動電話為我本人所使用之電話，為我及川順公司負責人戴沼澤2 人之對話，談話內容重點為戴沼澤與我談工程設計變更及車道高度等問題，並要我前往該公司工務所（即臺中市天祥街及旱溪西路交叉口之招待所）去坐。」

、「（96年8 月3 日12時58分許）前述通話確為戴沼澤打給我之通聯，通聯中戴沼澤就是在問我，有關前述便道工程中第三河川局副座（林傳茂）所簽的『水理分析』要怎麼作，我告訴他只要做雙車道變單車道的那一段就可以了，後來戴沼澤約我過去，我才叫戴沼澤派他的外甥廉裕隆過來載我。」

等語（見97年度偵字第10922 號卷4 ，第144-1 頁；

見偵卷二，第181 至182 頁）；

於偵查中供承：「該0000000000行動電話為我本人所使用之電話，因為砂石便道有受災害，所以台8 線有受損，．．要求我們變更工程設計、車道高度等問題，要求我去天祥招待所討論。」

、「（提示0000000000行動電話96年8 月27日18時35分之通訊監察譯文，對話之對方為何人？談話內容重點為何？）該段對話為戴沼澤與我之通話，談話內容重點為我向戴沼澤表示，我有向水利署楊偉甫副署長報告，楊副署長希望單線道，川順公司的前述便道工程，要改用三層箱型籠施工，而且楊副署長並不反對。」

等語（見97年度偵字第10922 號卷4 ，第193 頁）。

2007年8 月14日11時32分50秒，廉裕隆、戴沼澤與戊○○通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見偵卷二，第195 頁），並經該3人於偵查中證稱係對話無訛：「（戴）：『長仔』。

（許）：嗯，是，聽說水都蓋過去了。

（戴）：派一個課長來看一下，『水理』要怎麼算我也不會 。

（許）：『水理』、『水理』不會呀，不是有叫人幫你做， 不會喔，這樣，這樣我來指導了，我。

（戴）：好呀，好呀，我看，也是要來啦，我在這裡等你， 我在工地，早上7 點就來了。

由上通話內容，益見被告戊○○確有協助川順公司水理分析之製作。

2007年8 月20日9 時27分56秒，彭壽奇與戊○○通訊監察錄音及譯文內容（見偵卷十，第151 頁），並經該2 人於偵查中證稱係其等對話無訛：彭壽奇表示「我彭壽奇，那個，那個『水理演算』（指本便道工程水理演算）那個報告放在你桌上，你有看到嗎。

」；

戊○○表示「為什麼『8 層』的流速反而下降，這是什麼，什麼那個。」

。

彭壽奇表示「他主要是83.5那個斷面而已啦。」

及「就是『流況改變的關係』吧，我回來我再和局長解釋一下啦。」

，依照此部分譯文可證明證人彭壽奇製作水理分析後，確曾提出報告交由被告戊○○審閱，被告戊○○並針對報告內容詢問證人彭壽奇，證人彭壽奇並應允將就報告內容予以解釋。

證人彭壽奇於偵查中證稱：「世曦公司庚○○於96年間（詳細日期已忘記）主動到第三河川局工務課來找我，庚○○表示是世曦公司人員而且是我交通大學的學弟，向我請教大甲溪砂石運輸便道第三標水理演算之模式使用問題，庚○○第1 次來找我，我指導他有關大甲溪便道工程第三標之各斷面點如何演算，先後3 次，最後1 次庚○○將彙整之水理演算分析報告送給我過目確認內容有無需更正，又因之前局長戊○○知道我本人指導世曦公司人員演算水理分析方法，指示我如該份水理分析報告經我本人確認初稿沒問題後，即送1 份水理分析報告給局長戊○○參考，當日96年8 月20日我依戊○○指示將該份水理分析報告放在戊○○桌上，而戊○○才打此電話問我有關83.5斷面為何箱型石籠施作8 層反而會流速下降，我向戊○○答覆是因為水流流水況改變的關係。

至於戊○○為何特別關心該份水理演算報告內容，詳情我不清楚。」

等語（見偵卷十，第162 頁），而卷附之96年8 月23日大甲溪便道工程第3 標「調整斷面與線型修正原則」所附之斷面「83.5」水理分析資料－「表6 大甲溪砂石運輸便道第三標各方案水理演算洪水位斷面平均流速比較表」，內載本便道工程水理分析（見偵卷十，第154 頁）；

該份流速比較表證人彭壽奇亦證稱：是與局長戊○○討論之本便道工程斷面『83.5』之水理分析資料。」

（見偵卷十，第162 、163 頁），是被告戊○○有以其局長之職務身分關係，就所屬第三河川局正工程司彭壽奇業已確認，由證人庚○○彙整之水理演算分析報告，特別指示需提供給其參考，證人彭壽奇並曾向被告戊○○特別加以說明。

被告戊○○於調查站製作筆錄時亦供稱：「川順公司人員進行製作前述水理分析等資料時，有一天我曾經前往川順公司位於臺中市天祥街、旱溪路口之工務所，當時戴沼澤曾與我討論前述水理分析的結論，究竟是應該做單車道或雙車道何者為好，最後討論的結果是規劃做雙車道。」

、「，．．（96年8 月3 日12時58分56秒）通聯中戴沼澤就是在問我，有關前述便道工程中三河局副座（林傳茂）所簽的『水理分析』要怎麼作，我告訴他只要做雙車道變單車道的那一段就可以了，後來戴沼澤約我過去，我才叫戴沼澤派他的外甥廉裕隆過來載我。」

、「（96年8 月14日11時32分50秒）前述通話為戴沼澤打給我之通聯，通聯中戴沼澤問我前述便道工程中他於工地現場所做的工程，遭上游水庫放水而全部淹沒過去，那麼『水理分析』要怎麼作。

我只是在電話中跟他談這個事情而已。」

等語。

③關於聖帕颱風及柯羅莎颱風災損賠償部分：戴沼澤於96年9 月5 日17時53分45秒起與甲○○間有以下通話內容：「（戴）：就是那日，現在我們那裡有1個災害喔。

（張）：嗯。

（戴）：災害那個部分喔,早前那時候我們在這裡的,現在 目前『3層』沒有要加高，這部分喔。

（張）：嗯。

（戴）：有，昨天有跟『長仔』。

（張）：說3天內要會勘嘛，嗯。

（戴）：他們一些人在那裡，我現在是說那裡的不要修復 ，我跟『長仔』說那的不要修復喔，我們災害後 ，那個部分不修復啦。

（張）：對呀，如果你不修復的話，新工法就用新的工法 做嘛喔，然後災害損害的部分就是照原來你施作 的項目給付費用給你們嘛，依照契約裡面有的約 定。」

依上述通話內容，戴沼澤向甲○○表明關於聖帕颱風所生災損部分，已與被告戊○○聯繫討論過。

且川順公司於96年9 月6 日即於附表三編號2 所示之地點，招待被告戊○○前往九龍理容KTV 喝花酒，更可見戴沼澤等川順公司人員於前揭時間內，對被告戊○○提供不正利益，即係欲被告戊○○呼應川順公司前揭工程遂行之行為。

至證人甲○○於本院審理時雖曾證稱：前揭與戴沼澤之對話內容，係戴沼澤打電話給其詢問有關災害之問題，與被告戊○○間有無關係其不知道，其不知道戴沼澤在譯文中稱「昨天有跟長仔」，應該是在講災害會勘之事，但其不記得跟「長仔」（應即係指被告戊○○）間有何關係，其也不記得戴沼澤前揭通話後，是否曾再詢問被告戊○○跟該通電話有關之事等語（見本院卷第142 頁正反面）。

惟查，證人甲○○於本院審理時，就相關與被告戊○○相涉之事，多以「不記得」應答，且其中就最關鍵部分，亦即戴沼澤在譯文中稱「昨天有跟長仔」所指何事，亦係先證稱：不知道戴沼澤與長官講什麼事情等語（見本院卷第142 頁背面），直待辯護人再度提示證人甲○○於該譯文中，證人甲○○曾回應「說3 天內要會勘」等語後，證人甲○○始更改證詞，改證稱應是在講災害會勘之事。

蓋觀諸前揭通訊監察譯文所載，證人甲○○於與戴沼澤通話過程中，證人甲○○於聽聞戴沼澤敘述有關聖帕颱風災損之情形時，對於戴沼澤所提出之任何事項均能即刻應答，無任何遲疑或不解之處，卻於本院審理時語多保留，更可見證人甲○○迴護之情。

從而，證人甲○○前揭證述內容，尚無從為被告戊○○有利之認定。

戴沼澤與廉裕隆於96年9 月17日7 時57分許有以下電話通話內容：「（廉）：喂。

（戴）：現在就2個問題喔。

（廉）：嗯。

（戴）：「財益」他那裡的，1 個問題就是說，我們早先 做那個，那個管涵的部分喔，現在改喔，「長仔 」那裡有默認啦喔，你可以這樣簽下去啦，再來 就是說他的建議性，他的建議喔，他拆除之後的 建議喔。

（廉）：嗯。

（戴）：算說我們在管下那裡都「8層」的嘛。

（廉）：嗯 ． ．（戴）：對啦，他的建議啦喔，因為，你現在管子改掉他 要建議「箱籠」嘛。」

又證人曾財益於偵查中證稱：「我並不知道廉裕隆與戴沼澤之通話前段的意義為何，而有關其中『七層』、『八層』應該就是指災損會勘紀錄中將原先的管涵改設計為7 層或8 層的箱型石籠變動而言。」

等語（見97年度偵字第10922 號卷三第71頁），顯見戴沼澤、廉裕隆上開談話內容係有關聖帕颱風災損之問題，且因證人戴沼澤及廉裕隆並不知有遭監聽乙事，證人戴沼澤於電話中向證人廉裕隆提及「長仔」（即被告戊○○）那裡有默認啦等語，應係確有其事，亦即被告戊○○有默認之處及有提建議意見。

關於柯羅莎颱風災損賠償部分：嗣便道工程又因柯羅莎颱風發生災損，被告戊○○承續配合川順公司辦理聖帕颱風災損估驗與請款手續之手法，配合川順公司辦理柯羅莎颱風災損之估驗與請款手續。

且96年10月31日，便道工程正值辦理第2 次變更設計會勘審核及第2 次柯羅莎颱風災損會勘認定審核，於同日下午2 時30分許，戴沼澤邀被告戊○○赴川順公司位在臺中市旱溪旁之天祥街木屋打麻將。

嗣於同日下午4 時許，戴沼澤指示廉裕隆招待戊○○及林榮紹前往「九龍理容KTV 」飲酒作樂，並由徐玉玲接待、安排女侍坐檯飲酒作樂，該日消費至同日晚間11時許，消費帳款共1 萬6550元，由廉裕隆向徐玉玲簽帳，再持向川順公司請款。

④減災工程鋼柵位置依現況施作而免拆除重做部分：第三河川局於96年12月25日以水三工字第00000000000 號函請水利署就第三河川局辦理減災工程，為配合現場施工需要，派員辦理履勘。

嗣水利署於97年1 月7 日辦理會勘，並於97年2 月14日以經水工字第00000000000 號函行文第三河川局同意依97年1 月7 日會勘案結論辦理，所需增加經費由原計畫下支應等情，業據證人彭壽奇於偵查中證述屬實，並有上開2 件函文影本附於偵查卷（卷十第 192至198 頁）可稽。

戴沼澤於97年1 月2 日，與第三河川局派駐工務所監工彭壽奇研商如何變更設計解決，並要求彭壽奇協助製作同意「逕行施工」之紀錄為依據，以辦理會勘及變更設計，同年1 月3 日，川順公司收到1 月7 日辦理會勘公文，戴沼澤即邀請被告戊○○至川順公司天祥街招待所打麻將。

迨同年1 月7 日，辦理變更設計會勘，同日下午，被告戊○○邀第三河川局及第七河川局人員共同接受戴沼澤招待至「九龍理容KTV 」飲宴娛樂，晚上由徐玉玲安排該店105 號小姐陳瑤寰出場為戊○○提供性招待，均由川順公司支付帳款。

足見被告戊○○就此亦有踐履特定之職務行為配合川順公司。

辯護人雖為被告戊○○辯稱此部分實際業務是由徐崧清、彭壽奇、己○○、羅仕政、曹海珠等5 人負責；

且參與會勘之人員，亦非被告戊○○所指派等情，並援引證人己○○、張政茂、黃昌具、徐崧清、彭壽奇等人證述為證，惟被告戊○○於當時身為第三河川局局長，辦理前揭業務之對外行文，均需經過被告戊○○，被告戊○○復就相關事項多與川順公司人員私下討論，已可認被告戊○○有踐履特定職務行為，以便利配合川順公司。

辯護人此部分辯解，亦難為被告戊○○有利之認定。

⑵就被告壬○○部分：被告壬○○對本件便道工程、減災工程，於其擔任水利署工程事務組副組長職位上，具有有監督管理職務上之權限，證據資料臚列如下①水利署工程事務組鄭文亮於96年7 月25日簽擬授權本便道工程予第三河川局之公文上，被告壬○○簽註「擬同意」之職務上意見（見同上偵卷十，第184 至187 頁，第186頁）。

②97年3 月5 日本便道工程驗收紀錄，認本便道工程與竣工圖相符，驗收合格；

被告壬○○於「單位主管」核章。

（見同上偵卷十，第88至191 頁）③水利署工程事務組辛○○於97年2 月4 日簽辦本減災工程97年1 月4 日變更設計會勘案，被告壬○○簽註「擬同意」之職務上意見（見同上偵卷十，第193 至196 頁，第195 頁）。

④水利署工程事務組辛○○於97年4 月3 日簽辦本減災工程97年3 月12日變更設計會勘案，被告壬○○簽註「擬同意」之職務上意見。

（見同上偵卷十，第200 至202 頁，第201 頁）⑤被告壬○○於偵查中供承：水利署有組成工程督導小組，針對水利署及所屬河川局發包之各項工程進行督導事項，其成員並非固定，通常於每個月月底會排定下個月之預定督導行程，每次督導均由科長以上人員擔任領隊，並「由我指派」，組員則由第一至第四科之科長分別指派相關承辦人員擔任，該督導行程表於96年係由本組第二科副工程司牟敦梅負責編製，「經我指派」各工程領隊後核定。

（見同上偵卷十，第175 頁背面）。

⑥綜上證資資料顯示，被告壬○○對本件便道工程之施作，於其職務上具有管理監督之責，至屬明確，堪以認定之。

⑦至被告壬○○雖辯稱伊僅係基於一般公文流程而批示公文或簽註意見，且於該段期間內，伊就未接受飲宴招待之其他工程，亦無刻意刁難之處，難以認為伊係以公文之批示做為其向川順公司收受不正利益所為回報之對價。

且證人宋伯永亦於本院前審審理時證稱：「（你在96年、97年擔任什麼職務？工作內容為何？）在這段期間是擔任水利署的工務組組長。

工務組的業務是從招標、發包、訂約一直到驗收這些工務的業務。」

、「（被告壬○○在96、97年間是擔任什麼職務？工作內容為何？）他當時是擔任工務組的副組長。

他的業務是襄助組長的一些事務。」

、「（經濟部水利署在便道工程要負責什麼事項？就是沒有授權的部分是哪些部分？）沒有授權的部分是設計變更的經費跟驗收的一些業務。」

、「（經濟部水利署在減災工程部分是負責什麼事項？）也是從工務的招標開始一直到驗收的這些工務行政業務。」

、「（壬○○在減災工程跟便道工程的公文簽核上跟之前的公文簽核相比有沒有特別寬鬆或特別迅速，而讓這二個工程事實上比較容易通過的情形？）依我的感覺應該沒有。

因為一般我們都是有公文到我們手上，我們點到了、顯示出來了，我們再來做判決。」

、「（以被告的層級他能否因為對某個廠商的好惡在簽核上做刁難讓廠商比較不容易通過或是流程比較慢？）我想以公文判定的話應該是所謂的可行或不可行、內容有沒有問題。

有問題可能要退回基層再重新斟酌，假如沒有問題的話就再往上更高一階的公文程序。

所謂的刁難或沒有刁難，我想不是這個問題，是因為公文的內容有沒有問題，要不要做進一步的處分。」

、「（被告有沒有請你或是其他工程事務組的人在這二個工程的文件上減少提供意見，讓審核比較容易通過或比較快通過？）沒有這樣的情形。

」等語，欲證明並無證據足以證明被告壬○○本有刁難川順公司之意，係因川順公司加以行賄後始未予刁難；

且亦無證據證明被告壬○○有快速簽核公文之情形。

惟查，一般民眾及公司行號向行政機關申請為特定作為時，行政機關就相關公文簽核程序是否刻意刁難，對於一般民眾及公司行號，本係重要之點，雖被告及證人宋伯永均陳稱其等處理公文之程序，即係電腦顯示出來，其等即做判斷，惟依照證人宋伯永前揭證述可知，其等需對公文判定是否可行，及確認內容有無問題，如內容有問題，即應退回基層再重新斟酌，亦即，被告壬○○依照伊當時職務所處之層級，對於前揭相關公文，並非毫無影響力，且對於需在時程內完成前揭便道工程及減災工程之川順公司而言，更屬重要，從而，被告壬○○辯稱伊僅係基於一般公文流程批示公文，伊接受喝花酒招待與伊職務行為無關云云，尚難採信。

再者，被告壬○○於另案處理中，是否有刻意刁難之情，亦實與本案無關。

從而，被告壬○○前揭辯解，亦難為被告壬○○有利之認定。

⒌綜上所述，本院認為：⑴賄賂罪的成立，以公務員所擔當的職務與賄賂之間，居於對價關係為要件，而當作為賄賂對價之職務行為，並非公務員現實上實際處理的事項時，能否成立賄賂罪。

作為賄賂對象的職務，雖然不是該公務員具體擔當的事務，但是只要是屬於其一般性職務權限範圍之內，就足以成立賄賂罪。

亦即，行政機關內部的事務職掌的劃分，在職務行為的判斷上並非重要，只要在該當公務員所屬的組織、該當官職所掌的事務的範圍內，皆應認為包含於職務行為內。

例如國稅局的職員，在被委託對於自己負責的區域外之人的所得稅調查事項多加斟酌，並收受賂的情形，該職員「在同國稅局的管管轄內的納稅義務人中，不論是對何人，都有從事關於對義務人所得稅的賦課、減免等事務的法令上的職務權限，而且「分擔事務的內容，也是在主管認為必要之時，即能夠加以變更」。

具體而言，在屬於同一行政內部單位「組」、「科」、「課」或「股」的範圍內之事務，皆為該單位所屬人員之職務，並不因該內部單位再細分的職務而受影響。

公務員之職務應以法令為依據，且不以法令直接規定為必要。

從而，判斷公務員作為賄賂對價的行為，是否屬於其職務範圍內，還是必須回到該職務的法令依據來加加以觀察。

從一般的組織法觀之，公務員均是在任務編組在該組織內之行政內部單位，幾乎不可能以個人為單位，因此，不可能也不必要針對個別公務員去規範有別於其他公務員之職務權限範圍。

從而，所謂一般職務權限，應該以公務員「能夠」執行該職務行為為劃定範圍的標準。

⑵在賄賂罪中係以賄賂或不正利益與職務行為間的「對價關係」為要件，又所謂「對價關係」指的是賄賂或不正利益與職務行為問存在著給付與對待給付的關係，並且也以此作為賄賂與一般社交禮儀間的界線。

又職務行為的相對人支付這種類對待給付，只需就一特定職務務行為概括地確定，且在大體上可認定其間具有對價關係，即為已足，而不以對職務行為的種類與內容具體而詳細的圴加以確定為必要。

所謂的對價關係，是由行為人與相對人間所為的（或欲為的）不法約定所形成，其約定的內容，就是將賄賂或不正利益與職務行為互相成為給付與對待給付。

亦即，行為人向相對人表達出以利益交換職務上一定的作為或不作為即賄賂罪成立要件之要求，或者雙方就此一交換條件形成合意即賄賂罪成立要件之期約，就可認為已經締結前述的不法約定，從而也確立了賄賂或不正利益與職務行為問存在對價性。

對於公務員而言，該利益對於職務行為的影響，一方面來自於該利益本身，一方面亦源自於透過此一意思表示合致所產生的拘束力。

亦即會對職務行為產生影響的是「我可以在職務上給你方便，但是你要有所回饋」以及「我可以給你利益，但是定你要在職務上有所表示」這樣的的意思合致的拘束力。

在賄賂與職務行為的對價關係上，形成此一不法約定的，不在於行為主體與相對人間有何書面或口頭或其他形式的約定，而在於彼此間有無「互相交換職務與利益」的主觀想法，只要雙方對利益與所換取的職務，在主觀上都能夠接這樣的交換條件，就會影響行為主體執行職務行為的公正。

⑶被告戊○○及壬○○2 人身為國家中央機關之簡任第十一職等首長、簡任第十職等主管之公務員，職位上所承辦之職務復與該機關發包而具有監督管理之川順公司工程進行有關，非但未能消極避嫌而要求自己勿與該公司業者往來交遊，反而積極告知進而提供該公司工程進行事務進行之意見及提供職務上相對應之行為，再由其等在所屬簽擬職務之意見，展現高度之緊密配合關係，絕非單純基於私人情誼或為民服務之範疇，誠屬明確；

另川順公司承攬施作系爭便道工程與減災工程，倘循一定之程序與合約內容施工，本有一定之工程利潤，原無經常設宴款待被告戊○○及壬○○之必要，惟觀諸前揭廉裕隆與戴沼澤於2007年 9月6 日17時37分16秒及2008年3 月3 日13時59分19秒之通訊監察譯文內容所示，戴沼澤於電話中指示廉裕隆需找被告戊○○解決相關問題，更可見川順公司之廉裕隆及戴沼澤等人，為使系爭便道工程、減災工程得以順利施做之利益，經常提供高額之有女陪侍酒店消費及提供給被告戊○○一次性招待，已非正常之社交往來，且戴沼澤每每為解決系爭便道工程、減災工程之問題，即自行或委請廉裕隆為上開招待行為，其等自有行賄之意思。

從而，川順公司提供給被告戊○○、壬○○高額之酒店消費，與提供給被告戊○○性招待等不正利益間，確有對價關係無誤。

另被告戊○○、壬○○於川順公司承攬施作便道工程、減災工程期間，因踐履前述特定職務行為，而收受川順公司屢次提供之酒店消費招待及被告戊○○接受一次性招待，其等顯係基於該2 工程之順利進行，基於概括之犯意收受之，非謂每次特定職務行為即僅收受一次酒店消費之不正利益，亦不限於事前收受，即便多次收受或事後收受，均在其概括之犯意內；

且川順公司之戴沼澤、廉裕隆為使承攬、施作便道工程與減災工程此2 工程順利完工，亦概括式地提供被告戊○○、壬○○酒店消費之不正利益，及提供被告戊○○性招待之不正利益。

故如附表三所示之不正利益，均應認係被告戊○○踐履該2 工程特定職務行為之對價；

另如附表四所示之不正利益，則應認係被告壬○○踐屢前述2 工程特定職務行為之對價。

⑷本案被告戊○○及壬○○2 人在其等公務員職務上之行為，已被川順公司之戴沼澤、廉裕隆等人以上開不正利益以買通，雙方相互之間有對價關係之情形已明，又戴沼澤、廉裕隆等人所交付如附表三、四所示酒店消費款項，既係基於行賄意思為之，而被告戊○○及壬○○2 人，亦在其職務範圍內，踐履賄求對象之一定之職務上行為，亦如上所述明確。

至證人戴沼澤陳述及被告2 人辯稱如有提供川順公司工程上之意見，乃基於單純雙方個人情誼，其等上開接受之不正利益與其等職務上行為無對價關係云云，均無可採。

㈥併此敘明部分：有關本院認為被告戊○○處理本件川順公司所承攬便道工程、減災工程包括辦理變更設計、災損工程款、箱型石籠、鋼柵石籠之工務行政進行之程序，尚無違背法令，且收受上開不正利益並未有違背職務之情事，公訴意旨就此部分之認定，容有未洽，理由如下：⒈關於便道工程之變更設計，應屬該工程之必要，並非有所謂違背法令而圖利川順公司情事，證據理由如次：⑴便道工程係前總統陳水扁先生指示水利署須於96年12月底完成，水利署隨即成立專案小組由副署長楊偉甫負責該專案等情，此有證人即水利署副署長楊偉甫之證述（見97年度偵字第10922 號卷十，第54至77頁及原審卷五，第 312至316 頁，而證人楊偉甫證稱於調查員詢問、檢察官訊問及原審審理時之證述均實在，並無不同）、證人即水利署署長陳伸賢之證述及大甲溪砂石運輸便道專案小組第三次會議記錄、大甲溪砂石運輸便道執行情形會勘紀錄在卷（見97年度偵字第10922 號卷十，第64頁）可稽，證人之證述內容要旨如下。

堪認本件便道工程之工期緊迫必須於96年12月底竣工，工期確屬緊迫。

①證人陳伸賢於原審審理時證稱：「這個工程因為總統要求在十二月底，如果沒有趕在十一月底，就可能跳票了，所以要求第三河川局趕工。」

等語（見原審97年度訴字第3018號卷五，第309 頁背面）②證人楊偉甫於偵查中證稱：「95年11月30日陳水扁總統前往視察大甲溪砂石運輸便道工程後，指示經濟部水利署向上延伸大甲溪砂石運輸便道工程，並於96年底完成，所以經濟部水利署隨即成立專案小組並由我負責該專案。

96年3 月份第3 次專案小組會議曾討論如何加速，當時正在規劃96年度大甲溪砂石運輸便道工程第三標，經濟部水利署工務組提出『縮短招標期限及行政作業方式』，經檢討後決議『請第三河川局納入參考辦理；

運輸便道預算書成立及發包作業，為爭取時效，同意授權由第三河川局辦理，至發包後工務處理程序是否比照第二類工程辦理，原則上如屬一類工程仍應依一類工程工務處理規定辦理，如有必要再由相關組室檢討辦理。」

（見97年度偵字第10922 號卷十，第72、73頁）⑵便道工程確因時效性、安全性與工程進行當中施作環境之必要性，變更設計、改為箱型石籠施工之證據及理由如次：①便道工程原訂96年6 月15開工，但因設計單位世曦公司對於河川便道工程之設計缺乏經驗，不瞭解大甲溪上游之河川特性，故其於設計系爭便道工程時，因值枯水期，世曦公司為節省經費之考量，原設計採機編蛇籠施工，嗣得標廠商川順公司在實施測量、放樣時，已值汛水期，發現地形已改變，且該處河道狹窄、水流湍急，當時又正值汛期（梅雨季），且經常有颱風、豪雨及水庫放水．．等因素，蛇籠無法馬上施工，如等汛期過後再施工，適必無法在預定之96年12月31日前完工；

且如按原設計之機編蛇籠施工，因蛇籠坡度較緩，且佔水道面積較多，將使河道洪水斷面縮小，危及橋樑、道路之安全；

而箱型石籠施工較迅速，因石籠堆疊時即可回填土堤，而蛇籠則需等土堤完成後才能披掛上去，且箱型石籠較蛇籠穩固，故於96年6 月25開工前協調會時，第三河川局、世曦公司、川順公司已經就變更工法提出討論，業據證人即水利署副署長楊偉甫、第三河川局正工程司癸○○、曾財益、趙培善、甲○○、世曦公司工程師戴遐齡、張敬廉、廖嘉安、乙○○等人證述可按，證人之證述內容要旨如下：癸○○、林榮紹、許慶祥、高遐齡、楊青長、曾財益、張敬廉等在檢察官訊問時已陳述綦詳，其等偵查中之陳述亦與其等在原審審理中之證述意旨相同。

證人癸○○於97年12月18日原審審理時證述要旨：「（96年6 月25號開工前協調會有提到說工法要從甲種機編蛇籠變更為箱型石籠這件事是誰提出來的，當場是誰提出來的？）因為在6 月25號開工協調會之前大概一、兩天，就在旱溪工務所就討論過這個事了，那時候局長就告訴我了，就說我當時有提到。」

、「（當時在場的台灣世曦有張敬廉、高遐齡、還有一位楊長青他們三位對這個變更工法這件事情，他們表示什麼立場？）如果他們有表示反對意見或者不同的意見，我都會認真的考慮，不能說他們說沒有。」

、「（那你的意思是他們同意嘛？）是。」

、「（7月3 號實際開工以後，根據卷內的資料就是開始將箱型石籠來施作，是不是依照川順公司7 月2 號所提出的變更建議的變更書的方式來施作？）沒錯。」

、「技術層面就是工法的問題，就是上游河道狹窄，水流湍急，用蛇籠工法沒辦法做，必須改用箱型工法才能施工，技術層面指的是這個。」

（見原審卷六，第46至55頁背面）證人曾財益於97年12月18日原審審理時證述要旨：「（依你會勘的看法，它原先的設計是用蛇籠，它後來有變更為石籠，這個變更有沒有它的必要性？）因為在30K 以上這個河段，它事實上是比較狹窄，當初設計蛇籠的施工方式，在大水來的時候，它的土地馬上一定會被沖毀，蛇籠就沒辦法披掛上去，那就是沒辦法完成這個部分，對工期上的掌握是有問題的。」

、「（那你認為如果不變更設計，用原本的設計蛇籠，有辦法完工嗎？或是有辦法在期限內完工？）可能沒有辦法，因為大甲溪那個河道是真的比較狹窄，我的看法是沒有辦法。」

、「石籠因為它本身有自動可以保護，如果它底下被沖刷的話，它可以直接靠自己自動沈下去，不會說一下就被破壞掉，蛇籠部分有可能大水一沖它就翻掉，水就從翻掉的地方沖進去，因為我們那個便道就是填土方，整個便道就會流失。」

、「（你的意思是說台灣世曦公司當時在原設計階段沒有去考慮到汛期這個因素嗎？）有可能。」

、「（有可能是他們沒有考慮到？）還有整個河道狹小的問題，比較狹窄，他並沒有完全去考慮到這個因素。」

（見原審97年度訴字第3018號卷六，第88頁反面至90頁反面）證人趙培善於97年12月18日原審審理時證述要旨：「這個河道狹窄有必要一定要辦理變更設計，不然它會產生的後果影響就是它會減少通洪斷面，然後會影響河防安全，這部分地方的橋樑安全還有它在左邊有一個台八線，都可能會危及到，造成一個公共利益的危害。」

、「（如果按照原設計的話，它那個蛇籠位置已經在行水區的中央了？）對，在水路的中央。」

、「（那如果按照原設這樣做會有什麼後果？）第一個因為會減少通洪斷面可能就是旁邊的台八線，因為束縮造成這個水位會上升，然後整個會漫淹到台八線；

第二個它旁邊本身也有橋樑，就是我剛講的裡冷橋，．．；

第三個就是本身我們水利單位的河防安全，因為整個束縮造成可能的土石淤積也會影響到整個河川的安全。」

、「．．所以當時我認為這個部分在整個經費及整個通洪斷面安全上的考量，就我專業判斷應該是要辦理變更設計。」

（見原審97年度訴字第3018號卷六，第94至95頁反面）證人高遐齡在原審98年7 月23日審理中之證述要旨：「我們之前從30K+500 ，那一兩段開始的地方往上游走，在枯水期的時候，水流的行水區是在中央，水線很細，但大水沖蝕的時候整個深槽區就是組合到全部在我們要做的路的這一側，向下跟原始的路床降到3 到4 公尺深，寬差不多10公尺，所以那時候整個路堤都變了，就是跟原始地貌差了3 到4 公尺，所以我們那時候的看法也認為如果使用原設計用路堤先填再掛蛇籠，那是不行的。

那時癸○○有提議，我們沒有反對。

就是用石籠來做替代。

如依原設計圖說就不可能完成這便道工程。」

（見原審卷八，第195 頁至213 頁）證人張敬廉在原審98年7 月23日審理中之證述要旨：「因為在河道裡面，我們在6 月8 日的時候，有帶我們整個團隊上去看大水，整個漫過滿滿的狀況；

後來等到6 月15日進場以後他們實際測出來以後，果然跟我們的設計圖不一樣，就是以箱型石籠代替蛇籠，而沒有有停工是因為這個工程要求在年底完工。」

（見原審卷八，第213 頁至239頁）證人廖嘉安在原審98年7 月23日審理中之證述要旨：「因為在整個工程發包後，承商會在工地進行一些現地的地形測量，結果地形測量回到我們這邊，發現跟我們當初承攬設計案不一樣，原來設計圖可能要做一些修改；

我們才改用箱型蛇籠來做為變更設計。

箱型石籠的話，對整個工作後續影響最小。

如果用箱型石籠就可以解決問題。」

（見原審卷八，第239 頁至249 頁）證人乙○○在原審98年7 月23日審理中之證述要旨：「我後來有去工地時，現場有做斷面檢討，蛇籠沒有辦法施工，回到我們單位檢討，才去現場做確認。

我們去看現場，發現，現在水都整個流過來，沒辦法先築路堤再保護，只好用箱籠堆上來。」

（見原審卷八，第249 頁至254 頁）②關於大甲溪上游之水位與施工環境於96年6 月間起有所變化：96年6 月8 日起大甲溪上游確實有豪大雨發生，此有原審向台灣電力股份有限公司調取該公司在大甲溪流域設置之德基、青山、谷關、天輪壩（水庫）字96年6 月1 日至96年12月31日間每日放水量資料在卷可稽（台灣電力股份有限公司97年11月17日電發字第00000000000 號函，見原審卷五，第60至155 頁），依據該資料顯示德基壩之水位已96年6 月7 日24時是1397.09M、出水量30CMS ，6 月8 日24時已上升至1400.27M、出水量140CMS，6 月9 日24時已上升至1403.45M、出水量160CMS，6 月10日24時已上升至1404.19M、出水量196CMS，迄96年6 月30日之水位、出水量均較之96年6 月1 日至7 日為高。

而96年8 月間之水位、出水量亦均明顯有所升降。

又原審依職權向經濟部水利署調取「中華民國九十六年台灣水文年報第二部分水位及流量」一冊（外放）顯示，大甲溪流域在谷關大橋之測站所有顯示之水位變化資料，六月間最低為703.62M ，最高為706.55M ，7 月間最低為704.30M ，最高為704.38M ，8 月間最低為704.37M ，最高為708.32M ，9 月間最低為705.26M ，最高為706.51M ，10月間最低為704.92M ，最高為706.94M （見該冊書，第140 頁）。

可見於96年6 月至10月分間，大甲溪上游之水位高低相差有竟達3 公尺之譜。

又原審依職權向交通部中央氣象局調取96年臺中氣象站逐日雨量資料，顯示96年6 月、8 月間雨量與96年1 至5 月間每月雨量，96年1 至5 月每月平均雨量分別為：57.0、24.5、87.9、136.4 、169.1mm ，而96年6 至10月間每月平均雨量為：735.2 、62.0、516.0 、315.7 、289.8mm；

可見96年6 至10月間之與量較之前半年高出甚多，變化差異急遽（見原審卷三，第1 至3 頁）。

又本便道工程施作地點之雨量，經原審依職權向經濟部中央氣象局調取96年1 月至12月間臺中縣上谷關、新伯公、白冷3 站之逐日逐時雨量資料（交通部中央氣象局97年10月27日中象參字第0000000000號函）顯示，96年6 月、8 月、9 月、10月此三個月分降雨量為全年雨量最高之月分，分別是：96年6 月為1055mm、96年8 月為906.0mm 、96年9 月為379.0mm 、96年10月為431.0mm ，此有96年1 月至12月臺中縣上谷關、新伯公、白冷3 站逐日降水量資料1 份在卷可證（見原審卷四，第174 至175 頁）。

又原審依職權至經濟部中央氣象局網站所調查之96年8 月8 日帕布颱風之中央氣象局颱風警報發布概況表及動向圖、96年8 月9 日梧提颱風之中央氣象局颱風警報發布概況表及動向圖、96年8 月18日聖帕颱風之中央氣象局颱風警報發布概況表及動向圖、96年9 月18日韋帕颱風之中央氣象局颱風警報發布概況表及動向圖、96年10月6 日柯羅莎颱風警報發布概況表及動向圖、96年11月27日米塔颱風之中央氣象局颱風警報發布概況表及動向圖、發布颱風警報之列表各1 份（見原審卷二，第12至36頁），顯示96年 8月至11月間臺灣地區颱風密集，其中聖帕颱風、柯羅莎颱風雨量嚴重侵害臺灣中部地區。

③綜上所述，足見便道工程確因時效性、安全性與工程進行當中施作環境變動之必要性，變更設計、改為箱型石籠施工尚非無據，亦堪認便道工程變更設計、改為箱型石籠施工在該工程施作中應屬必要。

公訴意旨認便道工程變更設計，將「甲種機編蛇籠」全部改為「箱型石籠」施工，係僅為圖利川順公司，不無誤會。

⒉便道工程變更設計核准權限，由第三河川局核准，並非違背法令而有不法圖利川順公司，證據理由如次：⑴便道工程預算金額在5000萬元以上，固係屬水利署之第一類工程，然為爭取便道工程如期於96年12月底前完工之時效，乃於96年3 月29日由水利署副署長楊偉甫主持專案小組第三次會議，同意授權由第三河川局辦理該便道工程預算書之編列及發包作業，並附帶說明：「發包後工務處理程序是否比照第二類工程辦理，…如有必要再由相關組室檢討辦理」。

此有大甲溪砂石運輸便道專案小組第三次會議記錄附卷可證。

（見偵卷十，第42至43頁）⑵便道工程之變更設計，基於爭取工程時效及施工環境之必要之考量是屬必要的已如上所述。

而96年6 月22日水利署第54次擴大署務會報中，署長陳伸賢即已指示便道工程須加速處理，並同意便道工程之變更設計比照第二、三類工程授權第三河川局辦理。

理由如下：①經原審依職權向水利署調取該次會報之紀錄紀錄、簽到簿影本及錄音光碟在卷可按，該次會報係於96年6 月22日下午2 時正舉行，主席：陳署長伸賢（原審卷二，第3 至11頁），而該錄音光碟並在法庭上勘驗，其勘驗內容如下：第三河川局發言：「．．」（錄音模糊）陳伸賢：「第 3點最重要：一、被沖毀部分請他們趕快修 復。

二、發包部分工務組是不是設計變更可以授 權他們做．．（以下聽不出來) 」工務組：「不要因為個案授權！」陳伸賢：「這樣好不好，這個案子是總統去看了說要年底 ，我們給他開支票開到11月底。

就授權啦！授權 啦！就…快啦！這樣第三河川局就沒話說要趕快 趕。

第一個就授權啦。

第二個你就看怎樣快，那 個容易被沖毀，本來再做也沒有用的部分，你們 就讓他沖，然後就很簡單的就好，但可以做好的 就做好。

那另外是不是協調一下台電放水，台電 放水有沒有辦法協調？要找誰？署裡面？」不明人士發言：「．．」陳伸賢：「算是就互相尊重啦！他們的安全考量，但是在 安全無疑之下也要讓我們好施工啦！」不明人士：「可能要請中水局幫忙，就是看看那個量不要 一下子沖得太多，不過這個難，因為現在這個 蓄水量已經到達．．很久了。」

陳伸賢：「沒關係！怎麼樣折衷。

你若說安全要考慮這是 第一個嘛！水庫安全。

但是安全無疑之下也讓我 們好施工好不好？這個是不是連山兄（中區水資 源局局長林連山），那個上游台電的所有放水， 讓他們好施工，你先去配合第三河川局跟他們台 電協調一下，安全第一，但在安全無疑之下讓他 們好施工。

好不好？那這樣就盡快。

這個支票開 出去大家就都說要跳票了！想辦法想辦法。

就授 權。

然後這個要不要一個禮拜報一次進度？但是 有沒有進展？趕快！這個會．．然後汛期能施工 就盡量施工，這東西不能再．．這個一定要快一 定要快，好不好？就授權，但是你那個是不是． ．連山兄你協調，然後楊副你看看七月全部招標 完成後開個協調會看看哪邊有問題，事先預知一 下，怎麼樣協助他們，先如期完工！上一次說要 注意注意到現在才XX了！定到正常了我們再換！ 」不明人士：「第三河川局還有一個變造現在被掏空的情形， 當初設計的時候．．（錄音不明）．．我看不到 五年，這個問題當初在設計的時候就一直對外說 要小心，不然到時候來查說為什麼沖壞掉．．」陳伸賢：「像這一次被沖毀的，不是．．因為設計是我們 設計的嘛！所以就不是包商的問題。

如果按照我們 設計的規格施工的話那就是我們自己的問題啦！那 自己的問題就是說法的問題啦！那以後．．除非你 水文計算水位算錯了，不然你，以後名稱統一一下 ，．．那裏面的規格我們自己心裡有數就好。」

②證人陳伸賢於97年12月11日原審審理時證稱：「（是否有主持水利署於96年6 月22日下午2 點鐘召開之經濟部水利署第54次擴大署務會報？）是。」

、「（該次會報第三河川局參加人員為何人？）是林傳茂副局長。」

、「（在該次會報中何人提議有關大甲溪砂石便道工程之工程變更設計或施工預算書授權由第三河川局辦理？）是副局長林傳茂。」

、「（你是否於該次會報中有表示『這樣好不好，這個案子是總統去看了說要年底，我們給他開支票開到11月底。

就授權啦！授權啦！就．．快啦！這樣第三河川局沒話說要趕快趕。

第一個就授權啦。

第二個你就看怎樣快，那個容易被沖毀，本來再做也沒有用的部份，你們就讓他沖，然後就很簡單的就好，但可以做好的就做好。

那另外是不是協調一下台電放水，台電放水有沒有辦法協調？要找誰？署裡面？）有。」

、「（是否在該次會報中已口頭同意有關大甲溪砂石便道工程之工程變更設計或施工預算書授權由第三河川局辦理？）那天署務會議紀錄並沒有紀錄，會議中大家口頭交換意見，在政策上我們是同意第三河川局辦理，但是請第三河川局要依照程序呈報上來。

」、「（該次擴大署務會報有提到一句話『這個支票開出去大家就都說要跳票了』，你是否有說過這句話？）這個工程因為總統要求在十二月底，如果沒有趕在十一月底，就有可能跳票了，所以要求第三河川局趕工。」

、「（是否明白表示，請第三河川局如期完工？）當然希望第三河川局如期完工，但是還是要求第三河川局依照程序報上來。」

、「（將此工務行政授權第三河川局與如期完工有何關聯？）如果沒有授權的話，要由我們署裡面來做，時間上會長一點，變更部分可以授權，後來我知道變更預算書及驗收並沒有授權，授權就是少一個程序，時間上會比較快。」

等語（原審97年度訴字第3018號卷五，第308 頁反面至310 頁）。

③證人楊偉甫於97年12月11日原審審理時證稱：「（96年7月10日是否有到大甲溪視察便道工程？）有。」

、「（是否記得陪同視察三河局人員？）有三河局局長戊○○，本署公務組組長及河海組人員。」

、「（在視察當天，戊○○是否有提出此工程授權三河局？）討論過程，戊○○變更設計授權三河局的話，可加速完工。」

、「（就戊○○這些提議，如何指示？）擴大署務會報時，這個案子有討論過，視察中有發現有很多地方需要變更設計。

在現場發現需要變更設計地方很多，所以授權程序下來可以節省很多時間，所以我要求第三河川局儘快依程序報請授權。」

、「視察時，有發現很多地方被沖毀，施工位置約四分之一的長度受損，實際受損情況需現場評估。」

、「（現場視察時，是否有討論如何變更設計？）因過去大部分是利用蛇籠，比較容易被沖失，變更設計為石籠施工可以減少被沖失的情形，變更設計細節沒有談，但基本變更設計方式有討論。」

、「（站在水利署立場，變更工法為石籠，你是否贊同？）是。」

、「施工期間如果有洪水，石籠比較可以減少沖失，如果沒有洪水，石籠、蛇籠相差不大。

」、「就當天我到現場的情況，施工期間要在十一月底前完工的話有點困難。」

、「（在水利署立場，是希望工程要如期完工？）是。」

、「（九十六年八月十三日水利署同意授權的公文發出，如果從八月十三日開始工務行政，工期是否可以如期完工？）難度蠻高。」

、「（本件水利署同意授權後，權責機關是否為第三河川局？）是。」

、「水利署同意授權後，第三河川局就便道工程變更設計部分，是否仍須報水利署核准？）除了驗收及變更設計預算書部份，沒有授權外，其他都有授權，不需要再報水利署核准。」

等語（原審97年度訴字第3018號卷五，第312 頁至314 頁）。

④證人即第三河川局副局長林傳茂於原審審理時證稱：便道工程是96年8 月13日水利署公文授權。

署長在96年6 月22日擴大署務會報會議表示，就是同意授權第三河川局來辦理屬於水利工程事宜趕快來辦理這些事情。

我參加完該會議後，我以參加會議記錄的情形送給局長參考，另外用口頭方式告訴局長。

原審卷五第235 頁的便條紙就是我做給局長看的。

我認為水利署在96年6 月22日已經同意這樣一個授權。

如果等到96年8 月13日水利署正式公文下來以後，再辦理會勘變更設計等等程序完成以後，再來施工，要在年底前完工，困難度非常大等語（見原審97年度訴字第3018號卷六，第63至68頁）。

⑤證人即第三河川局管理課長甲○○於原審審理時證稱：96年6 月25日第三河川局的局務會報由戊○○局長主持，當天我有以管理課長報告大甲溪砂石運輸便道，大署授權由本局辦理變更設計計畫，以因應施工的實際需要，期使施工進度能如期完成，請工務所盡速簽報的事項，局長也有做裁示，這有記在當天會議記錄內，這局務會報會議記錄會傳送局內各課室等語。

（見原審97年度訴字第3018號卷六，第59至60頁）⑥又水利署於96年6 月22日下午2 點中召開之經濟部水利署第54次後，第三河川局於96年6 月25日即召開第5 次局務會報，在會報中該局管理課提出業務報告即已報告：「大甲溪砂石運輸便道，大署授權由本局辦理變更設計計畫，以因應施工的實際需要，期使施工進度能如期完成，請工務所盡速簽報」。

此有第三河川局於97年12月4 日以水三廉字第00000000000 號函送之該局96年6 月25日第5 次局務會報會議記錄，及參加水利署第54次擴大署務會報之第三河川局副局長林傳茂會議完畢後之翌日所上陳局長戊○○之便簽（見原審97年度訴字第3018號卷五，第226 至236 頁），該簽上記載：「9.大甲溪砂石運輸便道（13k 至33k ）工程設計變更授權三河局核行。

台電管有水庫放水影響施設，由中水局協同三河局洽辦台電公司大甲溪發電廠」。

⑦綜上所述，是有關便道工程之變更設計，於96年6 月22日之水利署擴大署務會報中已由水利署署長授權第三河川局核行，而第三河川局於96年6 月25日該局局務會報後，即轉知該局所屬員工有關便道工程變更設計係由第三河川局辦理，至為明確，應可認定之。

⒊按95年5 月30日修正公佈之貪污治罪條例第6條第1項第4款規定：「對於主管或監督之事務，明知違背法令，直接或間接圖自己或其他私人不法利益，因而獲得利益。」

，所謂「違背法令」之「法令」，依其立法理由係指包括法律、法律授權之法規命令、職權命令、自治條例、自治規則、委辦規則等對多數不特定人民就一般事項所作對外產生法律效果之規定。

於98年4 月22日復將貪污治罪條例第6條第1項第4款修正公布為「對於主管或監督之事務，明知違背法律、法律授權之法規命令、職權命令、自治條例、自治規則、委辦規則或其他對多數不特定人民就一般事項所作對外發生法律效果之規定，直接或間接圖自己或其他私人不法利益，因而獲得利益者。」

將違背「法令」之範圍明文化。

而所謂「法律授權之法規命令」，應係指行政程序法第150條第1項所稱「行政機關基於法律授權，對多數不特定人民就一般事項所作抽象之對外發生法律效果之規定」之法規命令而言，並不包括同法第159條所指「上級機關對下級機關，或長官對屬官，依其權限或職權為規範機關內部秩序及運作，所為非直接對外發生法規範效力之一般、抽象之規定」之行政規則。

至所謂「職權命令」，係指行政機關在職權範圍內為執行法律，未經法律授權，而逕依職權制定頒布之命令。

中央法規標準法第7條規定各機關依其法定職權訂定之命令，即所謂之職權命令。

如該職權命令係就不特定人民所作對外發生法律效果者，亦屬本條款所規定之「法令」；

反之，如僅對行政內部之下級機關及所屬行政人員發生效力之職權命令，則不屬之。

公務員之行為，倘僅違反具有規範內部效力之行政規則或職權命令，則屬行政責任或懲戒責任之範圍，尚非貪污治罪條例圖利罪規範之對象（最高法院98年台上字第292 號判決可參）。

起訴意旨認為本件便道工程、減災工程之施作程序，於程序時序上未能依「經濟部水利署工務處理要點」、「經濟部水利署辦理工程變更設計暨修正施工預算作業注意事項」善盡執行工程契約履約管理，而認被告有明知而故意違背之「法令」，係經濟部水利署訂定之「經濟部水利署工務處理要點」第7條、第21條規定及「經濟部水利署辦理工程變更設計暨修正施工預算作業注意事項」第3條、第10條等規定，然該等規定係規範經濟部水利署所屬機關為辦理各項工程採構等相關事務及辦理工程變更設計或修正施工預算作業所為之規定，並無直接對外發生法規範之效力，所屬公務員若有違反前揭規定，亦屬行政責任或懲戒責任之範圍，尚與貪污治罪條例第6條第1項第4款所稱「違背法令」之構成要件不合。

⒋就本件便道工程，綜上所查證據顯示及所述理由，本院認為：①水利署已於96年6 月22日第54次擴大署務會報已授權第三河川局辦理變更設計之權限，僅驗收、變更設計預算書尚須水利署核准，而第三河川局於96年6 月25日即召開第 5次局務會報，在會報中該局管理課提出業務報告即已報告：「大甲溪砂石運輸便道，大署授權由本局辦理變更設計計畫，以因應施工的實際需要，期使施工進度能如期完成，請工務所盡速簽報」，故第三河川局自96年6 月25日嗣後同意川順公司便道工程變更設計施工方法將蛇籠變更為箱型石籠進行施作，要無違背法令或上級命令之虞，至於第三河川局所屬公務員簽報之行政作業上公文函復往來，係屬程序問題，故而第三河川局於96年7 月17日以水三管字第00000000000 號函請水利署授權本便道工程變更設計（見原審卷十，第46頁），及水利署於96年8 月13日以經水工字第00000000000 號函之說明二「．．除變更設計預算書核定及工程驗收不予授權外其他工務行政作業均授權三河川局比照第二類工程辦理．．」（見原審卷十，第65頁），乃在完成上開96年6 月22日第54次擴大署務會報署長同意授權便道工程之變更設計之權限之行政作業流程。

公訴意指未能斟酌此署務會報中署長已明確指示同意授權之事證，遽以96年8 月13日始由水利署以經水字第00000000000 號函發後，始為授權第三河川局辦理便道工程之變更設計等工務行政，便道工程使得據以辦理變更設計將蛇籠施工法變更為石籠施工法，容有明顯錯誤，尚有未洽。

②又依據「經濟部水利署工務處理要點」第21條㈠固規定：水利署為工程契約之甲方，且屬第一審工程，相關工程變更設計或施工預算書修正，其所屬附屬機關應將會勘結論或查核報告或核准事項編製修正施工或變更設計預算書報本署核定、「經濟部水利署辦理工程變更設計暨修正施工預算作業注意事項」第3條固規定：「工程須辦理變更設計時，各所屬執行或主辦工程機關應事先詳實查核原因外，並須擬具處理方案及準備相關資料、圖表及增減經費估算表，依本署工務處理要點之工程類別處理權責報核；

需現場勘查以為核定依據時，由成立預算核定機關派員會勘決定，並依工程類別處理權責報請上級機關派員監辦。

會勘結果依工程別處理權責奉准後始可辦理變更設計手續」。

惟有關「先行施工」部分，上開處理要點第四項規定：各類工程經核定修正或變更設計原則後，於編製修正施工或變更設計預算書前，得先行與廠商辦理新增單價協議並達成協議後，得先行施工付款；

上開注意事項第10條規定：「工程有下列情形之一且其變更設計原則經會勘共同認定有先行施工之必要者，經依工程類別處理權責核准後得先行施工」。

亦足見變更設計原則確定後並經第三河川局之同意，即可先行施工。

而本件系爭便道工程，水利署既已於96年6 月22日該署第54次擴大署務會報中，水利署長同意授權第三河川局比照第二、三類工程自行辦理變更設計，則上開注意事項第10條所稱：『工程類別處理權責』即為第三河川局，故第三河川局於水利署同意授權辦理便道工程變更設計後，其變更設計原則經第三河川局工務所正工程司癸○○召集川順公司、世曦公司人員於96年6 月25日進行開工前協調會，該協調會議紀錄已載明同意以箱型石籠先行施工，工務所主任癸○○召開之上述96年6 月25日開工前協調會會議紀錄於當日送核第三河川局，由局長戊○○於96年6 月29日批示「一、會議記錄如擬，二、如以箱型籠施作，不須外加掛披蛇籠。」

因而此後有先行施工之必要，乃於變更設計預算書、變更設計圖表製作完成前，核准川順公司先行以箱型石籠施工，亦無違反於上開處理要點及注意事項及之規定。

③復按「經濟部水利署辦理工程變更設計暨修正施工預算作業注意事項」（原審卷一，第235 至236 頁）、「經濟部水利署工程監造注意事項」（原審卷三，第82至128 頁），該二項注意事項，僅屬規範水利署暨所屬機關內部行政程序之控管，並非法律、法律授權之法規命令、職權命令、委辦規則等，並不對不特定多數人民就一般事項所作對外發生法律效果之規定。

並非違背法令，況且該便道工程及減災工程之變更設計均屬必要且適法，難認有違背其等之職務上應作為。

④本件便道工程之變更設計確屬必要性、並須於96年12底前完工之急迫性已如上所述，其變更設計程序之行政作業程序在水利署之內部作業規定，如上所述之注意事項或處理要點，即有工程施工期間因時制宜之變通方式，不能單以工程進行之變更設計或先行施工等情事，遽認被告等有明知違背法令而圖利川順公司。

公訴意旨以水利署上開96年8 月13日核准授權公文函復第三河川局時起，始得就便道工程才得開始變更設計程序並先行施工之行政公文往來程序（相關公文內容要旨詳如附表十一）是否完備之行政瑕疵，認定為違背法令與不法圖利川順公司，不無誤會。

⑤另檢察官上訴意旨謂：第三河川局辦理便道工程，被告戊○○有違反水利法第46條規定，係違背法令云云。

惟查：水利法第46條係規定：「興辦水利事業，關於下列建造物之建造、改造或拆除，應經主管機關之核准：一、防水之建造物。

二、引水之建造物。

三、蓄水之建造物。

四、洩水之建造物。

五、抽汲地下水之建造物。

六、與水運有關之建造物。

七、利用水力之建造物。

八、其他水利建造物。

前項各款建造物之建造或改造，均應由興辦水利事業人備具詳細計畫圖樣及說明書，申請主管機關核准。

如因特殊情形有變更核准計畫之必要時，應由興辦水利事業人聲敘理由，並備具變更之計畫圖樣及說明書，申請核准後為之。

但為防止危險及臨時救濟起見，得先行處置，報請主管機關備案。

未經主管機關核准而擅行施工之水利建造物，主管機關得令其更改或拆除。」

而本件便道工程非屬上開法條所列之「防水建造物」、「引水建造物」、「蓄水建造物」、「洩水建造物」、「抽汲地下水之建造物」、「與水運有關之建造物（依水利建造物建造、改造或拆除審核作業要點第3條規定，係指開鑿運河及其相關設施）」、「利用水力之建造物」、「其他水利建造物（依上開審核作業要點第3條規定，係指其他非屬前七款建造物經中央主管機關認定，有納入管理必要之水資源利用或水患防治建造物及其相關設施」，自無水利法第46條規定之適用。

⒌本院認定減災工程之變更施作，應無違背法令亦尚非基於被告違背職務所為，證據及理由如下：⑴本件減災工程有關「鋼柵箱籠」廠商施作位置與設計圖不符部分，就「經濟部水利署辦理工程變更設計暨修正施工預算作業注意要點」規定而言，並非屬於「變更設計」項目，而係「修正施工預算」之項目，故依「經濟部水利署辦理工程變更設計暨修正施工預算作業注意要點」有關「修正預算」之規定，並無起訴書所指未經水利署核准前，必需「停工」或「先行施工」之情形，按檢察官偵查本件案發當時之「經濟部水利署辦理工程變更設計暨修正施工預算作業注意要點」第2 點：「本注意事項名詞定義如下：㈠變更設計：指工程施工中，因故需變更原設計原則以完備原設計標的之功能需求或為因應緊急事項、事實需求及其他必需配合處理等涉及設計原則及預算之變更。

㈡修正施工預算：指工程施工中，因經費之財源調整、工程項目數量漏列或誤估之調整、地形變動致施工數量不符之調整、其他署辦費用之調整、契約項目規定以實做數量結算之調整、因政府法令、稅捐、規費或管制費率變更之調整及因政策變更須作契約之終止或解除之調整等不涉及設計原則變更所為之預算修正。」

之規定。

所謂「工程變更」涉及到「設計原則」及「預算」的變更；

而「修正預算」則僅係涉及到預算之變更而已，二者並非相同。

而本件減災工程系因「地形變動致施工數量不符之調整」之事由，不涉及設計原則之變更，乃屬於「修正預算」項目，並非「工程變更」項目，應堪認定。

公訴意旨疏而未查，認為本件減災工程有「變更設計」情事，當屬誤會。

⑵減災工程依現狀施作鋼柵箱籠乃必要且適當合法，證據理由如次：①本件減災工程之「設計原則」乃依據經濟部水利署先於95年間委請青山工程顧問有限公司針對頭汴坑溪崩塌地所提出之「頭汴坑溪一江橋至內成橋河段崩塌地所研擬之治理對策及效益評估報告」（下稱：評估報告）中之「短期治理方案」，而該「短期治理方案」中對於本件減災工程右岸崩塌地部分，提出治理對策為「自0+390 左右銜接現有已建堤防，將崩塌地侵入河道之坡趾部分以鋼柵箱籠保護，施作長度約為460 公尺，即約在0+750 公尺左右。

崩塌地坡趾處施作鋼柵箱籠高約6M下埋約1-2M，+750往上游約900 公尺之範圍施作石籠護岸，最後100 公尺亦採鋼柵箱籠。

右岸部分長共計1435公尺。

．．另依設計圖於施作鋼柵箱籠時，需向內及向下開挖崩塌地坡趾，此時需特別注意開挖崩塌地坡趾時之施工安全，嚴防開挖坡趾時，誘發其上端土石之淺層滑動。」

，復於「6.2 建議」時，再次重申「二、現有崩塌區坡趾之土石堆積，需配合整體邊坡整治進行及護岸加固，現階段不宜任意清除該堆積土石。

」等語，可見，本件減災工程之設計原則：係在上址崩塌地坡趾處施作鋼柵箱籠，以防止崩塌地遭河流沖刷，致其上端土石繼續崩塌，尤其必須注意不宜任意清除該堆積土石，避免繼續造成崩塌。

惟本件減災工程於原設計時所標示之鋼柵箱籠位置，因在工程設計規劃後，崩塌地因再行崩落及河流沖刷等因素，現場實際坡趾位置與原設計鋼柵箱籠施作之坡趾位置有所變動，致使廠商川順公司於現場施作時，依照現有崩塌地坡趾位置施作鋼柵箱籠，而發生與原設計圖不符情形，此有卷內減災工程97年1 月7 日會勘記錄第六點「右岸0K+900至施工終點工區，同意依施工條件及崩塌地形調整施設位置。」

（見97年度偵字第10922 號卷九，第150 頁）可資證明。

②證人即本減災工程原設計者己○○之證述要旨如下：於偵查時檢察官訊問時證稱：「．．我在設計本減災工程崩塌地鋼柵箱籠保護工項時，即是設定施工時依崩塌地地形去配置鋼柵箱籠的地點，所以崩塌地形改變後，本來就會與原設計位置有所偏移，本變更設計項目並未涉及工法的改變，僅是施工里程總數量的改變（有增加也有減少）．．」（見97年度偵字第10922 號卷九，第133 頁）。

「依97年1 月7 日會勘結論第4 點、第6 點及97年3 月12日會勘結論第4 點，本減災工程右岸工區因崩塌地地形與設計時地形有所改變，允許承攬廠商依實際地形施作蛇籠、鋼柵石籠等設施。

故鋼柵石籠樁號及設置位置與原設計圖有不符及偏移狀況，但僅是施工里程數量的改變，並不是屬於重大變更設計。」

等語（見97年度偵字第10922 號卷九，第137 頁）。

於原審審理中之證述要旨如下：「最高學歷為博士。

研究的項目為大地工程組。

像本件這種崩塌地防治工程，是屬於我的專長。

這件減災工程在崩塌地施作鋼柵箱籠，它的設計原則在這裡面，因為我們一般作坡地保護，就是先把坡趾保護起來，也不能開挖太多的坡趾，也不能任意挖置，不然會影響邊坡穩定，造成邊坡地滑動災害。

兩個原則，第一個在坡趾地方施作；

第二個是不可以清除這些崩塌的土石。」

「這份評估報告在我們這件減災工程就是我們根據這份報告先作一個初步的處理，後續如果還要進行處理的話，會另案再處理。

參考評估報告來作一個坡趾保護工的厚度細部設計。

我有參加97年1 月7 號的會勘，第六點裡面有記載右岸0K+900至施工終點工區，同意依施工條件及崩塌地地形調整施設位置，是因為崩塌地在我們測量設計到施工的時候，坡趾有受到沖刷，坡地有繼續崩落，造成地形的改變，如果你要按照原線稜去施作的話，你必須削掉很多的崩塌坡地，那是不符合設計原則的，基本上只是線形按照我們安全性的原則去做一個修正，所以它其實是屬於修正施工方面。」

「這種情形是屬於因為地形變動，而需要作調整。

依照這個結論的意思，鋼柵箱籠它的設計原則及工法當時有沒有改變。」

等語（見原審98年6月18日審理筆錄）。

由上本件減災工程之原設計者之證人己○○之證詞可知，本件97年1 月7 日會勘結論第6 點部分，係依據地形變動所做之調整而已，並未變更任何設計原則，應可認定之。

證人辛○○在原審審理中之證述要旨：「關於會勘記錄的第六點『右岸0K+900至施工終點工區，仍依施工條件及崩塌地形調整施設位置』，是因為直接施工的時候，跟它原先設計的情況已經不一樣了，就是地形有稍微改變，因為右岸是護岸，所以按照地形去調整它的情況、位置，還有達到原來保護目的的施工方式。

未依照施工的條件，在實際上施工的設計與工法沒有改變。」

、「另外結論裡面記載依崩塌地形調整施設位置是因為它跟原來的情況不太一樣，崩塌地有再往河中心再崩塌一些，所以依崩塌地的現況去做調整位置。

本件是屬於地形變更的問題。」

等語，是川順公司施作本件鋼柵箱籠位置與設計圖不符，係因地形變動所致，原「設計原則」並未變更，而僅是數量的增減而已，參以上開注意要點相關規定，並非第2 點第1項之「變更設計」，亦可認定之。

③復按上開注意要點第10點（先行施工）所規定「工程有下列情形之一且變更設計經會勘共同認定有先行施工之必要者，經依工程類別處理權責核准後得先行施工，再依規定程序辦理變更設計手續：㈠遇風災、水災、震災、通水、抽心等不可抗力之事由。

㈡因施工危及公共設施、人民生命財產安全。

㈢上級教辦限期完成工程必須辦理變更或配合其他公共設施拆遷等工程。」

之規定，可知所謂「先行施工」係指在變更設計時始有適用，另於「修正施工預算」項目時，則並無相關停工、「先行施工」之適用已明。

而本件減災工程依上開注意要點第2 點規定，證人即原設計人己○○、證人辛○○等上述證詞可知，鋼柵箱籠施作位置與設計圖不符，並無變更設計問題，施作廠商川順公司亦並無應先行停工或施工之必要，故川順公司於97年2月24日水利署核定1 月7 日會勘記錄前先行施作鋼柵箱籠之行為，應屬於法有據。

④減災工程自96年6 月20日起，由第三河川局負責監造下開始施工，該工程因頭汴坑溪岸坡工程用地未完全取得，斷續停、復工，迄96年12月間川順公司施作左右岸「鋼柵石籠」、「箱型石籠」、「蛇籠」等護岸工程。

97年1 月初川順公司開始施作右岸「鋼柵石籠」，其間因施作位置係依據現狀施作與原設計圖有所差異，發現設計時環境與現況環境崩塌地有明顯不同，為求解決施工與現況問題，乃於97年1 月7 日進行該工程第3 次變更設計會勘機會，戴沼澤親赴會勘現場，提案要求「右岸0K+900至施工終點工區，能依施工條件及崩塌地地形調整施設位置」，現場水利署會勘代表辛○○、張政茂認為原則可行，作成會勘結論，該變更設計會勘紀錄陳報水利署後，辛○○於97年2月4 日簽報，經工程事務組副組長壬○○、組長宋伯永審查，水利署署長陳伸賢於97年2 月13日批示准許。

又97年3 月12日由水利署代表辛○○、張政茂等辦理變更設計，會勘紀錄載明第4 點「右岸箱籠、蛇籠（R0+000～R1+531）因現地曲度與原設計略有差異，與原設計樁號不符。

建議能依現場地形調整樁號，並核實結算計價」，辛○○、張政茂等人接受該建議，將該提案列入評估，迄97年4 月3 日簽核前述第4 點等變更設計會勘紀錄，並經工程事務副組長壬○○、組長宋伯永審核，於4 月8 日由總工程司室謝世傑決行，同意該變更設計會勘內容。

⑤綜上證據資料顯示及理由說明，本件川順公司承作減災工程之施作鋼柵箱籠，本屬依合約規範之施工方法施作，施作鋼柵石籠位置符合前述「評估報告」中之「短期治理方案」之「設計原則」，均已如上所述，而水利署於行政程序事後亦核准廠商川順公司依現場實際地形施作。

公訴意旨於偵查中未能調查並斟酌上開「評估報告」中之「短期治理方案」及原設計減災工程證人己○○之證詞，遽以本件減災工程施作鋼柵箱籠位置錯誤，遽認被告係為使川順公司之鋼柵箱籠實際施作位置「就地合法」或免「拆除重做」而有明知違背法令而有違背職務行為，自有未洽，當屬誤會。

㈦綜上所述，被告戊○○及壬○○前揭犯行均可認定，皆應予依法論科。

三、論罪科刑及對原審判決之判斷：㈠按受賄罪之客體，一為賄賂，二為不正利益。

所謂賄賂，指金錢或可以金錢計算之財物而言；

所謂不正利益，指賄賂以外足以供人需要或滿人慾望一切有形無形之利益而言（最高法院21年上字第369 號判例參照），是貪污治罪條例第5條第1項第3款之罪之客體有二種，一為賄賂，一為不正利益，所謂「賄賂」係指金錢或得以金錢計算之財物；

「不正利益」則指賄賂以外，足以供人需要或滿足人之慾望，一切有形無形之利益而言（最高法院74年臺上字第1355號判例意旨可資參照）。

被告戊○○及壬○○要求、收受川順公司給付至如附表三、四所示之臺中市有女陪侍之理容KTV 酒店宴飲，且被告戊○○另收受性交易招待，其等收受核均屬不正利益。

再按貪污治罪條例第5條第1項第3款所稱「職務上之行為」，係指公務員在其職務權責範圍內所應為或得為之行為而言。

亦即指其權限範圍內之事項，而不違背其義務責任者是也。

反之，若在其職權範圍內，不應為而為之，或應為而不為，或不正當為之，而與其職務上之義務責任有所違背者，則應屬同條例第4條第1項第5款所謂之「違背職務之行為」。

因此，若公務員受賄之原因，係為其職務上應為或得為之行為者，則受賄人應成立同條例第5條第1項第3款之「對於職務上之行為收受賄賂或其他不正利益罪」。

反之，若受賄之原因，係為其職務上所不應為，或應為而不為，或以不正當方式為之，而違背其職責者，則應成立同條例第4條第1項第5款之「對於違背職務之行為收受賄賂或其他不正利益罪」。

經查，本案被告戊○○及壬○○就川順公司所承攬之便道工程、減災工程施作期間，對該二工程之處理，均屬在其等職務權責範圍內所應為或得為之行為，亦為其等權限範圍內之事項，均已如上所述，是其等應無違背義務責任者，而收受川順公司給付如附表三、四所示之不正利益。

核被告戊○○及壬○○2 人所為，均係犯貪污治罪條例第5條第1項第3款之對於職務上行為收受不正利益罪。

公訴檢察官認被告戊○○係犯貪污治罪條例第4條第1項第5款之違背職務收受賄賂罪，惟依照前揭理由欄㈥之說明，認公訴意旨尚有誤會，起訴法條容有未洽，惟其起訴之基本事實同一，本院自得審理，並變更法條為貪污治罪條例第5條第1項第3款之對於職務上行為收受不正利益罪。

㈡再收受不正利益罪，不論其行求人或出於收受人之自動或被動均應成立。

所謂行求，係指行賄人自行向對方提出賄賂或不正利益，以備交付，祇以行賄者一方之意思表示為已足，不以受賄者之允諾為必要；

所謂期約，係指行賄者與受賄者雙方就期望而為約定於一定期間內交付賄賂或利益，乃雙方意思已合致而尚待交付；

所謂交付，係指行賄者事實上將賄賂或不正利益交付受賄者收受之行為。

行求、期約、交付行為，係屬階段行為，而收受不正利益行為，依高度行為吸收低度行為之原則，其要求之低度行為，已為收受之高度行為所吸收，應依收受不正利益罪論處（最高法院46年台上字第812 號、27年上字第448 號判例參照）。

㈢再按共犯之犯意聯絡，不以明示之意思表示為限，即有默示之相互瞭解亦應包括在內。

又意思之聯絡並不限於事前有所謀議，即僅於行為當時有共同犯意之聯絡者，亦屬之，且其表示之方法，亦不以明示通謀為必要，即相互間有默示之合致，亦無不可。

被告戊○○與壬○○間，有一同受邀前往有女陪侍酒店喝花酒，並互相知悉並要求川順公司之戴沼澤、廉裕隆等人給付前往有女陪侍酒店喝所花費之金額，顯示彼此間具有共同的謀意，共同向川順公司索取不正利益。

是被告2人應負共犯之責。

㈣又按要求、期約或收受不正利益罪所侵害之法益為國家公務執行之純正，苟係基於同一職務行為同時向數人為之或向一人多次為之，其所侵害之法益仍屬一個，應祇成立單純一罪（最高法院69年臺上字第1414號判例參照）。

又按於同一時、地，或密切接近之時、地，實行相同犯罪構成要件之作為，侵害同一之法益，而各相同作為之獨立性極為薄弱，依一般社會之健全觀念，難以將之強行分開，允宜予以包括合併，給予一個法律評價，較為合理之情形。

雖然刑法修正刪除連續犯，於修正說明中，提示：「委由學界及實務以補充解釋之方式，發展接續犯之概念，對於合乎接續犯或包括的一罪之情形，認為構成單一之犯罪，以限縮數罪併罰之範圍」，但仍不能過度放寬原有概念，否則將與廢止連續犯，改採數罪併罰之修法大原則相違背。

易言之，倘多次作為之時間，既非甚密接、地點有相隔，縱然手段或方法相同，且侵害同一法益，但衡諸社會通念，如不能認為出於先前之犯罪計畫或目的，而係對於偶發之預期外事件，採取因應措施，當認行為之接續關係，已經中斷，祇能依數罪併罰之例處遇。

本案被告戊○○收受川順公司付費喝花酒及性招待之時間，係自96年8 月15日起，迄97年3 月14日止，前後除1 次性招待外，另有16次喝花酒；

而被告壬○○接受川順公司付費喝花酒之時間，則係自96年10月8 日起至97年3 月25日止，前後共4 次，從而，被告戊○○及壬○○接受不正利益之時間，均長達數月之久，其中復牽涉川順公司所承攬之便道工程及減災工程2 種工程，雖因前揭二工程之工程期間有所重疊，致被告戊○○及壬○○接受不正利益之時間，與該2 工程之工程期間均有重疊，致無法強行分割，惟倘僅論以一罪，實無視本件川順公司行賄時，實係基於前揭2 項工程得以順利進行之動機。

至於前揭工程施做期間，因先後發生聖帕颱風及柯羅莎颱風，致有部分之應變措施，惟被告戊○○及壬○○接受不正利益，既係為使川順公司得以順利完成前揭2工程，從而，於該2 工程施工期間所發生之任何變數，均應含括在上開2 工程之同一法益內。

從而，本院認被告戊○○所為如附表三所示先後收受不正利益之行為，及被告壬○○所為如附表四所示先後收受不正利益之行為，均應依照川順公司所承攬之工程數即2 件工程，而應各論以2 罪，且予分論併罰之。

㈤又按犯貪污治罪條例第4條至第6條之罪，情節輕微，而其所得或所圖得財物或不正利益在5 萬元以下者，減輕其刑。

貪污治罪條例第12條第1項定有明文。

經查被告壬○○於前開2 件工程中，所收受之不正利益，經核算結果總額為47,700元（14,350＋9,100 ＋17,150＋7,100 ＝47,700），尚未逾5 萬元，應依前揭貪污治罪條例第12條第1項規定，各減輕其刑；

至被告戊○○所收受之不正利益，經核算結果總額已逾5萬元，自無從依前揭規定減輕其刑，附此敘明。

㈥原審認被告戊○○、壬○○罪證明確，因予論罪科刑，固非無見。

惟查：⒈原審判決認被告戊○○及壬○○分別收受如附表三、四所示不正利益之行為，因所侵害之法益仍屬一個國家公務執行之純正法益，應只成立一罪，惟依照前揭㈢之說明，本院認被告戊○○及壬○○應依照川順公司所承攬之工程數即2 件工程，而應各論以2 罪，故原審此部分認定尚有違誤。

⒉原審判決認定被告壬○○另有於97年3 月17日下午2 時許，在香格里拉理容KTV 接受喝花酒招待之不正利益，然依照後揭理由欄㈨之說明，被告壬○○此部分犯行尚屬不能證明，原審此部分認定亦有所誤。

⒊原審判決說明被告壬○○所收受之不正利益，經核算結果總額已逾5 萬元，故無從依貪污治罪條例第12條規定減輕其刑。

惟因本院調查證據審理結果，認被告壬○○並未接受前揭97年3 月17日之喝花酒不正利益，且依照上開理由欄㈤之說明，被告壬○○所收受之不正利益總額應為47,700元，並未逾50,000元。

從而，原審未能依照貪污治罪條例第12條第1項規定，就被告壬○○經論處之罪刑予以減輕，亦有所未合。

被告戊○○及壬○○上訴意旨猶執前詞否認犯行，其等上訴雖無理由；

另檢察官認被告戊○○所為，應係屬違背職務，亦違背法令部分，依照前揭理由欄㈥之說明，亦難認有理由，惟原判決既有上開可議之處，即屬無可維持，自應由本院將原判決關於被告戊○○及壬○○部分均予以撤銷改判。

㈦爰審酌被告戊○○身為國家中央機關經濟部水利署第三河川局簡任第11職等局長之機關首長、被告壬○○身為國家中央機關經濟部水利署簡任第10職等工程事務組副組長之副主管之主管層級機關公務員，卻未能潔身自愛，慎行自持，反屢屢利用上班時間，利用職務之機會收受不正利益，已嚴重破壞政府信譽，玷辱公務員應公正廉潔執行職務之本份，敗壞官箴，兼衡其等分別收受不正利益之情節及多寡，與犯罪後之態度等一切情狀，各量處如主文第二、三項所示之刑。

又被告戊○○及壬○○均犯貪污治罪條例之罪，並經宣告有期徒刑以上之刑，爰依貪污治罪條例第17條及刑法第37條第2項之規定，分別宣告褫奪公權如主文第二、三項所示。

復按貪污治罪條例第10條規定應予追繳沒收者，係以被告貪污所得之財物為限，而「不正利益」既無明文規定，自不能包括在內（參照最高法院74年臺上字第1355號判例意旨），是被告戊○○、壬○○所得財物以外喝花酒或性招待的不正利益並無追繳沒收的明文規定，自不得併予宣告追繳沒收。

㈧另按刑法第50條關於數罪併罰之規定業已於102 年1 月23日經總統以華總一義字第00000000000 號令公布，並自102 年1 月25日起施行；

修正前刑法第50條規定：「裁判確定前犯數罪者，併合處罰之。」

；

修正後刑法第50條規定：「裁判確定前犯數罪者，併合處罰之。

但有下列情形之一者，不在此限：一、得易科罰金之罪與不得易科罰金之罪。

二、得易科罰金之罪與不得易服社會勞動之罪。

三、得易服社會勞動之罪與不得易科罰金之罪。

四、得易服社會勞動之罪與不得易服社會勞動之罪。

前項但書情形，受刑人請求檢察官聲請定應執行刑者，依第51條規定定之。」

。

本案被告戊○○及壬○○上開所犯之2 罪均為不得易科罰金及易服社會勞動之罪，故不論依修正前之刑法第50條，或修正後之刑法第50條第1項前段之規定，法院均應於判決時定其應執行之刑，並無有利或不利之影響，依首揭說明，自無比較新舊法適用之必要，而應依一般法律適用之原則，適用現行、有效之裁判時法論處，並定其應執行之刑。

㈨被告壬○○不另為無罪諭知部分：⒈公訴意旨認被告壬○○有於97年3 月17日下午2 時許，在「香格里拉（原名金拿獎）理容KTV 」酒店喝花酒，消費金額1 萬5 千3 百元，由川順公司經理廉裕隆簽帳，再由川順公司97年4 月25日「傳票清單」項下支付云云，因認被告壬○○此部分亦違反貪污治罪條例第5條第1項第3款對於職務上行為收受不正利益罪，且與前揭經論罪科刑部分，有一罪關係。

⒉按犯罪事實應依證據認定之，無證據不得認定犯罪事實；

不能證明被告犯罪者，應諭知無罪之判決，刑事訴訟法第154條第2項、第301條第1項分別定有明文。

又認定不利於被告之事實，須依積極證據，苟積極證據不足為不利於被告事實之認定時，即應為有利於被告事實之認定，更不必有何有利之證據；

認定犯罪事實所憑之證據，雖不以直接證據為限，間接證據亦包括在內，然而無論直接或間接證據，其為訴訟上之證明，須於通常一般之人均不致有所懷疑，而得確信其為真實之程度者，始得據為有罪之認定，倘其證明尚未達到此一程度，而有合理性之懷疑存在時，即無從遽為有罪之確信，最高法院分別著有30年上字第816 號判例及76年臺上字第4986號判例可資參照。

⒊被告壬○○辯稱：其未於97年3 月17日下午2 時許，到「香格里拉（原名金拿獎）理容KTV 」酒店喝酒，其於該日上午10時30分至中午12時皆在高雄開會，下午4 時至6 時30分在嘉義參加會議，回到台中已晚上八點等語。

且證人陳順天業於本院審理時證稱：「（97年的時候你在什麼地方任職？擔任什麼職務？）在水利署工務組。」

、「〈證物七是會議的報到人員跟證物九是簽到單。

〉（你在97年3 月17日是否有參加證物七、八、九所述的經濟部所舉辦的易淹水地區水患治理計畫單位專案小組的會議？）有。

」、「（這個會議的舉行地點在哪裡？）早上十點半在高雄縣政府，下午四點在嘉義縣政府。」

、「（跟你一起去的有什麼人？）很多，包括壬○○副組長。

早上的部分是壬○○副組長、會計室鄭世輝科長、廖瓊霞、呂有平、陳新城、蕭嘉哲。

土地組有鄭正雄。

工務組就是我自己跟主辦牟敦元。

下午的會蔡副總他有趕到，財務組他也有趕到。

會計室有鄭世輝科長、廖瓊霞。

河海組有蔡孟演、張志輝、莊曜丞。

土地組有戴文伯、鄭正雄、陳豐永。

工務組就是我本人跟主辦江文治。

實際參加的人員要以正式簽到簿為準，這是我們一個表列的名單。」

、「（你們是否是一起過去的？是搭乘什麼交通工具過去？）我們搭公務車過去。」

、「（你剛才說高雄縣政府這一場壬○○有參加，下午嘉義縣政府那一場壬○○有沒有參加？）都有參加。」

、「（是否跟你們一樣都是搭公務車過去的？）我跟他都搭同一部公務車過去的。」

、「（在二個會議的過程當中被告壬○○有沒有提前離開會議或中途離開會議的情形？）沒有，我都跟他在一起。」

、「（高雄會議的場次結束是在十二點，嘉義會議的場次開始是在四點。

在這一段期間當中你有沒有與被告壬○○在一起？）有，我都跟他在一起。」

、「（你們在做什麼事情？）我們在高雄縣政府結束以後大概在那邊用餐，用完餐大概十二點多，然後再回到嘉義縣政府差不多是下午二點。

嘉義縣政府的會議是在四點開始，我們就是在嘉義縣政府中庭那邊叫個咖啡聊天。

中午這個期間我跟葉副組長都是在一起的。」

、「（被告壬○○在這一段期間有沒有可能自行離開回到台中？）我跟他都在一起。」

、「（你們是用幾部交通工具？）我的印象是早上有一部公務車，是廂型車大概可以搭六、七個人左右。」

、「（你是否知道嘉義那邊是幾點結束會議？）正確的時間我不記得。」

、「（高雄會議是幾點開始、幾點結束？）高雄那邊是十點半開始，大概十二點左右結束。

嘉義縣政府正確的時間我是不記得，是在四點開，一般來講都是開一、二個小時左右。」

、「（你們嘉義開完會是否就馬上回台中？）對。」

、「（回到台中幾點了？）很晚了。」

、「（你是否不敢確定幾點回到台中？）很晚了，大概是在七、八點以後。

因為嘉義縣政府會議結束大概是在六點左右，從嘉義縣政府回到台中的車程也要一個多小時，所以我估計大概是在七、八點左右。

」、「我估計回到台中大概是七、八點左右，正確時間我當然沒有記那麼清楚。」

、「回到台中以後我就自己回去了。」

等語明確，足見被告壬○○於97年3 月17日下午 3、4 點應係在嘉義縣政府，當無在「香格里拉理容KTV 」喝花酒之可能。

又證人陳秀月於原審審理時證稱：「（〈97年3 月17日監聽譯文〉你打這支電話的對話裡面，壬○○有在場嗎？）沒有。」

、「他那天有在場，這麼久的事，你這樣子問，當然我還要想一下，他有在場借我的手機打。」

、「（對3 月17日那一天去的人之記憶？）沒有很清楚。」

、「（你怎麼確定3 月17日壬○○有去香格里拉，你是看到什麼東西才有這個印象？）這樣我真的不清楚，你這樣子跟我問，離之前已經這麼久了，你再問，我真的是不知道。」

等語（97年度訴字第3018號卷六，第 214頁），足見證人陳秀月對於97年3 月17日當日之情境已不復記憶；

且依97年3 月17日16時44分42秒之通話紀錄顯示：與廉裕隆0000000000號行動電話通話之號碼為0000000000號，而同日17時35分53秒，陳秀月亦持0000000000號行動電話與廉裕隆上開門號通話，顯見陳秀月於97年3 月17日16時44分42秒係持其自己使用之0000000000號行動電話與廉裕隆通話，另該通話內容顯示另有林榮紹、周世杰持陳秀月上開行電話與廉裕隆對話，但並無被告壬○○與廉裕隆間之對話，是證人陳秀月證稱被告壬○○於上開時地有借其手機與廉裕隆通話云云，應與事實不符。

另證人林榮紹於本院前審審理時證稱：「（你答說調查局人員有提示前面監聽譯文，從譯文可以看出你有跟壬○○去喝酒消費。

你當時回答說是的，97年3 月17日我有跟壬○○去消費。

但是從剛剛監聽譯文，沒有看到壬○○的對話，為何調查人員提示監聽譯文給你看，你回答說你有跟壬○○去消費？）當初可能調查官在問時，我沒有仔細去深思，尤其時間問到很後面，我覺得我是說錯了，因為後來我有去詢問過我的長官、同仁，那天副座確實去開會，他沒有參加。」

、「（請你確定3 月17日監聽譯文，你是否可以確認壬○○有無在場？）沒有。」

、「（97年3 月17日在金拿獎KTV 消費過程，97年3 月17日當天是何人邀約？）是周世杰。

我記得當天有4 個人，分別為周世杰、劉建成、陳國和跟我。」

、「（當天是何人付款？）是廉裕隆他們公司付款。」

、「（你剛剛說4 個人，但不包括廉裕隆？）廉裕隆沒有去，周世杰有打電話給他，但他說沒有空。

」、「（所以是他同意支付這筆消費，但他沒有辦法過去？）是。」

等語，益見被告壬○○於97年3 月17日應未於金拿獎KTV 接受川順公司之招待喝花酒。

⒋綜前所述，被告壬○○辯稱伊於97年3 月17日並未曾前往香格里拉理容KTV 接受喝花酒招待等語，尚屬可採。

此外，復無任何積極證據足資證明被告壬○○此部分被訴犯行，即屬不能證明被告壬○○此部分犯罪，惟因起訴意旨認此部分與被告壬○○前經論罪科刑部分，有實質上一罪關係，爰不另為無罪之諭知。

㈩最高法院發回意旨認①本院前審判決就被告戊○○所涉及之犯罪，未能慮及係牽涉2 種不同之工程；

尤以其中減災工程部分，係因2 次遭遇颱風之應變措施，非事先所得預期，故就被告戊○○部分，究應成立2 罪或3 罪，實有慎酌餘地；

②本院前審判決未於理由內分別就被告戊○○如何明示與暗示要求不正利益予以敘明，亦嫌理由不備；

③本院前審判決就被告壬○○部分未兼就起訴效力範圍內相同之基本社會事實即未違背職務收受不正利益罪嫌部分，加以探討，故有未合。

經查，本院就被告戊○○所涉之犯罪，究應如何論處罪數，業已於理由欄㈣予以說明；

另就被告戊○○係如何明示與暗示要求不正利益部分，除於犯罪事實欄具體說明外，並於理由欄㈡⒉以下各編號予以說明；

另就被告壬○○部分，經本院調查審理後，則認被告壬○○係應構成貪污治罪條例第5條第1項第3款之罪，且經本院說明如前，併此敘明。

據上論斷，應依刑事訴訟法第368條、第369條第1項前段、第364條、第299條第1項前段、第300條，貪污治罪條例第5條第1項第3款、第12條第1項、第17條、刑法第11條、第28條、第51條第5款、第37條第2項，判決如主文。

本案經檢察官丁○○到庭執行職務。

中 華 民 國 103 年 5 月 29 日
刑事第七庭 審判長法 官 蔡 王 金 全
法 官 許 文 碩
法 官 簡 婉 倫
以上正本證明與原本無異。
如不服本判決應於收受送達後10日內向本院提出上訴書狀，其未敘述上訴之理由者，並得於提起上訴後10日內向本院補提理由書（均須按他造當事人之人數附繕本）「切勿逕送上級法院」。
書記官 陳 麗 玉

中 華 民 國 103 年 5 月 29 日
附錄論罪科刑法條：
貪污治罪條例第5條第1項
有下列行為之一者，處7年以上有期徒刑，得併科新台幣6千萬元以下罰金：
一、意圖得利，擅提或截留公款或違背法令收募稅捐或公債者。
二、利用職務上之機會，詐取財物者。
三、對於職務上之行為，要求、期約或收受賄賂或其他不正利益者。















【附表一】便道工程時程表
┌──────┬────────────────┬─────┐
│時間        │進行事項                        │備註      │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年5月31日 │第三河川局發包便道工程。        │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年6月8日  │6月8日前後大甲溪流域豪大雨，致使│          │
│            │便道工程之施工路段地形地貌變更。│          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年6月15日 │便道工程之合約開工日。          │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年6月22日 │便道工程，承包商川順公司機具進場│          │
│            │，隨即停工。                    │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年6月25日 │便道工程，由第三河川局工務所正工│          │
│            │程司癸○○召集川順公司、世曦公司│          │
│            │人員進行開工前協調會。          │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年6月28日 │便道工程，由工務所癸○○召開之上│          │
│            │述96年6月25日開工前協調會會議紀 │          │
│            │錄本日送核第三河川局，由局長許哲│          │
│            │彥於96年6月29日批示「一、會議記 │          │
│            │錄如擬，二、如以箱型籠施作，不須│          │
│            │外加掛披蛇籠。」                │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年7月2日  │第三河川局以水三管字第0000000000│          │
│            │0號函送前述96年6月25日開工前協調│          │
│            │會議紀錄與川順公司、世曦公司。  │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年7月2日  │川順公司向監造世曦公司提出「大甲│          │
│            │溪砂石運輸便道工程第三標（25K十 │          │
│            │400-32K十745）施工斷面建議變更建│          │
│            │議書。                          │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年7月3日  │便道工程，川順公司開始以箱型石籠│依監工日報│
│            │施作本便道並施作1000公尺。      │表        │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年7月12日 │便道工程變更設計會勘日，由癸○○│          │
│            │主持。                          │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年7月18日 │便道工程上述變更設計會勘紀錄，由│          │
│            │癸○○本日上簽送核第三河川局，由│          │
│            │局長戊○○批核。                │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年7月19日 │便道工程變更設計（施工斷面及線型│          │
│            │調整）會勘紀錄本日函送川順公司、│          │
│            │世曦公司。                      │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤                     
│            │川順公司所承包本便道工程免投保工│戊○○自認│
│            │程險一事，以電話向水利署工程事務│、宋伯永證│
│            │組組長宋伯永詢問呈報公文事宜。  │詞、監聽譯│
│            │                                │文        │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年7月27日 │戊○○為川順公司所承包本便道工程│戊○○自認│
│            │免投保工程險一事，以電話要求所屬│、癸○○證│
│            │癸○○向水利署陳報免除承保。    │詞、監聽譯│
│            │                                │文        │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年8月3日  │㈠第三河川局以水三管字第00000000│          │
│            │  750號函請川順公司、世曦公司， │          │
│            │  就川順公司提出之「大甲溪砂石運│          │
│            │  輸便道工程第三標(25K十400-32K │          │
│            │  十745)調整斷面與線型修正案」有│監聽譯文  │
│            │  缺失，必須以水理定量評析，提出│          │
│            │  數據說明。                    │          │
│            │㈡戴沼澤與戊○○就本便道工程進行│          │
│            │  水理分析討論，戊○○表示：那不│          │
│            │  用啦，那不用水理，只有作一段就│          │
│            │  好。                          │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年8月3日  │戊○○為川順公司所承包本便道工程│監聽      │
│            │變更設計一事，以電話與川順公司負│          │
│            │責人戴沼澤通話溝通工程設計變更及│          │
│            │車道高度問題，並應戴沼澤之邀前往│          │
│            │該公司天祥街招待所洽商。        │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年8月7日  │帕布颱風發布海上警報。川順公司請│          │
│            │求颱風前施工查核。              │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年8月8日  │第三河川局指派工程司林秀玲會同世│本次颱風未│
│            │曦公司、川順公司然源進行颱風前施│陳報有災損│
│            │工查核。                        │。        │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年8月13日 │水利署以經水工字第00000000000號 │          │
│            │函送第三河川局表示，大甲溪砂石運│          │
│            │輸便道工程第三標（25K十400-32K十│          │
│            │745)因工期緊迫，部分工務處理程序│          │
│            │（如變更設計、工期展延等)，請同 │          │
│            │意局部調整，授權貴局核辦。      │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年8月14日 │㈠第三河川局以水管三字第00000000│㈠停工至96│
│            │  110號函川順公司、世曦公司本便 │  年10月22│
│            │  道工程30K十500至32K十745停工，│  日      │
│            │  俟變更設計程序完成核定後再行復│          │
│            │  工。                          │          │
│            │㈡戊○○、戴沼澤、廉裕隆電話通話│          │
│            │  ，戊○○表示：水理不會啦，不是│          │
│            │  有人幫你做，不會喔、這樣，這樣│          │
│            │  我來指導了。                  │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年8月16日 │聖帕颱風海上警報發布。          │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年8月19日 │聖帕颱風侵臺，大甲溪流域溪水漫延│          │
│            │暴漲，便道更程有損毀。          │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年8月27日 │戊○○以電話告知川順公司戴沼澤有│          │
│            │關便道工程已向水利署楊副署長報告│          │
│            │改用三層箱型石籠施工，楊副署長並│          │
│            │不反對。                        │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年8月30日 │由曾財益擔任便道工程第一次變更設│          │
│            │計會勘。                        │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年9月10日 │上述變更設計會勘紀錄及變更設計原│          │
│            │則經局長戊○○核定。            │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年9月12日 │就本便道工程25K十400至32K十745，│          │
│            │由第三河川局曾財益主持進行聖帕颱│          │
│            │風災損會勘日。                  │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年9月18日 │第三河川局以水三管字第0000000000│          │
│            │0號函同意本便道工程之調整斷面與 │          │
│            │線型修正原則案，先行施作。      │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年9月27日 │第三河川局將聖帕颱風所造成之災害│          │
│            │損失及修復經費1711萬2764元函報水│          │
│            │利署核定籌措經費財源。          │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年9月28日 │水利署由科長林榮紹帶隊督導大甲溪│          │
│            │砂石運輸便道併同勞工安全檢查之日│          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年10月4日 │柯羅莎颱風發布警報。            │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年10月5日 │第三河川局指派正工程司林秀玲擔任│          │
│            │颱風前便道工程進行查核。        │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年10月11日│世曦公司本日發函檢送便道工程第1 │          │
│            │次變更設計預算書至第三河川局，再│          │
│            │由第三河川局函轉水利署核定。    │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年10月15日│國營會會同川順公司戴沼澤、紀駿富│          │
│            │、廉裕隆，世曦公司、水利署林榮紹│          │
│            │、江文助，第三河川局副局長林傳茂│          │
│            │、癸○○查核大甲溪砂石運輸便道工│          │
│            │程                              │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年10月18日│就本便道工程之25K十400至30K十500│          │
│            │，由第三河川局趙培善主持進行第二│          │
│            │次工程變更設計會勘日。          │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年10月22日│㈠水利署函復第三河川局有關聖帕颱│          │
│            │  風所造成之損失及修復經費1711萬│          │
│            │  餘元再第三標工程內支應。第三河│          │
│            │  川局於96年11月23日發函水利署請│          │
│            │  將本次損經費損壞應重作之部分之│          │
│            │  經費1400萬餘元併入第1次變更設 │          │
│            │  計預算書內。                  │          │
│            │㈡川順公司開始施作30K起之箱型石 │          │
│            │  籠。                          │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤ 
│96年10月24日│川順公司提報柯羅莎颱風災損報告與│          │
│            │世曦公司，經世曦公司提報災損慨算│          │
│            │1400萬餘元與第三河川局審核。。  │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年10月31日│就本便道工程25K十400至32K十745，│          │
│            │由第三河川局曾財益主持進行柯羅莎│          │
│            │颱風災損會勘日。                │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年10月31日│便道工程第一次估驗請款日。      │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年11月1日 │水利署函復第三河川局第一次變更設│          │
│            │計之經費3027萬9845元核准在水資源│          │
│            │作業基金下支應。                │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年11月2日 │第三河川局核定第二次便道工程設計│          │
│            │變更紀錄、設計原則及經費預算。並│          │
│            │於96年11月19日函轉水利署審核。  │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年11月19日│第三河川局函報水利署有關柯羅莎颱│水利署於96│
│            │風災損數量及補助川順公司經費慨算│年12月12日│
│            │1412萬核定，請求籌措財源。      │核定在水資│
│            │                                │源作業基金│
│            │                                │下支應。  │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年11月30日│便道工程第二次估驗請款日。      │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年12月4日 │就本便道工程之26K十450至26K十700│          │
│            │，由第三河川局趙培善主持進行工程│          │
│            │變更設計會勘日。                │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年12月7日 │水利署發函第三河川局本便道工程第│          │
│            │1次變更設計預算書核准成立，此後 │          │
│            │川順公司即可據以請領變更施作石籠│          │
│            │之災損及已施作之款項。          │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年12月6日 │就本便道工程之25K十400至32K十745│          │
│            │，由第三河川局曾財益主持進行工程│          │
│            │變更設計會勘日。                │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年12月11日│便道工程原契約所規定之完工日。  │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年12月14日│第三河川局函復世曦公司便道工程第│          │
│            │二次設計變更經費889萬5735元經水 │          │
│            │利署核定。                      │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年12月15日│便道工程第三次估驗請款日。      │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年12月28日│就本便道工程25K十400至32K十745，│          │
│            │由第三河川局趙培善主持進行工程變│          │
│            │更設計會勘日。                  │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年12月28日│便道工程須支付工程款500萬元支票 │監聽譯文  │
│            │須戊○○蓋章，戊○○以電話交代第│          │
│            │三河川局會計主任逕向局長室工友取│          │
│            │印自蓋即可。                    │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年12月31日│便道工程展延完工日並為川順公司陳│          │
│            │報第三河川局完工日。            │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│97年1月8日  │戴沼澤與世曦公司張敬廉電話通話，│監聽譯文  │
│            │詢問有關本便道工程受颱風損害請求│          │
│            │第三河川局補償金額之公文是否已函│          │
│            │送第三河川局進度情形？          │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│97年2月4日  │㈠水利署發函第三河川局核准第二次│          │
│            │  變更設計工程預算書成立。      │          │
│            │㈡便道工程完工辦理初驗日。      │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│97年2月22日 │便道工程完工辦理初驗之紀錄製作。│          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│97年3月5、6 │便道工程完工辦理複驗日。        │          │
│日          │                                │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│97年3月17日 │便道工程第四次請款日。          │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│97年3月20日 │便道工程第五次請款日。          │          │
└──────┴────────────────┴─────┘
【 附表二】減災工程時程表
┌──────┬────────────────┬─────┐
│時間        │進行事項                        │備註      │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年6月6日  │水利署發包減災工程。            │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年6月8日  │豪大雨沖刷減災工程施作估城區左岸│證人己○○│
│            │之河岸，產生立即性危險，由川順公│證述      │
│            │司增設臨時保護箱籠。            │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年6月20日 │減災工程契約開工日。            │申報開工後│
│            │                                │，因施作地│
│            │                                │點用地取得│
│            │                                │有問題，隨│
│            │                                │即停工，至│
│            │                                │96年11月川│
│            │                                │順公司申報│
│            │                                │復工      │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年7月20日 │減災工程第一次變更設計會勘日。  │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年11月2日 │減災工程第二次變更設計會勘日。  │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│96年12月22日│開始施作減災工程之左岸基腳      │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│97年1月3日  │開始施作鋼柵石籠                │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│97年1月7日  │減災工程第三次變更設計會勘日。  │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│97年1月11日 │減災工程先行查驗日查驗鋼柵石籠  │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│97年1月17日 │減災工程先行查驗日查驗鋼柵石籠  │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│97年1月30日 │減災工程同意展期至97年11月18日竣│          │
│            │工。                            │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│97年2月14日 │水署發函第三河川局同意97年1月7日│          │
│            │減災工程變更設計會勘紀錄（水利署│          │
│            │97年2月14日經水工字第00000000000│          │
│            │號函）                          │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│97年3月12日 │減災工程第四次變更設計會勘日。  │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│97年3月28日 │減災工程，川順公司函請第三河川局│          │
│            │准許篩取塊石施作蛇籠及石籠之用。│          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│97年6月13日 │減災工程契約原定完工日。        │          │
├──────┼────────────────┼─────┤
│97年11月18日│減災工程核准延展完工日。（水利署│          │
│            │97.3.13經水工字第030340號函准） │          │
└──────┴────────────────┴─────┘
【 附表三】戊○○要求、收受川順公司支付之酒店消費明細：┌─┬───┬────┬───┬───┬───┬───────┬────┐
│編│消費起│酒店名稱│已知在│已知在│消費金│付款方式      │備註    │
│號│始時間│陪侍人員│場公務│場其他│額新台│              │        │
│  │      │        │員    │人員  │幣    │              │        │
├─┼───┼────┼───┼───┼───┼───────┼────┤
│1 │96年8 │①九龍理│戊○○│陳玉瑛│1萬6千│①戊○○簽立一│消費過程│
│  │月15日│容KTV   │周世杰│（許哲│元    │張「許董」本票│詳如下備│
│  │下午3 │②徐玉玲│張榮傑│彥女友│      │，徐玉玲擔任連│註1.    │
│  │時30  │（即秀秀│楊昭睿│）    │      │保人；該筆消費│        │
│  │分許  │）      │      │      │      │載於川順公司96│        │
│  │      │③數名不│      │      │      │年9月25日「轉 │        │
│  │      │詳女侍  │      │      │      │帳傳票」項下支│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │付。②川順公司│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │96 年9月25日「│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │轉帳傳票」，內│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │載「便餐費」、│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │「九龍名店」、│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │「8/15」及「  │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │16,000」。③九│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │龍酒店「本票」│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │，內載「壹萬陸│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │仟」、「16000 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │」、「許董」、│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │連保人「秀」及│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │「96年8月15日 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │」。          │        │
├─┼───┼────┼───┼───┼───┼───────┼────┤
│2 │96年9 │①九龍理│戊○○│陳玉瑛│金額不│由廉裕隆以現金│消費過程│
│  │月6日 │容KTV   │      │與二位│詳    │支付消費金額  │詳如下備│
│  │下午3 │②徐玉玲│      │友人  │      │              │註2.    │
│  │時15分│③張淑惠│      │      │      │              │        │
│  │許    │（化名廖│      │      │      │              │        │
│  │      │怡君）④│      │      │      │              │        │
│  │      │不詳女侍│      │      │      │              │        │
├─┼───┼────┼───┼───┼───┼───────┼────┤
│3 │96年9 │①九龍理│戊○○│戴沼澤│1萬2千│①消費由川順公│消費過程│
│  │月14日│容KTV   │      │廉裕隆│1百元 │司本便道工程96│詳如下備│
│  │下午4 │②徐玉玲│      │      │、2 千│年10月25日「轉│註3.    │
│  │時50  │③不詳女│      │      │2百元 │帳傳票」項下支│        │
│  │分許  │侍      │      │      │共計：│付【應付票據九│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │1萬4千│龍名店JT003057│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │3百元 │4／96年12月25 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │日】②川順公司│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │96年10月25日「│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │轉帳傳票」，內│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │載「便餐費」、│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │「九龍名店」、│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │「9/14廉經理  │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │12,100」、「9/│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │14（續）2,200 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │」及「應付票據│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │九龍名店JT0030│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │57496/12/25」 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │。③九龍酒店「│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │本票」2紙，分 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │別內載「貳仟貳│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │佰」、「2200」│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │、「許董（川順│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │）續」、連保人│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │「秀」、「96年│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │9月14日」；及 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │內載「壹萬貳仟│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │壹佰」、「1210│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │0」、「廉裕隆 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │」、「川順」、│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │連保人「秀」、│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │「96年9月14日 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │」。          │        │
├─┼───┼────┼───┼───┼───┼───────┼────┤
│4 │96年9 │①九龍理│戊○○│陳玉瑛│金額不│戴沼澤以現金支│消費過程│
│  │月18日│容KTV301│周世杰│戴沼澤│詳    │付            │詳如下備│
│  │下午7 │包廂    │      │廉裕隆│      │              │註4.    │
│  │時許  │②徐玉玲│      │王莉婷│      │              │        │
│  │      │③不詳女│      │      │      │              │        │
│  │      │侍      │      │      │      │              │        │
├─┼───┼────┼───┼───┼───┼───────┼────┤
│5 │96年10│①九龍理│戊○○│陳玉瑛│1萬6千│①戊○○簽立本│消費過程│
│  │月2日 │容KTV   │      │廉裕隆│5百50 │票，徐玉玲擔任│詳如下備│
│  │下午4 │②徐玉玲│      │      │元    │連保人。②該筆│註5.    │
│  │時30分│③數名不│      │      │      │消費載於川順公│        │
│  │許    │詳女侍  │      │      │      │司96年11月25日│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │「轉帳傳票」項│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │下支付。③川順│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │公司96年11月25│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │日「轉帳傳票」│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │，內載「便餐費│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │」、「九龍名店│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │」、「10/2」及│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │「16,550」，併│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │同10月4日、10 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │月5日、10月11 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │日、10月17日及│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │10月31日之九龍│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │酒店帳款開立97│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │年1月25日到期 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │票號JT0000000 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │支票13萬6700元│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │④九龍酒店「本│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │票」，內載「壹│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │萬陸仟伍佰伍拾│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │」、「16550」 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │、「廉裕隆10/4│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │」、「許」、連│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │保人「秀」及「│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │96年10月2日」 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │。            │        │
├─┼───┼────┼───┼───┼───┼───────┼────┤
│6 │96年10│①九龍理│戊○○│陳玉瑛│2萬2千│①廉裕隆簽立本│消費過程│
│  │月4日 │容KTV   │吳水城│與1名 │6百元 │票；②該筆消費│詳如下備│
│  │下午4 │②徐玉玲│      │女性友│      │載於川順公司96│註6.    │
│  │時30分│③４名不│      │人廉裕│      │年11月25日「轉│        │
│  │許    │詳女侍  │      │隆    │      │帳傳票」項下支│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │付。③96年11月│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │25日「轉帳傳票│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │」，內載「便餐│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │費」、「九龍名│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │店」、「10/2」│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │及「16,550」，│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │併同10月4日 、│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │10月5日、10月 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │11日、10月17日│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │及10月31日之九│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │龍酒店帳款開立│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │97年1月25日到 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │期票號JT003058│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │1支票13萬6700 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │元。④九龍酒店│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │「本票」，內載│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │「貳萬貳仟陸佰│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │」、「22600」 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │、「廉裕隆10/4│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │」、連保人「秀│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │」及「96年10月│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │4日」。       │        │
├─┼───┼────┼───┼───┼───┼───────┼────┤
│7 │96年10│①九龍理│戊○○│陳玉瑛│1萬6百│①戊○○簽立本│消費過程│
│  │月5日 │容KTV   │      │戴美玲│50元  │票，徐玉玲擔任│詳如下備│
│  │下午7 │②徐玉玲│      │      │      │連保人。②該筆│註7.    │
│  │時許  │③數名不│      │      │      │消費載於川順公│        │
│  │      │詳女侍  │      │      │      │司96年11月25日│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │「轉帳傳票」項│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │下支付。③川順│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │公司96年11月25│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │日「轉帳傳票」│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │，內載「便餐費│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │」、「九龍名店│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │」、「10/5」及│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │「10,650」，併│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │同10月2日、1 0│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │月4日、10月11 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │日、10月17日及│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │10月31日之九龍│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │酒店帳款開立97│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │年1月25日到期 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │票號JT0000000 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │支票13萬6700元│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │。④九龍酒店「│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │本票」，內載「│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │壹萬╳仟陸佰伍│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │拾」、「10650 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │」、「廉裕隆10│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │/31」、「許」 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │、「英」、連保│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │人「秀」及「96│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │年10月5日」   │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │。            │        │
├─┼───┼────┼───┼───┼───┼───────┼────┤
│8 │96年10│①九龍理│戊○○│陳玉瑛│2萬8百│①陳玉瑛代許哲│消費過程│
│  │月11日│容KTV   │      │      │元    │彥簽立一張本票│詳如下備│
│  │下午4 │②徐玉玲│      │      │      │，徐玉玲擔任連│註8.    │
│  │時許  │③數名不│      │      │      │保人。②該筆消│        │
│  │      │詳女侍  │      │      │      │費載於川順公司│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │96年11月25日「│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │轉帳傳票」項下│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │支付。③川順公│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │司96年11月25日│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │「轉帳傳票」，│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │內載「便餐費」│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │、「九龍名店」│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │、「10/11」及 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │「20,800」，併│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │同10月2日、10 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │月4日、10月5日│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │、10月17日及10│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │月31日之九龍酒│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │店帳款開立97年│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │1月25日到期票 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │號JT0000000支 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │票13萬6700元。│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │④九龍酒店「本│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │票」，內載「貳│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │萬╳仟捌佰」、│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │「20800」、「 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │廉裕隆10/31 」│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │、「英」、連保│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │人「秀」及「96│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │年10月11日」。│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │秀秀帳冊記，96│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │年10月11日內載│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │「許」、「3600│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │」及「許」、「│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │20800」。     │        │
├─┼───┼────┼───┼───┼───┼───────┼────┤
│9 │96年10│①九龍理│戊○○│廉裕隆│4萬9千│①由廉裕隆簽立│消費過程│
│  │月17日│容KTV   │      │王莉婷│5 百50│本票；該筆消費│詳如下備│
│  │下午3 │②徐玉玲│      │      │元    │載於川順公司96│註9.    │
│  │時許  │③數名不│      │      │      │年11月25日「轉│        │
│  │      │詳女侍  │      │      │      │帳傳票」項下支│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │付。②川順公司│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │96年11月25日「│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │轉帳傳票」，內│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │載「便餐費」、│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │「九龍名店」、│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │「10/17」及「4│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │9,550」，併同1│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │0月2日、10月4 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │日、10月5日、1│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │0月11日及10月3│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │1日之九龍酒店 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │帳款開立97年1 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │月25日到期票號│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │JT0000000支票1│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │3萬6700元。③ │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │九龍酒店「本票│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │」內載「正確＄│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │49550」、「廉 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │裕隆10/17」、 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │連保人「秀」及│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │「96年10月17日│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │」。          │        │
├─┼───┼────┼───┼───┼───┼───────┼────┤
│10│96年10│①九龍理│戊○○│廉裕隆│1萬6千│①由廉裕隆簽立│消費過程│
│  │月31日│容KTV   │林榮紹│      │5百50 │本票。②該筆消│詳如下備│
│  │下午4 │②徐玉玲│      │      │元    │費載於川順公司│註10.   │
│  │時許  │③數名不│      │      │      │96年11月25日「│        │
│  │      │詳女侍  │      │      │      │轉帳傳票」項下│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │支付。③川順公│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │司96年11月25日│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │「轉帳傳票」內│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │載「便餐費」、│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │「九龍名店」、│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │「10/31」及「 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │16,550」，併同│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │10月2日、10月 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │4日、10月5日、│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │10月11日及10月│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │17日之九龍酒店│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │帳款開立97年11│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │月25日到期票號│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │JT0000000支票 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │13萬6700元。④│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │九龍酒店「本票│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │」，內載「壹萬│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │陸仟伍佰伍拾」│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │、「16550」、 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │「廉裕隆10/31 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │」、連保人「秀│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │」及「96年10月│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │31日」。      │        │
├─┼───┼────┼───┼───┼───┼───────┼────┤
│11│96年11│①九龍理│戊○○│顏沛華│1萬6千│①由廉裕隆簽立│消費過程│
│  │月28日│容KTV   │      │陳玉瑛│元    │本票；該筆消費│詳如下備│
│  │下午6 │②張淑惠│      │廉裕隆│      │載於川順公司96│註11.   │
│  │時許  │（化名廖│      │      │      │年12月25日「轉│        │
│  │      │怡君）  │      │      │      │帳傳票」項下支│        │
│  │      │③不詳女│      │      │      │付。②川順公司│        │
│  │      │侍      │      │      │      │96年12月25日「│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │轉帳傳票」，內│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │載「便餐費」、│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │「九龍名店」、│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │「11/28便餐費 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │」及「16,000」│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │，開立97年2月2│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │5日到期支票， │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │票號：JT003059│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │3。③九龍酒店 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │「本票」，內載│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │「壹萬陸仟」、│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │「16000」、「 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │ 廉裕隆11/28」│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │、及「96年11月│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │28日」。④「九│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │龍名店消費請款│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │單」內載「川順│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │先生」、「消費│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │日96年11月28日│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │」、「金額1600│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │0」等，張淑惠 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │於備註欄署名「│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │廖怡君」。    │        │
├─┼───┼────┼───┼───┼───┼───────┼────┤
│12│96年12│①九龍理│戊○○│廉裕隆│1萬7千│①由戴泱丞簽立│消費過程│
│  │月17日│容KTV107│      │劉禎忠│6百50 │本票。②該筆消│詳如下備│
│  │下午4 │包廂    │      │      │元    │費載於川順公司│註12.   │
│  │時30  │②徐玉玲│      │      │      │96年12月25日「│        │
│  │分許  │③不詳女│      │      │      │轉帳傳票」項下│        │
│  │      │侍      │      │      │      │支付。③川順公│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │司97年1月25 日│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │「轉帳傳票」，│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │內載「便餐費」│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │、「九龍名店」│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │、「12/17」及 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │「17,650」，併│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │同12月5日之九 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │龍酒店帳款開立│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │97年3月25日到 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │期票號JT003059│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │9支票2萬9650元│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │。④九龍酒店「│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │本票」，內載「│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │壹萬柒仟陸佰伍│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │拾」、「17650 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │」、「戴泱丞」│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │、連保人「秀」│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │及「96年12月17│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │日」。        │        │
├─┼───┼────┼───┼───┼───┼───────┼────┤
│13│97年1 │①九龍理│戊○○│戴沼澤│8萬4百│①由戴沼澤簽立│⑴戊○○│
│  │月7日 │容KTV   │第七河│      │50元  │本票。②該筆消│當晚將九│
│  │下午  │②徐玉玲│川局人│      │      │費載於川順公司│龍理容KT│
│  │      │③陳瑤寰│員    │      │      │97年2月25日「 │V店第105│
│  │      │④不詳女│      │      │      │轉帳傳票」項下│號女侍小│
│  │      │侍      │      │      │      │支付，並開立97│姐陳瑤寰│
│  │      │        │      │      │      │年4月25日到期 │帶出場，│
│  │      │        │      │      │      │票號JT0000000 │至台中市│
│  │      │        │      │      │      │支票八萬四百五│某汽車旅│
│  │      │        │      │      │      │十元。③川順公│館，接受│
│  │      │        │      │      │      │司97年2月25日 │該女侍之│
│  │      │        │      │      │      │「轉帳傳票」，│性服務進│
│  │      │        │      │      │      │內載「便餐費」│行性交行│
│  │      │        │      │      │      │、「九龍名店」│為。    │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │、「1/7」及「 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │80,450」，開立│⑵消費過│
│  │      │        │      │      │      │97年4月25日到 │程詳如下│
│  │      │        │      │      │      │期票號JT010371│備註13. │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │1支票8萬450元 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │。④九龍酒店「│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │本票」，內載「│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │捌萬零仟肆佰伍│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │拾」、「80450 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │」、「戴沼澤」│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │、連保人「秀」│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │及「97年1月7日│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │」。          │        │
├─┼───┼────┼───┼───┼───┼───────┼────┤
│14│97年2 │①九龍理│戊○○│廉裕隆│1萬7千│①由廉裕隆簽立│⑴戊○○│
│  │月12日│容KTV   │壬○○│      │1百50 │本票；②該筆消│當日晚上│
│  │下午4 │②徐玉玲│周世杰│      │元、6 │費載於川順公司│8時17分 │
│  │時15許│③楊雅惠│      │      │千元共│97年3月25日「 │許將「楓│
│  │      │④不詳女│      │      │計：2 │轉帳傳票」項下│之林理容│
│  │      │侍      │      │      │萬3千1│支付。③川順公│KTV」編 │
│  │      │        │      │      │百50元│司97年3月25日 │號第66號│
│  │      │        │      │      │      │「轉帳傳票」，│女侍楊雅│
│  │      │        │      │      │      │內載「便餐費」│惠買出場│
│  │      │        │      │      │      │、「九龍名店」│。      │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │、「2/12廉裕隆│⑵消費過│
│  │      │        │      │      │      │」、「17,150」│程詳如下│
│  │      │        │      │      │      │及「6,000」， │備註14. │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │併同97年2月28 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │日之消費，開立│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │97年5月25日到 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │期支票，票號：│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │JT0000000。④ │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │九龍酒店「本票│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │」2紙，內載「 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │壹萬柒仟壹佰伍│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │拾元整」、「17│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │150」、「廉裕 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │隆2/12」、「川│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │順」、「連保人│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │秀」及「97年2 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │月12日」，「陸│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │仟元整」、「60│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │00」、「川順楓│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │補66至1點」及 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │「97年2月12日 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │」。⑤「九龍名│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │店消費請款單」│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │內載「川順先生│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │」、「消費日97│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │年2月12日」、 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │「金額17150」 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │及「金額6000」│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │等，徐玉玲於備│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │註欄署名「秀秀│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │」。          │        │
├─┼───┼────┼───┼───┼───┼───────┼────┤
│15│97年3 │①楓之林│戊○○│陳玉瑛│4萬1千│①由廉裕隆簽立│消費過程│
│  │月3日 │理容KTV │林榮紹│廉裕隆│8百50 │本票。②該筆消│詳如下備│
│  │下午4 │②陳俞容│周世杰│      │元    │費載於川順公司│註15.   │
│  │時30分│③不詳女│      │      │      │97年4月25日「 │        │
│  │許    │侍      │      │      │      │傳票清單」項下│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │支付。③川順公│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │司97年4月25日 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │「傳票清單」內│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │載「3/3便餐費 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │」、「楓之林」│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │、「41,850」，│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │及「應付票據」│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │、「楓之林JT01│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │ 0000000/06/2 │        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │ 5」，開立97年│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │ 6月25日到期支│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │ 票，票號JT010│        │
│  │      │        │      │      │      │ 3725。       │        │
├─┼───┼────┼───┼───┼───┼───────┼────┤
│16│97年3 │①楓之林│戊○○│陳玉瑛│1萬3千│劉禎忠先行代戴│⑴消費過│
│  │月14日│理容KTV │林榮紹│戴沼澤│2百元 │沼澤簽帳於楓之│程詳如下│
│  │下午5 │②陳俞容│      │劉禎忠│      │林理容KTV董事 │備註1.  │
│  │時50分│③不詳女│      │顏沛華│      │謝翠芬應收帳款│        │
│  │許    │侍      │      │      │      │下            │⑵嗣因本│
│  │      │        │      │      │      │              │件經檢調│
│  │      │        │      │      │      │              │偵辦，迄│
│  │      │        │      │      │      │              │今戴沼澤│
│  │      │        │      │      │      │              │尚未償付│
│  │      │        │      │      │      │              │。      │
└─┴───┴────┴───┴───┴───┴───────┴────┘
【附表三備註】
各編號所示被告戊○○行求或期約、收受川順公司給付不正利益之過程：
⒈96年8 月15日下午3 時30分許，戊○○與陳玉瑛至「九龍理容KTV 」唱歌飲酒作樂，席間戊○○邀水利署周世杰前來，周世杰邀第三河川局同事張榮傑、楊昭璿於同日下午5 時許，共赴「九龍理容KTV 」與戊○○會合，並召數名女侍坐檯飲酒作樂，其間於同日晚上8 時許，楊昭璿與陳玉瑛因拼酒發生衝突，藉故離去，戊○○等人於同日晚上9 時結束消費，消費帳款為1 萬6000元，戊○○指示徐玉玲代為處理簽帳，徐玉玲遂製作由其擔任連保人之本票，並註記「許董」，交由「九龍理容KTV 」會計列記在應收帳冊，並載明「許董」之戊○○消費應收帳款1 萬6000元，徐玉玲乃再依戊○○指示，將該張註記「許董」之戊○○消費本票，向川順公司報帳請款，經戴沼澤核准，在川順公司96年9 月25日「轉帳傳票」項下支付1 萬6000元予「九龍理容KTV 」。
⒉96年9 月6 日下午3 時15分許，陳玉瑛電洽戊○○表示欲先行前往「九龍理容KTV 」飲酒作樂，戊○○允諾由其他人支付帳款，陳玉瑛遂與2 位友人先行前往該理容KTV ，戊○○隨後趕到，由徐玉玲安排女侍坐檯飲酒作樂，席間，戊○○電話要求廉裕隆前來招待，廉裕隆除向戴沼澤回報外，另戴沼澤交代廉裕隆到場要求戊○○能解決便道工程變更設計問題，消費結束，戊○○未簽帳及亦未付款，由廉裕隆以現金支付不詳金額之消費帳款。
⒊96年9 月14日下午2 時40分許，戊○○應戴沼澤之邀前往川順公司旱溪天祥街招待所，同日下午4 時50分許，戊○○在「九龍理容KTV 」接受戴沼澤、廉裕隆招待，安排女侍坐檯飲酒作樂，戊○○於同日晚上8 時24分許，離開該理容KTV 前，另名坐檯小姐加點延長檯費2 小時，全場2 消費帳款為1 萬2100元、2200元，合計1 萬4300元，該2 筆帳款，於96年10月25日，由川順公司本便道工程「轉帳傳票」會計項下支1 萬4300元予「九龍理容KTV 」。
⒋96年9 月18日下午7 時許，戊○○、陳玉瑛與周世杰共赴「九龍理容KTV 」301 包廂接受戴沼澤、廉裕隆招待，並由徐玉玲安排女侍坐檯飲酒作樂，本次消費帳款，戊○○未簽帳及亦未付款，由戴沼澤以現金支付不詳帳款。
⒌陳玉瑛明知戊○○在「九龍理容KTV 」消費，後續帳款均會透過徐玉玲找川順公司或指定之工程包商付款，陳玉瑛乃經常與「楓之林理容KTV 」朋友、戊○○等人前往「九龍理容KTV 」飲酒作樂，並召來酒店內熟識小姐坐檯同樂，消費帳款均由徐玉玲處理，並於「九龍理容KTV 」會計人員製作應收帳冊內註記「許」或「許董」之消費帳款紀錄，再向川順公司或戊○○指定之包商請款。
96年10月2 日下午4 時30分許，戊○○赴臺中市逢甲路，載陳玉瑛前往「九龍理容KTV 」消費，並召數名熟識的小姐坐檯喝酒作樂，迄同日晚上9 時許結束消費，全場消費1 萬6550元，戊○○指示徐玉玲代為處理簽帳，由徐玉玲製作由其擔任連保人之本票，並註記「許」，交由「九龍理容KTV 」會計列記在應收帳冊，並載明「許」之戊○○之消費應收帳款1 萬6550元，徐玉玲明知川順公司負責人戴沼澤同意為戊○○支付消費帳款，乃再依戊○○指示向川順公司請款，待川順公司廉裕隆於96年10月4 日，赴「九龍理容KTV 」招待戊○○時，再持註記「許」之戊○○消費帳款本票洽請廉裕隆補簽帳。
再於96年10月底，向川順公司請領該筆帳款1 萬6550元。
⒍96年10月4 日中午某時，廉裕隆、戊○○、第三河川局課員吳水城等人在臺中縣和平鄉之谷關飯店飲宴，於同日下午1 時15分許，陳玉瑛電告戊○○將於同日下午2 時30分許，前往「九龍理容KTV 」飲酒作樂，並相約前往「九龍理容KTV 」，陳玉瑛於同日下午3 時許，與1 名女性友人前往「九龍理容KTV 」，並點4 名熟識坐檯小姐喝酒同樂，戊○○與廉裕隆、吳水城於同日下午4 時30分許，赴「九龍理容KTV 」與陳玉瑛會飲酒作樂，迄同日下午7 時許結束，該次帳款連同陳玉瑛先行點熟識女子坐檯同樂消費，合計2 萬2600元，由廉裕隆當日向徐玉玲簽立本票，再由徐玉玲於月底向川順公司請領該筆帳款2 萬2600元。
⒎96年10月5 日下午某時，陳玉瑛自行前往「九龍理容KTV 」，並點數名熟識坐檯小姐喝酒同樂，戊○○於同日下午5 時許，至另女友戴美玲位在臺中市西屯路之住所會面，再於同日下午7 時許，轉赴「九龍理容KTV 」與陳玉瑛一起飲酒作樂，共消費1 萬650 元，依戊○○指示徐玉玲代為處理簽款，由徐玉玲製作由其擔任連保人之本票，並註記「許」、「英」，交由「九龍理容KTV 」會計列記在應收帳冊，並載明「許」之戊○○之消費應收帳款1 萬650 元，因當日川順公司之廉裕隆、戴沼澤均在從事便道工程颱風前工程查驗，而未到場，徐玉玲乃向川順公司請款，俟川順公司之廉裕隆於96年10月31日，至「九龍理容KTV 」招待戊○○時，再持該張註記「許」、「英」之戊○○、陳玉瑛消費帳款本票交予廉裕隆補簽帳，而於96年10月底，向川順公司請領該筆帳款1 萬650 元。
⒏96年10月11日於下午16時3 分，戊○○、陳玉瑛至「九龍理容KTV 」消費，並點數名熟識小姐坐檯飲酒作樂，於同日晚上 8時11分許，戊○○因妻林秀春催促接送小孩而先行離去，陳玉瑛帶同該名「九龍理容KTV 」小姐及其他女性友人轉往臺中市惠中路「楓之林理容KTV 」飲酒作樂，因該名「九龍理容 KTV」小姐已超出原先算帳之出場時間，陳玉瑛洽請徐玉玲再補 3小時出場費用（1200＊3 ＝3600元），陳玉瑛與戊○○在「九龍理容KTV 」飲酒作樂之費用為2 萬800 元，徐玉玲依戊○○指示代為簽帳，徐玉玲製作由其擔任連保人之本票，並註記「英」之陳玉瑛消費記錄，交由「九龍理容KTV 」會計人員列記在應收帳冊，並載明「許」之戊○○之消費應收帳款2 萬 800元，因當日川順公司之廉裕隆、戴沼澤均未到場，徐玉玲乃依戊○○指示向川順公司請款，俟川順公司之廉裕隆於96年10月31日，至「九龍理容KTV 」招待戊○○時，再持該張註記「英」之陳玉瑛消費帳款本票交予廉裕隆補簽帳，而於96年10月底向川順公司請領該筆帳款2 萬800 元。
⒐96年10月17日中午，川順公司之戴沼澤、廉裕隆、王莉婷以為戊○○慶生為名義，於當日中午，在臺中市文心路1 段與大業路口「阿杜餐廳」宴請戊○○，並於同日下午3 時許，招待戊○○前往「九龍理容KTV 」飲酒作樂，迄同日晚上10時30分始離去，由廉裕隆簽帳4 萬9950元，再由「九龍理容KTV 」之徐玉玲持簽帳本票向川順公司請款。
⒑96年10月31日，便道工程正值辦理第2 次變更設計會勘審核及第2 次柯羅莎颱風災損會勘認定審核，於同日下午2 時30分許，戴沼澤邀戊○○赴川順公司位在臺中市旱溪旁之天祥街木屋打牌。
嗣於同日下午4 時許，戴沼澤指示廉裕隆招待戊○○及林榮紹前往「九龍理容KTV 」飲酒作樂，並由徐玉玲接待、安排女侍坐檯飲酒作樂，該日消費至同日晚間11時許，消費帳款共1 萬6550元，由廉裕隆向徐玉玲簽帳，再持向川順公司請款，川順公司於大甲溪便道工程「轉帳傳票」中以支票付款。
另當日廉裕隆向「秀秀」徐玉玲簽認前揭戊○○與女友陳玉瑛分別於同年10月5 日、11日，在「九龍理容KTV 」消費所積欠帳款1 萬650 元及2 萬800 元之本票，事後再由徐玉玲持該等本票向川順公司請款。
⒒96年11月28日下午5 時許，戊○○與同學顏沛華出遊，於同日下午6 時許，電洽廉裕隆要求前往「九龍理容KTV 」招待，廉裕隆隨即電請該該理容KTV 之幹部化名「廖怡君」之大班張淑惠安排2 位女侍，並向戴沼澤回報於該酒店招待戊○○，另有陳玉瑛亦在場，席間適逢警方臨檢，該酒店人員安排戊○○至2 樓密室躲藏，臨檢結束後，戊○○、顏沛華、陳玉瑛即先行離去，本次消費由川順公司之廉裕隆簽帳，且於96年12月25日，由川順公司之便道工程「傳帳傳票」會計項下支付1 萬6000元予該理容KTV 。
⒓96年12月17日，便道工程國營會工程查核小組將於翌日進行工程查核，且將進入完工階段申報「箱型石籠」竣工數量，戴沼澤、廉裕隆為能順利查核通過，於中午宴請戊○○、林榮紹等人赴臺中市向上路「鶴園餐廳」吃飯，餐後，戊○○、林榮紹各自先返回辦公處所，而於同日下午3 時許，由廉裕隆與友人劉禎忠先赴「九龍理容KTV 」107 號包廂，再邀戊○○前來「九龍理容KTV 」飲酒作樂，戊○○於同日下午4 時30分許，前往「九龍理容KTV 」接受廉裕隆招待女侍陪酒唱歌作樂，迄同日晚上10時許結束，消費款項共1 萬7650元，由川順公司配合包商幀衡工程顧問公司之劉禎忠付帳，惟未依約向「九龍理容KTV 」幹部張淑惠（廉裕隆女友）付帳，而事後由戴泱丞補簽立本帳，並由徐玉玲向川順公司請款，川順公司則於97年1 月25日，以減災工程「轉帳傳票」之支票支付該筆帳款1 萬7650元。
⒔便道工程於96年12月31日完工，世曦公司於97年1 月7 日，將竣工報告表函送第三河川局請派員辦理驗收，加上前述「減災工程」施工期間，戴沼澤因發生鋼柵位置施作錯誤等問題，於97年1 月2 日，與第三河川局派駐工務所監工彭壽奇研商如何變更設計解決，並要求彭壽奇協助製作同意「逕行施工」之紀錄為依據，以辦理會勘及變更設計，同年1 月3 日，川順公司收到1 月7 日辦理會勘公文，戴沼澤即邀請戊○○至川順公司天祥街招待所打麻將，並指示廉裕隆招待林榮紹等公務員至「金拿獎理容KTV 」（改名香格里拉理容KTV ）飲宴娛樂，花費1 萬4800元，由川順公司支付帳款。
迨同年1 月7 日，辦理變更設計會勘，同日下午，戊○○邀第三河川局及第七河川局人員共同接受戴沼澤招待至「九龍理容KTV 」飲宴娛樂，晚上由徐玉玲安排該店105 號小姐陳瑤寰出場為戊○○提供性招待，共計花費8 萬450 元，係由川順公司支付帳款。
⒕97年2 月12日中午12時許，戊○○、林榮紹等人在「大北京餐廳」接受戴沼澤、王莉婷、廉裕隆招待飲宴，同日下午1 時40分許飲宴結束，林榮紹即搭乘戊○○座車同往川順公司之旱溪天祥街招待所，戊○○於該招待所電邀「楓之林理容KTV 」編號66號女侍楊雅惠前往陪侍。
而川順公司認壬○○係主管便道工程驗收、後續請領工程款、物價調整補助及減災工程施工、變更設計等，即由鄭年雅於同日下午4 時許，攜10萬元至該招待所予廉裕隆。
戊○○、壬○○、周世杰等人則應川順公司之邀前往「九龍理容KTV 」接受招待，由徐玉玲安排女侍坐檯飲酒作樂，壬○○、周世杰、戊○○先後於同日下午4 時15分許，抵達該理容KTV ，廉裕隆亦代表川順公司在現場招待飲宴。
另戊○○於同日晚上8時17分許，帶女侍楊雅惠出場，並透過徐玉玲向廉裕隆要求支付相關款項，於97年3月25日，川順公司支付本次飲宴費用1萬7150元及楊雅惠之出場費用6000元。
⒖97年3 月3 日中午12時許，戊○○與水利署水利行政組人員在「阿杜餐廳」用餐，戊○○以有事情交代為由，電洽戴沼澤要求廉裕隆前來，復值林榮紹在「小仙屋」餐廳接受廉裕隆招待，戴沼澤遂指示廉裕隆與林榮紹同往，另交代廉裕隆要求戊○○解決減災工程相關問題，於同日下午4 時30分許，林榮紹與周世杰應廉裕隆之邀，至「楓之林理容KTV 」，戊○○與陳玉瑛於同日下午6 時許，抵達「楓之林理容KTV 」，本次飲宴由酒店幹部綽號「淑萍」之女子陳俞容安排女侍坐檯飲酒作樂，消費款項由廉裕隆簽帳，而於97年4 月25日，向川順公司報帳順利請領該筆帳款4 萬1850元。
⒗水利署及第三河川局於97年3 月12日辦理減災工程辦理變更設計會勘後，於97年3 月14日川順公司負責人戴沼澤等為解決減災工程相關問題，指示廉裕隆於同日上午11時50分許，電邀戊○○前往川順公司之旱溪天祥街招待所商議，戊○○於同日下午3 時50分許，抵達該招待所；
適顏沛華至臺中出差，戊○○乃於同日下午4 時50分許，電請顏沛華至「楓之林理容KTV 」，並透過陳玉瑛安排，由該理容KTV 幹部綽號「淑萍」之女子陳俞容安排女侍坐檯飲酒作樂，陳玉瑛、戊○○、林榮紹、戴沼澤、劉禎忠隨後陸續抵達該理容KTV ，林榮紹因接送其妻卓淑煖於同日下午7 時20分先行離開，戴沼澤於同日晚上8 時20分許，因故由廉裕隆接送先行離開，戴沼澤亦電洽劉禎忠表示本次飲宴係由其招待，事後由劉禎忠先行向該理容KTV 簽帳，並列記於該理容KTV 董事謝翠芬應收帳款項下。

【附表四】
壬○○要求、收受川順公司支付之酒店消費明細：
┌─┬────┬────┬───┬───┬───┬───────┬────┐
│編│消費起始│酒店名稱│已知在│已知在│消費金│付款方式      │備註    │
│號│時間    │陪侍人員│場公務│場其他│額新臺│              │        │
│  │        │        │員    │人員  │幣    │              │        │
├─┼────┼────┼───┼───┼───┼───────┼────┤
│1 │96年10月│①麗登理│壬○○│      │1萬4千│①當日由林榮紹│⑴該支票│
│  │8日下午 │容KTV   │林榮紹│      │3百50 │、壬○○要求廉│開立後，│
│  │3時許   │②李幼綢│周世杰│      │元    │裕隆給付喝花酒│因李幼綢│
│  │        │（即花名│      │      │      │消費金額之不正│已離職，│
│  │        │；文華）│      │      │      │利益。②廉裕隆│由廉裕隆│
│  │        │③不詳女│      │      │      │事後簽認。③該│兌現該票│
│  │        │侍      │      │      │      │筆消費載於川順│金額以現│
│  │        │        │      │      │      │公司97年3月25 │金支付與│
│  │        │        │      │      │      │日「轉帳傳票」│李幼綢。│
│  │        │        │      │      │      │項下支付。④川│⑵消費過│
│  │        │        │      │      │      │順公司97年3月2│程詳如下│
│  │        │        │      │      │      │5日轉 帳傳票內│註1.    │
│  │        │        │      │      │      │載「麗登名店」│        │
│  │        │        │      │      │      │、「96/10/8便 │        │
│  │        │        │      │      │      │餐費」及「14,3│        │
│  │        │        │      │      │      │50」。④麗登酒│        │
│  │        │        │      │      │      │店簽帳本票內載│        │
│  │        │        │      │      │      │「壹萬肆仟參佰│        │
│  │        │        │      │      │      │伍拾元整」、「│        │
│  │        │        │      │      │      │14350」及「發 │        │
│  │        │        │      │      │      │票日中華民國96│        │
│  │        │        │      │      │      │年10月8日」。 │        │
├─┼────┼────┼───┼───┼───┼───────┼────┤
│2 │97年1月 │①香格里│壬○○│廉裕隆│新臺幣│①由廉裕隆簽立│消費過程│
│  │16日下午│拉（原名│林榮紹│      │9千1百│本票。②該筆消│詳如下備│
│  │2時30分 │金拿獎）│      │      │元    │費載於川順公司│註2.    │
│  │許      │理容KTV │      │      │      │「轉帳傳票」項│        │
│  │        │②陳秀月│      │      │      │下，並開立97年│        │
│  │        │（即花名│      │      │      │4月25日到期支 │        │
│  │        │：阿華）│      │      │      │票，票號JT0103│        │
│  │        │③不詳女│      │      │      │708。③轉帳傳 │        │
│  │        │侍      │      │      │      │票內載「便餐費│        │
│  │        │        │      │      │      │」、「金拿獎」│        │
│  │        │        │      │      │      │ 、「1/3便餐」│        │
│  │        │        │      │      │      │及「14,800 」 │        │
│  │        │        │      │      │      │，併同1月16日 │        │
│  │        │        │      │      │      │之消費開立97年│        │
│  │        │        │      │      │      │4月25日到期支 │        │
│  │        │        │      │      │      │票，票號：JT01│        │
│  │        │        │      │      │      │03708。④金拿 │        │
│  │        │        │      │      │      │獎簽帳本票內載│        │
│  │        │        │      │      │      │「金拿獎」、「│        │
│  │        │        │      │      │      │商業本票存根」│        │
│  │        │        │      │      │      │、「壹萬肆仟捌│        │
│  │        │        │      │      │      │佰元整」、「  │        │
│  │        │        │      │      │      │14800」、「廉 │        │
│  │        │        │      │      │      │裕隆元/3 」及 │        │
│  │        │        │      │      │      │「97年1 月3日 │        │
│  │        │        │      │      │      │」。          │        │
├─┼────┼────┼───┼───┼───┼───────┼────┤
│3 │97年2月 │①九龍理│壬○○│廉裕隆│1萬7千│支付方式同附表│⑴同附表│
│  │12日下午│容KTV   │戊○○│楊雅惠│1百50 │三編號14所載。│三編號14│
│  │4時15分 │②徐玉玲│周世杰│      │元（其│              │。      │
│  │許      │③楊雅惠│      │      │中另有│              │⑵消費過│ 
│  │        │④不詳女│      │      │6 千元│              │程詳如下│
│  │        │侍      │      │      │係許哲│              │備註3.  │
│  │        │        │      │      │彥帶楊│              │        │
│  │        │        │      │      │雅惠出│              │        │
│  │        │        │      │      │場費用│              │        │
│  │        │        │      │      │，與葉│              │        │
│  │        │        │      │      │奕匡無│              │        │
│  │        │        │      │      │關）  │              │        │
│  │        │        │      │      │      │              │        │
├─┼────┼────┼───┼───┼───┼───────┼────┤
│4 │97年3月 │①香格里│林榮紹│      │7千1百│①由廉裕隆支付│消費過程│
│  │25日下午│拉理容（│壬○○│      │元    │帳款。②該筆消│詳如下備│
│  │2時30分 │原名金拿│      │      │      │費載於川順公司│註4.    │
│  │許      │獎）KTV │      │      │      │97年4月25日「 │        │
│  │        │②不詳女│      │      │      │傳票清單」項下│        │
│  │        │侍      │      │      │      │支付。③傳票清│        │
│  │        │        │      │      │      │單內載「便餐費│        │
│  │        │        │      │      │      │」、「3/25便餐│        │
│  │        │        │      │      │      │」、「金拿獎」│        │
│  │        │        │      │      │      │及「7,100」， │        │
│  │        │        │      │      │      │併同3月17日之 │        │
│  │        │        │      │      │      │消費開立97年6 │        │
│  │        │        │      │      │      │月25日到期支票│        │
│  │        │        │      │      │      │，票號：JT0103│        │
│  │        │        │      │      │      │727。         │        │
└─┴────┴────┴───┴───┴───┴───────┴────┘
【附表四備註】
各編號被告壬○○，行求或期約、收受川順公司給付不正利益之過程：
1.96年10月8 日下午3 時許，壬○○、周世杰，至臺中市「麗登理容KTV 」找別名「文華」之店長李幼綢安排，召女侍坐檯飲酒作樂，壬○○、林榮紹交待李幼綢找戴沼澤、廉裕隆到場支付消費帳款，李幼綢去電廉裕隆，告知要求到場支付帳款，廉裕隆藉故拒絕前往（本院按此部份壬○○、林榮紹已完成行求不正利益之行為）。
壬○○、林榮紹未簽帳支付消費帳款1 萬4350元即離去，再次要求「文華」洽戴沼澤、廉裕隆支付。
事後，李幼綢曾向壬○○、周世杰催討該筆帳款，惟均遭拒絕支付，乃向川順公司請款，李幼綢至97年3 月10日再次向廉裕隆催討，廉裕隆認壬○○係主管便道工程驗收、後續請領工程款、物價調整補助及減災工程施工，因而簽認該筆帳款，並於97年3 月25日，由川順公司支付1 萬4350元予「文華」李幼綢。
（完成收受不正利益之行為）
2.97年1 月16日下午2 時30分許，壬○○、林榮紹再次前往「香格里拉理容KTV 」，由理容KTV 幹部陳秀月接待，召女侍坐檯飲酒作樂，席間壬○○、林榮紹數次電邀廉裕隆到場招待，並透過陳秀月與廉裕隆電洽本次消費帳款付款事宜，廉裕隆雖允諾支付本次消費帳款，惟本人不願到場，經壬○○、林榮紹數次邀請下，廉裕隆認壬○○係主管便道工程驗收、後續請領工程款、物價調整補助及減災工程施工、變更設計等，因而於同日下午4 時40分許到場、簽認該筆帳款，且於97年2 月25日，由川順公司支付9100元予「香格里拉理容KTV 」。
3.97年2 月12日下午，川順公司認壬○○主管便道工程驗收、後續請領工程款調、物價調整補助及減災工程施工、變更設計等，即由鄭年於雅於同日下午4 時許，攜10萬元至該招待所予廉裕隆，並應川順公司之邀前往「九龍理容KTV 」接受招待，由徐玉玲安排女侍坐檯飲酒作樂，壬○○、周世杰、戊○○先後於同日下午4 時15分許，抵達該理容KTV ，廉裕隆代表川順公司在現場招待飲宴，當日飲宴費用共計1 萬7150元。
（而戊○○於同日晚上8 時17分許，並帶女侍楊雅惠出場外遊，並透過徐玉玲向廉裕隆要求支付相關款項，於97年3 月25日，由川順公司支付楊雅惠出場費用6000元，惟此部分與壬○○無關）4.97年3 月25日下午2 時30分許，壬○○、林榮紹前往「香格里拉理容KTV 」，仍由幹部「阿華」陳秀月接待，召女侍坐檯飲酒作樂，壬○○、林榮紹2 人於同日下午2 時30分許，抵達該理容KTV ，便由壬○○以電話告知廉裕隆，請廉裕隆向戴沼澤要求處理本次消費帳款，廉裕隆亦電洽陳秀月允諾支付本次消費帳款而未到場接待，於97年4 月25日，由川順公司支付7100元予「香格里拉理容KTV 」。

【附表五】箱型石籠計算表、結算明細表
㈠大甲溪砂石運輸便道工程-第三標（25K＋400~32K＋745）（柯羅莎颱風災損修復）
┌──────┬──────┬─────────────────┬──────────────────┬─────┐
│    樁號    │   距離     │     箱型石籠（災損數量）         │       箱型石籠（修復數量）         │附註      │
│            │            │                                  │                                    │          │
│            │            ├────┬─────┬──────┼─────┬─────┬──────┤          │
│            │            │   m    │   平均   │    m       │    m     │  平均    │    m       │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│30＋550.00  │        0.00│    0.00│          │            │          │          │            │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│30＋600.00  │       50.00│    0.00│     0.000│      -     │          │     0.000│       -    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│30＋650.00  │       50.00│    0.00│     0.000│      -     │          │     0.000│       -    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│30＋728.00  │       78.00│    0.00│     0.000│      -     │     21.00│    10.500│       -    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│30＋750.00  │       22.00│    0.00│     0.000│      -     │     21.00│    21.000│     462.000│          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│30＋800.00  │       50.00│    0.00│     0.000│      -     │     21.00│    21.000│   1,050.000│          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│30＋824.00  │       24.00│    0.00│     0.000│      -     │     21.00│    21.000│     504.000│          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│30＋865.00  │       41.00│    0.00│     0.000│      -     │      0.00│    10.500│       -    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│30＋900.00  │       35.00│    0.00│     0.000│      -     │      0.00│     0.000│       -    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│30＋950.00  │       50.00│    0.00│     0.000│      -     │      0.00│     0.000│       -    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│30＋960.00  │       10.00│    0.00│     0.000│      -     │      0.00│     0.000│       -    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│30＋970.00  │       10.00│    7.00│     3.500│      35.000│      7.00│     3.500│       -    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│31＋000.00  │       30.00│    7.00│     7.000│     210.000│      7.00│     7.000│     210.000│          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│31＋050.00  │       50.00│    7.00│     7.000│     350.000│      7.00│     7.000│     350.000│          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│31＋070.00  │       20.00│    7.00│     7.000│     140.000│      7.00│     7.000│     140.000│          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│            │        0.00│        │     3.500│       -    │          │     3.500│       -    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│31＋176.00  │        0.00│    7.00│     3.500│       -    │      9.00│     4.500│       -    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│31＋203.00  │       27.00│    7.00│     7.000│     189.000│      9.00│     9.000│     243.000│          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│            │        0.00│        │     3.500│       -    │          │     4.500│       -    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│31＋226.00  │        0.00│   10.00│     5.000│       -    │     13.00│     6.500│       -    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│31＋261.00  │       35.00│   10.00│    10.000│     350.000│     13.00│    13.000│     455.000│          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│            │        0.00│        │     5.000│       -    │          │     6.500│       -    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│31＋315.00  │        0.00│   10.00│     5.000│       -    │     13.00│     6.500│       -    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│31＋340.00  │       25.00│   10.00│    10.000│     250.000│     13.00│    13.000│     325.000│          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│            │        0.00│        │     5.000│       -    │          │          │            │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│31＋356.00  │        0.00│   10.00│     5.000│       -    │     13.00│     6.500│       -    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│31＋414.00  │       58.00│   10.00│    10.000│     580.000│     13.00│    13.000│     754.000│          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│            │        0.00│        │     5.000│       -    │          │          │            │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│31＋845.00  │        0.00│   24.00│    12.000│       -    │     26.00│    13.000│       -    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│31＋855.00  │       10.00│   24.00│    24.000│     240.000│     26.00│    26.000│     260.000│          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│            │        0.00│        │    12.000│       -    │          │          │            │          │
├──────┴──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│本頁共計                  │        │          │    2,344.00│          │          │    4,753.00│          │
├─────────────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│連前共計                  │        │          │    2,344.00│          │          │    4,753.00│          │
└─────────────┴────┴─────┴──────┴─────┴─────┴──────┴─────┘

┌──────┬──────┬─────────────────┬──────────────────┬─────┐
│    樁號    │   距離     │     箱型石籠（災損數量）         │       箱型石籠（修復數量）         │附註      │
│            │            │                                  │                                    │          │
│            │            ├────┬─────┬──────┼─────┬─────┬──────┤          │
│            │            │    2   │   平均   │      3     │    m     │  平均    │    m       │          │
│            │            │   m    │          │     m      │          │          │            │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┴─────┴──────┼─────┤
│31＋855.00  │ 0.00       │24.00   │          │            │                                    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┤                                    ├─────┤
│31＋900.00  │45.00       │24.00   │24.000    │1,080.000   │                                    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┤                                    ├─────┤
│31＋950.00  │50.00       │24.00   │24.000    │1,200.000   │                                    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┤                                    ├─────┤
│32＋000.00  │50.00       │24.00   │24.000    │1,200.000   │                                    │上斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┤                                    ├─────┤
│32＋000.00  │ 0.00       │16.00   │20.000    │      -     │                                    │下斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┤                                    ├─────┤
│32＋033.00  │33.00       │16.00   │16.000    │  528.000   │                                    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┤                                    ├─────┤
│32＋050.00  │17.00       │16.00   │16.000    │  272.000   │                                    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┤            此段不修復              ├─────┤
│32＋100.00  │50.00       │16.00   │16.000    │  800.000   │                                    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┤                                    ├─────┤
│32＋150.00  │50.00       │16.00   │16.000    │  800.000   │                                    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┤                                    ├─────┤
│32＋186.00  │36.00       │16.00   │16.000    │  576.000   │                                    │上斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┤                                    ├─────┤
│32＋186.00  │ 0.00       │12.00   │14.000    │      -     │                                    │下斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┤                                    ├─────┤
│32＋195.00  │ 9.50       │12.00   │12.000    │  114.000   │                                    │上斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┤                                    ├─────┤
│32＋195.00  │ 0.00       │12.00   │12.000    │      -     │                                    │下斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┤                                    ├─────┤
│32＋250.00  │54.50       │12.00   │12.000    │  654.000   │                                    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┤                                    ├─────┤
│            │ 0.00       │        │ 6.000    │      -     │                                    │          │
├──────┴──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┬─────┬──────┼─────┤
│本頁共計                  │        │          │  7,224.00  │          │          │      -     │          │
├─────────────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│連前共計                  │        │          │ 11,977.00  │          │          │  4,753.00  │          │
└─────────────┴────┴─────┴──────┴─────┴─────┴──────┴─────┘
㈡大甲溪砂石運輸便道工程-第三標（25K＋400~32K＋745）（ 聖帕颱風災損修復）
┌──────┬──────┬─────────────────┬──────────────────┬─────┐
│    樁號    │   距離     │     箱型石籠（災損數量）         │       箱型石籠（修復數量）         │附註      │
│            │            │                                  │                                    │          │
│            │            ├────┬─────┬──────┼─────┬─────┬──────┤          │
│            │            │   m    │   平均   │    m       │    m     │  平均    │    m       │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│30＋550.00  │        0.00│13.00   │          │            │          │          │            │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│30＋600.00  │       50.00│13.00   │    13.000│     650.000│          │ 0.000    │    -       │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│30＋650.00  │       50.00│13.00   │    13.000│     650.000│          │ 0.000    │    -       │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│30＋700.00  │       50.00│13.00   │    13.000│     650.000│          │ 0.000    │    -       │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│30＋738.00  │       38.00│13.00   │    13.000│     494.000│          │ 0.000    │    -       │上斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│30＋738.00  │        0.00│ 6.00   │     9.500│         -  │          │ 0.000    │    -       │下斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│30＋789.40  │       51.40│ 6.00   │     6.000│     308.400│          │ 0.000    │    -       │上斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│30＋789.40  │        0.00│ 6.00   │     6.000│         -  │          │ 0.000    │    -       │下斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│30＋800.00  │       10.60│ 6.00   │     6.000│      63.600│          │ 0.000    │    -       │上斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│30＋800.00  │        0.00│ 6.00   │     6.000│         -  │          │ 0.000    │    -       │下斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│30＋824.00  │       24.00│ 6.00   │     6.000│     144.000│          │ 0.000    │    -       │上斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│30＋824.00  │        0.00│ 6.00   │     6.000│         -  │ 6.00     │ 3.000    │    -       │下斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│30＋850.00  │       26.00│ 6.00   │     6.000│     156.000│ 6.00     │ 6.000    │     156.000│          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│30＋865.00  │       15.00│ 6.00   │     6.000│      90.000│ 6.00     │ 6.000    │      90.000│上斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│30＋865.00  │        0.00│30.00   │    18.000│         -  │30.00     │18.000    │         -  │下斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│30＋900.00  │       35.00│30.00   │    30.000│   1,050.000│30.00     │30.000    │   1,050.000│          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│30＋950.00  │       50.00│30.00   │    30.000│   1,500.000│30.00     │30.000    │   1,500.000│          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│30＋960.00  │       10.00│30.00   │    30.000│     300.000│30.00     │30.000    │     300.000│          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│30＋970.00  │       10.00│33.00   │    31.500│     315.000│30.00     │30.000    │     300.000│上斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│30＋970.00  │        0.00│33.00   │    33.000│         -  │33.00     │31.500    │         -  │下斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│31＋000.00  │       30.00│33.00   │    33.000│     990.000│33.00     │33.000    │     990.000│          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│31＋050.00  │       50.00│33.00   │    33.000│   1,650.000│33.00     │33.000    │   1,650.000│上斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│31＋050.00  │        0.00│14.00   │    23.500│         -  │33.00     │33.000    │         -  │下斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│31＋070.00  │       20.00│14.00   │    14.000│     280.000│33.00     │33.000    │     660.000│          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│            │        0.00│        │     7.000│         -  │          │          │            │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│            │            │        │          │            │          │          │            │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│            │            │        │          │            │          │          │            │          │
├──────┴──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│本頁共計                  │        │          │    9,291.00│          │          │    6,696.00│          │
├─────────────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│連前共計                  │        │          │    9,291.00│          │          │    6,696.00│          │
└─────────────┴────┴─────┴──────┴─────┴─────┴──────┴─────┘

┌──────┬──────┬─────────────────┬──────────────────┬─────┐
│    樁號    │   距離     │     箱型石籠（災損數量）         │       箱型石籠（修復數量）         │附註      │
│            │            │                                  │                                    │          │
│            │            ├────┬─────┬──────┼─────┬─────┬──────┤          │
│            │            │    2   │   平均   │      3     │    m     │  平均    │    m       │          │
│            │            │   m    │          │     m      │          │          │            │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│31＋597.00  │        0.00│    3.00│          │            │      3.00│          │            │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│31＋650.00  │       53.00│    3.00│     3.000│     159.000│      3.00│     3.000│     159.000│          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│31＋700.00  │       50.00│    3.00│     3.000│     150.000│      3.00│     3.000│     150.000│          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│31＋750.00  │       50.00│    3.00│     3.000│     150.000│      3.00│     3.000│     150.000│          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│31＋800.00  │       50.00│    3.00│     3.000│     150.000│      3.00│     3.000│     150.000│          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│31＋850.00  │       50.00│    3.00│     3.000│     150.000│      3.00│     3.000│     150.000│          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│31＋918.00  │       68.00│    3.00│     3.000│     204.000│      3.00│     3.000│     204.000│上斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│31＋918.00  │        0.00│    7.00│     5.000│         -  │      7.00│     5.000│         -  │下斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│31＋939.00  │       21.00│    7.00│     7.000│     147.000│      7.00│     7.000│     147.000│上斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│31＋939.00  │        0.00│   11.00│     9.000│         -  │     11.00│     9.000│         -  │下斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│32＋000.00  │       61.00│   11.00│    11.000│     671.000│     11.00│    11.000│     671.000│上斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│32＋000.00  │        0.00│    0.00│     5.500│         -  │      0.00│     5.500│         -  │下斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│32＋033.00  │       33.00│    0.00│     0.000│         -  │      0.00│     0.000│         -  │上斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│32＋033.00  │        0.00│   12.00│     6.000│         -  │     16.00│     8.000│         -  │下斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│32＋050.00  │       17.00│   12.00│    12.000│     204.000│     16.00│    16.000│     272.000│          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│32＋100.00  │       50.00│   12.00│    12.000│     600.000│     16.00│    16.000│     800.000│          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│32＋150.00  │       50.00│   12.00│    12.000│     600.000│     16.00│    16.000│     800.000│          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│32＋186.00  │       36.00│   12.00│    12.000│     432.000│     16.00│    16.000│     576.000│上斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│32＋186.00  │        0.00│   12.00│    12.000│         -  │     12.00│    14.000│         -  │下斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│32＋250.00  │       64.00│   12.00│    12.000│     768.000│     12.00│    12.000│     768.000│          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│            │            │        │          │            │          │          │            │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│            │            │        │          │            │          │          │            │          │
├──────┴──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│本頁共計                  │        │          │    4,385.00│          │          │    4,997.00│          │
├─────────────┼────┼─────┼──────┼─────┼─────┼──────┼─────┤
│連前共計                  │        │          │   13,676.00│          │          │   11,693.00│          │
└─────────────┴────┴─────┴──────┴─────┴─────┴──────┴─────┘
㈢大甲溪砂石運輸便道工程-第三標（25K＋400~32K＋745）竣工結算
┌──────┬──────┬──────────────────────────┬─────┐
│    樁號    │   距離     │                                                    │附註      │
│            │            │                       箱型石籠                     │          │
│            │            ├────┬─────┬──────┬──┬──┬──┤          │  
│            │            │   m    │   平均   │    m       │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│25＋400.00  │        0.00│22.00   │          │            │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│25＋452.76  │       52.76│22.00   │22.000    │1,160.720   │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│25＋502.76  │       50.00│22.00   │22.000    │1,100.000   │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│25＋552.76  │       50.00│22.00   │22.000    │1,100.000   │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│25＋612.76  │       60.00│22.00   │22.000    │1,320.000   │    │    │    │上斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│25＋612.76  │        0.00│26.00   │24.000    │      -     │    │    │    │下斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│25＋662.76  │       50.00│26.00   │26.000    │1,300.000   │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│25＋712.76  │       50.00│26.00   │26.000    │1,300.000   │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│25＋762.76  │       50.00│26.00   │26.000    │1,300.000   │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│25＋812.76  │       50.00│26.00   │26.000    │1,300.000   │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│25＋862.76  │       50.00│26.00   │26.000    │1,300.000   │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│25＋882.76  │       20.00│26.00   │26.000    │  520.000   │    │    │    │上斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│25＋882.76  │        0.00│22.00   │24.000    │      -     │    │    │    │下斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│25＋932.76  │       50.00│22.00   │22.000    │1,100.000   │    │    │    │上斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│25＋932.76  │        0.00│18.00   │20.000    │      -     │    │    │    │下斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│25＋964.92  │       32.16│18.00   │18.000    │  578.934   │    │    │    │上斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│25＋964.92  │        0.00│24.00   │21.000    │      -     │    │    │    │下斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│25＋984.92  │       20.00│24.00   │24.000    │  480.000   │    │    │    │上斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│25＋984.92  │        0.00│ 4.00   │14.000    │      -     │    │    │    │下斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│26＋017.86  │       32.94│ 4.00   │ 4.000    │  131.760   │    │    │    │上斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│26＋017.86  │        0.00│15.00   │ 9.500    │      -     │    │    │    │下斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│26＋037.86  │       20.00│15.00   │15.000    │  300.000   │    │    │    │上斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│26＋037.86  │        0.00│14.00   │14.500    │      -     │    │    │    │下斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│26＋052.76  │       14.90│14.00   │14.000    │  208.600   │    │    │    │上斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│26＋052.76  │        0.00│18.00   │16.000    │      -     │    │    │    │下斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│26＋082.76  │       30.00│18.00   │18.000    │  540.000   │    │    │    │上斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│26＋082.76  │        0.00│22.00   │20.000    │      -     │    │    │    │下斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│26＋112.76  │       30.00│22.00   │22.000    │  660.000   │    │    │    │上斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│26＋112.76  │        0.00│26.00   │24.000    │      -     │    │    │    │下斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│26＋162.76  │       50.00│26.00   │26.000    │1,300.000   │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│26＋212.76  │       50.00│26.00   │26.000    │1,300.000   │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│            │        0.00│        │13.000    │      -     │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│            │        0.00│        │ 0.000    │      -     │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│            │        0.00│        │ 0.000    │      -     │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│            │        0.00│        │ 0.000    │      -     │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│            │        0.00│        │ 0.000    │      -     │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│            │        0.00│        │ 0.000    │      -     │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│            │        0.00│        │ 0.000    │      -     │    │    │    │          │
├──────┴──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│本頁共計                  │        │          │18,300.01   │    │    │    │          │
├─────────────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│連前共計                  │        │          │18,300.01   │    │    │    │          │
└─────────────┴────┴─────┴──────┴──┴──┴──┴─────┘
┌──────┬──────┬──────────────────────────┬─────┐  
│  樁號      │    距離    │                   箱型石籠                         │  附註    │
│            │            │                                                    │          │
│            │            ├────┬─────┬──────┬──┬──┬──┤          │
│            │            │    2   │          │     3      │    │    │    │          │
│            │            │   m    │  平均    │    m       │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│27＋405.38  │        0.00│   18.00│          │            │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│27＋455.38  │       50.00│   18.00│   18.000 │    900.000 │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│27＋505.38  │       50.00│   18.00│   18.000 │    900.000 │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│27＋555.38  │       50.00│   18.00│   18.000 │    900.000 │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│27＋605.38  │       50.00│   18.00│   18.000 │    900.000 │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│27＋655.38  │       50.00│   18.00│   18.000 │    900.000 │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│27＋705.38  │       50.00│   18.00│   18.000 │    900.000 │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│27＋755.38  │       50.00│   18.00│   18.000 │    900.000 │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│27＋805.38  │       50.00│   18.00│   18.000 │    900.000 │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│27＋855.38  │       50.00│   18.00│   18.000 │    900.000 │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│27＋905.38  │       50.00│   18.00│   18.000 │    900.000 │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│27＋955.38  │       50.00│   18.00│   18.000 │    900.000 │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│28＋005.38  │       50.00│   18.00│   18.000 │    900.000 │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│28＋055.38  │       50.00│   18.00│   18.000 │    900.000 │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│28＋105.38  │       50.00│   18.00│   18.000 │    900.000 │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│28＋155.38  │       50.00│   18.00│   18.000 │    900.000 │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│28＋205.38  │       50.00│   18.00│   18.000 │    900.000 │    │    │    │          │
├──────┴──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│本頁共計                  │        │          │   14,400.00│    │    │    │          │
├─────────────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│連前共計                  │        │          │   32,700.01│    │    │    │          │
└─────────────┴────┴─────┴──────┴──┴──┴──┴─────┘

┌──────┬──────┬──────────────────────────┬─────┐
│    樁號    │   距離     │                                                    │附註      │
│            │            │                       箱型石籠                     │          │
│            │            ├────┬─────┬──────┬──┬──┬──┤          │  
│            │            │   m    │   平均   │    m       │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│30＋507.61  │        0.00│21.00   │          │            │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│30＋557.61  │       50.00│21.00   │    21.000│   1,050.000│    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│30＋607.61  │       50.00│21.00   │    21.000│   1,050.000│    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│30＋657.61  │       50.00│21.00   │    21.000│   1,050.000│    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│30＋704.07  │       46.46│21.00   │    21.000│     975.660│    │    │    │上斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│30＋704.07  │        0.00│23.00   │    22.000│         -  │    │    │    │下斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│30＋724.28  │       20.21│23.00   │    23.000│     464.830│    │    │    │上斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│30＋724.28  │        0.00│27.00   │    25.000│         -  │    │    │    │下斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│30＋753.64  │       29.36│27.00   │    27.000│     792.781│    │    │    │上斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│30＋753.64  │        0.00│30.00   │    28.500│         -  │    │    │    │下斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│30＋779.30  │       25.66│30.00   │    30.000│     769.740│    │    │    │上斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│30＋779.30  │        0.00│32.00   │    31.000│         -  │    │    │    │下斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│30＋820.73  │       41.43│32.00   │    32.000│   1,325.789│    │    │    │上斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│30＋820.73  │        0.00│37.00   │    34.500│         -  │    │    │    │下斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│30＋875.01  │       54.28│37.00   │    37.000│   2,008.371│    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│30＋903.91  │       28.90│37.00   │    37.000│   1,069.247│    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│30＋953.91  │       50.00│37.00   │    37.000│   1,850.000│    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│31＋003.91  │       50.00│37.00   │    37.000│   1,850.000│    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│31＋023.91  │       20.00│37.00   │    37.000│     740.000│    │    │    │上斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│31＋023.91  │        0.00│18.00   │    27.500│         -  │    │    │    │下斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│31＋053.91  │       30.00│18.00   │    18.000│     540.000│    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│31＋103.91  │       50.00│18.00   │    18.000│     900.000│    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│31＋153.91  │       50.00│18.00   │    18.000│     900.000│    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│31＋203.91  │       50.00│18.00   │    18.000│     900.000│    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│31＋253.91  │       50.00│18.00   │    18.000│     900.000│    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│31＋293.71  │       39.80│18.00   │    18.000│     716.400│    │    │    │上斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│31＋293.71  │        0.00│ 4.00   │    11.000│         -  │    │    │    │下斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│31＋310.33  │       16.62│ 4.00   │     4.000│      66.480│    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│31＋353.91  │       43.58│18.00   │    11.000│     479.380│    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│31＋403.91  │       50.00│18.00   │    18.000│     900.000│    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│31＋453.91  │       50.00│18.00   │    18.000│     900.000│    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│31＋503.91  │        0.00│18.00   │    18.000│         -  │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│31＋553.91  │       50.00│26.00   │    22.000│   1,100.000│    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│31＋603.91  │       50.00│26.00   │    26.000│   1,300.000│    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│31＋653.91  │       50.00│26.00   │    26.000│   1,300.000│    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│31＋703.91  │       50.00│26.00   │    26.000│   1,300.000│    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│31＋753.91  │       50.00│26.00   │    26.000│   1,300.000│    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│31＋793.55  │       39.64│26.00   │    26.000│   1,030.640│    │    │    │          │
├──────┴──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│本頁共計                  │        │          │   29,529.32│    │    │    │          │
├─────────────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│連前共計                  │        │          │   62,229.33│    │    │    │          │
└─────────────┴────┴─────┴──────┴──┴──┴──┴─────┘

┌──────┬──────┬──────────────────────────┬─────┐  
│  樁號      │    距離    │                   箱型石籠                         │  附註    │
│            │            │                                                    │          │
│            │            ├────┬─────┬──────┬──┬──┬──┤          │
│            │            │    2   │          │     3      │    │    │    │          │
│            │            │   m    │  平均    │    m       │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│32＋159.00  │        0.00│   18.00│          │            │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│32＋169.00  │       10.00│   18.00│    18.000│      18.000│    │    │    │上斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│32＋169.00  │        0.00│   20.00│    19.000│         -  │    │    │    │下斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│32＋189.50  │       20.50│   20.00│    20.000│     410.000│    │    │    │上斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│32＋189.50  │        0.00│   22.00│    21.000│         -  │    │    │    │下斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│32＋199.75  │       10.25│   22.00│    22.000│     225.500│    │    │    │上斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│32＋199.75  │        0.00│   18.00│    20.000│         -  │    │    │    │下斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│32＋249.96  │       50.21│   18.00│    18.000│     903.780│    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│32＋299.96  │       50.00│   18.00│    18.000│     900.000│    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│32＋349.96  │       50.00│   18.00│    18.000│     900.000│    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│32＋399.96  │       50.00│   18.00│    18.000│     900.000│    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│32＋449.96  │       50.00│   18.00│    18.000│     900.000│    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│32＋499.67  │       49.71│   18.00│    18.000│     894.780│    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│32＋536.83  │       37.16│   18.00│    18.000│     668.880│    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│32＋536.83  │        0.00│   28.00│    23.000│         -  │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│32＋556.83  │       20.00│   28.00│    28.000│     560.000│    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│32＋556.83  │        0.00│   10.00│    19.000│         -  │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│32＋611.03  │       54.20│   10.00│    10.000│     542.000│    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│32＋611.03  │        0.00│   24.00│    17.000│         -  │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│32＋631.03  │       20.00│   24.00│    24.000│     480.000│    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│            │            │        │          │            │    │    │    │          │
├──────┴──────┴────┴─────┴──────┴──┴──┴──┴─────┤
│                                  跨河段修正數量                                            │
├──────┬──────┬────┬─────┬──────┬──┬──┬──┬─────┤
│            │            │        │          │            │    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│32＋555.86  │       17.00│   28.00│    28.000│     476.000│    │    │    │          │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│            │            │        │          │            │    │    │    │上斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│            │            │        │          │            │    │    │    │下斷面    │
├──────┼──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│32＋610.06. │       14.00│  24.000│    24.000│     336.000│    │    │    │          │
├──────┴──────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│本頁共計                  │        │          │    9,276.94│    │蛇籠│總計│          │
│                          │        │          │            │    │段箱│    │          │
│                          │        │          │            │    │籠  │    │          │
├─────────────┼────┼─────┼──────┼──┼──┼──┼─────┤
│連前共計                  │        │          │   71,506.27│    │786.│72,2│          │
│                          │        │          │            │    │00  │92.2│          │
│                          │        │          │            │    │    │7   │          │
└─────────────┴────┴─────┴──────┴──┴──┴──┴─────┘

㈣經濟部水利署第三河川局結算明細表(填表日期:97年1月5日)┌────────────────┬────────────────────────────────┬──────┬──────────────────────────────────────┐
│案號及合約號                    │096-I-00000-000-000，96-水工-303號                              │廠商名稱    │川順營造股份有限公司                                                        │
├────────────────┼────────────────────────────────┼──────┼──────────────────────────────────────┤
│標的名稱及數量摘要              │大甲溪砂石運輸便道工程-第三標(25K＋400~32K＋745)                │契約金額    │                                                                 173,428,613│
├──────┬─────────┼──┬──┬───────┬──────────────────┼──────┴───────────┬─────────────────────┬────┤
│            │                  │    │    │              │               契約                 │          結算結果                  │                增減金額                  │  備註  │
│項次        │    項目名稱      │說明│單位│   單價       ├──────┬───────────┼──────┬───────────┼─────────┬───────────┤        │
│            │                  │    │    │              │   數量     │        金額          │   數量     │         金額         │     增加金額     │     減少金額         │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│壹          │發包工作費        │    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│壹.一       │主體工程          │    │全  │              │            │        127,931,479.00│            │        119,535,538.00│         10,445.00│          8,406,386.00│增減分列│
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.一.1  │純挖方            │    │M3  │       13.00  │   64,240.00│            835,120.00│   63,068.00│            819,884.00│              -   │             15,236.00│        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.一.2  │回填方            │    │M3  │       20.00  │   64,240.00│          1,284,800.00│   63,068.00│          1,261,360.00│              -   │             23,440.00│        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.一.3  │純填方            │    │M3  │       29.00  │  220,583.00│          6,396,907.00│  200,507.00│          5,814,703.00│              -   │            582,204.00│        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.一.4  │140kg/cm2預拌混凝 │    │M3  │              │            │                  0.00│        0.00│                  0.00│              -   │                   -  │        │
│            │土                │    │    │    1,117.00  │           -│                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.一.5  │210kg/cm2預拌混凝 │    │M3  │    1,379.00  │    5,324.00│          7,341,796.00│    5,324.00│          7,341,796.00│              -   │                   -  │        │
│            │土（結構用）      │    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.一.6  │甲種模型損耗      │    │M2  │      203.00  │           -│                  0.00│        0.00│                  0.00│              -   │                   -  │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.一.7  │乙種模型損耗      │    │M2  │      175.00  │    2,588.00│            452,900   │    2,590.00│            453,250.00│            350.00│                   -  │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.一.8  │鋼筋及加工組立    │    │噸  │   14,596.00  │           -│                  0.00│        0.00│                  0.00│              -   │                   -  │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.一.9  │級配粒料底層，碎石│    │C.M3│      127.00  │   13,816.00│          1,754,632.00│   13,769.00│          1,748,663.00│              -   │              5,969.00│        │
│            │級配              │    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.一.10 │瀝青透層鋪設      │    │M2  │        8.00  │   64,439.00│            515,512.00│   64,677.00│            517,416.00│          1,904.00│                   -  │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.一.11 │瀝青黏層鋪設      │    │M2  │        7.00  │   59,717.00│            418,019.00│   59,720.00│            418,040.00│             21.00│                   -  │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.一.12 │再生瀝青混凝土鋪設│    │M2  │      113.00  │   58,621.00│          6,624,173.00│   58,617.00│          6,623,721.00│               -  │                452.00│        │
│            │（t=8cm）         │    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.一.13 │鋼筋混凝土管（B型 │    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
│            │），D=3000mm，四級│    │支  │   82,398.00  │       42.00│          3,460,716.00│       42.00│          3,460,716.00│               -  │                   -  │        │
│            │管，未含開挖回填  │    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.一.14 │鋼筋混凝土管（B型 │    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
│            │），D=2000mm，三級│    │支  │   40,787.00  │      224.00│          9,136,288.00│      224.00│          9,136,288.00│               -  │                   -  │        │
│            │管，未含開挖回填  │    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.一.15 │鋼筋混凝土管（B型 │    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
│            │），D=900mm，三級 │    │支  │    8,392.00  │      374.00│          3,138,608.00│       91.00│            763,672.00│               -  │                      │        │
│            │管，未含開挖回填  │    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │          2,374,936.00│        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.一.16 │甲種機編蛇籠（    │    │M   │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
│            │100cm*60cm ）     │    │    │      430.00  │    4,830.00│          2,076,900.00│     4849.00│          2,085,070.00│          8,170.00│                   -  │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.一.17 │箱型石籠          │    │M   │      977.00  │   82,928.00│         81,020,656.00│   79,516.00│         77,687,132.00│               -  │          3,333,524.00│        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.一.18 │梯形導溝          │    │M   │      139.00  │    7,089.00│            985,371.00│    2,500.00│            347,500.00│               -  │            637,871.00│        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.一.19 │帆布              │    │M2  │       36.00  │   42,486.00│          1,529,496.00│    2,947.00│            106,092.00│               -  │          1,423,404.00│        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.一.20 │活動型紐澤西護欄（│    │塊  │    1,167.00  │      240.00│            280,080.00│      240.00│            280,080.00│               -  │                      │        │
│            │單面）            │    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                   -  │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.一.21 │鋁板標誌牌面      │    │面  │    4,007.00  │       18.00│             72,126.00│       16.00│             64,112.00│               -  │              8,014.00│        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.一.22 │標線，熱塑性塑膠，│    │M2  │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
│            │反光，厚1.5mm     │    │    │      167.00  │    3,637.00│            607,379.00│    3,629.00│            606,043.00│               -  │              1,336.00│        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│壹.二       │雜項工程          │    │    │              │            │          2,550,656.00│            │          2,550,656.00│               -  │                   -  │增減分列│
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.二.1  │工程告示牌（      │    │面  │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                   -  │        │
│            │300cm*170cm，含基 │    │    │   17,515.00  │        2.00│             35,030.00│        2.00│             35,030.00│               -  │                      │        │
│            │腳固定設施）      │    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.二.2  │施工攝影及照片費（│    │式  │   26,273.00  │        1.00│             26,273.00│        1.00│             26,273.00│               -  │                   -  │        │
│            │含影片製作）      │    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.二.3  │承包商竣工圖、結算│    │式  │   48,167.00  │        1.00│             48,167.00│        1.00│             48,167.00│               -  │                   -  │        │
│            │書及竣工報告製作費│    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
│            │（含光碟）        │    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.二.4  │太空包（          │    │袋  │      584.00  │      100.00│             58,400.00│      100.00│             58,400.00│               -  │                  -   │        │
│            │0.8m*0.8m*0.8m）  │    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.二.5  │臨時電力、電訊設施│    │全  │   78,818.00  │        1.00│             78,818.00│        1.00│             78,818.00│               -  │                  -   │        │
│            │及維護費          │    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.二.6  │河流改道移抽排水費│    │全  │  840,726.00  │        1.00│            840,726.00│        1.00│            840,726.00│               -  │                  -   │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.二.7  │施工中車輛租用（供│    │全  │  175,151.00  │        1.00│            175,151.00│        1.00│            175,151.00│               -  │                  -   │        │
│            │甲方使用）        │    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.二.8  │施工測量費        │    │全  │  613,029.00  │        1.00│            613,029.00│        1.00│            613,029.00│               -  │                  -   │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.二.9  │臨時材料倉庫及管理│    │全  │  160,555.00  │        1.00│            160,555.00│        1.00│            160,555.00│               -  │                  -   │        │
│            │員室損耗費        │    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.二.10 │臨時施工便道設置及│    │全  │  229,886.00  │        1.00│            229,886.00│        1.00│            229,886.00│               -  │                  -   │        │
│            │修護費            │    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.二.11 │工地整理及既有物打│    │全  │  284,621.00  │        1.00│            284,621.00│        1.00│            284,621.00│               -  │                  -   │        │
│            │除與修復費        │    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│壹.三       │勞工安全衛生費    │    │全  │              │            │          1,321,924.00│            │          1,321,924.00│               -  │                  -   │增減分列│
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.三.1  │勞工安全衛生管理教│    │次  │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
│            │育訓練費          │    │    │    3,649.00  │        3.00│             10,947.00│        3.00│             10,947.00│               -  │                  -   │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.三.2  │其它安衛設施及管理│    │全  │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
│            │維護費            │    │    │   87,576.00  │        1.00│             87,576.00│        1.00│             87,576.00│               -  │                  -   │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.三.3  │安全衛生告示牌    │    │面  │    2,919.00  │        1.00│              2,919.00│        1.00│              2,919.00│               -  │                  -   │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.三.4  │夜間照明具        │    │座  │      584.00  │       70.00│             40,880.00│       70.00│             40,880.00│               -  │                  -   │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.三.5  │活動廁所          │    │座  │   14,596.00  │        4.00│             58,384.00│        4.00│             58,384.00│               -  │                  -   │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.三.6  │支架式旋轉警示燈  │    │盞  │    1,460.00  │       70.00│            102,200.00│       70.00│            102,200.00│               -  │                  -   │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.三.7  │活動型拒馬，一般型│    │個  │    1,460.00  │       30.00│             43,800.00│       30.00│             43,800.00│               -  │                  -   │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.三.8  │警告標示牌        │    │面  │    4,379.00  │       20.00│             87,580.00│       20.00│             87,580.00│               -  │                  -   │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.三.9  │交通錐，高70cm，塑│    │個  │      182.00  │      350.00│             63,700.00│      350.00│             63,700.00│               -  │                  -   │        │
│            │膠                │    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.三.10 │黃色警示帶        │    │M   │        4.00  │    6,000.00│             24,000.00│    6,000.00│             24,000.00│               -  │                  -   │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.三.11 │出入口管制措施    │    │處  │  253,969.00  │        2.00│            507,938.00│        2.00│            507,938.00│               -  │                  -   │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.三.12 │工程安全圍籬（含折│    │M   │    1,460.00  │      200.00│            292,000.00│      200.00│            292,000.00│               -  │                  -   │        │
│            │舊與損耗）        │    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│壹.四       │環境保護措施費    │    │全  │              │            │            637,114.00│            │            578,730.00│               -  │             58,384.00│增減分列│
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.四.1  │環境保護管理教育訓│    │次  │    3,649.00  │        3.00│             10,947.00│        3.00│             10,947.00│               -  │                   -  │        │
│            │練費              │    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.四.2  │工地清潔費        │    │式  │   76,629.00  │        1.00│             76,629.00│        1.00│             76,629.00│               -  │                   -  │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.四.3  │工地灑水費        │    │全  │  328,409.00  │        1.00│            328,409.00│        1.00│            328,409.00│               -  │                   -  │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.四.4  │洗車設備          │    │全  │   58,384.00  │        1.00│             58,384.00│        0.00│                  0.00│               -  │             58,384.00│        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.四.5  │施工車輛汙泥沖洗費│    │全  │   89,765.00  │        1.00│             89,765.00│        1.00│             89,765.00│               -  │                   -  │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.四.6  │其它環境設施及管理│    │全  │   72,980.00  │        1.00│             72,980.00│        1.00│             72,980.00│               -  │                   -  │        │
│            │維護費            │    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│壹.五       │品質管制作業費    │    │全  │              │            │          1,254,195.00│            │          1,259,084.00│          8,028.00│              3,139.00│增減分列│
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.五.1  │檢驗費            │    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │               -  │                   -  │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.五.1.A│蛇籠檢驗費        │    │次  │    2,189.00  │        1.00│              2,189.00│        1.00│              2,189.00│               -  │                   -  │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.五.1.B│石籠檢驗費        │    │次  │    4,014.00  │       25.00│            100,350.00│       27.00│            108,378.00│          8,028.00│                   -  │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.五.1.C│粗粒料（37.5mm以下│    │次  │    2,189.00  │       73.00│            159,797.00│       73.00│            159,797.00│               -  │                   -  │        │
│            │）磨損試驗法      │    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.五.1.D│含泥量試驗        │    │次  │      730.00  │       73.00│             53,290.00│       73.00│             53,290.00│               -  │                   -  │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.五.1.E│骨材篩分析試驗    │    │次  │    1,095.00  │       73.00│             79,935.00│       73.00│             79,935.00│               -  │                   -  │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.五.1.F│工地密度試驗      │    │次  │      584.00  │      120.00│             70,080.00│      120.00│             70,080.00│               -  │                   -  │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.五.1.G│瀝青級配粒徑篩分析│    │次  │      730.00  │       10.00│              7,300.00│       10.00│              7,300.00│               -  │                   -  │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.五.1.H│瀝青厚度試驗      │    │次  │      219.00  │       59.00│             12,921.00│       59.00│             12,921.00│               -  │                   -  │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.五.1.I│瀝青壓實度        │    │次  │      365.00  │       59.00│             21,535.00│       59.00│             21,535.00│               -  │                   -  │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.五.1.J│瀝青含量試驗      │    │次  │    1,460.00  │       10.00│             14,600.00│       10.00│             14,600.00│               -  │                   -  │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.五.1.K│竹節鋼筋拉伸1試驗 │    │支  │      584.00  │        1.00│                584.00│        0.00│                  0.00│               -  │                584.00│        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.五.1.L│鋼筋外觀試驗      │    │支  │       73.00  │        1.00│                 73.00│        0.00│                  0.00│               -  │                 73.00│        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.五.1.M│鋼筋化學成份分析  │    │次  │    1,241.00  │        1.00│              1,241.00│        0.00│                  0.00│               -  │              1,241.00│        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.五.1.N│熱處理鋼筋判定試驗│    │次  │    1,241.00  │        1.00│              1,241.00│        0.00│                  0.00│               -  │              1,241.00│        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.五.1.O│圓柱試體製作與養治│    │組  │    1,095.00  │       19.00│             20,805.00│       19.00│             20,805.00│               -  │                   -  │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.五.1.P│圓柱試體養護蓋平試│    │組  │      839.00  │       19.00│             15,941.00│       19.00│             15,941.00│               -  │                   -  │        │
│            │壓                │    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.五.1.Q│鑽心試體取樣      │    │組  │    2,189.00  │        8.00│             17,512.00│        8.00│             17,512.00│               -  │                   -  │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.五.1.R│鑽心試體切割蓋平試│    │組  │      985.00  │        8.00│              7,880.00│        8.00│              7,880.00│               -  │                   -  │        │
│            │壓                │    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.五.2  │品管費            │    │式  │              │            │                      │            │                      │               -  │                   -  │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.五.2.A│品管作業費        │    │全  │  666,921.00  │        1.00│            666,921.00│        1.00│            666,921.00│               -  │                   -  │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│壹.六       │包商管理費（壹. 一│    │全  │11,697,669.00 │        1.00│         11,697,669.00│        1.00│         10,954,628.00│               -  │            743,041.00│        │
│            │＋壹. 二）*8.85%＋│    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
│            │150000            │    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│壹.七       │營業說（壹. 一-壹.│    │全  │ 7,269,652.00 │        1.00│          7,269,652.00│        1.00│          6,810,028.00│               -  │            459,624.00│        │
│            │六）*5%           │    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│壹.八       │工程保險費（壹. 一│    │    │         0.00 │        1.00│                  0.00│        0.00│                  0.00│               -  │                  -   │        │
│            │＋壹. 二）*（1.05 │    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
│            │＋1.347）%*1.05   │    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│            │                  │    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│            │小計（壹. 一 - 壹.│    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
│            │八）              │    │    │              │            │        152,662,689.00│            │        143,010,588.00│         18,473.00│          9,670,574.00│增減分列│
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│壹.九       │聖帕颱風災損修復  │    │    │              │            │         14,321,629.00│            │         13,761,077.00│               -  │            560,552.00│增減分列│
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.一.3  │純填方            │    │M3  │         29.00│   20,683.00│            599,807.00│   20,683.00│            599,807.00│               -  │                   -  │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.一.17 │箱型石籠          │    │M   │        977.00│   12,195.00│         11,914,515.00│   11,693.00│         11,424,061.00│               -  │            490,454.00│        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.五.1.B│石籠檢驗費        │    │次  │      4,014.00│        4.00│             16,056.00│        4.00│             16,056.00│               -  │                   -  │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.五.1.F│工地密度試驗      │    │次  │        584.00│        3.00│              1,752.00│        3.00│              1,752.00│               -  │                   -  │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.六    │包商管理費（壹. 一│    │全  │  1,107,517.00│        1.00│          1,107,517.00│        1.00│          1,064,112.00│               -  │             43,405.00│        │
│            │）*8.85%          │    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.七    │營業說（壹. 一-壹.│    │全  │    681,982.00│        1.00│            681,982.00│        1.00│            655,289.00│               -  │             26,693.00│        │
│            │六）*5%           │    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│壹.十       │柯羅莎颱風災損修復│    │    │              │            │          6,444,295.00│            │          6,439,091.00│               -  │              5,204.00│增減分列│
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.一.3  │純填方            │    │M3  │         29.00│   31,929.00│            925,941.00│   31,772.00│            921,388.00│               -  │              4,553.00│        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.一.14 │鋼筋混凝土管（B型 │    │支  │      8,392.00│        7.00│             58,744.00│        7.00│             58,744.00│               -  │                   -  │        │
│            │），D=900mm，三級 │    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
│            │管，未含開挖回填  │    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.一.17 │箱型石籠          │    │M   │        977.00│    4,753.00│          4,643,681.00│    4,753.00│          4,643,681.00│               -  │                   -  │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.五.1.B│石籠檢驗費        │    │次  │      4,014.00│        2.00│              8,028.00│        2.00│              8,028.00│               -  │                   -  │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.五.1.F│工地密度試驗      │    │次  │        584.00│        5.00│              2,920.00│        5.00│              2,920.00│               -  │                   -  │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.六    │包商管理費（壹. 一│    │全  │    498,110.00│        1.00│            498,110.00│        1.00│            497,707.00│               -  │                403.00│        │
│            │）*8.85%          │    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│   壹.七    │營業說（壹. 一-壹.│    │全  │    306,871.00│        1.00│            306,871.00│        1.00│            306,623.00│               -  │                248.00│        │
│            │六）*5%           │    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│            │                  │    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│            │小計（壹. 一 - 壹.│    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │增減分列│
│            │十）              │    │    │              │            │        173,428,613.00│            │        163,210,756.00│         18,473.00│         10,236,330.00│        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│            │                  │    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│            │                  │    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │               -  │                   -  │        │
├──────┼─────────┼──┼──┼───────┼──────┼───────────┼──────┼───────────┼─────────┼───────────┼────┤
│            │總計（壹. 一 - 壹.│    │    │              │            │                      │            │                      │                  │                      │增減分列│
│            │十）              │    │    │              │            │                      │            │       163,210,756.00 │         18,473.00│         10,236,330.00│        │
├──────┴─────────┴──┴──┴───────┴──────┴───────────┴──────┴───────────┴─────────┴───────────┴────┤  
│承辦採購及監工（造）單位主管及人員                                                          機關首長或其授權人員                                                                              │
│                                                                                                                                                                                              │
│                                                                                                                                                                                              │
│                                                                                                                                                                                              │
│                                                                                                                                                                                              │
│                                                                                                                                                                                              │  
└───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘
《附件》通訊監察錄音譯文內容
┌────────────────────────────────┬────────────────────────────────────────┐
│編號 日期        時間      監聽電話       撥/接   對方電話      │通聯內容摘要                                                                備註│
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│1.   2007/08/14  08:53:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │與某女閒聊                                                                      │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│2.   2007/08/14  14:04:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中縣和平鄉○○村○○路○段號14"                                              │  
│                           局長戊○○             九龍酒店戴美玲│九龍酒店戴美玲：我在洗澡。                                                      │
│                                                                │許：有沒有信件。（☆戴美玲於偵查中證稱：應係「有沒有去復健」）                  │
│                                                                │戴：還沒。                                                                      │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│3.   2007/08/14  14:24:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │戊○○表示在「谷關」                                                            │
│                           局長戊○○             九龍酒店戴美玲│                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│4.   2007/08/14  14:29:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中縣新社鄉○○段○○○段000000地號"                                          │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │許：我在谷關。                                                                  │
│                                                                │女友陳玉瑛：我下午去友朋那裡學做餅。                                            │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│5.   2007/08/14  14:45:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │臺中市○○區○○里○○路○段000○0號16樓頂                                      │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │我去我朋友家玩學做餅干！做給你吃！那你去那  遠開車                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│6.   2007/08/14  15:12:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號14F頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○             九龍酒店戴美玲│許：我10分鐘（後）到你那邊。                                                    │
│                                                                │戴美玲：你到的時候打給我。                                                      │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│7.   2007/08/14  15:23:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段00號5F頂"                                                │
│                           局長戊○○             九龍酒店戴美玲│戴美玲：你到了嗎？                                                              │
│                                                                │許：在對面。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│8.   2007/08/14  15:24:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │戴美玲：你在哪？                                                                │
│                           局長戊○○             九龍酒店戴美玲│許：在對面。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│9.   2007/08/14  15:35:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路00號7樓頂"                                                   │
│                           局長戊○○             九龍酒店戴美玲│短訊：你怎麼生氣了？對一                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│10.  2007/08/15  13:18:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○區○○街00號6樓頂"                                                     │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │與某女閒聊                                                                      │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│11.  2007/08/15  15:28:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號14F頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │陳玉瑛：到了沒。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：差不多10分鐘到。                                                            │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│12.  2007/08/15  16:30:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                           局長戊○○             九龍酒店某女  │理容KTV女子：我跟你講喔，我沒有買皮帶，我買1個皮夾子給你。                      │
│                                                                │許：什麼。                                                                      │
│                                                                │女：我有買1個皮夾要給你啦。                                                     │
│                                                                │許：喔，但是今日沒空，今日沒空。                                                │
│                                                                │女：…事事大順，六六大順。                                                      │
│                                                                │許：好啦，好，改天啦。                                                          │
│                                                                │女：好，BYEBYE。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：改天啦，今天沒空。                                                          │
│                                                                │女：我知道啦，改天啦，好，BYEBYE，好，好。                                      │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│13.  2007/08/15  16:47:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶林秀春    │配偶表示在科學園區                                                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│14.  2007/08/15  16:52:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○             戊○○之女兒  │打電話叫女兒自己處理晚餐                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│15.  2007/08/15  16:53:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○             水利署周世杰  │（周世杰持用第三河川局張榮傑行動電話與戊○○通聯）                              │
│                                                                │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │周：頭仔喔。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：嗯，是，嗯。                                                                │
│                                                                │周：啊，現在在東勢，快到台中了，不然來那裡好嗎。                                │
│                                                                │許：哪裡。                                                                      │
│                                                                │周：就…，那個，來那個，不然來「九仔」（指九龍酒店）好嗎。                      │
│                                                                │許：隨便你呀，看你呀，我差不多7、8點到啦。                                      │
│                                                                │周：7、8點，現在幾點。                                                          │
│                                                                │許：現在6點多。（實際時間為下午16時，為避免監聽故意講為6點多）                  │
│                                                                │周：你7、8點才會到喔。                                                          │
│                                                                │許：是，嗯。                                                                    │
│                                                                │周：7、8點我就醉了。                                                            │
│                                                                │許：不要啦，你不要醉啦…。                                                      │
│                                                                │周：7、8點喔，好，我來那裡，好，好。                                            │
│                                                                │許：好，OK，OK。                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│16.  2007/08/15  20:08:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路0000號8F頂"                                                  │
│                           局長戊○○             第三河川局    │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                  管理課張榮傑  │榮傑：我榮傑，你等一下，「小乖」（第三河川局楊昭璿）說很抱歉要跟你說一下。      │
│                                                                │小乖：老闆。                                                                    │
│                                                  第三河川局    │許：不要緊，不要緊啦，沒什麼事情。                                              │
│                                                  楊昭璿（綽號小│小乖：因為我被拖出去了我。（指被張榮傑拖出去酒店包廂）                          │
│                                                  乖）          │許：沒關係，你回家休息。                                                        │
│                                                                │小乖：對不起喔。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：早點休息。                                                                  │
│                                                                │小乖：謝謝。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│17.  2007/08/15  21:05:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路0000號8F頂"                                                  │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶林秀春    │林：老爺。                                                                      │
│                                                                │許：在路上了。                                                                  │
└────────────────────────────────┴────────────────────────────────────────┘

┌────────────────────────────────┬────────────────────────────────────────┐
│編號 日期        時間      監聽電話       撥/接   對方電話      │通聯內容摘要                                                                備註│
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│1.   2007/09/06  15:15:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○區○○街00號6樓頂"                                                     │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │B：你要忙到幾點？                                                               │
│                                                                │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳玉瑛：喂。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：嗯，怎麼。                                                                  │
│                                                                │陳：你要忙到幾點。                                                              │
│                                                                │許：還不知道，你有事要出去嗎，有事你出去那個。                                  │
│                                                                │陳：你要忙到很晚喔。                                                            │
│                                                                │許：可能比較晚。                                                                │
│                                                                │陳：比較晚，這樣我跟你講，我可以先去嗎。                                        │
│                                                                │許：什麼。                                                                      │
│                                                                │陳：先去呀。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：去哪裡，「阿九」（指九龍酒店）那裡？                                        │
│                                                                │陳：對呀，對呀。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：隨便你啦，隨便你啦。                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：啊，你呢。                                                                  │
│                                                                │許：不要緊，你就去，反正我可以就去，我會叫人那個。（指要求川順公司前來買單）    │
│                                                                │陳：你再打電話跟我講對不對。                                                    │
│                                                                │許：對呀，對呀，對呀，對呀。                                                    │
│                                                                │陳：不管啦，我等你喔。                                                          │
│                                                                │許：呵呵呵呵。                                                                  │
│                                                                │陳：我不管。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：我工作還一大堆，好啦，好啦，好啦，去啦。                                    │
│                                                                │陳：好，OK，好，好。                                                            │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│2.   2007/09/06  16:43:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○區○○路000號9樓頂"                                                    │
│                           局長戊○○             九龍酒店戴美玲│戊○○向九龍酒店女友戴美玲表示明天中午過去找戴女。                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│3.   2007/09/06  16:50:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○路0段000號12F"                                               │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │陳玉瑛：喂。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：你在哪裡。                                                                  │
│                                                                │陳：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：你在哪裡。                                                                  │
│                                                                │陳：在「阿九」（九龍酒店）。                                                    │
│                                                                │許：OK，我知道，我知道，好。                                                    │
│                                                                │陳：好，OK。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│4.   2007/09/06  17:30:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中縣和平鄉○○村○○路○段號14"                                              │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         九龍酒店張淑惠│張淑惠：喂。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：你在上班。                                                                  │
│                                                                │張：不然呢？                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：不然呢。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：不然。                                                                      │
│                                                                │張：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：沒有。                                                                      │
│                                                                │張：我有看到「局長」（指戊○○）呀，我有。                                      │
│                                                                │廉：喔喔喔 。                                                                   │
│                                                                │張：我們沒有啦，我們沒有啦，我在山上。                                          │
│                                                                │廉：現在是怎麼樣，等一下我馬上打給你。                                          │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│5.   2007/09/06  17:31:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中縣和平鄉○○村○○路○段號14"                                              │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         局長戊○○    │（戊○○持用女友陳玉瑛行動電話與?裕隆通聯）                                     │
│                                                                │廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：「長仔」（指戊○○）。                                                      │
│                                                                │許：啊，你在哪裡，在哪裡。                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：山上。                                                                      │
│                                                                │許：埔裡。                                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：山上。（指大甲溪便道工程谷關工地）                                          │
│                                                                │許：喔，山上啦，OK，喔，忙到什麼時候。                                          │
│                                                                │廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：忙到什麼時候啦。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：山上。                                                                      │
│                                                                │許：我知道啦，我知道，我知道，嗯。                                              │
│                                                                │廉：收訊不好，我等一下打過去。                                                  │
│                                                                │許：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：我這裡收訊不好。                                                            │
│                                                                │許：好啦，不要緊，我知道，我知道，我知道。                                      │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│6.   2007/09/06  17:33:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中縣新社鄉○○村○○0號1F頂"                                                 │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         局長戊○○    │（戊○○持用女友陳玉瑛行動電話與?裕隆通聯）                                     │
│                                                                │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：長仔。                                                                      │
│                                                                │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：長仔。                                                                      │
│                                                                │許：怎麼，沒空嗎。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：在山上。（指大甲溪便道工程谷關工地）                                        │
│                                                                │許：我知道，我知道，嗯，怎麼，準備還沒好嗎，他們有去勘查嗎？                    │
│                                                                │廉：還沒，還沒，還沒。                                                          │
│                                                                │許：還沒喔。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：那個，這邊的都還沒過去。                                                    │
│                                                                │許：這樣喔。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：喔，好，這樣我知道。沒有啦，我在，我在那個，本來要叫你過來那個，輕鬆一下啦。│
│                                                                │（指過來九龍酒店）                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：喔喔喔，在哪裡。                                                            │
│                                                                │許：「阿九」（指九龍酒店）。                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：喔，好呀，好呀，我要下山了，我要下山了。                                    │
│                                                                │許：OK，喔。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：好好好。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：好好好。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│7.   2007/09/06  17:37:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中縣新社鄉○○村0鄰○○0○0號1F頂"                                           │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造戴沼澤│戴：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：「老闆」（指戊○○）在「阿九」（指九龍酒店），剛才有打給我。                │
│                                                                │戴：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：說叫我過去，我過去，那些我再跟他講一下。                                    │
│                                                                │戴：喔，你跟他看那個，你過去，你問他看那個這裡的行水區有沒有公告。              │
│                                                                │廉：沒有啦，沒有啦，沒有啦，今日張敬廉，我那時我在那邊把他載回來，他就說這邊那時│
│                                                                │候中興有測，我再和他確認啦，張敬廉那時是這樣跟我講啦，我那時候開完會，我們要回去│
│                                                                │他事務所，他是跟我說這邊喔，中興有過來做規劃過，做水規所的工作嘛，啊，有規劃過，│
│                                                                │但是堤線什麼都規劃好了，但是還沒公告。                                          │
│                                                                │戴：還1點喔，沒公告，他們現在看他們土地怎麼解決喔。                             │
│                                                                │廉：我現在就看土地啦，啊，會勘，他剛才有在問那個，那個，那個災害的啦，我說那就根│
│                                                                │本還沒出去到那裡。                                                              │
│                                                                │戴：我們這裡出去了，他們還在「世曦」（指世曦公司）啦。                          │
│                                                                │廉：我說那個，我現在說那個，那個「副座」（指第三河川局副局長林傳茂）的問題啦，還│
│                                                                │那個「逕行施工」那個啦。                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：對呀，…還有問題啦。                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：說叫他們怎麼。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：啊，鄉長剛才有打電話啦，說有回電話啦。                                      │
│                                                                │戴：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：有回電話啦，可能他們課長回去跟他講，我說，沒有說很好聽啦，好像說，就是好像說│
│                                                                │丟給他們啦，大家都去找，都說找鄉公所啦，他說，他說怎麼搞得這樣，他們覺得說鄉民，│
│                                                                │給他們的鄉民聽起來感覺說，感覺不好就對啦，嗯。                                  │
│                                                                │戴：我現在在，跟人在。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：好好好。                                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：看怎麼樣，看怎樣喔，叫他說，若「世曦」那個你跟他說一說喔，明天他可能「長仔」│
│                                                                │（指戊○○）還是那個喔，跟「世曦」叫他們過來溝通一下，和他們直接叫起來說不要在那│
│                                                                │裡寫那些有的沒有的，這樣，這樣就都沒有事情。                                    │
│                                                                │廉：好，好好。                                                                  │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│8.   2007/09/06  17:38:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶林秀春    │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │妻：怎麼。                                                                      │
│                                                                │許：晚點回去，晚點回去。                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│9.   2007/09/06  18:28:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段00號5F頂"                                                │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         九龍酒店張淑惠│廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：你在忙。                                                                    │
│                                                                │張：沒有呀，怎麼。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：沒有呀，沒有沒空呀，怎麼，…（與旁人對話），在山上不是嗎。                  │
│                                                                │廉：你怎麼知道。                                                                │
│                                                                │張：你有講呀。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：我剛有跟你說我在山上嗎。                                                    │
│                                                                │張：有呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：喔，下來了啦。                                                              │
│                                                                │張：下來了早點回去呀。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：要去『你們那裡』（指九龍理容KTV）。                                         │
│                                                                │張：不會累嗎。關我屁事。                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：怎樣。                                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：不要講話這樣好嗎。                                                          │
│                                                                │張：關我啥事，這樣有沒有比較好聽，…（與旁人對話），這樣說有沒有比較好聽，我等一│
│                                                                │下打給你好不好。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：好啦。                                                                      │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│10.  2007/09/06  18:30:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         九龍酒店張淑惠│廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：怎麼。                                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：我就很痛苦你還這樣講，我聽了更痛苦。                                        │
│                                                                │張：痛苦什麼，是我痛苦還是你痛苦。                                              │
│                                                                │廉：因為痛苦，所以我。                                                          │
│                                                                │張：不要來這一套好嗎。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：我沒有要講什麼，所以你不要覺得說。                                          │
│                                                                │張：我跟你講，沒什麼啦，其實，我沒什麼意思好不好，人是互相的。                  │
│                                                                │廉：對呀，所以我，是我自己比較。                                                │
│                                                                │張：怎麼對待我，我點滴在心頭，我不會煩你、不會吵你，我自己的事情我自己承擔。    │
│                                                                │廉：好啦，不要再講，等一下。                                                    │
│                                                                │張：BYEBYE。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│11.  2007/09/06  19:45:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         九龍酒店張淑惠│無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│12.  2007/09/06  19:45:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         九龍酒店張淑惠│張：你在哪裡。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：你在「105」（指九龍酒店105包廂）。                                          │
│                                                                │張：對對對，我剛進來，對。                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：我在你後面。                                                                │
│                                                                │張：進來呀。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：我在門口。                                                                  │
│                                                                │張：進來呀。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：那客人，我怎麼進去。                                                        │
│                                                                │張：什麼。                                                                      │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│13.  2007/09/06  20:38:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路000○00號12F"                                                │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶林秀春    │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │妻：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：怎麼。                                                                      │
│                                                                │妻：晚了耶。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：好啦，好啦，好啦。                                                          │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│14.  2007/09/06  21:09:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號12樓頂"                                             │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         九龍酒店張淑惠│張：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：我在醉了。                                                                  │
│                                                                │張：到家了嗎，你要回家了喔。                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：輾過別人家的路障，他叫我不要輾，我說不然現在是怎麼樣。                      │
│                                                                │張：現在怎麼回事。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：我輾過你家路障，那大樓路障，叫我不要輾，我說不然這裡不能停嗎，他說我為什麼要│
│                                                                │跟你講。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：好呀，你來公司載我，我帶你，帶你回家好不好。                                │
│                                                                │廉：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：好不好，你來公司載我，我帶你回家好不好。                                    │
│                                                                │廉：還沒，時間還沒到呀。                                                        │
│                                                                │張：沒關係，我先帶你回家，我先帶你回家，我還在忙，我先帶你回家，好不好。        │
│                                                                │廉：我跟他講這樣不行嗎，他說我是跟你說不能停嗎，啊。                            │
│                                                                │張：對呀，你先來「公司」（指九龍理容KTV）載我。                                 │
│                                                                │廉：我說不然我這樣不能嗎，說沒有呀，是沒有說不行。                              │
│                                                                │張：你們一起下去，還是先來載我。                                                │
│                                                                │廉：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：你要先下去，還是先來載我。                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：啊，你還沒下班呀。                                                          │
│                                                                │張：我不能下班，不能下班，我真的不能下班。                                      │
│                                                                │廉：好啦，好啦，好啦。                                                          │
│                                                                │張：不然你先回家，我不予置評呀。                                                │
│                                                                │廉：好啦，沒關係啦。                                                            │
│                                                                │張：沒關係是怎樣，你要回家，BYE。                                               │
│                                                                │廉：你的意思說是說。                                                            │
│                                                                │張：怎樣。                                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：好啦，好啦。                                                                │
│                                                                │張：好是什麼，我帶你下去，你來公司載我，我帶你下去。                            │
│                                                                │廉：157嘛，我自己下去就好了。                                                   │
│                                                                │張：你可以停下去嗎。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：可以啦，可以啦。                                                            │
│                                                                │張：好，我自己會回家，喔，OK，BYE。                                             │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│15.  2007/09/06  22:30:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆                       │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│16.  2007/09/06  22:31:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆                       │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│17.  2007/09/06  22:39:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         九龍酒店張淑惠│無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│18.  2007/09/07  03:37:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆                       │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│19.  2007/09/07  05:15:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆                       │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│20.  2007/09/07  06:33:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆                       │廉裕隆向妻表示醉了                                                              │
└────────────────────────────────┴────────────────────────────────────────┘

┌────────────────────────────────┬────────────────────────────────────────┐
│編號 日期        時間      監聽電話       撥/接   對方電話      │通聯內容摘要                                                                備註│
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│1.   2007/09/14  13:26:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○區○○街00號6樓頂"                                                     │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │戊○○與女友陳玉瑛閒聊                                                          │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│2.   2007/09/14  13:36:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○街00號13F頂"                                                 │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         局長司機      │第三河川局戊○○司機向?裕隆表示戊○○先回辦公室，現在與人談事情                 │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│3.   2007/09/14  14:17:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○街00巷00號7F頂"                                            │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         局長戊○○    │(戴沼澤持用?裕隆行動電話與戊○○通聯)                                           │
│                                                                │許：喂，喂。                                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：過來「旱溪工地」（指川順公司旱溪天祥街招待所）等你好嗎。                    │
│                                                                │許：好，好。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│4.   2007/09/14  14:32:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                           局長戊○○             水利署周世傑  │周：「頭仔」（指戊○○）喔。                                                    │
│                                                                │許：嗯，是。                                                                    │
│                                                                │周：嗯，在忙喔。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：嗯，還好，還好，怎麼。                                                      │
│                                                                │周：這樣我被調回來，你，你有要過去那邊嗎。                                      │
│                                                                │許：有啦。                                                                      │
│                                                                │周：若沒有。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：有啦，有啦，我等一下要過去啦。                                              │
│                                                                │周：我本來是打算中午來找你說。                                                  │
│                                                                │許：喔，這樣喔。                                                                │
│                                                                │周：好，不要緊。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：不然，過來那裡啦，過來那裡。                                                │
│                                                                │周：好。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：喔。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│5.   2007/09/14  14:37:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○○路0段000號12頂"                                              │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         女友王莉婷    │女友王莉婷：吃那麼久。                                                          │
│                                                                │戴：結束了。醉了。叫「阿扁」過來賭博，玩2圈而已。                               │
│                                                                │王：誰。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：副座呀。還有學弟。                                                          │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│6.   2007/09/14  14:42:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○區○○街00號6樓頂"                                                     │
│                           局長戊○○             川順營造戴沼澤│許：喂，喂。                                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：有空了嗎。                                                                  │
│                                                                │許：嗯，我現在那個，先那個一下，對，好，要過來了，要過來了。                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│7.   2007/09/14  14:59:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"台中市○區○○○0鄰○○○路000號4樓頂"                                         │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         女友王莉婷    │戴邀女友王莉婷賭博，並表示學弟跟副座都在這裡。                                  │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│8.   2007/09/14  16:20:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         水利署周世傑  │水利署周世傑：喂。                                                              │
│                           局長戊○○                           │?：課長，你請稍等。                                                             │
│                                                                │（?裕隆將電話交予戊○○）                                                       │
│                                                                │許：喂。（戊○○在於川順公司天祥街招待所）                                      │
│                                                                │周：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：你是去哪裡。                                                                │
│                                                                │周：在開車，在開車。                                                            │
│                                                                │許：你不要說那麼多，你是去哪。                                                  │
│                                                                │周：要辦一些事情一下。                                                          │
│                                                                │許：不要黑白講啦。                                                              │
│                                                                │周：真實的啦，真實的啦，對呀，我有跟「脫普」（音譯，指戴沼澤）講了，對呀，對呀，│
│                                                                │嗯。                                                                            │
│                                                                │許：你有跟他講喔。                                                              │
│                                                                │周：有呀，有呀，有有有有。                                                      │
│                                                                │許：真的還假的。                                                                │
│                                                                │周：真的，真的，真的，嗯，喔。                                                  │
│                                                                │許：「阿忠」是（指幀衡公司劉禎忠）先走還是。                                    │
│                                                                │周：我不知道，我開我的，嗯。                                                    │
│                                                                │許：喔。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│9.   2007/09/14  16:50:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │陳玉瑛：喂。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：喂，在睡嗎。                                                                │
│                                                                │陳：…。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：被我吵醒喔。                                                                │
│                                                                │陳：沒有啦，剛剛有3通電話我都起來接了。                                         │
│                                                                │許：喔，這樣行情不錯喔，電話又一堆。                                            │
│                                                                │陳：亞太的。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：然後，我媽媽，然後另外1通我就不想接的人。                                   │
│                                                                │許：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：啊，你不是說要去那個工地。                                                  │
│                                                                │許：什麼。                                                                      │
│                                                                │陳：你不是說要工地。                                                            │
│                                                                │許：現在就在工地。                                                              │
│                                                                │陳：…。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：什麼。                                                                      │
│                                                                │陳：我先生，今日禮拜5。                                                         │
│                                                                │許：喔，對對對。                                                                │
│                                                                │陳：今天我先生要回來。                                                          │
│                                                                │許：對呀，對呀，對呀。                                                          │
│                                                                │陳：你在工地喔。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：沒有呀，要去工地呀，工地要回來了。                                          │
│                                                                │陳：不是很遠嗎。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：還好啦。                                                                    │
│                                                                │陳：也在台中喔。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：有在台中喔。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：附近啦，附近。                                                              │
│                                                                │陳：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：怎麼，你是要，要怎麼處理。                                                  │
│                                                                │陳：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：要怎麼處理。                                                                │
│                                                                │陳：我喔，我都是聽別人的，我不發表意見的啦。                                    │
│                                                                │許：你都不發表意見喔，那很好呀。                                                │
│                                                                │陳：本來就是了，女人吵什麼。                                                    │
│                                                                │許：什麼。                                                                      │
│                                                                │陳：女人吵什麼。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：女人吵什麼。                                                                │
│                                                                │陳：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │許：女人要聽話呀。                                                              │
│                                                                │陳：對呀，老大都沒吵了，老二。                                                  │
│                                                                │許：女人聽話就好了，你還吵什麼。                                                │
│                                                                │陳：對呀，老爺。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：怎樣。                                                                      │
│                                                                │許：沒有呀，你。                                                                │
│                                                                │陳：我在家打電腦。                                                              │
│                                                                │許：呀，…，喂。                                                                │
│                                                                │陳：你在幹嘛，怎麼有聲音。                                                      │
│                                                                │許：有呀，你不曉得，你們，你們很吵。                                            │
│                                                                │陳：你那裡很吵耶。                                                              │
│                                                                │許：對呀，我這邊很吵呀。                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：為什麼那裡很吵。                                                            │
│                                                                │許：就是很吵呀。                                                                │
│                                                                │陳：都是女孩子的聲音耶。                                                        │
│                                                                │許：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │陳：啊，你不是在工地。                                                          │
│                                                                │許：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │陳：怎麼會這樣。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：工地，啊，你不知道工地都很吵。                                              │
│                                                                │陳：怎樣啦。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：沒有啦，現在他們在「阿九」（指九龍理容KTV）這裡啦。                         │
│                                                                │陳：你在那裡喔。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：對啦。                                                                      │
│                                                                │陳：對呀，我就覺得怪，還跟我說工地。                                            │
│                                                                │許：呵呵，這樣不是工地嗎。                                                      │
│                                                                │陳：每次都跟我考試，我就感覺不是這樣，怪怪。                                    │
│                                                                │許：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：你就已經到了，對呀。                                                        │
│                                                                │許：你要不要過來。                                                              │
│                                                                │陳：可是你都已經到那邊了呀。                                                    │
│                                                                │許：呀，有什麼關係，坐車子過來呀。                                              │
│                                                                │陳：啊，你有幫我留位置喔。                                                      │
│                                                                │許：有呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │陳：我整理整理，我叫人載我過去。                                                │
│                                                                │許：好呀，好呀。                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│10.  2007/09/14  16:56:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │女友陳玉瑛表示她先生8、9點回來                                                  │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│11.  2007/09/14  17:13:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○             水利署人員    │與水利署人員聯繫                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│12.  2007/09/14  17:16:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○             水利署人員    │戊○○回報顏清標中科處理情形                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│13.  2007/09/14  17:21:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○○路○段000號"                                                 │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         楓之林理容KTV │戴沼澤：喂。                                                                    │
│                                                  鄧秋蘭        │楓之林理容KTV幹部鄧秋蘭：戴董。                                                 │
│                                                                │戴：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │鄧：我『鄧』啦。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │鄧：我想要跟你說喔，要把『阿華』（指金拿獎視聽歌唱坊幹部陳秀月，綽號阿華）叫過來│
│                                                                │『楓之林』（指楓之林理容KTV）當副總不知道好不好，要問你一下。                   │
│                                                                │戴：你講這樣。                                                                  │
│                                                                │鄧：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：當然好呀。                                                                  │
│                                                                │鄧：好喔，你說好喔，真的喔。                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：我現在在，我現在也是在你們這個什麼，『九龍』（指九龍理容KTV）耶。           │
│                                                                │鄧：不要說我講的喔，我請我們公司的總經理現在『謝翠芬』跟你講好不好，好不好。    │
│                                                                │戴：不好啦，這個不是我的事情啦，你不要這樣啦。                                  │
│                                                                │鄧：我們現在有跟他邀請了耶。                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：對啦。                                                                      │
│                                                                │鄧：他說他要考慮耶。                                                            │
│                                                                │戴：你就跟他講就好了，在那裡沒前途就要走了，好嗎。                              │
│                                                                │鄧：沒有啦，幫我旁邊講一下啦，我叫我們『總仔』跟你講一下啦，好嗎，戴董。        │
│                                                                │戴：不要啦。                                                                    │
│                                                                │鄧：你給我3分鐘就好了啦。                                                       │
│                                                                │戴：不要啦，那個不重要啦，不要啦，不要啦，你跟他講一下啦。                      │
│                                                                │鄧：你要幫我跟『阿華』講一下啦。                                                │
│                                                                │戴：好啦，好啦，好啦。                                                          │
│                                                                │鄧：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：好啦。                                                                      │
│                                                                │鄧：剛才『總仔』有打電話給『阿華』啦，他說他考慮啦，我們『潘董』也說我們先打啦，│
│                                                                │啊，我說要先問你啦。                                                            │
│                                                                │戴：沒有啦。                                                                    │
│                                                                │鄧：對呀，先尊重你呀，你說好就好呀。                                            │
│                                                                │戴：沒有啦。                                                                    │
│                                                                │鄧：好嗎。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：你先跟他講好就好了，對否，人就是兄弟、朋友、姊妹、社會。                    │
│                                                                │鄧：對呀，你把『阿華』帶來給我，我現在就是這裡比較好、小姐比較多，我是說最好的機│
│                                                                │會就是這樣，啊，他現在就裝潢，啊，他那邊就沒辦法做起來，…，啊，你人帶來交給我，│
│                                                                │啊，有好的機會我當然要先給他嘛，好嗎。                                          │
│                                                                │戴：不要我帶，你去帶過來，我就，我再跟他講一下啦。                              │
│                                                                │鄧：我帶我就…。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：我跟他講啦，好嗎。                                                          │
│                                                                │鄧：好啦，你跟他講喔，好，謝謝。                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│14.  2007/09/14  17:36:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         配偶賴雲梅    │廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │妻：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │妻：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │妻：現在在做什麼。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：在，在「吃飯喝酒唱歌的地方」（指九龍理容KTV）。                             │
│                                                                │妻：在哪裡。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：台中呀。                                                                    │
│                                                                │妻：喔，今日沒進去喔。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │妻：你今天沒進去。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │妻：你車子又放在那裡。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │妻：你晚上要回來嗎。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：應該有吧。                                                                  │
│                                                                │妻：應該有。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │妻：又用應該。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │妻：應該是怎麼樣，等一下不知道會不會喝醉酒。                                    │
│                                                                │廉：你怎麼知道，應該是不會醉啦。                                                │
│                                                                │妻：不要這樣，這麼愛喝。                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：不是我愛喝。                                                                │
│                                                                │妻：不然是怎麼樣，別人都一直灌你。                                              │
│                                                                │廉：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │妻：哪有可能。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │妻：我不要再相信你，再見。                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：不會啦，不會啦，不會啦，喔。                                                │
│                                                                │妻：你若喝酒你就坐計乘車。                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：好啦，好。                                                                  │
│                                                                │妻：不要開那台車回來，BYEBYE，再見。                                            │
│                                                                │廉：好。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│15.  2007/09/14  17:40:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○                           │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│16.  2007/09/14  17:40:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○                           │與某女通聯                                                                      │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│17.  2007/09/14  17:41:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺北縣中和市○○○0鄰○○路○段00000號13樓屋頂瞭望台水箱頂"                    │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         幀衡公司劉禎忠│無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│18.  2007/09/14  17:42:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○                           │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│19.  2007/09/14  18:29:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○○路○段000號"                                                 │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         金拿獎視聽歌唱│金拿獎視聽歌唱坊幹部陳秀月：喂。                                                │
│                                                  坊幹部陳秀月  │戴：你在哪裡。                                                                  │
│                                                                │陳：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：你在哪裡。                                                                  │
│                                                                │陳：『公司』（指金拿獎視聽歌唱坊）呀。                                          │
│                                                                │戴：公司做什麼。                                                                │
│                                                                │陳：照輪班呀。                                                                  │
│                                                                │戴：今天輪你喔。                                                                │
│                                                                │陳：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：你們不是都沒有事情。                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：沒事情，我就跟你說我在輪班。                                                │
│                                                                │戴：輪到什麼時候，剛才回來在說，你要過去那裡。                                  │
│                                                                │陳：沒有，我哪有說我要過去那裡。                                                │
│                                                                │戴：你不是有跟他講。                                                            │
│                                                                │陳：我哪時跟他講，聽他在亂唬。                                                  │
│                                                                │戴：不是說他們1個『總仔』，誰。                                                 │
│                                                                │陳：他打電話給我，問說我要不要，我說看看，我沒辦法做決定。                      │
│                                                                │戴：他們『總仔』。                                                              │
│                                                                │陳：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：他們『總仔』是誰。                                                          │
│                                                                │陳：他在跟我講他們『潘總』，我哪知。                                            │
│                                                                │戴：『潘總』不是誰。                                                            │
│                                                                │陳：『阿國』嘛，我不知道啦，我就跟他講，我都沒有做決定，沒有答應好啦。明天呢，你│
│                                                                │明天要做什麼。                                                                  │
│                                                                │戴：啊。你若要就現在下來呀。                                                    │
│                                                                │陳：我不行啦，對呀。                                                            │
│                                                                │戴：在店裡都不能跑喔。                                                          │
│                                                                │陳：不能跑啦。                                                                  │
│                                                                │戴：不能營業，不能跑，是幾個在那裡顧。                                          │
│                                                                │陳：剩我跟『總會』2個而已，他要做帳呀，大廳要有人顧呀。                         │
│                                                                │戴：不是開開的，不是關起來了。                                                  │
│                                                                │陳：沒有呀，關起來沒有錯呀，也是有人會回帳呀。                                  │
│                                                                │戴：有客人嗎。                                                                  │
│                                                                │陳：多少有客人進去回帳呀。                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：有在喝嗎。                                                                  │
│                                                                │陳：那是要怎麼喝，又沒有小姐，就沒得喝，那是開門，大家都休息，只有我，照輪流，會│
│                                                                │計要固定在那裡，還1個幹部在那裡，是客人要回帳的問題。                           │
│                                                                │戴：回帳，哪有可能說去店裡回帳沒那個。                                          │
│                                                                │陳：有的都，有的有從公司回帳呀。                                                │
│                                                                │戴：不是都要，現在沒營業，人就要出去收了，不是嗎。                              │
│                                                                │陳：有的出去收，有的也是叫進去公司回呀。                                        │
│                                                                │戴：你們現在那個，現在誰，誰做經理、做總仔，『洪小惠』（音譯）。                │
│                                                                │陳：洪執董呀。                                                                  │
│                                                                │戴：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：洪執董呀。                                                                  │
│                                                                │戴：你們執董還在那裡經營喔。                                                    │
│                                                                │陳：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：他就沒有，還在那裡做什麼。                                                  │
│                                                                │陳：誰沒那個，他要接起來做呀。                                                  │
│                                                                │戴：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：他說他要接起來做呀。                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：接起來沒，何時要接。                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：還沒啦，要到月底啦，月底才有那個啦。                                        │
│                                                                │戴：你們整群還要在那裡。                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：沒有啦，看看，我想要休息，身體先調養好再說。                                │
│                                                                │戴：壞掉了喔。                                                                  │
│                                                                │陳：對啦。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：對啦。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：休息就調養，沒休息就那麼懶。                                                │
│                                                                │陳：休息，休息當然也要調養。                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：好啦，說喝酒，看，喝一喝，你剛好休息，看要不要過來。                        │
│                                                                │陳：我哪有休息，我下午在跟你講電話的時候，我就跟你說我沒休息，我來這裡輪班，若休│
│                                                                │息我就要回去南部了，對呀，不一定，我就在問說你禮拜6、禮拜天有時間嗎，若有時間就 │
│                                                                │那個，若沒有，我就要回去南部了。                                                │
│                                                                │戴：沒有啦，那是剛才回去打給我啦，說你有，跟你說啦，說看有沒有辦法給你鼓勵過去，│
│                                                                │我說那他自己的事情。                                                            │
│                                                                │陳：嗯嗯嗯，我是還沒做決定，還沒做決定。                                        │
│                                                                │戴：那裡都。                                                                    │
│                                                                │陳：其實我跟你講啦，不是那間在叫，2、3間在叫啦，說業績都要做多少多少，對否，一間│
│                                                                │一間又不同。                                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：那間，好啦，好啦，我是剛才，剛才他打給我在說。                              │
│                                                                │陳：你不用嗎。                                                                  │
│                                                                │戴：沒有啦，在『九龍』（指九龍理容KTV）在喝啦。                                 │
│                                                                │陳：喔，好啦，好啦，慢慢喝啦，喔。                                              │
│                                                                │戴：好啦。                                                                      │
│                                                                │陳：好。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│20.  2007/09/14  18:43:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路0000號8F頂"                                                  │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造王莉婷│無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│21.  2007/09/14  19:02:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造王莉婷│無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│22.  2007/09/14  19:03:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造王莉婷│無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│23.  2007/09/14  19:03:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造王莉婷│廉裕隆邀王莉婷過來（九龍理容KTV），陪戴沼澤上去（本便道工程工地），王莉婷因細故 │
│                                                                │不願。                                                                          │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│24.  2007/09/14  19:09:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         三舅          │與三舅通聯                                                                      │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│25.  2007/09/14  19:39:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           局長戊○○                           │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│26.  2007/09/14  19:45:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         九龍理容KTV張 │廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                  淑惠          │九龍理容KTV張淑惠：喂，還在「包廂」（指九龍理容KTV包廂）裡面嗎。                │
│                                                                │廉：出來外面，我出來在3樓口，沒看到你。                                         │
│                                                                │張：我在計乘上面，你不要讓我進去很尷尬，好像沒有人叫的時候，不能進去。          │
│                                                                │廉：你不用進來啦。                                                              │
│                                                                │張：我不用進去，啊，你要找我呀。                                                │
│                                                                │廉：對呀，你就不用進來呀，我就出來外面了。                                      │
│                                                                │張：喔，先回去了呀。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：我還沒啦，他們就還在裡面在坐，我出來外面，透透。                            │
│                                                                │張：你先回去吧。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：我。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：要回去哪裡，他們還沒要走。                                                  │
│                                                                │張：回去大甲呀。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：他們還沒走呀。                                                              │
│                                                                │張：我進來跟你們。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：跟那個，跟「長仔」（指戊○○）喝呀。                                        │
│                                                                │廉：你說怎麼。                                                                  │
│                                                                │張：我跟「長仔」喝呀。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：何時。                                                                      │
│                                                                │張：現在呀，我上來上面了。                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：你說和誰喝，你說你晚上喔。                                                  │
│                                                                │張：對呀，我現在要去了。                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：已經。                                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：跟你們「長仔」喝呀，跟「你大舅」（指戴沼澤）講話呀。                        │
│                                                                │廉：何時。                                                                      │
│                                                                │張：現在呀，我要進去呀。                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：現在你要。                                                                  │
│                                                                │張：你會怕喔。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：你會怕喔。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：怕什麼。                                                                    │
│                                                                │張：不是不認識他們 ，也不是現在，因為你才認識他們的。                           │
│                                                                │廉：你是喝多少了。                                                              │
│                                                                │張：你管我喝多少。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：好啦，好啦，好啦。                                                          │
│                                                                │張：現在是怎麼樣。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：沒有呀，沒有怎麼呀。                                                        │
│                                                                │張：我不想跟你講太多話。                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：喔，好啦，好啦，好啦。                                                      │
│                                                                │張：今天是我國曆生日。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：對呀，9月14號。                                                             │
│                                                                │張：對呀，好多人。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：喔，生日快樂啦。                                                            │
│                                                                │張：不用，我不是，我不是為誰，不用跟我講生日快樂。                              │
│                                                                │廉：喔，沒有要。                                                                │
│                                                                │張：BYEBYE。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│27.  2007/09/14  20:22:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中縣外埔鄉○○○段00000地號"                                                 │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆                       │九龍理容KTV女友張淑惠要廉裕隆明晚陪他                                           │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│28.  2007/09/14  20:23:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           局長戊○○                           │某主秘表示與「張副座」在「魔根」（西餐廳）在坐                                  │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│29.  2007/09/14  20:24:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           局長戊○○             戊○○子      │子：我現在下交流道。                                                            │
│                                                                │許：我現在過去，要等喔。                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│30.  2007/09/14  20:27:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           局長戊○○             妻林秀春      │妻：去接兒子了沒。                                                              │
│                                                                │許：有。                                                                        │
└────────────────────────────────┴────────────────────────────────────────┘

┌────────────────────────────────┬────────────────────────────────────────┐
│編號 日期        時間      監聽電話       撥/接   對方電話      │通聯內容摘要                                                                備註│
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│1.   2007/09/18  15:57:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○區○○街00號6樓頂"                                                     │
│                           局長戊○○             川順營造戴沼澤│（戴沼澤持用川順公司旱溪天祥街招待所市內電話與戊○○通聯）                      │
│                                                                │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：是。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：看好了嗎。                                                                  │
│                                                                │許：還差不多要半個鐘頭。                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：嗯，嗯。                                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：在「旱溪」（指川順公司旱溪天祥街招待所）。                                  │
│                                                                │許：OK，好，好。                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│2.   2007/09/18  15:59:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○區○○街00號6樓頂"                                                     │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │許：他們在「旱溪」，打2、3次了，我可能要去一趟，還是你要一起過來。              │
│                                                                │陳玉瑛：我準備好再打給你。                                                      │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│3.   2007/09/18  17:00:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"台中市○區○村路○段000號五樓室內及頂樓"                                       │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤                       │戴：副總。                                                                      │
│                                                                │副總：你的工地要緊嗎？                                                          │
│                                                                │戴：應該是還好。                                                                │
│                                                                │副總：你不來台中讓我請一下，我現在和兄弟在消遣。                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│4.   2007/09/18  17:38:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中縣太平市○○路000巷00號7樓頂"                                              │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         局長戊○○    │同下                                                                            │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│5.   2007/09/18  17:38:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段00號17樓頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○             川順營造廉裕隆│許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                          戴沼澤│廉：長仔，請稍等 。                                                             │
│                                                                │（?裕隆將電話交予戴沼澤）                                                       │
│                                                                │許：怎麼。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：嗯，怎麼。                                                                  │
│                                                                │戴：現在那個「許副座」（指前中區水資源局副局長許慶祥）在這裡。                  │
│                                                                │許：在哪裡。                                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：你有事情嗎。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：沒有啦，你在哪裡啦。                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：「天」，「天」，「旱溪」（指川順公司天祥街招待所）。                        │
│                                                                │許：喔，在「旱溪」嗎。                                                          │
│                                                                │戴：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：OK，好，好，好，晚一點，晚一點，喔，我晚一點過去。                          │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│6.   2007/09/18  17:42:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○街000號14F頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳玉瑛：啊，你還沒好喔。                                                        │
│                                                                │許：現在到台中港路。                                                            │
│                                                                │陳：喔，好。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：這樣你等一下準備下來。                                                      │
│                                                                │陳：5分鐘喔。                                                                   │
│                                                                │許：嗯嗯嗯。                                                                    │
│                                                                │陳：好，好。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│7.   2007/09/18  18:07:00   0000000000      接    0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○路○段000巷00號16F屋頂"                                        │
│                            川順營造戴沼澤        川順營造鄭年雅│戴沼澤向媳婦鄭年雅表示和朋友在說話                                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│8.   2007/09/18  18:17:00   0000000000      接    0000000000    │台中市○○區○○路○段000巷00號16F屋頂                                          │
│                            川順營造戴沼澤                      │您有未接來電:                                                                   │
│                                                                │09/18 11:02AM來自0000000000 (0通)                                               │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│9.   2007/09/18  18:27:00   0000000000      接    0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○路○段000巷00號16F屋頂"                                        │
│                            川順營造戴沼澤        幀衡公司劉禎忠│（幀衡公司劉禎忠持用九龍理容KTV徐玉玲行動電話與戴沼澤通聯）                     │
│                                                                │戴：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │劉：董仔，董仔。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │劉：董仔，董仔。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │劉：要不要來。                                                                  │
│                                                                │戴：要啦，在講話，等一下過去啦。                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│10.  2007/09/18  18:28:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號12樓頂"                                             │
│                           局長戊○○             九龍酒店徐玉玲│許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │九龍理容KTV徐玉玲：大哥。                                                       │
│                                                                │許：嗯，怎麼。                                                                  │
│                                                                │徐；吃飯了。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：他們在那裡喔。                                                              │
│                                                                │徐：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │許：我現在快到「他們工務所」（指川順公司天祥街招待所）了，他們去「那裡」（指九龍│
│                                                                │理容KTV）。                                                                     │
│                                                                │徐：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │許：去你那邊了嗎。                                                              │
│                                                                │徐：對呀。吃飯呀，快點呀。                                                      │
│                                                                │許：那個，「旱溪」（指川順公司天祥街招待所）那裡沒人了嗎。                      │
│                                                                │徐：應該是沒有吧。                                                              │
│                                                                │許：OK，OK，我過來，我過來。                                                    │
│                                                                │徐：好，好。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：好啦，好啦，好啦。                                                          │
│                                                                │徐：好，好。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│11.  2007/09/18  18:30:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號12樓頂"                                             │
│                           局長戊○○             川順營造廉裕隆│許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：長仔，阿隆。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：阿隆。                                                                      │
│                                                                │許：嗯，嗯。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：你有要過來嗎。                                                              │
│                                                                │許：「旱溪」（指川順公司天祥街招待所），「旱溪」有人嗎。                        │
│                                                                │廉：有呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │許：不然是什麼人說要給我叫「那個」（指九龍理容KTV）。                           │
│                                                                │廉：叫哪裡，喔，那邊喔。                                                        │
│                                                                │許：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：不然我先過來「旱溪」，我過來「旱溪」。                                      │
│                                                                │廉：好呀，好好好好。                                                            │
│                                                                │許：我是要到了，他跟喊說，喊說什麼，那個，那個在那邊。                          │
│                                                                │廉：有的走開了，有的走開了。                                                    │
│                                                                │許：OK，OK，我先過來，OK啦。                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│12.  2007/09/1   18:44:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆                       │廉裕隆向女兒表示不回家吃飯                                                      │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│13.  2007/09/18  19:04:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │台中市○○區○○○00鄰○○路00000號五樓頂及屋凸                                 │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤                       │您有未接來電:                                                                   │
│                                                                │09/18 11:02AM來自0000000000 (0通)                                               │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│14.  2007/09/18  19:10:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           局長戊○○             九龍酒店徐玉玲│許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │九龍理容KTV徐玉玲：我幫你拿雨傘嗎。                                             │
│                                                                │許：我這個車子不能不能停你們前面啦。                                            │
│                                                                │徐：我知道呀，就你有帶雨傘嗎。                                                  │
│                                                                │許：沒問題啦，沒問題啦，沒問題啦。                                              │
│                                                                │徐：沒問題喔。                                                                  │
│                                                                │許：對啦，對啦。                                                                │
│                                                                │徐：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：好好好。                                                                    │
│                                                                │徐：好好好。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│15.  2007/09/18  19:26:00  0000000000      接      0000000000   │"台中市○○區○○○路○段000號"                                                 │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤                       │您有未接來電:                                                                   │
│                                                                │09/18 11:02AM來自0000000000 (0通)                                               │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│16.  2007/09/18  19:26:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號3F"                                                 │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造王莉婷│（王莉婷背景有KTV歌唱聲）                                                       │
│                                                                │王：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：你在上面。                                                                  │
│                                                                │王：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：你在樓上嗎。                                                                │
│                                                                │王：對啦，「301」（指九龍理容KTV編號301包廂）。                                 │
│                                                                │廉：沒有啦，不是等一下要走嗎。                                                  │
│                                                                │王：要走，不過他說那個載他，我怎知。                                            │
│                                                                │廉：我在，這樣我沒有要上去了，我在旁邊而已，要走再打電話給我就好。              │
│                                                                │王：喔，好呀，好呀，好呀。                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：我在旁邊而已。                                                              │
│                                                                │王：好呀，好呀，好呀，好呀。                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│17.  2007/09/18  19:29:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆                       │廉裕隆與某男通聯                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│18.  2007/09/18  19:44:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○○路○段000號"                                                 │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤                       │您有未接來電:                                                                   │
│                                                                │09/18 11:02AM來自0000000000 (0通)                                               │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│19.  2007/09/18  19:56:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號3F"                                                 │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆                       │妻：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │妻：你吃過了嗎。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：還沒，我在等「大舅」（指戴沼澤）。                                          │
│                                                                │妻：喔，在「天祥街」（指川順公司天祥街招待所）喔。                              │
│                                                                │廉：沒有啦，在外面。                                                            │
│                                                                │妻：在外面等他。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：在外面啦，嗯。                                                              │
│                                                                │妻：在台中嗎。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │妻：等他去吃飯喔。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：他去唱歌，我在等他啦，等他要載他。                                          │
│                                                                │妻：喔，你還沒吃喔。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │妻：回來吃呀。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：好。                                                                        │
│                                                                │妻：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：好。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│20.  2007/09/18  20:00:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○○路○段000號"                                                 │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤                       │您有未接來電:                                                                   │
│                                                                │09/18 11:02AM來自0000000000 (0通)                                               │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│21.  2007/09/18  20:28:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│22.  2007/09/18  21:22:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○路○段00000號"                                                 │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤                       │您有未接來電:                                                                   │
│                                                                │09/18 11:02AM來自0000000000 (0通)                                               │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│23.  2007/09/19  07:36:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中縣外埔鄉○○路00巷00號3樓頂"                                               │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造王莉婷│王莉婷：昨（18）日水利署周世傑酒駕撞到人，撞的很嚴重。                          │
│                                                                │廉：唉！                                                                        │
│                                                                │王：怎麼喝成這樣！他（周世傑）昨天很急，一直要找「董仔」（指戴沼澤）。          │
│                                                                │廉：他撞到人，那一定要處理，一定要報警。                                        │
│                                                                │王：那又喝酒，又撞到人，一定很嚴重！                                            │
│                                                                │廉：對啊！那也是要處理，要不然，要如何處理！又不能私底給錢！像我上次告訴你的一樣│
│                                                                │！因為撞到人很嚴重。也沒有人敢！                                                │
│                                                                │王：你有去戴他（戴沼澤）嗎？                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：還沒有喔！我現人在路上。                                                    │
└────────────────────────────────┴────────────────────────────────────────┘

┌────────────────────────────────┬────────────────────────────────────────┐
│編號 日期        時間      監聽電話       撥/接   對方電話      │通聯內容摘要                                                                備註│
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│1.   2007/10/02  11:51:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○區○○街00號6樓頂"                                                     │
│                           局長戊○○             水利署周世傑  │許：「阿九」（音譯）來這裡，我想說你有空過來，現在去「四河局」了。              │
│                                                                │水利署河川勘測隊周世傑：好。                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│2.   2007/10/02  12:06:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○區○○街00號6樓頂"                                                     │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │...許：下午忙完就可以找你，差不多3點半就結束了…                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│3.   2007/10/02  12:20:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○區○○街00號6樓頂"                                                     │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │戊○○與女友閒聊                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│4.   2007/10/02  15:37:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中縣和平鄉○○路○段○○○巷0000號"                                          │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆        九龍理KTV張淑惠│張：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：我禮拜5要回花蓮。                                                           │
│                                                                │廉：為什麼。                                                                    │
│                                                                │張：想回去。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：想回去。                                                                    │
│                                                                │張：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：要回去幾天。                                                                │
│                                                                │張：2、3天吧。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：想回去就回去。                                                              │
│                                                                │張：買到假不回去幹嘛。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：買到假不回去幹嘛，留在這邊喔，顧人怨喔。                                    │
│                                                                │廉：顧人怨，顧誰怨了。                                                          │
│                                                                │張：啊，顧大家的怨呀。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：休息，在那裡亂逛，再來公司亂逛這樣嘛。                                      │
│                                                                │張：啊，是嗎，對呀，反正就顧人怨呀，回去了，大家要放這邊放多1點。               │
│                                                                │廉：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：沒有就剛好有人給我1天假，…就1天，我想說，因為我跟我媽講過回去是在1天、2天就│
│                                                                │OK了，不要，我搭飛機，我不想回去太多天。                                        │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：撐不住，我想回去呀。                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：剛那個誰，剛「number one」（指戊○○女友陳玉瑛）打了2通電話給我了，打來公司 │
│                                                                │。                                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：打給你。                                                                    │
│                                                                │張：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：打給你要做什麼。                                                            │
│                                                                │張：叫我他留他的電話，叫我電話給他呀，說他都在休息呀，有時要出來，「楓之林」（指│
│                                                                │楓之林理容KTV）過來好幾個呀。                                                   │
│                                                                │廉：哪裡，「number one」叫你留，叫你留電話給他。                                │
│                                                                │張：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：嗯，做什麼。                                                                │
│                                                                │張：他叫「阿瑛」（指陳玉瑛）喔。                                                │
│                                                                │廉：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │張：他就說，他就說他現在沒上班呀，他一些姊妹都跑來找我呀，說以後他要，不管在哪裡│
│                                                                │，他要帶他們出去唱歌呀。                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：時間他會叫人算這樣呀。                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：喔，他的朋友去你們那裡上班就對啦。                                          │
│                                                                │張：「楓之林」過來3、4個，這2天呀。                                             │
│                                                                │廉：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：別人帶過來的，…也過來。                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：過來好幾個，以前在那裡的，條件都不大好，你知道嗎，是要怎麼做坐檯的。        │
│                                                                │廉：不會啦，總是，都很會算。                                                    │
│                                                                │張：他就，他就這樣講呀。                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：啊，他叫我留電話給他，叫我給他電話輸入，又丟掉，再打來說我怎麼都不打電話給他│
│                                                                │，我說我真的丟，我唸唸我就忘記了。                                              │
│                                                                │廉：是說你不會問我喔。                                                          │
│                                                                │張：神經病耶，我是很有行情的人耶。                                              │
│                                                                │廉：我是多沒行情啦。                                                            │
│                                                                │張：你那麼花。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：我那麼花。                                                                  │
│                                                                │張：被人知道我就都沒行情了。                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：對否，等一下別人說，唉唷，他那麼花你不過其中1個。                           │
│                                                                │廉：我才不會。                                                                  │
│                                                                │張：不會嗎，你怎麼那麼喘。                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：我在走路呀。                                                                │
│                                                                │張：喔，反正你要是碰到「他」（指陳玉瑛）。                                      │
│                                                                │廉：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：你應該還經常碰到「他」吧。                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：沒有，最近沒有。                                                            │
│                                                                │張：因為你最近很少跟「他們」（指戊○○等人）喝酒。                              │
│                                                                │廉：對呀，就那一次而已呀。                                                      │
│                                                                │張：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：好，我跟你講禮拜5第1班飛機，然後我是訂禮拜天中午的飛機。                    │
│                                                                │廉：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：好啦，好啦。                                                                │
│                                                                │張：好。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│5.   2007/10/02  16:10:00  0000000000      接      0000000000   │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                           局長戊○○              女友陳玉瑛   │陳玉瑛：你說沒聽到嗎。                                                          │
│                                                                │許：不是沒聽到，是署長室裡面，在署長室裡面。                                    │
│                                                                │陳：有人比你大啦，你就知道。                                                    │
│                                                                │許：什麼。                                                                      │
│                                                                │陳：上面還有人，有人比你大啦，你知道嗎。                                        │
│                                                                │許：什麼比我大，當然有人比我大呀。                                              │
│                                                                │陳：對呀，所以你就要怕。                                                        │
│                                                                │許：好啦。                                                                      │
│                                                                │陳：我想說你睡過頭了。                                                          │
│                                                                │許：沒有，哪那麼好命，在裡面講事情。                                            │
│                                                                │陳：這樣你還在忙喔。                                                            │
│                                                                │許：沒有啦，我現在回家，車子開了就過來了。                                      │
│                                                                │陳：喔，你到你再打給我，我再下來，…。                                          │
│                                                                │許：好啦，好啦。                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│6.   2007/10/02  16:10:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號6樓"                                                │
│                           局長戊○○             局長司機      │司機：喂喂。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：你車子開過來。                                                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│7.   2007/10/02  16:29:00  0000000000     撥     0000000000     │陳玉瑛  "臺中市○○區○○路000號5樓頂"                                          │
│                            局長戊○○            女友陳玉瑛    │陳玉瑛：喂。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：要下來了，下來。                                                            │
│                                                                │陳：喔，好。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│8.   2007/10/02  20:54:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶林秀春    │妻：在哪裡？                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：好啦，好啦，在路上了。                                                      │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│9.   2007/10/02  14:35:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"台中縣和平鄉○○村0鄰○○路0段000號1F"                                         │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤                       │聯繫施工                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│10.  2007/10/02  15:36:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中縣和平鄉○○路○段○○○巷0000號"                                          │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造戴沼澤│廉裕隆現於谷關工地事務所旁                                                      │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│11.  2007/10/02  16:58:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"台中縣和平鄉○○路0段○○○巷00號1樓室外"                                      │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         川順營造戴泱丞│聯繫施工                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│12.  2007/10/02  17:33:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"台中縣和平鄉○○村0鄰○○路0段000號1F"                                         │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         某男          │某男表示會晚點下去，要戴沼澤代轉達。                                            │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│13.  2007/10/02  19:53:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造戴永恭│戴永恭：隆仔。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：在忙喔。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：在忙喔。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：在『山上』（指台中縣和平鄉），『山上』。                                    │
│                                                                │戴：喔，『山上』喔。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：那個『技師』（指前中區水資源局副局長許慶祥）的電話幾號你知道嗎。            │
│                                                                │廉：你說『副座』（指中區水資源局副局長許慶祥）喔。                              │
│                                                                │戴：嗯嗯嗯。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：0937。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：嗯嗯。                                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：262841。                                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：262841。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：就『許副座』（指中區水資源局副局長許慶祥）嘛。                              │
│                                                                │戴：嗯，『許副座』，嗯。                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：嗯，0000000000（中區水資源局副局長許慶祥持用之行動電話）。                  │
│                                                                │戴：喔喔。最近比較忙喔。                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：最近就，對呀，可能月中別人要來工程督導，國營會。                            │
│                                                                │戴：喔喔喔，好，好。                                                            │
└────────────────────────────────┴────────────────────────────────────────┘

┌────────────────────────────────┬────────────────────────────────────────┐
│編號 日期        時間      監聽電話       撥/接   對方電話      │通聯內容摘要                                                                備註│
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│1.   2007/10/04 12:20:00   0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"台中縣和平鄉○○路0段○○○巷00號1樓室外"                                      │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         女友王莉婷    │王莉婷：喂。                                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：吃飯了。                                                                    │
│                                                                │王：你們吃了嗎                                                                  │
│                                                                │戴：你吃了沒。                                                                  │
│                                                                │王：還沒。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：喔，等一下和『長仔』（指戊○○）他們吃，吃飯。                              │
│                                                                │王：要哪裡吃飯。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：他們那邊客人很多嗎。                                                        │
│                                                                │王：不知道，還沒下去看。要來這裡吃嗎。                                          │
│                                                                │戴：過去那裡吃比較好，這裡也沒有什麼地方好吃。                                  │
│                                                                │王：也是要下去看。                                                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│2.   2007/10/04  12:21:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"台中縣和平鄉○○路0段○○○巷00號1樓室外"                                      │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         谷關飯店劉副總│谷關飯店劉副總：喂，戴董，戴董。                                                │
│                                                                │戴：嗯，副總。                                                                  │
│                                                                │劉：你好，你好。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：今天會不會很忙。                                                            │
│                                                                │劉：我現在在鄉公所開會耶。                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：鄉公所開會喔。                                                              │
│                                                                │劉：我說不定下午會和鄉長上來附近。                                              │
│                                                                │戴：喔，你們要往那裡上去喔。                                                    │
│                                                                │劉：嗯嗯。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：我是說『長仔』（指戊○○）他們和你一起開會，和『丁仔』。                    │
│                                                                │劉：對對對，嗯嗯。                                                              │
│                                                                │戴：他們說要上來這裡，我是說過來『你那邊』（指谷關飯店）吃飯店。                │
│                                                                │劉：這樣喔，抱歉，抱歉，抱歉。                                                  │
│                                                                │戴：不要緊，現在就是說那邊，1點你那裡餐廳部不知道會不會太晚。                   │
│                                                                │劉：1點，不會啦，不會啦，我會電話回去，我會電話回去。                           │
│                                                                │戴：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │劉：我會電話回去，嗯。你再打給我。                                              │
│                                                                │戴：他們那裡差不多4、5個嘛，我們這裡，差不多6、7個，7個、8個這樣。              │
│                                                                │劉：7、8個喔，好好好好，這樣我來交代，我來交代。                                │
│                                                                │戴：我是說你餐廳部不知道那麼早收沒有。                                          │
│                                                                │劉：這樣我來把你交代好嗎。                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：好呀，好呀，好。                                                            │
│                                                                │劉：謝謝，嗯。                                                                  │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│3.   2007/10/04  12:23:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中縣和平鄉○○路○段○○○巷0000號"                                          │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         谷關飯店劉副總│谷關飯店劉副總：喂，你好，我谷關飯店劉副總。                                    │
│                                                                │廉：我川順啦，『我們董仔』（指戴沼澤）剛才跟你說了。                            │
│                                                                │劉：哪裡，哪位，哪位。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：川順，川順營造。                                                            │
│                                                                │劉：喔喔。                                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：我們董仔剛才跟你講，是是。                                                  │
│                                                                │劉：抱歉，抱歉，我剛才在開會。                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：不要緊，不要緊。                                                            │
│                                                                │劉：…抱歉，抱歉，抱歉。                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：等一下要過去。                                                              │
│                                                                │劉：這樣喔，好，好，謝謝，謝謝。                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│4.   2007/10/04  12:33:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中縣和平鄉○○路○段○○○巷0000號"                                          │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         所長丁振章    │（川順營造戴沼澤持用戊○○手機與行政院農業委員會水土保持局第二工程所所長丁振章通│
│                                                                │聯）                                                                            │
│                                                                │戴：所長。                                                                      │
│                                                                │丁：戴董。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：這麼久沒看到你，你一定要回去，我訂桌好了。                                  │
│                                                                │丁：…辦公室現在有人來找我，要我趕回去，我已經到東勢…                          │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│5.   2007/10/04  12:37:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中縣和平鄉○○村○○段00地號"                                                │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │…                                                                              │
│                                                                │女友陳玉瑛：很吵喔，你在吃飯喔。                                                │
│                                                                │許：對呀，剛進來餐廳…「戴董」（指川順營造戴沼澤）說叫你上來啦，「戴董」叫你坐計│
│                                                                │程車上來。                                                                      │
│                                                                │陳：你跟他們喔。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：對呀，在工地呀，在谷關呀…                                                  │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│6.   2007/10/04  13:06:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中縣和平鄉○○村○○段00地號"                                                │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │女友陳玉瑛：我先出去，我們再電話聯絡。                                          │
│                                                                │許：好。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│7.   2007/10/04  13:15:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中縣和平鄉○○村○○段00地號"                                                │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │女友陳玉瑛：我跟你講喔。                                                        │
│                                                                │許：怎麼。                                                                      │
│                                                                │陳：我跟你講喔，你不要講話喔。                                                  │
│                                                                │許：嗯嗯。                                                                      │
│                                                                │陳：我那個，我2點半就在「阿九」（「九龍理容KTV」）了喔。                        │
│                                                                │許：喔，2點就要過去了喔。                                                       │
│                                                                │陳：2點半啦，我跟你講我真的吃太飽了，我要減肥。                                 │
│                                                                │許：不會太早嗎。                                                                │
│                                                                │陳：不會呀。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：但是我沒那麼早下去啦。                                                      │
│                                                                │陳：不要緊，我就等你就對了。                                                    │
│                                                                │許：好啦，好啦，好啦。                                                          │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│8.   2007/10/04  15:19:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中縣新社鄉○○○段○○○○○段地號361之10"                                   │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │許：還沒醉喔。                                                                  │
│                                                                │女友陳玉瑛：還沒。                                                              │
│                                                                │許：我要過去，還是。                                                            │
│                                                                │陳：當然。                                                                      │
│                                                                │許：我還在路上。                                                                │
│                                                                │陳：等你。                                                                      │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│9.   2007/10/04  15:29:00 0000000000       撥     0000000000    │"臺中縣和平鄉○○路○段○○○巷0000號"                                          │
│                          川順營造廉裕隆         九龍理KTV張淑惠│廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張淑惠：酒醉了對不對。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：我。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：我剛睡起來，我哪會。                                                        │
│                                                                │張：你剛睡起來。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │張：你怎麼又騙人。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：我剛睡起來，看到，剛要打電話，看到簡訊。                                    │
│                                                                │張：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：是嗎。                                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │張：不然別人跟我說你在喝酒。                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：哪一個。                                                                    │
│                                                                │張：「1號」（指戊○○女友陳玉瑛）呀，他1點多的時候打電話說你，說「長仔」（指局長│
│                                                                │戊○○）跟你在山上喝酒。                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：很可怕。                                                                    │
│                                                                │張：什麼很可怕，有沒有這件事情。                                                │
│                                                                │廉：有呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │張：1點出頭，我說啊，說我不知道耶。                                             │
│                                                                │廉：好可怕喔，竟然這樣被你們翻出來，被你們翻出來，通報這樣就。                  │
│                                                                │張：沒有，好，那就這樣，剛到呀，「他」（指陳玉瑛）1點多的時候說他3點會到呀。    │
│                                                                │廉：通報好了，到了嗎。                                                          │
│                                                                │張：剛到，還沒進去。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：剛到。                                                                      │
│                                                                │張：因為他嗆要把我灌醉，我不要進去，他帶1個女孩來，叫4個女孩。                  │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：現在裡面6個女孩就對了。                                                     │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：我哪知。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：好啦，好啦。                                                                │
│                                                                │張：你呢，你現在人在哪裡。                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：我還在山上，可能等一下下去吧。                                              │
│                                                                │張：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：你沒有酒醉。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：沒有啦，喝2杯而已啦，醉。                                                   │
│                                                                │張：那你還給我騙說你沒有，消息那麼不靈通耶。                                    │
│                                                                │廉：好啦，好啦，很可怕。                                                        │
│                                                                │張：是喔，上次我還在香港，我就接到電話，你還在我們公司喝酒了，我過去香港，剛開機│
│                                                                │而已，就接到你在我們公司喝酒的事情，你看。                                      │
│                                                                │廉：好啦，好啦。                                                                │
│                                                                │張：BYEBYE，我好痛喔，我的背好痛，肩膀又受傷。                                  │
│                                                                │廉：我早上要看你，要跟你抹藥你就不要。                                          │
│                                                                │張：那時候還不知道哪裡痛呀。                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：…筋骨啦，以後可能還好啦，就是筋骨，好像拉傷的感覺。                        │
│                                                                │張：你等一下就要下來了喔。                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │張：嗯，那你會跑來嗎。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：不曉得。                                                                    │
│                                                                │張：唉唷，不要進去好了，很可怕。                                                │
│                                                                │廉：很可怕。                                                                    │
│                                                                │張：還想騙我，好啦，好啦，好，BYE。                                             │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│10.  2007/10/04  15:41:00  0000000000      撥    0000000000     │"中華電信未提供"                                                                │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆        水利署科長林榮 │廉：科長                                                                        │
│                           水哥（三河局吳水城）  紹             │林榮紹：嗯。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：你稍等喔，「水哥」。                                                        │
│                                                                │（廉裕隆將電話交予某綽號「水哥」男子）                                          │
│                                                                │水哥：科長呀，你在忙呀。                                                        │
│                                                                │林：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │水哥：你何時有空呀。                                                            │
│                                                                │林：怎樣。                                                                      │
│                                                                │水哥：我們在「1+8」（指九龍理容KTV）。                                          │
│                                                                │林：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │水哥：我們先過去了。                                                            │
│                                                                │林：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │水哥：「你的兄弟」（指水利署及第三河川局人員）都在那裡。                        │
│                                                                │林：好好好。                                                                    │
│                                                                │水哥：好啦…                                                                    │
│                                                                │（「水哥」將電話交還?裕隆）                                                     │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：現在要「下去」（指?裕隆等人正要從谷關工地起程往台中市九龍理容KTV）。        │
│                                                                │林：喔。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│11.  2007/10/04  16:29:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │許：幾號房。                                                                    │
│                                                                │陳玉瑛：我叫人去帶你。                                                          │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│12.  2007/10/04  16:36:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           局長戊○○             川順營造戴沼澤│（戴沼澤持用王莉婷電話與戊○○通聯）                                            │
│                                                                │戴：現在在哪裡？                                                                │
│                                                                │許：在「阿九」（指「九龍理容KTV」）。                                           │
│                                                                │戴：好。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│13.  2007/10/04  17:30:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         水利署科長林榮│（廉裕隆背景有KTV音樂）                                                         │
│                                                  紹            │林榮紹：隆呀，我沒空喔。                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：好。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│14.  2007/10/04  17:39:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶林秀春    │許：晚一點回去。                                                                │
│                                                                │妻：早一點回來。                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│15.  2007/10/04  17:45:00  0000000000      接      0000000000   │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆          廉裕隆妻     │（?裕隆背景有女侍嘻?聲）                                                        │
│                                                                │妻：你下山嗎。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：下山了，喝酒。                                                              │
│                                                                │妻：這樣我不等你了。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │妻：這樣我不等你。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：等我怎麼。                                                                  │
│                                                                │妻：等你吃飯呀。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：喔，吃飯不用啦。                                                            │
│                                                                │妻：吃飯不用。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：對。                                                                        │
│                                                                │妻：你在吃飯就對了。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：沒有啦，我沒有在吃飯啦，我說吃飯不用等我啦。                                │
│                                                                │妻：吃飯不用等你。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：對。                                                                        │
│                                                                │妻：你有要回來吃嗎。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：沒有啦。                                                                    │
│                                                                │妻：好啦。                                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │妻：啊你，你又要去天祥街睡了嗎。                                                │
│                                                                │廉：沒有啦，不知道啦，還沒有啦，應該不會啦。                                    │
│                                                                │妻：不知道。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：不會啦，不會啦，晚點而已。                                                  │
│                                                                │妻：怎麼。                                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：晚點而已。                                                                  │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│16.  2007/10/04  17:55:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○             上立汽車某男  │「上立汽車」（音譯）與戊○○聯繫汽車保養                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│17.  2007/10/04  18:40:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂                                                │
│                           局長戊○○                           │短訊：二手假睫毛拍賣, 戴上後能預知前世今生你敢用嗎? 按回覆鍵後輸入ＰＡ傳送, 挑戰│
│                                                                │陰森顫慄忌諱每則１０元,包準讓伀                                                 │
└────────────────────────────────┴────────────────────────────────────────┘

┌────────────────────────────────┬────────────────────────────────────────┐
│編號 日期        時間      監聽電話       撥/接   對方電話      │通聯內容摘要                                                                備註│
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│1.   2007/10/05  09:11:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○區○○街00號6樓頂"                                                     │
│                           局長戊○○             女友戴美玲    │女友戴美玲向戊○○要2萬元說要給「阿媽」，戊○○表示不要用匯的，將會親自交給她。 │
│                                                                │女友有小孩。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│2.   2007/10/05  12:00:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○區○○街00號6樓頂"                                                     │
│                           局長戊○○                           │女友表示要1點多才有空                                                           │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│3.   2007/10/05  13:11:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○區○○街00號6樓頂"                                                     │
│                           局長戊○○            「佳佳」       │戊○○與「佳佳」約在公司旁邊等                                                  │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│4.   2007/10/05  14:59:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號14F頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○             水利署周世傑  │找戊○○喝酒，共約12人。                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│5.   2007/10/05  15:42:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號14F頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○             水利署周世傑  │水利署河川勘測隊周世傑表示總幹事去台東打球，帶6個女孩，周表示要與某人過去       │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│6.   2007/10/05  16:24:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號6F頂"                                               │
│                           局長戊○○                           │戊○○使用車輛車號00-0000                                                       │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│7. 2007/10/05    16:27:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                           局長戊○○             「佳佳」      │理容KTV女子佳佳：那個香水味很濃，你回去先洗澡。                                 │
│                                                                │許：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │女：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：喔，好。                                                                    │
│                                                                │女：好，好。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│8.   2007/10/05  16:29:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號6F頂"                                               │
│                           局長戊○○             女友戴美玲    │許：喂，有起床嗎。                                                              │
│                                                                │戴：…。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：還在床上喔。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：現在幾點了。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：現在4點多，快5點了。                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：快5點，那我要起來了。                                                       │
│                                                                │許：要起來嘛。                                                                  │
│                                                                │戴：要，要起來，…，我看了快氣死了，輸人家一堆，浪費時間。                      │
│                                                                │許：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：啊，你有要過來我家吃飯嗎。                                                  │
│                                                                │許：要限時專送嗎。                                                              │
│                                                                │戴：什麼叫限時專送。                                                            │
│                                                                │許：就要跟你送東西過去。                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：不用，不用，等一下，稍等，我問阿嬤看有沒有買菜，稍等，等一下喔…。喂，阿嬤說│
│                                                                │他現在去買，他買菜很快。                                                        │
│                                                                │許：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：他買菜很快，我起來洗澡吹頭髮，約1小時，阿嬤去買菜。                         │
│                                                                │許：還要1小時喔。                                                               │
│                                                                │戴：差不多吧。                                                                  │
│                                                                │許：我過去，我過去不要那麼久吧。                                                │
│                                                                │戴：你過去不用那麼久，那。                                                      │
│                                                                │許：你是。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：我去洗澡，我還去吹頭髮一下。                                                │
│                                                                │許：喔，還要到外面吹喔。                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：對，在家裡旁邊而已。                                                        │
│                                                                │許：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：我吹頭髮很快，洗澡差不多40分鐘。                                            │
│                                                                │許：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：好吧。                                                                      │
│                                                                │許：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：最快最快也要40分鐘。                                                        │
│                                                                │許：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：好不好。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：阿嬤去買菜了，下去，那等我，那我弄弄我等你。                                │
│                                                                │許：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：你在樓下等我一下，因為我去吹頭髮很快。                                      │
│                                                                │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：好嗎。                                                                      │
│                                                                │許：這樣喔，好。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：好，BYEBYE。                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│9. 2007/10/05 17:07:00     0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段00號5F頂"                                                │
│                           局長戊○○             女友戴美玲    │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴美玲：喂，我好了耶，你到哪裡。                                                │
│                                                                │許：我在找位置停車。                                                            │
│                                                                │戴：你在找位置，那我在我們家樓下等你。                                          │
│                                                                │許：OK。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：好，BYEBYE。                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│10.  2007/10/05  17:21:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段00號5F頂"                                                │
│                           局長戊○○             水利署周世傑  │水利署河川勘測隊周世傑要戊○○有空過來                                          │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│11.  2007/10/05  18:16:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號4F"                                                 │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶林秀春    │戊○○向妻表示晚點回去                                                          │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│12.  2007/10/05  19:58:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶林秀春    │戊○○向妻子表示沒有辦法去接小孩，在忙                                          │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│13.  2007/10/05  16:38:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段0000號8F頂"                                        │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造戴沼澤│戴沼澤要?裕隆購買魚飼料                                                         │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│14.  2007/10/05  19:05:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路0000號8F頂"                                                  │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆          某女         │廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │某女：你還在台中。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：開車。                                                                      │
│                                                                │女：開車喔。                                                                    │
│                                                                │…（談論與該女婚外情、昨（4）日發生性行為情形）                                 │
│                                                                │女：風很大，早點回去。                                                          │
│                                                                │…                                                                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│15.  2007/10/05  18:04:00  0000000000     接      0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○路○段000巷00號16F屋頂"                                        │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         水利署科長林榮│戴：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                  紹            │林榮紹：喂，谷關，LONG STAY。                                                   │
│                                                                │戴：LONG STAY，沒有，回來台，回來在『天祥街』（指川順公司旱溪天祥街招待所）。   │
│                                                                │林：打麻將喔。                                                                  │
│                                                                │戴：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：明天水都把你流掉了，哈。                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：對呀，都流掉。                                                              │
│                                                                │林：這次大粒的喔。                                                              │
│                                                                │戴：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：很大。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：現在在哪裡，回來到哪裡了。                                                  │
│                                                                │林：回家，回來在路上了。                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：還沒到家喔。                                                                │
│                                                                │林：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：很大，很大。                                                                │
│                                                                │林：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：很大，雨。                                                                  │
│                                                                │林：很大，要注意，好啦。                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：謝謝啦。                                                                    │
│                                                                │林：好啦，好。                                                                  │
└────────────────────────────────┴────────────────────────────────────────┘

┌────────────────────────────────┬────────────────────────────────────────┐
│編號 日期        時間      監聽電話       撥/接   對方電話      │通聯內容摘要                                                                備註│
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│1.   2007/10/08  17:28:00  0000000000     接      0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆        麗登理容KTV文華│廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                 (本名李幼綢)   │麗登理容KTV幹部文華：喂，隆哥喔。                                               │
│                                                                │廉：你是誰。                                                                    │
│                                                                │文華：我文華。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：喔，店長。                                                                  │
│                                                                │文華：我不是店長了，那個誰，那個誰，那個「周大哥」（指周世傑）跟那個那個「葉大哥│
│                                                                │」（指壬○○）在這裡，他說要請你過來。                                          │
│                                                                │廉：我不在台中耶。                                                              │
│                                                                │文華：是喔。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │文華：那怎麼辦，剛剛「林榮紹」有，「林大哥」（指林榮紹）有交待呀。              │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │文華：對呀。那是要怎麼處理，還是。                                              │
│                                                                │廉：我就人不在台中。                                                            │
│                                                                │文華：這樣子喔。。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │文華：那就讓他們自己處理了喔。                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：對呀，我就往谷關，在谷關。                                                  │
│                                                                │文華：對呀，就讓他們自己處理，就這樣喔。                                        │
│                                                                │廉：好啦，好啦。                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│2.   2008/03/10  15:25:00  0000000000     接      0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆        麗登理容KTV文華│廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                 (本名李幼綢)   │文華：喂，阿隆喔。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │女：我「文華」啦。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │女：嗯，不好意思喔，最近好不好。                                                │
│                                                                │廉：喔，也是這樣，嗯，                                                          │
│                                                                │女：那個「周」，「周科長」（指水利署河川勘測隊周世傑）有沒有打電話跟你說。      │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │女：那個，那筆帳的事。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：他們那個是怎麼呀。                                                          │
│                                                                │女：啊，沒有呀，他叫我說把那個帳寄過去給你。                                    │
│                                                                │廉：嗯，啊，那到底當初。                                                        │
│                                                                │女：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │女：當初怎樣。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：沒有呀，我也不知道你們那到底是，帳到底是怎樣。                              │
│                                                                │女：他就是跟，他跟那個，「葉科長」跟「周科長」一起來的嘛。                      │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │女：本來就是他們要來付這筆帳嘛，然後，但是「周科長」叫我說已經跟你講好了，說他要│
│                                                                │去，他，你說可以寄過去了，一直叫我說寄過去，所以我才寄過去。                    │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │女：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：你寄了嗎。                                                                  │
│                                                                │女：我，會計說寄過去了。                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：多少。                                                                      │
│                                                                │女：那個帳我看一下，等一下，喂，1萬4千350，10月8號的。                          │
│                                                                │廉：他們這個當初是怎麼。                                                        │
│                                                                │女：當初他們就喝喝，他們就走掉呀，這樣子呀，因為喔，「葉科長」他以前來喝他都是付│
│                                                                │錢的，然後「周科長」他來喝也付錢，這樣子呀，然後後來我就叫他們，因為，因為很久帳│
│                                                                │喔，我叫他們來回，到最後「周科長」叫我說，叫我寄過去給你。                      │
│                                                                │廉：沒有啦，他也搞不清楚這到底是，沒有啦，這個，因為有時候喔，你們在，你們在轉述│
│                                                                │喔，變成會走掉你們知道嗎，我現在是說你們當初是怎樣發生的，他也搞不清楚你知道嗎。│
│                                                                │女：2個人醉醉的就進來喔。                                                       │
│                                                                │廉：沒有呀，你不能這樣講呀。                                                    │
│                                                                │女：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：那是你要去收的你知道嗎。                                                    │
│                                                                │女：我知道啦。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：是不是這樣。                                                                │
│                                                                │女：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │女：「周科長」還很清醒呀，那個時候。                                            │
│                                                                │廉：沒有呀，喔，這變成說像這種，不然他這筆帳是2個都還，搞到現在還搞不清楚耶。   │
│                                                                │女：他們2個為什麼搞不清楚，「周科長」他本來就是2個人一起進來的，「周科長」。    │
│                                                                │廉：1個說有，1個說沒有。                                                        │
│                                                                │女：「周科長」說他一直，他就是說，他說是「葉科長」先進來然後他才進來的，其實那1 │
│                                                                │天他們2個一起進來的，所以不簽名的話就變成這樣，要簽名。                         │
│                                                                │廉：對呀，那是你處理的方式呀，沒有呀，那是你處理的方式呀，對否，喔。            │
│                                                                │女：因為大家都老朋友，那麼相信他。                                              │
│                                                                │廉：沒有，那是你的事情呀，喔，是說那麼久了，他就有在講，我也是要跟「我們董仔」（│
│                                                                │指戴沼澤）報告一下啦。                                                          │
│                                                                │女：好啦。                                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │女：那你報告一下，看怎樣。                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：不然這麼久的事情，我怎麼，他們2個，1個。                                    │
│                                                                │女：如果說。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：他們2個啦。                                                                 │
│                                                                │女：沒有。                                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：他1個若說沒有，沒有，沒有這1筆呀。                                          │
│                                                                │女：有啦，確實有啦，我跟你講喔。                                                │
│                                                                │廉：啊，有沒有，我沒有記。                                                      │
│                                                                │女：如果說，如果說他們。                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：因為他們一開始說很久的啦，一開始他在講的意思說問我看有沒有去，我說沒有呀，我│
│                                                                │多少沒有走到你那裡去了。                                                        │
│                                                                │女：嗯嗯嗯嗯。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │女：他們來，應該是那個啦，「葉科長」，「葉科長」，我實在喔，你如果說喔。        │
│                                                                │廉：沒有啦，是說這應該你們自己處理。                                            │
│                                                                │女：如果說不接受，如果這1筆帳不處理，你可以寄回來，我一定會找他們處理這筆帳。   │
│                                                                │廉：沒有啦，因為說這種事情你們日後自己處理好啦，喔。                            │
│                                                                │女：好啦。                                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：算說沒有，沒有的話你們也，沒有，這我跟我…報告一下，是說沒有的話，你隔天，隔│
│                                                                │天，隔1、2天，大家你也是要會一下。                                              │
│                                                                │女：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：不然你隔那麼久。                                                            │
│                                                                │女：我都有跟他們，跟他們講呀，我有跟他們講呀，對呀，就這樣喔，這樣他們這個。    │
│                                                                │廉：好啦，我收到再看看好嗎。                                                    │
│                                                                │女：好，謝謝你喔。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：喔，看怎麼再聯絡好嗎，好。                                                  │
│                                                                │女：好，BYEBYE。                                                                │
└────────────────────────────────┴────────────────────────────────────────┘

┌────────────────────────────────┬────────────────────────────────────────┐
│編號 日期        時間      監聽電話       撥/接   對方電話      │通聯內容摘要                                                                備註│
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│1.   2007/10/11  08:24:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中縣和平鄉○○村○○路○段號14"                                              │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆        川順營造鄭年雅 │鄭年雅：喂。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │鄭：你在山上喔。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │鄭：喔，說那個錢要怎麼給你呀。                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：喔，遇到再拿啦。                                                            │
│                                                                │鄭：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │鄭：啊，你昨天住在那裡喔。                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：我。                                                                        │
│                                                                │鄭：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：沒有呀。                                                                    │
│                                                                │鄭：你那麼早就到了喔。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：對呀，快到了，在路上了。                                                    │
│                                                                │鄭：喔喔喔，好，好，BYE。                                                       │
│                                                                │廉：好，BYE。                                                                   │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│2.   2007/10/11  15:08:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○路○段00000號4F頂"                                           │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │許：喂！                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：我向你請假好不好！我想等一下就去找房子。                                    │
│                                                                │許：什麼？                                                                      │
│                                                                │陳：我今天就要去找房子了，我等一下要叫我弟弟來載我，我等一下就要去找房子。      │
│                                                                │許：不要啦！你不要不火氣那麼大。                                                │
│                                                                │陳：我不是火氣那麼大，我的個性，是想要趕快把事情作一作。要房子要租人就去租人。  │
│                                                                │許：嗯！                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：我等一下就去看房子，好不好！                                                │
│                                                                │許：改天我在忙時，你自已再去找。明天你就可以去找了。                            │
│                                                                │陳：好！好！我馬上到！                                                          │
│                                                                │許：你真是很火性。                                                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│3.   2007/10/11  16:03:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○街000巷00弄0號10F頂"                                           │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │戊○○：喂！                                                                    │
│                                                                │陳：喂！                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：那有洗個澡，洗1個小時20分鐘。                                               │
│                                                                │陳：我早就準備好了！正在等你電話。                                              │
│                                                                │許：拜託，我已在樓下等你，你還在等我回電話。                                    │
│                                                                │陳：這不是我的錯，是你的錯，這不能怪我，不甘我的事，我現在下去了。（指下樓見面）│
│                                                                │許：好！                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│4.   2007/10/11  20:11:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶林秀春    │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │妻：…。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：怎麼樣，在路中了，好啦。                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│5.   2007/10/12 12:14:00   0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○區○○街00號6樓頂"                                                     │
│                           局長戊○○             九龍理容KTV   │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                  徐玉玲        │徐：大哥。                                                                      │
│                                                                │許：嗯嗯。                                                                      │
│                                                                │徐：昨天「阿瑛」說要再把他朋友「補3小時」啦。                                   │
│                                                                │許：什麼人呀，什麼人。                                                          │
│                                                                │徐：「阿瑛」啦。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │徐：說要再把他朋友「補3小時」啦，要嗎。                                         │
│                                                                │許：呵呵呵呵呵，呵呵，好啦，好啦。                                              │
│                                                                │徐：好，BYE。                                                                   │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│6.   2007/10/11  16:14:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中縣和平鄉○○村○○路○段號14"                                              │
│                           川順廉裕隆             某男          │某樹木廠商與廉裕隆聯繫樹木已扶正                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│7.   2007/10/11  16:31:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中縣和平鄉○○村○○路○段號14"                                              │
│                           川順廉裕隆             某男          │某男表示戴沼澤女友王莉婷於天祥街打牌                                            │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│8.   2007/10/11  18:18:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號7F頂"                                               │
│                           川順廉裕隆                           │妻問是否要回來吃飯                                                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│9.   2007/10/11  17:04:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"台中縣新社鄉○○○段○○○○段000地號1/3"                                      │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤                       │您有未接來電:                                                                   │
│                                                                │10/09 03:06PM來自0000000000 (0通)                                               │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│10.  2007/10/11  17:59:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○路○段000巷00號16F屋頂1/3"                                     │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤                       │您有未接來電:                                                                   │
│                                                                │10/09 03:06PM來自0000000000 (0通)                                               │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│11.  2007/10/11  19:07:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○路○段000巷00號16F屋頂1/3"                                     │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤                       │您有未接來電:                                                                   │
│                                                                │10/09 03:06PM來自0000000000 (0通)                                               │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│12.  2007/10/11  20:37:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○路○段000巷00號16F屋頂1/3"                                     │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤                       │您有未接來電:                                                                   │
│                                                                │10/09 03:06PM來自0000000000 (0通)                                               │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│13.  2007/10/11  21:04:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○路○段000巷00號16F屋頂1/3"                                     │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤                       │您有未接來電:                                                                   │
│                                                                │10/09 03:06PM來自0000000000 (0通)                                               │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│14.  2007/10/11  21:21:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○路○段000巷00號16F屋頂1/3"                                     │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤                       │您有未接來電:                                                                   │
│                                                                │10/09 03:06PM來自0000000000 (0通)                                               │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│15.  2007/10/11  21:42:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"台中市○區○○路000號12樓頂1/3"                                                │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤                       │您有未接來電:                                                                   │
│                                                                │10/09 03:06PM來自0000000000 (0通)                                               │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│16.  2007/10/11  21:46:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"台中市○區○○○00鄰○○街000號12樓頂及屋凸"                                   │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤        金拿獎視聽歌唱 │與金拿獎視聽歌唱坊綽號「阿華」陳秀月約在五權西路忠明南路口                      │
│                                                 坊陳秀月       │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│17.  2007/10/11  23:28:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○○○○路00號"                                                  │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         某女          │戴沼澤回家                                                                      │
└────────────────────────────────┴────────────────────────────────────────┘

┌────────────────────────────────┬────────────────────────────────────────┐
│編號 日期        時間      監聽電話       撥/接   對方電話      │通聯內容摘要                                                                備註│
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│1.   2007/10/17  09:40:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造戴沼澤│戴：「辛○○」你要不要跟他問一下？                                              │
│                                                                │廉：「老鍾」問啦，先給「老鍾」問啦。                                            │
│                                                                │戴：不要緊呀，我們問也不要緊呀。                                                │
│                                                                │廉：好呀，好呀，這樣我打電話問一下。                                            │
│                                                                │戴：本來我今天打算叫「辛○○」和「阿茂」（指水利署河川海岸組張政茂）他們出來吃飯│
│                                                                │，就說「長仔」（指局長戊○○）今天做生日。                                      │
│                                                                │廉：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：所以「老哥」（指水利署工程事務組第四科科長林榮紹）在那裡就沒有，他要參加他們│
│                                                                │那個。                                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：好呀，這樣我打電話跟他問一下。                                              │
│                                                                │戴：不要緊啦，你說上回那個預算…，他以前是跟我說出去了，有沒有再回來。          │
│                                                                │廉：好。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│2.   2007/10/17  12:15:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號10樓"                                               │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶林秀春    │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │妻：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：有要過來嗎。                                                                │
│                                                                │妻：我吃飽了。                                                                  │
│                                                                │許：看你呀，看你呀                                                              │
│                                                                │妻：有女生嗎。                                                                  │
│                                                                │許：我不知道呀，應該『秀美』（音譯）他們有來。                                  │
│                                                                │妻：看看，我不要去了，不然我晚上和孩子我又很想睡。                              │
│                                                                │許：隨便你，隨便你。                                                            │
│                                                                │妻：不要，我不要去。                                                            │
│                                                                │許：好，好。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│3.   2007/10/17  12:20:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │台中市○○區○○00街000號13F屋頂                                                │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤                       │您有未接來電:                                                                   │
│                                                                │10/16 08:13AM來自0000000000 (0通)                                               │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│4.   2007/10/17  12:51:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │臺中市○○區○○路○段000號14F頂                                                │
│                           局長戊○○                           │短訊：１０∕１８前中華電信手機撥７６０１５按２回覆簡訊下載蔡健雅－當你離開的時候│
│                                                                │答鈴,即可憑系統回覆的簡訊,參加蔡健雅發片演唱會,詳ｅｍ        臿    袖    進  觿 │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│5.   2007/10/17  13:27:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │台中市○○區○○00街000號13F屋頂                                                │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤                       │您有未接來電:                                                                   │
│                                                                │10/16 08:13AM來自0000000000 (0通)                                               │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│6.   2007/10/17  14:00:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │臺中市○○區○○路○段000號14F頂                                                │
│                           局長戊○○                           │短訊：祝局長生日快樂排水暨防洪指揮中心及八百儀                                  │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│7.   2007/10/17  14:03:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號14F頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │女友陳玉瑛問戊○○可不可以和朋友去「泡茶」，戊○○答可以。                      │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│8.   2007/10/17  14:44:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號14F頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○             第三河川局司機│司機：喂喂。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：你現在在哪裡。                                                              │
│                                                                │司機：要到了，要到了。                                                          │
│                                                                │許：OK，OK，OK，好。                                                            │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│9.   2007/10/17  14:58:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○00街000號13F屋頂"                                              │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         女友王莉婷    │王莉婷：在哪裡。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：來載我，我在。                                                              │
│                                                                │王：哪裡。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：來載我呀。                                                                  │
│                                                                │王：『阿杜』（指阿杜餐廳）這裡呀。                                              │
│                                                                │戴：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │王：到門口了呀。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：好啦。                                                                      │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│10.  2007/10/17  15:08:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造張義忠│廉：「忠哥」（指川順營造張義忠）。                                              │
│                                                                │張：你有在「天祥街」嗎？                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：沒有，怎樣。                                                                │
│                                                                │張：我有寫信過去。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：怎樣。                                                                      │
│                                                                │張：「董仔」（指戴沼澤）說要那種的，斷面有沒有，明天要會勘要用的，涵管的我們預計│
│                                                                │變更那個。                                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：好了，都出來了。                                                            │
│                                                                │張：都出來了。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：都起來了嗎？                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：沒有啦，還沒有啦。                                                          │
│                                                                │張：不然你們回去再看呀。                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：好啦，好啦，若有進去（天祥街）再看，不然就明早進去，早一點進去再看，好嗎。  │
│                                                                │張：好。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│11.  2007/10/17  15:24:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         水利署辛○○  │…                                                                              │
│                                                                │水利署工程事務組第一科承辦人辛○○：那個早上問說，那個有2個嘛，一個是。         │
│                                                                │廉：那個變更設計跟災修的。                                                      │
│                                                                │黃：對對對，一個是說，是說調整斷面和限期修正原則那個，那個案子。                │
│                                                                │廉：是。                                                                        │
│                                                                │黃：那個案子他是，是，是河川局那邊函廠商的資料嘛，他沒有沒有直接報給我們呀，呀，│
│                                                                │我們這邊是副本對不對。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：正本。                                                                      │
│                                                                │黃：是正本喔。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │黃：我們這裡有一件是。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：因為那個籌措財源，籌措財源一定要，給「署」（指水利署）一定是正本嘛。        │
│                                                                │黃：籌措財源是正本，籌措財源那一件現在還在「總工程司室」。                      │
│                                                                │廉：喔那個，那個就變更設計3000多萬那個嘛。                                      │
│                                                                │黃：籌措財源是在「總工程司室」，那個另外一個是那個。                            │
│                                                                │廉：災損的。                                                                    │
│                                                                │黃：有災損的，災損的沒有看到，現在還有看到，是有一個報一個說要調整什麼「線形」（│
│                                                                │音譯）跟修正原則。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：嗯嗯，是。                                                                  │
│                                                                │黃：那個原則是我們這邊沒有啦，我們這邊只有副本而已，所以我們這邊也沒什麼意見。  │
│                                                                │廉：那現在給。                                                                  │
│                                                                │黃：現在你們還比較需要知道是哪一件，你說那個。                                  │
│                                                                │廉：嗯，就是那個…那個他們後來是「一起」啦，因為修正預算跟，跟災損，他們後來是把│
│                                                                │那個預算書一起，編在一起但是分，有分項。                                        │
│                                                                │黃：喔，我知道，那個還沒有報過來呀。                                            │
│                                                                │廉：對呀，但是他們就是第一次報的那個概算的原則，給署，報給大署，署還沒有下來，所│
│                                                                │以他們現在。                                                                    │
│                                                                │黃：概算的原則，那就是籌措財源那個嘛。                                          │
│                                                                │廉：對對對對。                                                                  │
│                                                                │黃：那個還沒有，那個還在簽辦當中。                                              │
│                                                                │廉：還在簽辦當中，還在總工程司。                                                │
│                                                                │黃：對，等那個總工程司批下來之後，我們才能夠辦理呀。                            │
│                                                                │廉：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │黃：應該這幾天啦。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：好好好，麻煩你喔，謝謝。                                                    │
│                                                                │黃：不會，不會…                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│12.  2007/10/17  15:37:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○             第五河川局副局│與第五河川局副局長通聯                                                          │
│                                                  長            │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│13.  2007/10/17  15:47:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           局長戊○○                           │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│14.  2007/10/17  15:59:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         第三河川局鍾彥│廉裕隆向第三河川局癸○○轉述水利署辛○○表示修正預算部分水利署仍在內簽，並表示黃│
│                                                  虎            │昌巨的電話為00000000。                                                          │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│15.  2007/10/17  16:32:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"台中市○區○○路000號12樓頂"                                                   │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         逢甲大學連惠邦│逢甲大學連惠邦：喂。                                                            │
│                                                                │戴：老師，你現在在哪裡。                                                        │
│                                                                │連：我現在在學校呀。                                                            │
│                                                                │戴：你要出來嗎。                                                                │
│                                                                │連：要去哪裡。                                                                  │
│                                                                │戴：「旱溪」（指川順公司旱溪天祥街招待所）、「旱溪大學」。                      │
│                                                                │連：要「旱溪大學」，我怕就死了我，我昨天受傷，受重傷回來，快不能走路這樣。      │
│                                                                │戴：對呀，你，…，你被打，對否。                                                │
│                                                                │連：被打的這樣，頭暈眼花這樣，我等一下喔，我等一下要回家處理一下事情，我現在等1 │
│                                                                │個，等我的助理影印1個資料給我，我等一下要回家處理一些事情這樣，我等一下過去「旱 │
│                                                                │溪大學」困難啦。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：我以為說昨天那個贏的那個又在「邱抖」（台語音譯，指囂張），你知道。          │
│                                                                │連：「邱抖」，喔，我不敢，這樣我不行，他那記憶那麼好，不行。                    │
│                                                                │戴：是最不會賭的，你不知道喔。                                                  │
│                                                                │連：對呀，我也是不會呀，不會，我現在。                                          │
│                                                                │戴：剛才叫1個…，不是這樣講啦，真的，這都手氣手氣啦。                           │
│                                                                │連：嗯，我知道啦，這我知道。我等一下，我等一下真的有事情，嗯，我等一下真的有事情│
│                                                                │，我不能過去。                                                                  │
│                                                                │戴：明天，明天下午好嗎。                                                        │
│                                                                │連：明天下午，明天下午喔，水利署要來跟我開工作會報，3點呀，要開工作會報，可能開 │
│                                                                │一開也要5點多了。                                                               │
│                                                                │戴：今天我醉了耶。                                                              │
│                                                                │連：我知道呀，我聽聽聲音也知道你醉了。                                          │
│                                                                │戴：今日，今日是「許董仔」（指戊○○），「許董仔」做生日。                      │
│                                                                │連：這樣，今天「許董仔」做生日。                                                │
│                                                                │戴：瞭解，對否。                                                                │
│                                                                │連：「許董仔」做生日，你，你只下午灌醉這樣，後面都沒有「處理」（指招待至理容KTV │
│                                                                │飲酒作樂）。                                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：我去給大家灌醉，我在灌醉別人我哪有辦法，對否。                              │
│                                                                │連：對啦，沒有啦，你「許董仔」後面你都沒有把他「處理」喔。                      │
│                                                                │戴：在「阿九他家」（指九龍酒店）在喝茶啦。                                      │
│                                                                │連：現在在「阿九他家」喝茶喔，現在。                                            │
│                                                                │戴：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │連：這樣喔，啊，你是要出來，要出來「相殺」（指打麻將）這樣。                    │
│                                                                │戴：對呀，你要嗎，學弟叫…。                                                    │
│                                                                │連：這樣我要來去，我也要去「阿九」（指九龍酒店）那裡喝酒呀。                    │
│                                                                │戴：沒有啦，原班人馬好嗎，我輸這個輸得很不甘願。                                │
│                                                                │連：很不甘願，你也沒有。                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：6000、9000、8000輸得快50場了啦。                                            │
│                                                                │連：哈哈哈，不是，我今天也不行。對呀，今天不行，今天我跟你講我等一下要回去家裡處│
│                                                                │理一下事情。                                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：…好啦。                                                                    │
│                                                                │連：學弟有辦法嗎，我學弟你打電話他有辦法嗎。                                    │
│                                                                │戴：我還沒打給他，我是說你若有辦法我再打你學弟呀。                              │
│                                                                │連：我學弟可能也沒辦法，我今日有聯絡他，他今天沒空，我也知道。                  │
│                                                                │戴：等一下就有空了，要嗎。                                                      │
│                                                                │連：我沒辦法，真的，我沒辦法。                                                  │
│                                                                │戴：好啦，沒辦法就好啦，改天啦喔。                                              │
│                                                                │連：好啦，改天啦，改天啦。                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：再說，再說啦，再研究啦。                                                    │
│                                                                │連：OK，好，BYEBYE。                                                            │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│16.  2007/10/17  16:40:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂                                                │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         九龍酒店張淑惠│短訊：不言                                                                      │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│17.  2007/10/17  16:48:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           局長戊○○                           │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│18.  2007/10/17  16:53:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造王莉婷│王莉婷：「隆哥」（指?裕隆），不要酒醉耶。                                       │
│                                                                │廉：沒有啦，怎麼會醉，我怎麼有可能醉。                                          │
│                                                                │王：說叫你不能酒醉喔。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：好啦。                                                                      │
│                                                                │王：「他」（指戴沼澤）說問看看，問看看「大胖子」有沒有酒醉。                    │
│                                                                │廉：沒有啦，還好啦，還好啦，平分秋色，還好。                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│19.  2007/10/17  16:55:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           局長戊○○             九龍酒店戴美玲│無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│20.  2007/10/17  17:10:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路0000號8F頂"                                                  │
│                           局長戊○○             九龍酒店戴美玲│許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │九龍酒店戴美玲：老大，你到底是17號生，還是18號生呀。                            │
│                                                                │許：我天天都是生日啦，怎麼。                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：我怎麼一直以為你是18號，你到底是今天還是明天呀。                            │
│                                                                │許：我怎麼曉得。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：我跟你講你現在在我們「公司」（指九龍酒店）對不對，那我打去跟那個。          │
│                                                                │許：沒有。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：哪是，姐姐打電話說你有喝酒了。                                              │
│                                                                │許：什麼。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：那我等一下，我打電話去跟那個客人講說我不要過去，我等一下弄一弄過去「公司」了│
│                                                                │。（指九龍酒店）                                                                │
│                                                                │許：我不曉得啦。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：好啦，我等一下進去了。                                                      │
│                                                                │許：我不曉得啦。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：好啦，老大生日快樂，親1個…（親嘴聲）。                                     │
│                                                                │許：…（親嘴聲）。                                                              │
│                                                                │戴：好，BYEBYE了。                                                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│21.  2007/10/17  17:11:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆                       │廉裕隆表示在喝酒                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│22.  2007/10/17  17:13:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路0000號8F頂"                                                  │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶林秀春    │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │妻：喂，怎麼。                                                                  │
│                                                                │許：晚一點回去。                                                                │
│                                                                │妻：為什麼。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：有事啦。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│23.  2007/10/17  17:38:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路0000號8F頂"                                                  │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         第三河川局彭壽│?：彭主任，你等一下。                                                           │
│                           局長戊○○             奇            │（?裕隆將電話交給第三河川局局長戊○○）                                         │
│                                                                │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │第三河川局彭壽奇：嗯。                                                          │
│                                                                │許：你們下午去哪裡爽快。                                                        │
│                                                                │彭：沒有啦，在家裡啦，回去家裡一下，就回來上班了。                              │
│                                                                │許：現在要來上班喔，對呀。                                                      │
│                                                                │彭：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：來呀，過來呀。                                                              │
│                                                                │彭：「九」（指九龍酒店）。                                                      │
│                                                                │許：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │彭：好好好好。                                                                  │
│                                                                │許：你徒弟要不要叫來。                                                          │
│                                                                │彭：好，我再邀他。                                                              │
│                                                                │許：要見習嗎，要給他見習嗎？                                                    │
│                                                                │彭：好好好，好好。                                                              │
│                                                                │許：好啦。                                                                      │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│24.  2007/10/17  17:45:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶林秀春    │與妻討論女兒配眼鏡                                                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│25.  2007/10/17  18:10:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆                       │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│26.  2007/10/17  18:15:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造戴沼澤│廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：還沒結束。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：還沒。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：你不要喝太多，明天你就直接到工地去，我叫「阿如」（音譯，戴沼澤女友王莉婷）載│
│                                                                │過去就好了。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：喔，好呀，好。                                                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│27.  2007/10/17  18:16:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         妻            │妻：你剛才怎麼沒接。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：可能沒聽到。                                                                │
│                                                                │妻：沒聽到，在睡喔。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：沒有啦，還在KTV喔。                                                         │
│                                                                │妻：你在茫了嗎？                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：喔，從（下午）3點多喝到現在。…                                             │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│28.  2007/10/17  19:10:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           局長戊○○                           │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│29.  2007/10/17  19:15:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶林秀春    │戊○○向妻表示會晚點回去                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│30.  2007/10/17  19:16:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶林秀春    │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│31.  2007/10/17  19:17:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶林秀春    │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│32.  2007/10/17  19:17:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶林秀春    │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│33.  2007/10/17  19:18:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶林秀春    │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│34.  2007/10/17  19:18:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶林秀春    │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│35.  2007/10/17  19:20:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶林秀春    │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│36.  2007/10/17  19:22:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶林秀春    │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│37.  2007/10/17  19:23:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶林秀春    │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│38.  2007/10/17  19:26:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○街00號5F頂"                                                │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶林秀春    │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│39.  2007/10/17  19:40:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           局長戊○○             第三河川局顏詒│無人接聽                                                                        │
│                                                  星            │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│40.  2007/10/17  19:43:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路0000號8F頂"                                                  │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶林秀春    │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│41.  2007/10/17  19:43:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶林秀春    │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│42.  2007/10/17  19:54:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶林秀春    │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│43.  2007/10/17  19:55:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶林秀春    │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│44.  2007/10/17  20:06:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○街00號5F頂"                                                │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶林秀春    │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│45.  2007/10/17  20:11:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           局長戊○○             第三河川局顏詒│無人接聽                                                                        │
│                                                  星            │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│46.  2007/10/17  20:18:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶林秀春    │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│47.  2007/10/17  20:21:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路0000號8F頂"                                                  │
│                           局長戊○○             第三河川局顏詒│無人接聽                                                                        │
│                                                  星            │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│48.  2007/10/17  21:14:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           局長戊○○             第三河川局顏詒│與第三河川局顏詒星通聯                                                          │
│                                                  星            │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│49.  2007/10/17  21:36:00  0000000000      接     000000000     │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           川順廉裕隆             九龍酒店張淑惠│張淑惠：你還在樓上嗎？                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：嗯，怎樣。                                                                  │
│                                                                │張：酒醉了喔。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：OK了，沒有喝了。                                                            │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│50.  2007/10/17  21:48:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○街00號5F頂"                                                │
│                           局長戊○○                           │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│51.  2007/10/17  21:49:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○街00號5F頂"                                                │
│                           局長戊○○                           │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│52.  2007/10/17  21:50:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○街00號5F頂"                                                │
│                           局長戊○○                           │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│53.  2007/10/17  21:53:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○街00號5F頂"                                                │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶林秀春    │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│54.  2007/10/17  21:53:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           川順廉裕隆                           │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│55.  2007/10/17  21:53:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           川順廉裕隆             妻            │妻：你還在「那裡」喔。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。…                                                                      │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│56.  2007/10/17  22:17:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○街00號5F頂"                                                │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶林秀春    │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│57.  2007/10/17  22:18:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○街00號5F頂"                                                │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶林秀春    │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│58.  2007/10/17  22:25:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○街00號5F頂"                                                │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶林秀春    │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│59.  2007/10/17  22:26:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○街00號5F頂"                                                │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶林秀春    │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│60.  2007/10/17  22:27:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○街00號5F頂"                                                │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶林秀春    │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│61.  2007/10/17  22:37:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○區○○街○段000○00號12F頂"                                            │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶林秀春    │戊○○向妻表示在開車了                                                          │
└────────────────────────────────┴────────────────────────────────────────┘

┌────────────────────────────────┬────────────────────────────────────────┐
│編號 日期        時間      監聽電話       撥/接   對方電話      │通聯內容摘要                                                                備註│
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│1.   2007/10/31  14:37:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號6F頂"                                               │
│                           局長戊○○             川順營造廉裕隆│許：你現在在「旱溪」）還是。                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：現在要過去，差不多要到了，再5分鐘就到了。                                   │
│                                                                │許：「老林仔」他們人過去了嗎。                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：我要過去，我不知道耶。                                                      │
│                                                                │許：喔。你現在在「旱溪」啦喔。                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：對。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│2.   2007/10/31  15:27:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           局長戊○○             水利署科長林榮│許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                  紹            │林：「老闆」（指戊○○）。                                                      │
│                                                                │許：老林，怎麼樣。                                                              │
│                                                                │林：我，你把我放在這裡，給我「亂亂游」（台語音譯）呀。                          │
│                                                                │許：是怎麼「亂亂游」，我等一下。                                                │
│                                                                │林：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │許：交代他們要給你弄好，什麼「亂亂游」。                                        │
│                                                                │林：我就弄不好。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：為什麼弄不好。                                                              │
│                                                                │林：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │許：什麼人在旁邊，你跟我講。                                                    │
│                                                                │林：你要來嗎，你要來嗎，你講1句，這樣而已。                                     │
│                                                                │許：我就不能來，我要來。                                                        │
│                                                                │林：「two sister」、「two sister」，嗯。                                        │
│                                                                │許：我知道，我知道，我知道，嗯。                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│3.   2007/10/31  15:36:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           局長戊○○             酒家女「佳佳」│理容KTV女子「佳佳」表示在忙                                                     │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│4.   2007/10/31  16:15:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○路○段000巷00號16F屋頂"                                        │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         水利署科長林榮│林：喂，你好。                                                                  │
│                                                  紹            │戴：「摩西摩西」（音譯）                                                        │
│                                                                │林：「摩西摩西」，我要回去，我上班的地方。                                      │
│                                                                │戴：現在喔。                                                                    │
│                                                                │林：嗯嗯嗯，對。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：你離開了嗎。                                                                │
│                                                                │林：嗯，我離開了。                                                              │
│                                                                │戴：3隻龜2隻鱉，趕快弄一弄。                                                    │
│                                                                │林：有什麼問題嘛，你說啊。                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：「阿九」呀。                                                                │
│                                                                │林：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：叫他，他們（指戊○○）要去「九仔他家」啦。                                  │
│                                                                │林：叫他別這樣啦，在那裡就好了啦，常常去那裡。                                  │
│                                                                │戴：好啦，好啦。                                                                │
│                                                                │林：他現在在那裡嗎。                                                            │
│                                                                │戴：對啊。                                                                      │
│                                                                │林：我是要去哪，你說啊。                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：你就彎回來就好了啊，他們那邊結束了吧。                                      │
│                                                                │林：我轉回來，是要轉回去哪裡，你跟我講一下。                                    │
│                                                                │戴：「阿九」那裡啊，你車子你若是會開，就開來天祥街，載你去這樣比較好啦。        │
│                                                                │林：沒有啦，我現在開得多勇。                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：現在像牛一樣，不需要回去就不要回去，就往這裡來就好了。                      │
│                                                                │林：沒有啦，我要回去處理一下。                                                  │
│                                                                │戴：好啦，好啦，快點，快點。                                                    │
│                                                                │林：喔。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│5.   2007/10/31  16:33:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           局長戊○○                           │同事表示行政院中部辦公室「廖永來」要戊○○回電，告知電話                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│6.   2007/10/31  16:36:00  0000000000      撥     00000000000   │"臺中市○○區○○○路○段00號7F頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○                           │行政院中部辦公室執行長「廖永來」表示看到新閒很無奈，並表示某人表示戊○○係好朋友│
│                                                                │。                                                                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│7.   2007/10/31  16:54:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳玉瑛：喂，在忙喔。                                                            │
│                                                                │許：好忙喔，『經濟不好要趕快拚一拚』啦。                                        │
│                                                                │陳：我都沒講話，電話馬上打給你，就知道你在那裡哭夭了。                          │
│                                                                │許：啊，就快沒飯吃了。                                                          │
│                                                                │陳：沒關係，我餵你。                                                            │
│                                                                │許：喔，這樣喔。                                                                │
│                                                                │陳：我昨天還故意騎那個車子去買那個生蠔。                                        │
│                                                                │許：不用這樣那麼周到啦。                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：不過我跟你講喔，…，他們這個沒有放防腐劑，他說吃完再買，不然不要把他放著，1 │
│                                                                │盒裡面把你放3種口味。                                                           │
│                                                                │許：喔，這樣我們好好試一下。                                                    │
│                                                                │陳：好呀，明天開始你就可以吃香腸大餐。                                          │
│                                                                │許：明天喔，明早，明早我在家，明天下午要去台北喔，OK。                          │
│                                                                │陳：你在那裡『拚經濟』對不對。                                                  │
│                                                                │許：啊，嗯，對。                                                                │
│                                                                │陳：我知道，我聽到了，好，這樣我跟你講明天再講，BYEBYE，電話中不要，啊。        │
│                                                                │許：好。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：好啦，OK。                                                                  │
│                                                                │許：好。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│8.   2007/10/31  17:00:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           局長戊○○             酒家女「佳佳」│戊○○向理容KTV女子「佳佳」表示在忙                                             │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│9.   2007/10/31  17:03:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶林秀春    │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │妻：喂，晚上要幫你買起來嗎。                                                    │
│                                                                │許：不用，我現在在「拚經濟」。                                                  │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│10.  2007/10/31  17:12:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段0000號8F頂"                                        │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         水利署科長林榮│廉：科長。                                                                      │
│                                                  紹            │林：隆仔。                                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：現在黎明是風瀟瀟雨濛濛啦，有點瀟颯之氣啦。                                  │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：現在「老闆」是要怎麼樣。                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：在這裡呀。                                                                  │
│                                                                │林：「老闆」還在「天祥街」嘛，我要回去了，現在你要叫我去哪裡。                  │
│                                                                │廉：還在那裡，還在那裡。                                                        │
│                                                                │林：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：還在那裡。                                                                  │
│                                                                │林：在打麻將喔。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：打麻將。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：抱歉，這樣我就回去，你跟「你舅舅」說喔，啊。                                │
│                                                                │廉：好呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │林：對啦，喔。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：好。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：好。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│11.  2007/10/31  17:16:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○路○段000巷00號16F屋頂"                                        │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         水利署科長林榮│林：喂，「你們」在打麻將，我就不過去了，我直接回去。                            │
│                           局長戊○○             紹            │戴：就和「長仔」要去「阿九」那裡啦。                                            │
│                                                                │林：沒有啦，「你們」在打麻將，因為時間的問題，我跟「阿隆」說，我就回來了，我不去│
│                                                                │啦喔。                                                                          │
│                                                                │戴：你現在到哪裡了。                                                            │
│                                                                │林：我現在快來，本來要去「九龍」那裡，我再10分鐘就到「九龍」了，但我現在改變路線│
│                                                                │。                                                                              │
│                                                                │戴：不會啦，再10分鐘就到了。                                                    │
│                                                                │林：隨便講講，你們現在你們在打麻將。                                            │
│                                                                │戴：沒有啦，我們結束了。                                                        │
│                                                                │林：哪有結束。                                                                  │
│                                                                │戴：你跟「長仔」講，「長仔」跟你講。                                            │
│                                                                │林：不要啦。                                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：沒有啦，你跟他說一下。                                                      │
│                                                                │林：不要啦。                                                                    │
│                                                                │（戴沼澤將電話交予戊○○）                                                      │
│                                                                │許：喂，喂。                                                                    │
│                                                                │林：老闆，老闆。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：怎樣。                                                                      │
│                                                                │林：你們就打麻將就好了。                                                        │
│                                                                │許：當然啊，經濟這麼差，不拚一下怎麼過日子。                                    │
│                                                                │林：人生喔，經濟第2啦，女人第1啦，講實在我本來我說要去「那裡」，我衝很快，很多那│
│                                                                │個我就叫人代理。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：什麼。                                                                      │
│                                                                │林：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：什麼。                                                                      │
│                                                                │林：要去「九仔」那裡嘛。                                                        │
│                                                                │許：好啦，好啦，我會到啦。                                                      │
│                                                                │林：你何時會到，我現在就快回到家了，何時會到。                                  │
│                                                                │許：我就說我會到，你等一下啦，我正在認真賺錢，我會到。                          │
│                                                                │林：這樣喔，好，好。                                                            │
│                                                                │許：對啦。                                                                      │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│12.  2007/10/31  17:31:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         水利署科長林榮│林：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                  紹            │廉：科長。                                                                      │
│                                                                │林：隆仔，這樣我不要去啦，喔。                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：人過去了耶。                                                                │
│                                                                │林：過去了。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：嗯，「老闆」呀。                                                            │
│                                                                │林：因為我剛好要到了。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：「老闆」過去了。                                                            │
│                                                                │林：「老闆」過去了。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：差不多快到了。                                                              │
│                                                                │林：快到了。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：嗯，我也要過去啦。                                                          │
│                                                                │林：這樣喔，但是「老闆」不是英明的「老闆」，我今日是有話要跟他講啦。            │
│                                                                │廉：好呀，好呀，就差不多，在路上了啦，頂多，至多5分鐘就到了。                   │
│                                                                │林：這樣喔。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：我沒有，我沒有「開間」啦，因為我還沒到啦，我還沒到啦。                      │
│                                                                │廉：喔，你等一下會過去嘛。                                                      │
│                                                                │林：會，我現在剛好到哪裡你知道嗎，松竹路的什麼地方這樣而已。                    │
│                                                                │廉：喔，好啦，好啦，好啦，這樣近近的，好。                                      │
│                                                                │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│13.  2007/10/31  17:42:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                           局長戊○○             九龍酒店戴美玲│九龍酒店女友戴美玲：你怎麼上電視了。                                            │
│                                                                │許：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：就算要看也不需要再電視上看嘛。（指處理百姓抗爭）                            │
│                                                                │許：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：怎麼會上，你現在在哪裡。                                                    │
│                                                                │許：現在呀，現在。                                                              │
│                                                                │戴：還在公司喔。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：我沒有，我，怎麼曉得我公司。                                                │
│                                                                │戴：沒有，因為人家抗議又帶200多個人去抗議，今天不就比較忙。                     │
│                                                                │許：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：是喔，沒事了吧。                                                            │
│                                                                │許：還好啦，沒事。                                                              │
│                                                                │戴：這個場面不夠怕，200個不夠多，下次我要帶多一點人去看局長喔。                 │
│                                                                │許：我曾經曾經遇過30台遊覽車的。                                                │
│                                                                │戴：30台，喔1000多個。                                                          │
│                                                                │許：對呀，所以。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：200個不夠。                                                                 │
│                                                                │許：還算小兒科的啦。                                                            │
│                                                                │戴：這算不算是選舉造勢呀。                                                      │
│                                                                │許：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：喔，我想說，要看你也不需要電視才看到，跟阿嬤講，阿嬤阿嬤你看局長耶，要看也不│
│                                                                │用在電視看，對，他說局長在電視耶，好好笑喔，好啦，那你忙啦，有空我們一起吃飯，來│
│                                                                │家裡吃飯。                                                                      │
│                                                                │許：到你家吃飯呀。                                                              │
│                                                                │戴：嗯，有空的話。                                                              │
│                                                                │許：沒關係呀，你現在在家裡是吧。                                                │
│                                                                │戴：對呀，我等一下去，我等一下去「公司」（指九龍酒店）了。                      │
│                                                                │許：早一點過來，早一點過來。（指過來戴美玲之公司九龍酒店）                      │
│                                                                │戴：什麼，你今天會過來喔。（指過來戴美玲之公司九龍酒店）                        │
│                                                                │許：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：今天可能沒空，因為等一下客人有約吃飯，已經約了好幾天了。                    │
│                                                                │許：OK，好啦。                                                                  │
│                                                                │戴：啊，不要生氣喔，明天好不好。                                                │
│                                                                │許：不是生氣的問題，有事情要和你談談，沒關係啦，你去忙你的。                    │
│                                                                │戴：有事情和我談，什麼事，你先講。                                              │
│                                                                │許：見面才能談的。                                                              │
│                                                                │戴：喔，是喔，好，不嚴重吧，我沒有錢喔。                                        │
│                                                                │許：也很嚴重。                                                                  │
│                                                                │戴：很嚴重。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：為什麼。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：呵呵呵。                                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：不要，怕，我這樣我不敢，我會掛在心裡面。                                    │
│                                                                │許：沒有啦，沒有啦，你做你的事啦，做你的事情。                                  │
│                                                                │戴：嚴不嚴重的事情。                                                            │
│                                                                │許：沒有，天下無嚴重事情。                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：喔，真的喔。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：時間解決所有問題啦。                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：喔，好，好，你自己，自己要吃飯喔，好，好，BYEBYE。                          │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│14.  2007/10/31  17:50:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                           局長戊○○             九龍酒店戴美玲│戴：老大。                                                                      │
│                                                                │許：怎麼。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：在忙嗎。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：沒有，怎樣。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：不然的話，我跟你講，我今天不用進「公司」，因為我跟客人吃飯，客人拿「外全」（│
│                                                                │音譯）的錢，到10點多我就會回到家了。                                            │
│                                                                │許：10點多我也要回家了。                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：10點多我也要回家。                                                          │
│                                                                │戴：後來可以不用進去了耶。                                                      │
│                                                                │許：那你到時候再講，看我在不在。                                                │
│                                                                │戴：還是我回來的時候我打看看，有接你就見面，沒接就算了。                        │
│                                                                │許：對呀，對呀，對呀。                                                          │
│                                                                │戴：嚴不嚴重，這樣我會一直掛在心上耶。                                          │
│                                                                │許：沒什麼大事情，世間有什麼大事情。                                            │
│                                                                │戴：「calcal」（音譯）的事情嗎。                                                │
│                                                                │許：什麼「calcal」。                                                            │
│                                                                │戴：「calcal」就錢錢。                                                          │
│                                                                │許：沒有啦。                                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：那其他就不是很大問題了，是我的事嗎，我。                                    │
│                                                                │許：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：我怎麼了。                                                                  │
│                                                                │許：沒有啦，沒有啦，你做你的啦。                                                │
│                                                                │戴：真的。                                                                      │
│                                                                │許：對啦。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：好啦，那我10點多我再撥電話給你看。                                          │
│                                                                │許：好。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：好不好，好，BYEBYE。                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│15.  2007/10/31  18:40:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         水利署周世傑  │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│16.  2007/10/31  19:40:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │無人接聽                                                                        │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造戴沼澤│                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│17.  2007/10/31  20:41:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造王莉婷│無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│18.  2007/10/31  20:45:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造王莉婷│廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │王莉婷：要發小費放再把我留著就好了啦。                                          │
│                                                                │廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │王：要發小費放再把我留著就好了啦。                                              │
│                                                                │廉：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │王：要發小費放再把我放在旁邊就好了。                                            │
│                                                                │廉：什麼。                                                                      │
│                                                                │王：要發小費放把我放在旁邊就好了。                                              │
│                                                                │廉：喔，好啦，好啦。                                                            │
│                                                                │王：你打電話要做什麼。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：沒有啦，你們要過來嗎。                                                      │
│                                                                │王：沒有，「他」等一下要去山上，這「雀」（台語音譯）玩完就走了。                │
│                                                                │廉：你們差不多到幾點。                                                          │
│                                                                │王：我們差不多，現在幾點，差不多10點半吧。                                      │
│                                                                │廉：玩幾「雀」。                                                                │
│                                                                │王：4「雀」。                                                                   │
│                                                                │廉：啊，又上訴了。                                                              │
│                                                                │王：本來要走了，本來要走了，現在又打下去。                                      │
│                                                                │廉：喔，好啦，好啦，碗公再打下去這樣就好了。                                    │
│                                                                │王：沒有啦，你不要再打下去，你說去山上了。                                      │
│                                                                │廉：沒有，我跟他們說再打下去，他們就會走了啦，你們不會過來，這樣我知道啦。      │
│                                                                │王：好啦，好好。                                                                │
│                                                                │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│19.  2007/10/31  22:27:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         九龍酒店張淑惠│與九龍酒店女友閒聊，女友已先離開九龍回家                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│20.  2007/10/31  23:35:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │無人接聽                                                                        │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶林秀春    │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│21.  2007/10/31  23:35:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │無人接聽                                                                        │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶林秀春    │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│22.  2007/10/31  23:51:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路00號5F"                                                      │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         九龍酒店張淑惠│與九龍酒店女友閒聊                                                              │
└────────────────────────────────┴────────────────────────────────────────┘

┌────────────────────────────────┬────────────────────────────────────────┐
│編號 日期        時間      監聽電話       撥/接   對方電話      │通聯內容摘要                                                                備註│
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│1.   2007/11/28  17:11:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000○0號4F頂"                                            │
│                           局長戊○○             成功大學顏沛華│許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │成功大學顏沛華：喂，同學呀。                                                    │
│                                                                │許：嗯，是，你好，嗯。                                                          │
│                                                                │顏：嗯，對，嗯，請教你1個問題台中，台中這邊能夠上網的那個那個住宿的地方，曉不曉 │
│                                                                │得。                                                                            │
│                                                                │許：上網的。                                                                    │
│                                                                │顏：能夠上綱，上網，因為我有些東西我今天晚上要把傳回學校，因為明天我還在『三河局│
│                                                                │』這裡。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：喔，你要不要一起吃飯。                                                      │
│                                                                │顏：吃飯是OK啦，還好啦，還可以啦。                                              │
│                                                                │許：上網的喔，應該，應該，他現在那個，那個都有吧。                              │
│                                                                │顏：都有喔，不一定耶，不一定耶，我剛剛已經晃了2間都沒有耶。                     │
│                                                                │許：喔，我也不大知道耶，因為…。                                                │
│                                                                │顏：不要緊，我找，我找。                                                        │
│                                                                │許：你現在在台中嗎。                                                            │
│                                                                │顏：我現在在台中，我現在在台中。                                                │
│                                                                │許：那個，這樣你吃飯有問題嗎。                                                  │
│                                                                │顏：沒問題，哪有什麼問題。                                                      │
│                                                                │許：沒問題嗎。                                                                  │
│                                                                │顏：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：有什麼節目嗎。                                                              │
│                                                                │顏：沒有，不能有節目。                                                          │
│                                                                │許：不能有節目嗎。這樣啦，你先找有的時候，再跟我講一下。                        │
│                                                                │顏：好呀，好呀，好呀。                                                          │
│                                                                │許：我再帶你出來玩一玩。                                                        │
│                                                                │顏：OK，好。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│2.   2007/11/28  17:33:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○區○○○路○段00號12樓頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○             成功大學顏沛華│戊○○推廌「同學」顏沛華下榻柳川西路附近「帝寶飯店」                            │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│3.   2007/11/28  17:59:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路00號5F"                                                      │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         局長戊○○    │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：長仔。                                                                      │
│                                                                │許：喂，阿隆喔。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：嗯，長仔。                                                                  │
│                                                                │許：你在「旱溪」還是在哪裡。                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：我剛從那裡走。                                                              │
│                                                                │許：你從那裡走喔。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：呀，來「阿九」怎麼樣。                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：你到了嗎。                                                                  │
│                                                                │許：我再差不多5分鐘到。                                                         │
│                                                                │廉：喔，好呀，好呀，這樣我等一下，好。                                          │
│                                                                │許：OK，好。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│4.   2007/11/28  18:21:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │廉裕隆向妻表示有事情，在台中。                                                  │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         配偶          │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│5.   2007/11/28  18:28:00  0000000000      接     000000000     │廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆          九龍理容KTV  │張：要跟你排小姐嗎。                                                            │
│                                                  張淑惠        │暗廉：喔，免啦，免啦，免啦。                                                    │
│                                                                │張：這樣就好嗎。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：呀。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：2個就好嗎。                                                                 │
│                                                                │廉：對呀，看，看等一下再講啦。                                                  │
│                                                                │張：好。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│6.   2007/11/28  20:25:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │戴：你們回去了嗎？                                                              │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造戴沼澤│廉：還沒，在「阿九」。                                                          │
│                                                                │戴：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：和「許仔」他們去。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：嗯嗯嗯，「老闆」，嗯。                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：那個，明天公司給我拿10萬（元）上來。                                        │
│                                                                │廉：喔，好好好。                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│7.   2007/11/28  21:34:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │陳：你還OK嘛喔。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：嗯嗯。                                                                      │
│                                                                │陳：OK，好。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│8.   2007/11/28  21:35:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：你還OK嗎。                                                                  │
│                                                                │許：嗯嗯。                                                                      │
│                                                                │陳：你在哪裡。                                                                  │
│                                                                │許：在2樓。                                                                     │
│                                                                │陳：OK，好。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│9.   2007/11/28  21:40:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：狀況解除，狀況解除。                                                        │
│                                                                │許：OK，好，我下來。                                                            │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│10.  2007/11/28  21:42:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │許：來這裡有看身份證嗎？                                                        │
│                           局長戊○○             成功大學顏沛華│旁人：沒有呀。                                                                  │
│                                                                │許：只有看一下這樣，謝謝。                                                      │
│                                                                │（撥通）                                                                        │
│                                                                │顏：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │顏：同學，嗯。                                                                  │
│                                                                │許：你現在在哪裡。                                                              │
│                                                                │顏：喔，我坐計乘車回我住的地方了。                                              │
│                                                                │許：OK，呀，你曉得啦喔。                                                        │
│                                                                │顏：我知道，我知道，我知道。                                                    │
│                                                                │許：OK，好。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│11.  2007/11/28  21:50:00  0000000000      接     000000000     │張：你OK喔。                                                                    │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         九龍理容KTV   │廉：OK，OK。                                                                    │
│                                                  張淑惠        │女：到家門口可以1通電話嗎。                                                     │
│                                                                │廉：好。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│12.  2007/11/28  21:55:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段0000號3F頂"                                        │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造鄭年雅│向鄭年雅表示戴沼澤要其明日過去拿10萬元                                          │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│13.  2007/11/28  22:16:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中縣大甲鎮○○路000號4F"                                                     │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         九龍理容KTV女 │九龍理容KTV女友張淑惠：到了喔。                                                 │
│                                                  友張淑惠      │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│14.  2007/11/29  09:51:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中縣新社鄉○○○段0000000地號"                                               │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造王莉婷│廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │王：你現在在公司喔。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：沒有呀，現在來新社（鄉）。                                                  │
│                                                                │王：你昨天偷去喝酒，你要被打了你。                                              │
│                                                                │廉：我。                                                                        │
│                                                                │王：（笑），「他」說你怎麼沒講，我說沒講一定是「長仔」打給他的，不然你們「阿隆」│
│                                                                │怎麼可能去那裡。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │王：是嗎。                                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │王：對喔。                                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：對呀，我就回到公司了，「長仔」打電話給我。                                  │
│                                                                │王：我說，唉唷，喝酒「人家」也不用找「舅舅」了，「阿孫」出馬就可以了，你是在。  │
│                                                                │廉：好了，不要再叮了啦。                                                        │
│                                                                │…（閒聊）                                                                      │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│15.  2007/11/29  11:20:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○區○○街00號6樓頂"                                                     │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │陳：昨天應該OK啦喔，那個「顏大哥」他們OK啦喔。                                  │
│                                                                │許：那個，沒有事情啦，沒有事情啦。                                              │
│                                                                │陳：你也OK啦嘛喔。                                                              │
│                                                                │許：怎麼。                                                                      │
│                                                                │陳：你也OK嘛，我也OK嘛。                                                        │
│                                                                │許：喔，對呀。                                                                  │
│                                                                │陳：我也很OK。                                                                  │
│                                                                │許：大家，大家都很高興。                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：這樣子就好了啦。                                                            │
│                                                                │許：圓滿啦，本來就是世間事圓滿就好。                                            │
└────────────────────────────────┴────────────────────────────────────────┘
┌────────────────────────────────┬────────────────────────────────────────┐
│編號 日期        時間      監聽電話       撥/接   對方電話      │通聯內容摘要                                                                備註│
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│1.   2007/12/17  15:18:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○區○○街00號6樓頂"                                                     │
│                           局長戊○○            九龍理容KTV徐玉│徐：大哥，大哥。                                                                │
│                                                 玲             │許：嗯，是。                                                                    │
│                                                                │徐：嗯，你在忙嗎。                                                              │
│                                                                │許：嗯嗯嗯。                                                                    │
│                                                                │徐：嗯，你有聽到聲音啦喔。                                                      │
│                                                                │許：我知道，我知道，好，好，好。                                                │
│                                                                │徐：你在忙嗎。                                                                  │
│                                                                │許：嗯，現在，現在還在那個，還在看。                                            │
│                                                                │徐：喔，這樣喔。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │徐：好好好好。                                                                  │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│2.   2007/12/17  15:27:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○區○○街00號6樓頂"                                                     │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │與女友陳玉瑛聊閒                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│3.   2007/12/17  15:30:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造王莉婷│王：你現在在哪裡。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │王：你現在在哪裡。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：在「九龍」。                                                                │
│                                                                │王：「阿忠」他們在這邊嗎，不然怎麼電話一直打。                                  │
│                                                                │廉：只有他而已。                                                                │
│                                                                │王：只有他而已嗎。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │王：你呢。                                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：我跟他而已。                                                                │
│                                                                │王：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │王：喔，好啦，好啦。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：怎麼。                                                                      │
│                                                                │王：有人在問呀。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：沒啦，你跟他說不要接就好了啦。                                              │
│                                                                │王：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：對啦。                                                                      │
│                                                                │王：好啦，好。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：喔，沒做什麼。                                                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│4.   2007/12/17  16:33:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路00號7樓頂"                                                   │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │戊○○向女友陳玉瑛表示晚上8時前再過去。                                         │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│5.   2007/12/17  16:38:00  0000000000      接     000000000     │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆                       │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│6.   2007/12/17  16:38:00  0000000000      撥     000000000     │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆                       │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│7.   2007/12/17  16:39:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         第九河川局江宗│與第九河川局江宗基聯繫工程事宜（有關電線桿維修），並表示第3次就是明年2月了。    │
│                                                  基            │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│8.   2007/12/17  16:52:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │…                                                                              │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         水利署河川勘測│林榮紹：這樣你聽沒有，這樣你還聽沒有。                                          │
│                                                  隊周世傑      │…                                                                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│9.   2007/12/17  16:53:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         水利署河川勘測│無人接聽                                                                        │
│                                                  隊周世傑      │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│10.  2007/12/17  16:54:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造戴沼澤│無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│11.  2007/12/17  16:54:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造戴沼澤│無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│12.  2007/12/17  16:54:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"中華電信未提供"                                                                │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造戴沼澤│廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：嗯，啊，那個「長仔他們」有都來「那裡」嗎。                                  │
│                                                                │廉：剛才到。                                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：喔，明天那「標」是早上還是下午。                                            │
│                                                                │廉：你說開標嗎。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：開標早上10點呀。                                                            │
│                                                                │戴：「泱丞」有過來嗎。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：沒有。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：要算看看嗎。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：不知道耶。                                                                  │
│                                                                │戴：喔。看他，看他，不然你就電話叫他再算看看，若沒有明日早一點就要去打押標金。  │
│                                                                │廉：喔，好呀，好呀，好                                                          │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│13.  2007/12/17  16:55:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │戴泱丞：喂。                                                                    │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造戴泱丞│廉：「乾溪」有領1標喔，有領2標啦，明天要「開」喔。                              │
│                                                                │戴：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：公司有標單喔，你回去，你若有空先回去看好嗎。                                │
│                                                                │戴：明天再寄來得及嗎，「他」說，你爸說明天早一點，算看看啦。                    │
│                                                                │廉：好啦，好。                                                                  │
│                                                                │戴：若可以，明早，明早再打押標金，因為10點開嘛，9點50（分）決標嘛。             │
│                                                                │廉：好呀，好，好。…                                                            │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│14.  2007/12/17  16:57:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造鄭年雅│向鄭年雅表示明日標案戴泱丞會回去計算                                            │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│15.  2007/12/17  17:07:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           局長戊○○                           │短訊：您有１通新留言』請撥７７７﹒國外撥＋○○○○○○○○○○○○（需付費）來自│
│                                                                │０９３２１                                                                      │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│16.  2007/12/17  17:12:00  0000000000      撥     777           │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           局長戊○○                           │戊○○聽取李介賓（音譯）留言。                                                  │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│17.  2007/12/17  17:25:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         配偶          │廉裕隆與妻通聯                                                                  │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│18.  2007/12/17  17:27:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○                           │戊○○與李介賓（音譯）約明日於台中市富王飯店吃飯。                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│19.  2007/12/17  17:29:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶          │戊○○向妻表示晚點回去                                                          │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│20.  2007/12/17  17:31:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         配偶          │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│21.  2007/12/17  17:32:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         配偶          │廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │妻：喔，沒有，你在哪裡。                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：台中呀。                                                                    │
│                                                                │妻：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：台中啦。                                                                    │
│                                                                │妻：在台中喔。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：嗯，怎麼樣。                                                                │
│                                                                │妻：在吃飯喔。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：在「KTV」。                                                                 │
│                                                                │妻：喔，好啦。                                                                  │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│22.  2007/12/17  17:55:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         水利署河川勘測│撥打水利署河川勘測隊周世傑，無人接聽                                            │
│                                                  隊周世傑      │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│23.  2007/12/17  18:29:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造戴泱丞│戴泱丞表示（指第三河川局「乾溪福新上游工程-新厝橋上游-乾溪橋工程」標案）已計算好│
│                                                                │（投標價格）                                                                    │
│                                                                │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│24.  2007/12/17  18:52:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         九龍理容KTV張 │廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                  淑惠          │張：你聽我講。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：我現在等『忠哥』跟我回帳8萬多。                                             │
│                                                                │廉：怎麼。                                                                      │
│                                                                │張：你可以出來，方便出來講話嗎。                                                │
│                                                                │廉：我出來外面聽，你稍等。喂。                                                  │
│                                                                │張：我現在等『忠哥』跟我回帳，還差我8萬多元。                                   │
│                                                                │廉：你說回帳怎麼。                                                              │
│                                                                │張：他要跟我回帳。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：我要跟你回帳。                                                              │
│                                                                │張：『他』啦，我出去了不會再回來了。                                            │
│                                                                │廉：你說怎麼。                                                                  │
│                                                                │張：我現在，我現在跟你講，我在等『忠哥』跟我回帳，我怕我出去，我怕我不會再回來啦│
│                                                                │。                                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：我現在不知道他，你們今天，你老實跟我講你們2個怎麼會相約一起『進來』。       │
│                                                                │廉：我跟你講啦，今天他，他邀我進來，嗯，怎麼，你說。                            │
│                                                                │張：他邀你進來，他跟我回帳耶。                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：他要跟你回帳。                                                              │
│                                                                │張：嗯，我怕我走，他現在很醉，他也不可能回了。                                  │
│                                                                │廉：對呀，不可能了，他不管說你在不在都差不多醉了。                              │
│                                                                │張：對呀，我意思說我要走了，不會回來了。                                        │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：你懂我意思嗎。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：他今天就給『秀秀』去處理這張單子。                                          │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：可以嗎。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：對呀，應該今天也『秀秀』啦。                                                │
│                                                                │張：對呀，我想你們都做『秀秀』的。                                              │
│                                                                │廉：沒有啦，因為今天『忠哥』去買的。                                            │
│                                                                │張：你讓『忠哥』處理『秀秀』的。                                                │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：我出去，沒有要再進來了。                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：我等一下打聲招呼，我跟『長仔』打聲招呼啦。                                  │
│                                                                │廉：嗯，喔，好啦。                                                              │
│                                                                │張：『長仔』他應該是為了帳款，不然他不會再進來啦。                              │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：我打聲招呼，我就走掉，我就不會再進來了啦。                                  │
│                                                                │廉：好啦，好啦。                                                                │
│                                                                │張：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：好啦，好。                                                                  │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│25.  2007/12/17  19:30:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         九龍理容KTV張 │廉：喂，喂。                                                                    │
│                                                  淑惠          │張：你在哪裡。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：『裡面』。                                                                  │
│                                                                │張：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：『公司』裡面喔。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │張：…。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：好啦，好啦，好啦，回去再講。                                                │
│                                                                │張：你回去再講。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：好。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：你哪會講。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：我就不會講就對了。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：好啦，好啦，好啦。                                                          │
│                                                                │張：你不要這樣好嗎。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：好。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：你每次酒醉都這樣喔。                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：好，好。                                                                    │
│                                                                │張：好什麼啦。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：改進。                                                                      │
│                                                                │張：你可以聽我講一句話嗎。                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：好啦，好啦，我知道啦喔。                                                    │
│                                                                │張：我現在沒有在包廂耶。                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：好啦。                                                                      │
│                                                                │張：沒有在『公司』耶。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：好啦，好，好啦，我知道啦。                                                  │
│                                                                │張：…。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：你不要跟我好好好。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：沒有，沒有，真的，真的。                                                    │
│                                                                │張：什麼意思，你跟我講。                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：沒有，沒有，沒有，沒有，沒有。                                              │
│                                                                │張：我已經心很痛了。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：我有收斂。                                                                  │
│                                                                │張：我知道你個性，你也知道你個性，再這樣下，我一點…都沒有。                    │
│                                                                │廉：好啦，我知道啦，真的啦。                                                    │
│                                                                │張：問題，問題，現在我沒有在公司，你要叫我去公司罵。                            │
│                                                                │廉：沒有。                                                                      │
│                                                                │張：沒有是怎麼。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：清醒了。                                                                    │
│                                                                │張：清醒了嗎。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：你有辦法這樣子讓我一次一次的…嗎。                                          │
│                                                                │廉：清醒了，真的，喔，我等一下打給你。                                          │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│26.  2007/12/17  19:43:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：可能要晚半個鐘頭喔。                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：喔，好呀。                                                                  │
│                                                                │許：喔。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│27.  2007/12/17  19:43:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         九龍理容KTV張 │張：你還在包廂裡面嗎。                                                          │
│                                                  淑惠          │廉：嗯。我等一下打給你。                                                        │
│                                                                │張：我要進去了，你不用打給我。                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：好。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│28.  2007/12/17  20:18:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造鄭年雅│（廉裕隆與鄭年雅通聯前背景聲，戊○○與旁人交談）                                │
│                                                                │第三河川局局長戊○○：為什麼不可能，你不是…。                                  │
│                                                                │（廉裕隆與戴沼澤女兒開始通聯）                                                  │
│                                                                │鄭年雅表示戴沼澤的電話有通沒人接，廉裕隆表示明日再打電話。                      │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│29.  2007/12/17  20:25:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │許：我本來現在要過去，我發現皮包不曉得丟在哪裡，我要回辦公室看一下。            │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │陳：你先去找。                                                                  │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│30.  2007/12/17  20:27:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號7F頂"                                               │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │陳：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：那個辦公室的鑰匙我沒帶出來喔，不要緊啦，明天再看啦，我差不多10分鐘到你那裡。│
│                                                                │陳：你不要緊嗎。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：我現在沒有鑰匙可以進去，鑰匙沒有帶出來。                                    │
│                                                                │陳：好。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│31.  2007/12/17  22:43:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         九龍理容KTV張 │張：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                  淑惠          │廉：你要回去了沒。                                                              │
│                                                                │張：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：你要回去了沒。                                                              │
│                                                                │張：我要呀，我換一下衣服好嗎。                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：我在這裡等你喔。                                                            │
│                                                                │張：你哪裡等我。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：你哪裡等我。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：我在這裡等你呀。                                                            │
│                                                                │張：你哪裡等我。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：我在『107』等你呀。                                                         │
│                                                                │張：你哪裡等我啦。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：我在『107』等你呀，喔。                                                     │
└────────────────────────────────┴────────────────────────────────────────┘

┌────────────────────────────────┬────────────────────────────────────────┐
│編號 日期        時間      監聽電話       撥/接   對方電話      │通聯內容摘要                                                                備註│
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│1.   2008/01/03 07:18:00   000000000       接     0000000000    │臺中縣大甲鎮○○路0段0000號4F                                                   │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         九龍理容KTV張 │短訊：你也可以照顧我, 也可以對我更好只是你不願也不肯所以不要對我說何謂好與壞, 我│
│                                                  淑惠          │心知肚明, 我目前只想活在當下! 即使我知道伀臿袖                  邘  惿          │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│2.   2008/01/03  07:18:00  000000000       接     0000000000    │臺中縣大甲鎮○○路0段0000號4F                                                   │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         九龍理容KTV張 │短訊：不要說些冠冕堂皇的理由, 我的生活與將來都無須你來安排或負責, 我只要你多一點│
│                                                  淑惠          │關心  多一些陪伴  我就會                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│3.   2008/01/03  10:02:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │    臺中市○區○○街00號6樓頂                                                   │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │短訊：老公相信我的直覺﹒最近不要管別人的事﹒為自己帶來不                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│4.   2008/01/03  14:21:00  000000000       接     0000000000    │"臺中市○區○○街00號7樓頂"                                                     │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造戴沼澤│戴：把他載到「阿華」那裡。                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：好。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│5.   2008/01/03  14:21:00  0000000000      撥     000000000     │"未提供"                                                                        │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         川順營造廉裕隆│戴：把他載到「阿華」那裡。                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：好。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│6.   2008/01/03  14:22:00  000000000       接     0000000000    │"臺中市○區○○街00號7樓頂"                                                     │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造戴沼澤│廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：叫林榮紹，可能你載他回去，可能也會過去啦。                                  │
│                                                                │廉：好。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│7.   2008/01/03  14:22:00  0000000000      撥     000000000     │"未提供"                                                                        │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         川順營造廉裕隆│廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：叫林榮紹，可能你載他回去，可能也會過去啦。                                  │
│                                                                │廉：好。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│8.   2008/01/03  14:25:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○區○○街○段000○00號12F頂"                                            │
│                           局長戊○○             川順營造戴沼澤│許：喂，結束沒有。                                                              │
│                                                                │戴：結束了。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：啊，在哪裡。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：就「阿隆」，「阿隆」在召集，你們那個「副座」不知道怎麼走。                  │
│                                                                │許：喔，這樣喔，你們現在在「旱溪」就對了。                                      │
│                                                                │戴：要回去「旱溪」。                                                            │
│                                                                │許：要回去「旱溪」喔。                                                          │
│                                                                │戴：嗯，啊，你呢。                                                              │
│                                                                │許：我就反正，你要去「旱溪」我過來「旱溪」陪你。                                │
│                                                                │戴：好呀，好呀，「旱溪工地」啦喔。                                              │
│                                                                │許：好。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│9.   2008/01/03  14:26:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"台中市○區○○路000號12樓頂"                                                   │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         局長戊○○    │許：喂，結束沒有。                                                              │
│                                                                │戴：結束了。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：啊，在哪裡。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：就「阿隆」，「阿隆」在召集，你們那個「副座」不知道怎麼走。                  │
│                                                                │許：喔，這樣喔，你們現在在「旱溪」就對了。                                      │
│                                                                │戴：要回去「旱溪」。                                                            │
│                                                                │許：要回去「旱溪」喔。                                                          │
│                                                                │戴：嗯，啊，你呢。                                                              │
│                                                                │許：我就反正，你要去「旱溪」我過來「旱溪」陪你。                                │
│                                                                │戴：好呀，好呀，「旱溪工地」啦喔。                                              │
│                                                                │許：好。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│10.  2008/01/03  14:36:00  000000000       撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號6F頂"                                               │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         金拿獎視聽歌唱│金拿獎視聽歌唱坊陳秀月：喂。                                                    │
│                                                  坊陳秀月      │廉：在哪裡。                                                                    │
│                                                                │陳：「公司」啦，在哪裡，不然會在。                                              │
│                                                                │廉：老朋友，老朋友啦，要過去看你啦。                                            │
│                                                                │陳：有喔，「幾個」。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：「幾個」。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：幾個啦。                                                                    │
│                                                                │陳：幾個，好呀。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：我們先2個啦，等一下再，再CALL啦。                                           │
│                                                                │陳：好，好。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：喔，好。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│11.  2008/01/03  14:40:00  000000000       撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號6F頂"                                               │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         水利署科長林榮│林：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                  紹            │廉：「科長」，喂，科長。                                                        │
│                                                                │林：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：嗯，你回來了。喂。（斷訊）                                                  │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│12.  2008/01/03  14:43:00  000000000       撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號6F頂"                                               │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         水利署科長林榮│廉：科長，科長。                                                                │
│                                                  紹            │林：嗯，嗯，嗯，嗯。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：忙完了嗎。喂，喂，喂。                                                      │
│                                                                │林：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：科長。                                                                      │
│                                                                │林：嗯，嗯。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：嗯，忙完了嘛。                                                              │
│                                                                │林：啊，我就載他們回來。                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：喔喔喔喔。                                                                  │
│                                                                │林：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：「阿華」。                                                                  │
│                                                                │林：喔。啊。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：「TWO WORD」。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：「阿華」，嗯。                                                              │
│                                                                │林：還有誰。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：就我們2個而已。                                                             │
│                                                                │林：嘻嘻嘻嘻嘻（笑）。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：「THREE WORD」啦。                                                          │
│                                                                │林：THREE WORD。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：THREE WORD，喔。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：喔，喔。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：喔，好，好。                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│13.  2008/01/03  14:44:00   000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號6F頂"                                               │
│                            川順營造廉裕隆                      │廉邀某男至金拿獎視聽歌唱坊                                                      │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│14.  2008/01/03  14:51:00   000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號6F頂"                                               │
│                            川順營造廉裕隆        川順營造戴永恭│廉裕隆：喂。                                                                    │
│                                                                │戴永恭：阿隆，你在哪裡。                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：在河南路。                                                                  │
│                                                                │戴：喔，你吃飯嗎。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：唱歌。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：喔，河南路，河南路那麼遠。公司有沒有人。                                    │
│                                                                │廉：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：河南路。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：路底，最南邊這裡。                                                          │
│                                                                │戴：喔，公司有人嗎。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：「天祥街」喔。                                                              │
│                                                                │戴：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：「天祥街」有呀，「小紀」他們都在那裡。                                      │
│                                                                │戴：不然，你叫電話叫他們燒個茶。                                                │
│                                                                │廉：好。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：燒個茶，泡個茶。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：好。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│15.  2008/01/03  14:51:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           局長戊○○             第三河川局劉士│第三河川局劉士榮表示國有財產局下禮一10時至該局開協調會，戊○○表示主持人為「副座│
│                                                  榮            │」。                                                                            │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│16.  2008/01/03  15:09:00  000000000       接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號6F頂"                                               │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造王莉婷│與王莉婷通聯                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│17.  2008/01/03  15:22:00  000000000       撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號6F頂"                                               │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         某男          │某男表示快到了。                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│18.  2008/01/03  15:39:00  000000000      接     0000000000     │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號6F頂"                                               │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆        川順營造戴永恭 │廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴永恭：嗯，嗯，喔，你們外出喔，外出了喔。                                      │
│                                                                │廉：嗯，嗯。                                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：喔，沒進來啦喔。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：沒有，嗯，沒有。                                                            │
│                                                                │戴：瞭解，那種的，河南路喔。                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：喔盡頭那個喔。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：對。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：喔，那間叫什麼名字。                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：就走到底。                                                                  │
│                                                                │戴：叫什麼名字，那不會死啦。                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：「金拿獎」。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：喔，我知道啦…好，好，我爸在唱歌嗎。（斷訊）                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│19.  2008/01/03  16:15:00  0000000000      撥     000000000     │"未提供"                                                                        │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         川順營造廉裕隆│廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：叫「林榮紹」過去一下喔。                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：叫他回給你喔。                                                              │
│                                                                │戴：沒有啦，叫「林榮紹」過去啦。                                                │
│                                                                │廉：有呀，都過來了。                                                            │
│                                                                │戴：有去「那裡」嗎。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：都過來了，都有過來。                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│20.  2008/01/03 16:15:00   000000000       接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號6F頂"                                               │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造戴沼澤│廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：叫「林榮紹」過去一下喔。                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：叫他回給你喔。                                                              │
│                                                                │戴：沒有啦，叫「林榮紹」過去啦。                                                │
│                                                                │廉：有呀，都過來了。                                                            │
│                                                                │戴：有去「那裡」嗎。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：都過來了，都有過來。                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│21.  2008/01/03  17:56:00  000000000       接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號5樓頂"                                              │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         配偶          │廉裕隆向妻表示剛才喝酒、唱歌出來。                                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│22.  2008/01/03  18:07:00  000000000       撥     0000000000    │王莉婷：喂。                                                                    │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造王莉婷│廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │王：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：我要回家了。                                                                │
│                                                                │王：喔，「林科長」喝醉了嗎。                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │王：「林科長」喝醉了嗎。                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：還好啦。                                                                    │
│                                                                │王：還好喔，他不是叫你帶他過來。                                                │
│                                                                │廉：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │王：不是叫你帶他過來。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：帶他過去哪裡。                                                              │
│                                                                │王：「天祥街」呀。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：沒有吧。                                                                    │
│                                                                │王：你喝醉酒，你要被打了。                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │王：你喝醉酒，你要被打了。                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：誰。                                                                        │
│                                                                │王：剛才在說，你沒聽到嗎。                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：沒有，說什麼。                                                              │
│                                                                │王：叫你帶「林科長」過來。                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：沒有，哪有跟我講這樣。                                                      │
│                                                                │王：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：不然你先回去。                                                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│23.  2008/01/03  18:22:00  000000000       接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         林榮紹配偶    │林榮紹配偶表示找不到林榮紹，且林榮紹行動電話未開機，並表示林榮紹（12月）31日不是│
│                                                                │亦與?裕隆喝酒，且喝的很醉。                                                     │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│24.  2008/01/03  18:24:00  000000000       撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號12樓頂"                                             │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         水利署科長林榮│無人接聽                                                                        │
│                                                  紹            │                                                                                │
└────────────────────────────────┴────────────────────────────────────────┘

┌────────────────────────────────┬────────────────────────────────────────┐
│編號 日期        時間      監聽電話       撥/接   對方電話      │通聯內容摘要                                                                備註│
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│1.   2008/01/07  14:40:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○街0號9樓頂"                                                │
│                           局長戊○○             川順營造戴沼澤│許：老闆，怎麼樣。                                                              │
│                                                                │戴：怎麼樣，在哪裡。                                                            │
│                                                                │許：現在和「第七」的兄弟要去「阿九」。                                          │
│                                                                │戴：喔，好呀，好呀，好。                                                        │
│                                                                │許：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：好。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│2.   2008/01/07  14:46:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                           局長戊○○             水利署周世傑  │周：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：你現在在哪裡。                                                              │
│                                                                │周：載，載太太回來。                                                            │
│                                                                │許：好，回去後，「阿九」。                                                      │
│                                                                │周：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：回去後，「阿九」啦。                                                        │
│                                                                │周：好好好好。                                                                  │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│3.   2008/01/07  15:06:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           局長戊○○             第三河川局秘書│第三河川局秘書廖大模：局長你好。                                                │
│                                                  廖大模        │許：你在外面還是裡面。                                                          │
│                                                                │廖：我在辦公廳。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：辦公廳喔。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廖：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：「第七」的同事來在「阿九」，你要過來嗎。                                    │
│                                                                │廖：「阿九」，我現在，我現在沒有在喝酒。                                        │
│                                                                │許：沒喝酒，沒喝酒，人家「阿三哥」要看你呀。                                    │
│                                                                │廖：喔，這樣喔。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │廖：好啦，好啦，啊，我不要「喝」啦，好否。                                      │
│                                                                │許：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廖：好，好，好。                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│4.   2008/01/07  15:16:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           局長戊○○             某女          │某女表示有陳情案件                                                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│5.   2008/01/07  16:06:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○0路000號8 F頂"                                                 │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │許：喂，喂。                                                                    │
│                                                                │女友陳玉瑛：喂。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：怎樣，剛睡醒嗎。喔，你這2日是去哪，電話都不通。                             │
│                                                                │陳：你的。                                                                      │
│                                                                │許：我，我每日也給你打電話。                                                    │
│                                                                │陳：你現在在哪裡。                                                              │
│                                                                │許：現在我屏東的朋友上來，在「阿九」。                                          │
│                                                                │陳：我知道，我聽到聲音。                                                        │
│                                                                │許：嗯嗯嗯，嗯。                                                                │
│                                                                │陳：好啦，你快去…。                                                            │
│                                                                │許：OK，好。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│6.   2008/01/07  16:11:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │臺中市○○區○○0路000號8 F頂                                                   │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │短訊：怡君那裡有一張３                                                          │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│7.   2008/01/07  16:11:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │女友陳玉瑛：你看一下訊息。                                                      │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │許：喔，好，好。                                                                │
│                                                                │陳：你知道喔…                                                                  │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│8.   2008/01/07  16:12:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           九龍理容KTV張淑惠      女友陳玉瑛    │張淑惠：喂。                                                                    │
│                                                                │陳玉瑛：怡君。                                                                  │
│                                                                │張：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：你現在講話沒關係喔？                                                        │
│                                                                │張：嗯，不要緊，嗯。                                                            │
│                                                                │陳：你有在「大哥」那個包廂嗎？                                                  │
│                                                                │張：「他們」在「315」。                                                         │
│                                                                │陳：我告訴你，我跟他說了喔。                                                    │
│                                                                │張：他剛剛有問我啦。                                                            │
│                                                                │陳：他剛剛有問你喔。                                                            │
│                                                                │張：對啦，他問我，我有說。                                                      │
│                                                                │陳：因為他好幾天找不到我，我都關機，我想說今天差不多該回他個電話，他大概3天、4天│
│                                                                │找不到了。                                                                      │
│                                                                │張：喔，他還問我說你怎麼那麼「趴」（台語音譯），我說沒有啦，我說一點點，他說一點│
│                                                                │點也要說多少，我說不急，他說你不是要回去，我說我今天才要走，我今天公司結完帳才要│
│                                                                │走。                                                                            │
│                                                                │陳：那也真有夠默契，我跟你講我，4天他打我都關機，然後今天我就睡醒，我想說怕他在 │
│                                                                │那邊煩惱東煩惱西，就打給他，他說他屏東的朋友來，在「那邊」，但                  │
│                                                                │那種事我是剛打訊息跟他講，我電話中沒有用講的，這樣等一下他可能會問你，他問你，他│
│                                                                │問你什麼？                                                                      │
│                                                                │張：他問我說我還有沒有欠你錢，我說一點點，他說他，沒有說你。                    │
│                                                                │陳：他知道，他的意思是說，他就是要說我代表他。                                  │
│                                                                │張：他說，對，對，他說我有欠你錢嗎，我說一點點，一點點是多少，就是一點點，他說啊│
│                                                                │是多少，我說幾千塊而已，他說，啊，什麼時候又來喝的，他說他何時又來喝，我說沒有啦│
│                                                                │，你那天帶小姐去「楓之林」，他說，喔，我都沒帶到，小姐都被他                    │
│                                                                │帶去，哈哈，他就這樣講呀，就這樣講呀。                                          │
│                                                                │陳：因為我說給你聽，他覺得奇怪，為什麼我都自己玩，不要找他玩，你知道嗎。        │
│                                                                │張：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：他，他，他搞到最後，他，我跟你講這個，你連「阿隆」都不要                    │
│                                                                │講喔。                                                                          │
│                                                                │張：不會，不會。                                                                │
│                                                                │陳：他就說奇怪，為什麼我都自己玩，都不找他去就對了，可是我現在都習慣了，習慣自己│
│                                                                │玩比較自由你知道嗎。                                                            │
│                                                                │張：嗯嗯嗯。                                                                    │
│                                                                │陳：啊，你進去，「秀秀」是，今天是「秀秀的桌」嗎？                              │
│                                                                │張：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：她又搶去了喔。                                                              │
│                                                                │張：沒關係啦。                                                                  │
│                                                                │陳：她就是都顧緊緊，對不對。                                                    │
│                                                                │張：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：怕搞丟對不對。                                                              │
│                                                                │張：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │陳：你進去的時候，「他」有在那裡嗎？                                            │
│                                                                │張：啊？                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：你進去的時候，「秀秀」有在嗎？                                              │
│                                                                │張：沒有，沒有，沒有，沒有，我帶上去的。                                        │
│                                                                │陳：為什麼你帶進去的，又變她的？                                                │
│                                                                │張：啊，啊他進來就說要找「秀秀」啊。                                            │
│                                                                │陳：喔，他今天有說要找他嘛。                                                    │
│                                                                │張：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：有說嘛。                                                                    │
│                                                                │張：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：那我再，啊，「阿隆」沒有和他們去就對啦。                                    │
│                                                                │張：沒有，沒有，沒有，他和別人的，我不認識的，「秀秀」認識吧。                  │
│                                                                │陳：可能她認識吧。                                                              │
│                                                                │張：嗯，別的廠商的。                                                            │
│                                                                │陳：啊？                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：別間公司的啦。                                                              │
│                                                                │陳：他還知道要主動問你，他還跟你講我什麼時候走。                                │
│                                                                │張：沒有，他問我，他問我還有沒有欠你錢，他說他有欠我錢嗎，我說一點點，他說多少你│
│                                                                │不快點講，我說等我回來再說，他說我不就吃有沒有那麼久，他說他不就吃有沒有那麼久。│
│                                                                │陳：你在外面嗎？                                                                │
│                                                                │張：嗯，我在外面，我在門口啦。                                                  │
│                                                                │陳：你，剛才他去的時候你不在公司嗎？                                            │
│                                                                │張：有啊，我帶上去的啊。                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：喔喔喔喔。                                                                  │
│                                                                │張：嗯，啊，那時候「秀秀」還沒來呀，他就問我有欠我嗎，我就說一點點而已，他又問我│
│                                                                │說什麼時候又來喝的，我說沒有啦，帶小姐去「楓之林」，他就說小姐都被他帶走，難怪我│
│                                                                │都沒帶到，他就這樣說呀。                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：不好意思，我什麼時候有叫他不要帶對不對，我才不是那種人，你要帶，你帶你的，各│
│                                                                │人做各人的工作，怡君你也知道我的人，對不對。                                    │
│                                                                │張：嗯嗯嗯嗯。                                                                  │
│                                                                │陳：你自己不要帶，你娘咧，有誰叫你不要帶。                                      │
│                                                                │張：歡迎光臨。                                                                  │
│                                                                │陳：好啦，客人來了，OK。                                                        │
│                                                                │張：嗯，嗯。                                                                    │
│                                                                │陳：重點我跟你講，他可能會再問你，你不要跟他講說我現在有打電話給你。            │
│                                                                │張：好，我知道，OK。                                                            │
│                                                                │陳：他若問你我的事，不要讓他知道。                                              │
│                                                                │張：我知道，我知道，我都沒跟他說其他的事情，他就問這個錢是從哪裡，這個帳是怎樣的│
│                                                                │。                                                                              │
│                                                                │陳：我跟你講，我跟你說的事，你不能說喔，我跟他的遊戲應該差不多可以了，你懂不懂，│
│                                                                │但是我不曉得要怎麼跟他講，因為他很疼我你知道嗎。                                │
│                                                                │張：慢慢疏遠啦，慢慢啦。                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：你沒有感覺嗎，，你不覺得我這幾個月都這樣做，我剛剛打給他的時候，他就講說，他│
│                                                                │都跑去哪裡，我都打給你，你都不開機，我現在喔，我在那個「阿九」（指九龍理容KTV） │
│                                                                │，我朋友屏東上來啦，上來，我就帶來這，我聽到這個我就說好啦，你去玩啦，ok，好，拜│
│                                                                │拜，我又想到，我又打手機說你的帳。                                              │
│                                                                │張：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：認識比較久，我跟你講啦，因為我覺得我有自己的生活要顧，我不想這樣的生活，不喜│
│                                                                │歡耶。                                                                          │
│                                                                │張：沒關係，慢慢來，慢慢來，感覺是，感覺要怎樣過。                              │
│                                                                │陳：你看呢，你看呢，你看我們2個的感覺呢。                                       │
│                                                                │張：可是我覺得「他」很疼你呀，其實不要說太黏在一起，偶爾有人疼也不錯            │
│                                                                │呀。                                                                            │
│                                                                │陳：不好意思，我不會黏喔。                                                      │
│                                                                │張：對啊，對啊，我就說不要每天在一起，這樣喔，久久有人疼惜一下也不錯。          │
│                                                                │陳：久久這樣，但你知道嗎，變成你知道嗎，我跟你說你不要講，我現在到了下午我就有恐│
│                                                                │懼感都會關機，到下午我就關機了，你知道嗎…。                                    │
│                                                                │張：歡迎光臨。                                                                  │
│                                                                │陳：客人來了，你也不能說話了啦，好啦，你先去忙，有空我們再講喔，你不要說喔，等一│
│                                                                │下「他」可能問你那筆帳。                                                        │
│                                                                │張：好，好，OK。                                                                │
│                                                                │陳：別說我打給你。                                                              │
│                                                                │張：好。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│9.   2008/01/07  16:13:00   0000000000     接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○0路000號8 F頂"                                                 │
│                            局長戊○○            川順營造戴沼澤│戴：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：嗯，是。                                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：這個「江水」（音譯）有在這裡。                                              │
│                                                                │許：「江水」沒有，「江水」說去那個「阿弟仔」他家，在「阿水」、「阿水」。        │
│                                                                │戴：喔，喔，啊那個，啊這個誰，「阿忠」有到這裡來嗎。                            │
│                                                                │許：「阿忠」喔，「阿忠」他在那裡醉，但是沒有過來。                              │
│                                                                │戴：不然，我要過去嗎。                                                          │
│                                                                │許：都可以呀，來呀。                                                            │
│                                                                │戴：好。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：來呀，大家朋友在這裡。                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：好啦。                                                                      │
│                                                                │許：喔。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│10.  2008/01/07  16:16:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○0路000號8 F頂"                                                 │
│                           局長戊○○             Peter         │某男：我人在台中了，你人在哪裡。                                                │
│                                                                │許：你電話拿給那個PETER。                                                       │
│                                                                │某男：喔，我拿給PETER，好好好好，你稍等。                                       │
│                                                                │（某男將電話交予PETER）                                                         │
│                                                                │PETER：喂。                                                                     │
│                                                                │許：PETER呀。                                                                   │
│                                                                │某男：嗯。                                                                      │
│                                                                │許：新天地崇德店你知道嗎。                                                      │
│                                                                │P：新天地崇德店我知道。                                                         │
│                                                                │許：嗯，他後面1個「阿九」。                                                     │
│                                                                │P：後面1個「阿九」喔。                                                          │
│                                                                │許：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │P：「阿九」，好，好，好。                                                       │
│                                                                │許：你知道意思喔。                                                              │
│                                                                │P：我知道，我知道。                                                             │
│                                                                │許：OK，好。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│11.  2008/01/07  16:17:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○0路000號8 F頂"                                                 │
│                           局長戊○○                           │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│12.  2008/01/07  16:25:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │某女欲找戊○○，與戊○○約於新天地餐廳門口。                                    │
│                           局長戊○○             某女          │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│13.  2008/01/07  16:26:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │某女欲找戊○○，與戊○○約於新天地餐廳門口。                                    │
│                           局長戊○○             某女          │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│14.  2008/01/07  16:44:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │臺中市○○區○○0路000號8 F頂                                                   │
│                           九龍理容KTV張淑惠                    │短訊：姐: 妳排１０５的檯十桌有九桌都不會打槍的呢! 這一檔業績如果破十萬就給妳兩仟│
│                                                                │吃紅(別讓其她幹部知道,因為只有怡君姐姐妳戀                                      │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│15.  2008/01/07  16:49:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○0路000號8 F頂"                                                 │
│                           局長戊○○             某女          │某女已抵達新天地餐廳。                                                          │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│16.  2008/01/07  16:52:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○0路000號8 F頂"                                                 │
│                           局長戊○○                           │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│17.  2008/01/07  16:53:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○0路000號8 F頂"                                                 │
│                           局長戊○○             課長甲○○    │與第三河川局課長甲○○聯繫水利會申請「浮馬圳」（音譯）之河川供地使用事宜，並請回│
│                                                                │覆立委「陳傑」（音譯）。                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│18.  2008/01/07  16:55:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○0路000號8 F頂"                                                 │
│                           局長戊○○             課長甲○○    │與第三河川局課長甲○○聯繫水利會申請「浮馬圳」（音譯）之河川供地使用事宜，交待本│
│                                                                │日務必發文。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│19.  2008/01/07  16:56:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○0路000號8 F頂"                                                 │
│                           局長戊○○                           │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│20.  2008/01/07  17:23:00   0000000000     接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○0路000號8 F頂"                                                 │
│                            局長戊○○            配偶          │許：喂，喂，喂。                                                                │
│                                                                │妻：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：那個「第七的同事」上來，我來和他們吃飯。                                    │
│                                                                │妻：早點回來。                                                                  │
│                                                                │許：好啦。                                                                      │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│21.  2008/01/07  18:34:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │台中市○○區○○○路○段000號                                                   │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤                       │您有未接來電:                                                                   │
│                                                                │01/07 11:14AM來自0000000000 (0通)                                               │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│22.  2008/01/07  18:48:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○○路○段000號"                                                 │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         川順營造王莉婷│無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│23.  2008/01/07  18:49:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○○路○段000號"                                                 │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         川順營造王莉婷│無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│24.  2008/01/07  19:23:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○0路000號8 F頂"                                                 │
│                           九龍理容KTV徐玉玲      川順公司戴泱丞│戴：喂，親愛的「秀秀」。                                                        │
│                                                                     │徐：是。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：現在在「公司」喔。                                                          │
│                                                                │徐：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：你魯味何時可以吃啦，你說你們員林的魯味是何時啦。                            │
│                                                                │徐：喔，你不來，我…，有啦，現在也有魯味，我現在也有紅鞠香腸，你趕快過來，你趕快│
│                                                                │過來，但是「你爸」在這裡。                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：今天過去那裡喔。                                                            │
│                                                                │徐：對呀，對呀。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：今天就來我那個，後來，沒有啦，那，過來我工地呀。                            │
│                                                                │徐：誰。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：我們「老頭子」（台語音譯）就一些事情，跟大家過來，過來工地呀，他            │
│                                                                │們，我看看，「他們」過去我過去適合嗎。                                          │
│                                                                │徐：你看呢，不要緊呀，你要按摩也不要緊呀。                                      │
│                                                                │戴：沒有啦，這2天我也要過去呀，「阿忠」的事情也要先跟你處理一下。               │
│                                                                │徐：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：「他們」不就過去沒多久。                                                    │
│                                                                │徐：喔，很久了啦。                                                              │
│                                                                │戴：很久了。                                                                    │
│                                                                │徐：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：中午就吃飯吃完，不知道幾點去，我不知道「他們」幾點去，我不知道              │
│                                                                │幾點去。                                                                        │
│                                                                │徐：「他」跟「第七的」。                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：喔，好啦，看怎麼樣再和你聯絡。                                              │
│                                                                │徐：好，好，好，好，BYEBYE。                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│25.  2008/01/07  19:25:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○○路○段000號"                                                 │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤                       │短訊：買票的人抓賄選？被告江連福踐踏愛心糟蹋公益行動，愛心媽媽挺身而出譴責江連福│
│                                                                │，為規避賄選被告踐踏愛心胡亂栽贓，簡肇棟蒙受不白之冤，請鄉親評理。              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│26.  2008/01/07  19:46:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○○路○段000號"                                                 │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤                       │您有未接來電:                                                                   │
│                                                                │01/07 11:14AM來自0000000000 (0通)                                               │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│27.  2008/01/07  19:57:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │台中市○○區○○○路○段000號                                                   │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤                       │您有未接來電:                                                                   │
│                                                                │01/07 11:14AM來自0000000000 (0通)                                               │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│28.  2008/01/07  20:11:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │台中市○○區○○○路○段000號                                                   │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤                       │您有未接來電:                                                                   │
│                                                                │01/07 11:14AM來自0000000000 (0通)                                               │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│29.  2008/01/07  20:25:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │台中市○○區○○○路○段000號                                                   │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤                       │您有未接來電:                                                                   │
│                                                                │01/07 11:14AM來自0000000000 (0通)                                               │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│30.  2008/01/07  20:39:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │台中市○○區○○○路○段000號                                                   │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤                       │您有未接來電:                                                                   │
│                                                                │01/07 11:14AM來自0000000000 (0通)                                               │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│31.  2008/01/07  23:30:00  0000000000     接      0000000000    │（無人接聽）                                                                    │
│                           局長戊○○             九龍理容KTV編 │陳：好，OK了。                                                                  │
│                                                  號105號小姐陳 │                                                                                │
│                                                  瑤寰          │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│32.  2008/01/08  00:18:00  0000000000     接       0000000000   │無人接聽                                                                        │
│                           九龍理容KTV徐           九龍理容KTV編│                                                                                │
│                           玉玲                    號105號小姐陳│                                                                                │
│                                                   瑤寰         │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│33.  2008/01/08  00:19:00  0000000000     接       0000000000   │"臺中縣烏日鄉○○○段000000地號"                                                │
│                           九龍理容KTV徐           九龍理容KTV編│無人接聽                                                                        │
│                           玉玲                    號105號小姐陳│                                                                                │
│                                                   瑤寰         │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│34.  2008/01/08  00:19:00  0000000000     撥       0000000000   │"臺中縣烏日鄉○○路000號3F頂"                                                   │
│                           九龍理容KTV徐           九龍理容KTV編│無人接聽                                                                        │
│                           玉玲                    號105號小姐陳│                                                                                │
│                                                   瑤寰         │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│35.  2008/01/08  00:20:00  0000000000     接       0000000000   │"臺中縣烏日鄉○○路000號3F頂"                                                   │
│                           九龍理容KTV徐           九龍理容KTV編│徐：你好。                                                                      │
│                           玉玲                    號105號小姐陳│陳：喂，姊，我「105」。                                                         │
│                                                   瑤寰         │徐：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：那個，那個「局長」剛才，對不對。                                            │
│                                                                │徐：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：4點嘛，對不對。                                                             │
│                                                                │徐：對。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：喔，我有送他回去，你有開到車了嗎。                                          │
│                                                                │徐：有，有。                                                                    │
│                                                                │陳：有喔，好喔，我有送他回家了。                                                │
│                                                                │徐：妹妹，有「處理」吧。                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │徐：有沒有「處理」。                                                            │
│                                                                │陳：有呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │徐：有喔，因為比較就是。                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：「『他』還問我說買到幾點」，我說4點嘛，對不對。                             │
│                                                                │徐：對，嗯。                                                                    │
│                                                                │陳：對，對，對。                                                                │
│                                                                │徐：喔，好。                                                                    │
└────────────────────────────────┴────────────────────────────────────────┘

┌────────────────────────────────┬────────────────────────────────────────┐
│編號 日期        時間      監聽電話       撥/接   對方電話      │通聯內容摘要                                                                備註│
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│1.   2008/01/14  11:14:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○路○段000巷00號16F屋頂"                                        │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         水利署科長林榮│戴沼澤邀林榮紹過來「天祥街」                                                    │
│                                                  紹            │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│2.   2008/01/14  11:26:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"未提供"                                                                        │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         第三河川局彭壽│第三河川局彭壽奇：喂。                                                          │
│                                                  奇            │戴：喂，彭主任喔。                                                              │
│                                                                │彭：嗯，怎麼樣。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：我董仔。                                                                    │
│                                                                │彭：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：嗯，在哪裡。                                                                │
│                                                                │彭：我在辦公廳。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：喔，啊，要進去「工地」嗎。                                                  │
│                                                                │彭：工地，好呀。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：還是，還是，不然到「天祥街」來啦，我一些事情跟                              │
│                                                                │你跟你研究看看一下，看可行性否。                                                │
│                                                                │彭：喔，這樣要工地好了，來工地。                                                │
│                                                                │戴：要工地喔。                                                                  │
│                                                                │彭：嗯，嗯。                                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：不過等林榮紹，我順便要給他、給他、給他、給他、給他、跟他撟一下，撟一下，撟一│
│                                                                │下我們這個角度。                                                                │
│                                                                │彭：好呀，好呀，好呀，看怎麼樣，約幾點。                                        │
│                                                                │戴：…這樣，不然我們來吃飯一下，不然來「野店」吃啦。                            │
│                                                                │彭：好，好，好。                                                                │
│                                                                │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│3.   2008/01/14  11:27:00  0000000000      撥     00000000000   │"台中市○○區○○路○段000巷00號16F屋頂"                                        │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         水利署科長林榮│林：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                  紹            │戴：中午我有叫「彭壽奇」來「野店」啦。                                          │
│                                                                │林：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：來「野店」啦。                                                              │
│                                                                │林：喔，我知，嗯。                                                              │
│                                                                │戴：嗯，出來沒，出來了嗎。                                                      │
│                                                                │林：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：出來，好，好。                                                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│4.   2008/01/14  11:27:00  00000000000     接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號 1F"                                                │
│                           水利署科長林榮         川順營造戴沼澤│林：喂。                                                                        │
│                           紹                                   │戴：中午我有叫「彭壽奇」來「野店」啦。                                          │
│                                                                │林：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：來「野店」啦。                                                              │
│                                                                │林：喔，我知，嗯。                                                              │
│                                                                │戴：嗯，出來沒，出來了嗎。                                                      │
│                                                                │林：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：出來，好，好。                                                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│5.   2008/01/14  11:29:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○路○段000巷00號16F屋頂"                                        │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         川順營造戴泱丞│川順營造頭汴坑工務所女職員：喂，川順，喂。                                      │
│                                                                │戴沼澤：喂。                                                                    │
│                                                                │女：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴沼澤：「副總」有在那裡嗎。                                                    │
│                                                                │ 女：喔，等一下喔，「副總」電話喔。                                             │
│                                                                │（女職員將電話交予副總）                                                        │
│                                                                │戴泱丞：喂。                                                                    │
│                                                                │戴沼澤：你把那張圖喔，那張我說現在要、要，用那個、那個、那個「鋼柵」那個部分那段│
│                                                                │的那圖喔，看要拿過來給我還是怎麼，我叫「彭壽奇」往這裡過來，我跟他們研究看看。  │
│                                                                │戴泱丞：好呀，好。                                                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│6.   2008/01/14  13:13:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │新竹市○區○○路00號7 F                                                         │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │短訊：老公你忙啦不用陪我玩沒關係﹒我不要你這樣趕來趕去﹒回家開踀                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│7.   2008/01/14  13:26:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"台中市○區○○○○鄰○○路0號五樓頂及屋凸"                                     │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         水土保持局第二│（電話撥通前，戴沼澤行動電話傳出林榮紹談話聲）                                  │
│                                                  工程所所長丁振│林榮紹：我帶完，我帶完又帶去玩女人耶，我沒黑白講耶…                            │
│                                                  章            │（電話通聯後）                                                                  │
│                                                                │行政院農業委員會水土保持局第二工程所所長丁振章：喂，我在忙，不好意思…          │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│8.   2008/01/14  15:09:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○路○段0號5F頂"                                               │
│                           水利署科長林榮紹                     │（無人接聽，林榮紹旁傳出戴沼澤談話聲）                                          │
│                                                                │戴沼澤：過來這裡喝，那個是他們的啦，我們常常半年喔喔喔，啊就那個下來下來，也有我│
│                                                                │們自己的對否。                                                                  │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│9.   2008/01/14  15:10:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○路○段0號5F頂"                                               │
│                           水利署科長林榮紹                     │撥打水利署林森興電話未果                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│10.  2008/01/14  15:11:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○路○段000巷00號16F屋頂"                                        │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         川順廉裕隆    │廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：你現在弄好沒。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：喔，有些還要弄那個，現在要載他們回去。                                      │
│                                                                │戴：好啦，好啦。                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│11.  2008/01/14  15:11:00  0000000000      接      0000000000   │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           川順廉裕隆              川順營造戴沼 │廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：你現在弄好沒。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：喔，有些還要弄那個，現在要載他們回去。                                      │
│                                                                │戴：好啦，好啦。                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│12.  2008/01/14  15:42:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │林榮紹向配偶表示在「戴先生」這裡，已從「天祥街」離開，現在要去「頭汴坑」工地    │
│                           水利署科長林榮紹       配偶          │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│13.  2008/01/14  16:40:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段0000號8F頂"                                        │
│                           川順廉裕隆             九龍理容KTV張 │與女友張淑惠閒聊，廉裕隆詢問戴沼澤和「阿忠」有無去九龍理容KTV，張淑惠表示不知道 │
│                                                  淑惠          │。                                                                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│14.  2008/01/14  17:08:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○○路○段000號"                                                 │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤                       │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│15.  2008/01/14  17:47:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○○路○段000號"                                                 │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤                       │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│16.  2008/01/14  17:48:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │台中市○○區○○○路○段000號                                                   │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤                       │1/2                                                                             │
│                                                                │您有未接來電:                                                                   │
│                                                                │01/11 09:21PM來自0000000000 (0通)                                               │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│17.  2008/01/14  17:55:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │無人接聽                                                                        │
│                           水利署科長林榮紹                     │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│18.  2008/01/14  17:58:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │無人接聽                                                                        │
│                           水利署科長林榮紹                     │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│19.  2008/01/14  18:00:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │無人接聽                                                                        │
│                           水利署科長林榮紹                     │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│20.  2008/01/14  18:00:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │台中市○○區○○○路○段000號                                                   │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤                       │1/2                                                                             │
│                                                                │您有未接來電:                                                                   │
│                                                                │01/11 09:21PM來自0000000000 (0通)                                               │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│21.  2008/01/14  18:02:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │林榮紹配偶：喂，喂。                                                            │
│                           水利署科長林榮紹       配偶          │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│22.  2008/01/14  18:03:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │林榮紹配偶：喂。                                                                │
│                           水利署科長林榮紹       配偶          │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│23.  2008/01/14  18:03:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           川順廉裕隆             林榮紹配偶    │廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林榮紹配偶某女：喂。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：嗯，大嫂。                                                                  │
│                                                                │女：嗯，?先生。                                                                 │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │女：啊，「科長」有沒有和你們在一起。                                            │
│                                                                │廉：沒有耶，我剛從工地出來，剛從「天祥街」出來。                                │
│                                                                │女：你從「天祥街」出來。                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │女：啊，「他」不是去你們工地。                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：對呀，中午有在一起呀，啊後來我有事情，我就先走。                            │
│                                                                │女：啊，他跟誰走，剛才都是KTV的聲音，他跟誰。                                   │
│                                                                │廉：嗯，我聯絡看看。                                                            │
│                                                                │女：跟你「舅舅」喔。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：不知道有沒有，我就回來，他們就都走了。                                      │
│                                                                │女：啊，然後他4點說他要去工地，怎麼現在跑去KTV，好奇怪喔。                      │
│                                                                │廉：我問看看啦，我問看看。                                                      │
│                                                                │女：麻煩你，麻煩你打電話給我，因為他剛剛都是那個KTV的聲音。                     │
│                                                                │廉：好，好，好。                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│24.  2008/01/14  18:05:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │林榮紹配偶：林榮紹，「臭耳人」（台語）你呀。                                    │
│                           水利署科長林榮紹       配偶          │（現場女侍嘻鬧聲）                                                              │
│                                                                │女侍：…回去，回去，回去。                                                      │
│                                                                │林榮紹配偶：幹什麼呀。                                                          │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│25.  2008/01/14  18:06:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○○路○段000號"                                                 │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         林榮紹配偶    │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│26.  2008/01/14  18:07:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │無人接聽                                                                        │
│                           水利署科長林榮紹       配偶          │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│27.  2008/01/14  18:07:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │女侍：你要唱歌。                                                                │
│                           水利署科長林榮紹       配偶          │林榮紹配偶：喂。                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│28.  2008/01/14  18:08:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           川順廉裕隆             林榮紹配偶    │廉裕隆向林榮紹配偶表示還沒聯絡到林榮紹。                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│29.  2008/01/14  18:09:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │無人接聽                                                                        │
│                           水利署科長林榮紹       配偶          │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│30.  2008/01/14  18:09:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │無人接聽                                                                        │
│                           水利署科長林榮紹       配偶          │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│31.  2008/01/14  18:11:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │無人接聽                                                                        │
│                           水利署科長林榮紹       配偶          │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│32.  2008/01/14  18:11:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │無人接聽                                                                        │
│                           水利署科長林榮紹       配偶          │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│33.  2008/01/14  18:13:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │無人接聽                                                                        │
│                           水利署科長林榮紹       配偶          │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│34.  2008/01/14  18:14:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │無人接聽                                                                        │
│                           水利署科長林榮紹       配偶          │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│35.  2008/01/14  18:16:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │無人接聽                                                                        │
│                           水利署科長林榮紹       配偶          │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│36.  2008/01/14  18:16:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │無人接聽                                                                        │
│                           水利署科長林榮紹       配偶          │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│37.  2008/01/14  18:17:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │無人接聽                                                                        │
│                           水利署科長林榮紹       配偶          │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│38.  2008/01/14  18:18:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │無人接聽                                                                        │
│                           水利署科長林榮紹       配偶          │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│39.  2008/01/14  18:19:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │無人接聽                                                                        │
│                           水利署科長林榮紹       配偶          │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│40.  2008/01/14  18:34:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○0路000號8 F頂"                                                 │
│                           九龍理容KTV張淑惠      川順廉裕隆    │張：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉裕隆：嗯，清醒了喔。                                                          │
│                                                                │張：沒有啦，還在喝。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：我是說你比較清醒了喔。                                                      │
│                                                                │張：有休息一下子。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：嗯。在忙，你不是去找「他們」了喔。                                          │
│                                                                │廉：對呀，剛要去。                                                              │
│                                                                │張：要去哪一間。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：就以前你要去那間。                                                          │
│                                                                │張：「寶麗晶」。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：喔，少喝一點啦。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：我去我不會啦，不會喝啦。                                                    │
│                                                                │張：不會喝喔。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：「人家」剛才電話催，電話，有1個電話這樣打的「砰磅叫」（台語音譯）           │
│                                                                │張：誰。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：沒有你看那個麵不是重做…                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：好啦，少喝一點，喔。                                                        │
│                                                                │張：好。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│41.  2008/01/14  18:38:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路00號5F"                                                      │
│                           水利署科長林榮紹       配偶          │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│42.  2008/01/14  18:54:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │台中市○○區○○○路○段000號                                                   │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤                       │1/2                                                                             │
│                                                                │您有未接來電:                                                                   │
│                                                                │01/11 09:21PM來自0000000000 (0通)                                               │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│43.  2008/01/14  19:10:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000號5F頂"                                         │
│                           水利署科長林榮紹                     │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│44.  2008/01/14  19:12:00  0000000000      撥     000000000     │"臺中市○○區○○街000號12F頂"                                                  │
│                           水利署科長林榮紹       配偶          │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│45.  2008/01/14  19:12:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │台中市○○區○○○路○段000號1/2                                                │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤                       │您有未接來電:                                                                   │
│                                                                │01/11 09:21PM來自0000000000 (0通)                                               │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│46.  2008/01/14  19:30:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○0路000號8 F頂"                                                 │
│                           九龍理容KTV徐玉玲                    │某女向「秀秀」表示某人現在要過去了，應該到門口了。                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│47.  2008/01/14  19:31:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○0路000號8 F頂"                                                 │
│                           九龍理容KTV張淑惠      川順廉裕隆    │張淑惠：喂。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：很怕被你處理。                                                              │
│                                                                │張：你要回去了，對不對。                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：嗯，我要趕快回去。                                                          │
│                                                                │張：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：我很怕被你處理，我要趕快回去。                                              │
│                                                                │張：好呀，回去呀。「忠哥」他們來，和「彭大哥」啦。                              │
│                                                                │廉：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：「忠哥」來啦。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：又過去了。                                                                  │
│                                                                │張：對呀，他說不能跟任何人說他來。                                              │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：他說不能跟任何人說他來。                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：啊，我不是人。                                                              │
│                                                                │張：你又不會跟他講，跟我也沒有關係。                                            │
│                                                                │廉：他自己，還是。                                                              │
│                                                                │張：跟「彭大哥」，姓「彭的」。                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：我知道，我知道，嗯，嗯，又在追了。                                          │
│                                                                │張：對呀。啊，人家9點要下班說，你要回去了，要好好跟你處理說。人家今天9點就下班說│
│                                                                │。                                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：不早一點講。                                                                │
│                                                                │張：你要回家了。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：不早一點講。                                                                │
│                                                                │張：我要怎麼跟你講，叫你…，下班就下班了呀，我想說你去那裡最少坐2個鐘頭，…。   │
│                                                                │廉：晚上10點還要來說。                                                          │
│                                                                │張：要豬屎。人家9點下班說，我想說你去那裡最少坐2個鐘頭，我要跟你講，我說你今天最│
│                                                                │好喝醉，…來看看。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：我下午我就不要去，我知道他們一定，整群一定又跑去，我才問你說是不是去「你們那│
│                                                                │裡」，我想說會去你們那裡。                                                      │
│                                                                │張：他現在和「彭大哥」2個進來呀，說不能和任何人說他來呀。                       │
│                                                                │廉：嗯，又在追了呀。                                                            │
│                                                                │張：你開到哪裡了。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：我載我們「董仔」回來了。                                                    │
│                                                                │張：公司喔。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：公司。                                                                      │
│                                                                │張：這樣我要去追酒了。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：你不要再追了。                                                              │
│                                                                │張：不要，我這時間本來就想追酒…，好啦，你回家啦，我要去追酒了。                │
│                                                                │廉：好啦。                                                                      │
│                                                                │張：好啦，好啦，知道了，BYEBYE。                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│48.  2008/01/14  19:38:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○0路000號8 F頂"                                                 │
│                           九龍理容KTV徐玉玲      川順戴泱丞    │戴泱丞：喂。                                                                    │
│                                                                │徐：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │徐：親愛的。                                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：親愛的，怎麼樣。                                                            │
│                                                                │徐：那個。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：…我有收到呀。                                                              │
│                                                                │徐：我知道啦。那個誰找你啦，那個「澎湖來的朋友」啦，「澎湖來的朋友」找你。      │
│                                                                │戴：啊，他跟我們裡面的人去嗎。                                                  │
│                                                                │徐：嗯，他跟「忠哥」。                                                          │
│                                                                │戴：嗯，好呀，啊，我們「老仔」，「那個」走了。                                  │
│                                                                │徐：沒有來。                                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：喔，這樣喔。                                                                │
│                                                                │徐：對。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：好啦。                                                                      │
│                                                                │徐：只有他們2個。                                                               │
│                                                                │戴：好啦，好啦。                                                                │
│                                                                │徐：「澎湖來的朋友」這樣知道啦喔。                                              │
│                                                                │戴：好，好啦，好啦。                                                            │
│                                                                │徐：喔，喔，好，好，好。                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：好。                                                                        │
│                                                                │徐：「他」叫我跟你打的啦喔。                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：好啦，好啦。                                                                │
│                                                                │徐：好，BYEBYE。                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│49.  2008/01/14  20:10:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○0路000號8 F頂"                                                 │
│                           九龍理容KTV徐玉玲      川順戴泱丞    │徐：哈囉。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴泱丞：你1張開初1還是初2的，啊。                                               │
│                                                                │徐：你說什麼。                                                                  │
│                                                                │戴：有1張開初1還是初2的啦。                                                     │
│                                                                │徐：喔，不要緊，不然你走出來好不好。                                            │
│                                                                │戴：好啦。                                                                      │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│50.  2008/01/14  20:35:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○0路000號8 F頂"                                                 │
│                           九龍理容KTV徐玉玲      營造公司張啟晃│（指彭壽奇持用徐玉玲行動電話與張啟晃通聯）                                      │
│                           第三河川局彭壽奇                     │營造公司張啟晃：喂。                                                            │
│                                                                │徐玉玲：胖嘟嘟。                                                                │
│                                                                │張：胖嘟嘟，在減肥了啦。                                                        │
│                                                                │徐：減肥，早就該減了，肚子那麼大，能看嗎。                                      │
│                                                                │張：快生了啦。                                                                  │
│                                                                │徐：明天有要給「楓之林」請尾牙嗎。                                              │
│                                                                │張：明天喔，明天我在新竹吃尾牙耶。                                              │
│                                                                │徐：這樣禮拜4來給我請喔。                                                       │
│                                                                │張：我一定去你那裡。                                                            │
│                                                                │徐：因為有1個「澎湖來的朋友」，我有跟他講，他說好。                             │
│                                                                │張：有遇到我「澎湖的朋友」嗎。                                                  │
│                                                                │徐：有呀，他現在在我旁邊呀。                                                    │
│                                                                │張：好。                                                                        │
│                                                                │徐：你等一下，我叫他跟你講，你等一下喔。                                        │
│                                                                │張：好。                                                                        │
│                                                                │（徐玉玲將電話交予彭壽奇，徐玉玲背景有KTV音樂）                                 │
│                                                                │彭：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：大仔，你不要殺了我。                                                        │
│                                                                │彭：你不來我要殺了你。                                                          │
│                                                                │張：我一定去，我一定去。                                                        │
│                                                                │彭：嗯，17號。                                                                  │
│                                                                │張：17號。                                                                      │
│                                                                │彭：好好好，你要來載我。                                                        │
│                                                                │張：我會挺著大肚子去啦。                                                        │
│                                                                │彭：挺著大肚子，為什麼。                                                        │
│                                                                │張：「秀秀」講的，我肚子愈來愈大，好。                                          │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│51.  2008/01/14  20:59:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○0路000號8 F頂"                                                 │
│                           九龍理容KTV徐玉玲                    │聯繫「103」包廂事宜                                                             │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│52.  2008/01/14  21:13:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │臺中市○○區○○0路000號8 F頂                                                   │
│                           九龍理容KTV徐玉玲                    │短訊：妳有吃飯嗎？請妳吃火錀                                                    │
└────────────────────────────────┴────────────────────────────────────────┘
┌────────────────────────────────┬────────────────────────────────────────┐
│編號 日期        時間      監聽電話       撥/接   對方電話      │通聯內容摘要                                                                備註│
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│1.   2008/01/16  14:25:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段0000號8F頂"                                        │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         金拿獎視聽歌唱│廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                  坊陳秀月(綽號 │阿華：喂，等一下。                                                              │
│                                                  ：阿華)       │（陳秀月將電話交予林榮紹，水利署科長林榮紹持用金拿獎視聽歌唱坊陳秀月行動電話與? │
│                                                  水利署科長林榮│裕隆通聯）                                                                      │
│                                                  紹            │林榮紹：喂，「隆仔」。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：有。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：嗯，跟我們「副座」在，在，在台北，「阿華這裡」啦。                          │
│                                                                │廉：好呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │林：啊，我們副座是說他，他要做「組長」了，你，你「舅舅」看要不要來。            │
│                                                                │廉：喔，他出去啦。                                                              │
│                                                                │林：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：出去啦。                                                                    │
│                                                                │林：出去喔。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：嗯，中午就，約1點那時就出去了。                                             │
│                                                                │林：沒有，他剛才有打給我耶。                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：對呀，就出去了。                                                            │
│                                                                │林：喔喔喔。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：「阿如」載。                                                                │
│                                                                │林：喔，好啦。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：喔，好。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│2.   2008/01/16  14:29:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"台中市○區○○路000號12樓頂"                                                   │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         水利署壬○○  │戴：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │：戴董。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │葉：你在哪裡。                                                                  │
│                                                                │戴：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │葉：我，我壬○○。                                                              │
│                                                                │戴：嗯，你怎麼好像「醉聲醉聲」（台語音譯）。                                    │
│                                                                │葉：沒有啦，沒有啦，哪有醉。                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：沒有喔。                                                                    │
│                                                                │葉：啊，你人在哪裡。                                                            │
│                                                                │戴：我人在「天祥街」。                                                          │
│                                                                │葉：「天祥街」喔。                                                              │
│                                                                │戴：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │葉：哇，你在賭博喔。                                                            │
│                                                                │戴：你難道沒有聽到聲音嗎。                                                      │
│                                                                │葉：沒有啦，哪有聽到，這樣，這樣叫「阿隆」來可以嗎。                            │
│                                                                │戴：好呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │葉：好嗎。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：好，好。                                                                    │
│                                                                │葉：來「3字」的好不好。                                                         │
│                                                                │戴：好，好啦，好。                                                              │
│                                                                │葉：好嗎。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：好。                                                                        │
│                                                                │葉：「金拿獎」喔。                                                              │
│                                                                │戴：好。                                                                        │
│                                                                │葉：好。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│3.   2008/01/16  14:32:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         金拿獎視聽歌唱│金拿獎視聽歌唱坊「阿華」：喂。                                                  │
│                                                  坊陳秀月(綽號 │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                  ：阿華)       │女：啊，「董仔」有沒有打電話給你。                                              │
│                                                                │廉：怎麼。                                                                      │
│                                                                │女：我說「董仔」有沒有打電話給你。                                              │
│                                                                │廉：沒有耶。                                                                    │
│                                                                │女：說叫你過來。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：誰說的。                                                                    │
│                                                                │女：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：我現在有客人在這裡，你說誰說的。                                            │
│                                                                │女：「葉仔」說的呀。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：叫我過去。                                                                  │
│                                                                │女：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：他打電話跟他講。                                                            │
│                                                                │女：打電話給你們「董仔」，你們「董仔」在打麻將呀。                              │
│                                                                │廉：喔，我不知道啦，就出去了。                                                  │
│                                                                │女：現在呢，要「怎麼處理」。                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：不要緊啦，你就在那裡就一樣就看多少再說呀，喔。                              │
│                                                                │女：喔，好啦，這樣我知道啦。                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：「他們2個」而已嗎。                                                         │
│                                                                │女：嗯，他們2個而已，嗯。                                                       │
│                                                                │廉：喔，好啦，好啦，好啦，我現在，我有客人在這裡啦，你說我剛好客人在這裡。      │
│                                                                │女：喔，好，好。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：好，好。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│4.   2008/01/16  14:46:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         金拿獎視聽歌唱│金拿獎視聽歌唱坊阿華表示要?裕隆打電話給「葉仔」                                 │
│                                                  坊陳秀月(綽號 │                                                                                │
│                                                  ：阿華)       │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│5.   2008/01/16  14:47:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中縣太平市○○路000巷00號7樓頂"                                              │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         水利署壬○○  │水利署工程事務組副組長壬○○：喂。                                              │
│                                                                │廉：「副座」。                                                                  │
│                                                                │葉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：阿隆。                                                                      │
│                                                                │葉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │葉：啊，你人在哪裡。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：我就在「天祥街」呀，剛好有人來在這裡。                                      │
│                                                                │葉：但是你們「董仔」說要交代你這樣，是怎麼。                                    │
│                                                                │廉：會啦，會啦。                                                                │
│                                                                │葉：我找你就是，我在找你就是，啊。                                              │
│                                                                │廉：我跟「阿華」講了，我就剛好有人來這裡。                                      │
│                                                                │葉：喔，你跟，你現在愈做愈大。                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：沒有啦，副座你不要這樣刮我，不要這樣挖苦我嘛。                              │
│                                                                │葉：我挖誰呀，你神經病呀你。                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │葉：我還要你們支援，什麼挖苦。                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：唉唷，你沒有問題啦，是眾望所歸。                                            │
│                                                                │葉：你沒有問題，好，謝謝你。不是，我是說喝了酒我都找你，就是意思說對不起你，這樣│
│                                                                │子啦。                                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：怎麼會對不起我。                                                            │
│                                                                │葉：對不起你啦。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：沒有找我去喝酒這樣喔。                                                      │
│                                                                │葉：對呀，吃飯的時候沒有找你，我有跟你們「老董」講，說抱歉抱歉，剛喝酒沒有找你這│
│                                                                │樣子。                                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：不會啦，不會啦，不會啦。                                                    │
│                                                                │葉：啊，你什麼時候來。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：我忙完，忙完就。                                                            │
│                                                                │葉：麻煩誰。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │葉：你麻煩誰。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：不是，我如果忙完啦，忙完我看，我會打電話給那個「阿華」看你們還在那邊嗎，喔。│
│                                                                │葉：你是什麼意思呀，你這樣子不好吧。                                            │
│                                                                │廉：我現在有，剛好有。                                                          │
│                                                                │葉：我知道，我知道。好好好，我知道，好，好。                                    │
│                                                                │廉：好。                                                                        │
│                                                                │葉：好，謝謝你，謝謝你。                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：好，謝謝。                                                                  │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│6.   2008/01/16  14:55:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         金拿獎視聽歌唱│金拿獎視聽歌唱坊阿華：喂。                                                      │
│                                                  坊陳秀月(綽號 │廉：我有打給「他」。                                                            │
│                                                  ：阿華)       │女：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │女：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：我，嗯，若晚一點，我人在工地啦喔，若晚一點沒有過去，他們要，看多少再跟我講一│
│                                                                │下就好了。                                                                      │
│                                                                │女：OK，好，沒有啦，常叫我打，多麻煩。                                          │
│                                                                │廉：我知道，我知道，我知道，我知道，我知道他。                                  │
│                                                                │女：好，好，好。                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│7.   2008/01/16  15:00:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市南屯區向上路二段1"                                                       │
│                           水利署科長林榮紹       水利署工程事務│林：煒仔。                                                                      │
│                                                  組李傳煒      │水利署工程事務組李傳煒：嗯，科長。                                              │
│                                                                │林：我桌上有1個黃色的盒子裡面，在我的書上有1個盒子，有那個「周世傑」的大哥大，「│
│                                                                │副座」現在要CALL他，你把大哥大查看看，打電話。                                  │
│                                                                │李：你說放在哪裡。                                                              │
│                                                                │林：放在我，有否，放在我的書有沒有，前面那排那資料有沒有，書呀，上面有1個黃色的 │
│                                                                │盒子。                                                                          │
│                                                                │李：黃色的盒子。                                                                │
│                                                                │林：嗯。黃色的盒子，裡面有一些電話。                                            │
│                                                                │李：桌上嗎。                                                                    │
│                                                                │林：在桌上，對對，桌上，對。                                                    │
│                                                                │李：好好，我看看，好，好。                                                      │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│8.   2008/01/16  15:02:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市南屯區向上路二段1"                                                       │
│                           水利署科長林榮紹       水利署工程事務│水利署工程事務組李傳煒回覆周世傑行動電話號碼                                    │
│                                                  組李傳煒      │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│9.   2008/01/16  15:11:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │台中市○區○○路000號12樓頂                                                     │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤                       │1/6                                                                             │
│                                                                │您有未接來電:                                                                   │
│                                                                │01/13 10:26PM來自0000000000 (0通)                                               │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│10.  2008/01/16  15:14:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段0000號8F頂"                                        │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造戴永恭│戴永恭表示有聯繫陳某處理                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│11.  2008/01/16  16:08:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市南屯區向上路二段1"                                                       │
│                           水利署科長林榮紹       川順營造廉裕隆│廉：「科長」。                                                                  │
│                                                                │林：「隆仔」。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：有。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：喔，我們，你沒來我們，「我們副座」生氣了，你有空嗎。                        │
│                                                                │廉：我就剛才，客人剛走。                                                        │
│                                                                │林：喔，這樣不然你過來。                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：好。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：坐一坐啦。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：好。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：跟我說的「很鹹」（台語音譯）。                                              │
│                                                                │廉：好，好。                                                                    │
│                                                                │林：喔，好。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│12.  2008/01/16  16:08:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         水利署科長林榮│廉：「科長」。                                                                  │
│                                                  紹            │林：「隆仔」。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：有。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：喔，我們，你沒來我們，「我們副座」生氣了，你有空嗎。                        │
│                                                                │廉：我就剛才，客人剛走。                                                        │
│                                                                │林：喔，這樣不然你過來。                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：好。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：坐一坐啦。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：好。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：跟我說的「很鹹」（台語音譯）。                                              │
│                                                                │廉：好，好。                                                                    │
│                                                                │林：喔，好。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│13.  2008/01/16  16:10:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市北屯區南京東路三段"                                                      │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         花旗銀行人員  │與花旗銀行電話行銷人員通聯                                                      │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│14.  2008/01/16  16:36:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市南屯區向上路二段1"                                                       │
│                           水利署科長林榮紹       川順營造廉裕隆│林：「隆仔」。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：到哪裡了。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：到「3字」的前面這裡。                                                       │
│                                                                │林：喔，我，我今日「泡沫很大」耶，泡沫。                                        │
│                                                                │廉：什麼很大。                                                                  │
│                                                                │林：喔，夭壽，整個財產都拿出來，但是財產沒有很多，哈哈哈。（指林榮紹表示未帶錢）│
│                                                                │廉：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：哈哈哈哈。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：好啦。                                                                      │
│                                                                │林：好啦，好啦，好啦，好，好。                                                  │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│15.  2008/01/16  16:37:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │林：「隆仔」。                                                                  │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         水利署科長林榮│廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                  紹            │林：到哪裡了。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：到「3字」的前面這裡。                                                       │
│                                                                │林：喔，我，我今日「泡沫很大」耶，泡沫。                                        │
│                                                                │廉：什麼很大。                                                                  │
│                                                                │林：喔，夭壽，整個財產都拿出來，但是財產沒有很多，哈哈哈。                      │
│                                                                │廉：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：哈哈哈哈。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：好啦。                                                                      │
│                                                                │林：好啦，好啦，好啦，好，好。                                                  │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│16.  2008/01/16  16:46:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市南屯區向上路二段1"                                                       │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆                       │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│17.  2008/01/16  16:47:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市南屯區向上路二段1"                                                       │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         某男          │某男表示不小心按到電話                                                          │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│18.  2008/01/16  17:00:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市南屯區向上路二段1"                                                       │
│                           水利署科長林榮         水利署林森興  │向水利署工程事務組林森興表示來不及回去                                          │
│                           紹                                   │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│19.  2008/01/16  17:03:00  0000000000      接     000000000     │"臺中市南屯區向上路二段1"                                                       │
│                           水利署科長林榮         配偶          │妻：喂。                                                                        │
│                           紹                                   │林：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │妻：下班了喔。                                                                  │
│                                                                │林：嗯，我，我等一下就回去了，嗯，我和「副座」出來外面一下，嗯。                │
│                                                                │妻：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：我和「副座」外面一下，嗯。                                                  │
│                                                                │妻：要回去吃飯。                                                                │
│                                                                │林：嗯，對。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│20.  2008/01/16  17:32:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○街0號9樓頂"                                                │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         配偶          │廉裕隆與妻聯繫                                                                  │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│21.  2008/01/16  17:39:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號9樓頂"                                              │
│                           九龍理容KTV張淑惠      川順營造廉裕隆│廉裕隆向張淑惠表示要回去了                                                      │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│22.  2008/01/16  17:39:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市南屯區環中路四段2"                                                       │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         九龍理容KTV張 │廉裕隆向張淑惠表示要回去了                                                      │
│                                                  淑惠          │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│23.  2008/01/16  17:49:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○路○段000巷00號16F屋頂"                                        │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         川順營造廉裕隆│廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：嗯。啊，啊這個，「那個」沒和你聯絡喔。                                      │
│                                                                │廉：有呀，結束了。                                                              │
│                                                                │戴：啊，喔。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：結束了，嗯。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：林榮紹有去嗎。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：有呀，我就約要4點多才到，後來又叫，叫那個誰，叫「周世傑」去。               │
│                                                                │戴：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：嗯，都結束了，約5點、5點半就結束了。                                        │
│                                                                │戴：喔，啊，那個，那個，那個叫「保林仔」（音譯）沒打電話喔，還沒有喔。          │
│                                                                │廉：沒有。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：看怎麼再聯絡。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：好。                                                                        │
│                                                                │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│24.  2008/01/16  17:49:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中縣神岡鄉○○村○○路000號3樓"                                              │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造戴沼澤│廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：嗯。啊，啊這個，「那個」沒和你聯絡喔。                                      │
│                                                                │廉：有呀，結束了。                                                              │
│                                                                │戴：啊，喔。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：結束了，嗯。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：林榮紹有去嗎。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：有呀，我就約要4點多才到，後來又叫，叫那個誰，叫「周世傑」（指水利署河川勘測 │
│                                                                │隊周世傑）去。                                                                  │
│                                                                │戴：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：嗯，都結束了，約5點、5點半就結束了。                                        │
│                                                                │戴：喔，啊，那個，那個，那個叫「保林仔」（音譯）沒打電話喔，還沒有喔。          │
│                                                                │廉：沒有。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：看怎麼再聯絡。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：好。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│25.  2008/02/18  13:33:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路00號6F頂"                                                    │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         金拿獎視聽歌唱│廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                  坊陳秀月(綽號 │金拿獎視聽歌唱坊陳秀月：喂，在忙嗎。                                            │
│                                                  ：阿華)       │廉：過年完了才在打電話。                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：為什麼說過年完了才在打電話。                                                │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：還沒過耶。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：過了。                                                                      │
│                                                                │陳：15了嗎。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：你鄉下算。                                                                  │
│                                                                │陳：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：你鄉下人，過到15。                                                          │
│                                                                │陳：喔，為什麼叫鄉下人，你說那什麼話。                                          │
│                                                                │廉：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：啊，喔，是喔，有分喔。                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：啊，過年走哪裡玩。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：去那個海底、水底寮呀。                                                      │
│                                                                │陳：吹牛。                                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：水底寮呀，怎麼吹牛。                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：你有去那裡玩。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：有呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │陳：吹牛，在那裡塞車，去那裡塞車。                                              │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：吹牛，你有去那裡，你們「董仔」不是出國，回來了不是。                        │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：麻煩你一下，「換現金」。                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：是沒多少。                                                                  │
│                                                                │陳：2萬多呀。                                                                   │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：好啦，好啦，好啦。                                                          │
│                                                                │陳：謝謝啦，喔，好，好，BYEBYE。                                                │
└────────────────────────────────┴────────────────────────────────────────┘

┌────────────────────────────────┬────────────────────────────────────────┐
│編號 日期        時間      監聽電話       撥/接   對方電話      │通聯內容摘要                                                                備註│
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│1.   2008/02/12  14:07:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           局長戊○○            楓之林理容KTV編│楊：喂，新年快樂。                                                              │
│                                                 號66號小姐楊雅 │許：好快樂喔。                                                                  │
│                                                 惠             │楊：你真的，你過年都在幹嘛。                                                    │
│                                                                │許：我說你現在有沒有空呀，要不要過來喝酒呀。                                    │
│                                                                │楊：我現在不行，因為剛剛那個公司打電話來說，好像就是有客人不知道要帶5個小姐去哪 │
│                                                                │裡，那個客人我也不曉得是誰。                                                    │
│                                                                │許：那你不要，你就算我的，你就直接過來就好了。                                  │
│                                                                │楊：要喝酒喔。                                                                  │
│                                                                │許：不然咧。                                                                    │
│                                                                │楊：喔，你會不會把我灌醉，哈哈哈。啊，不行，不行，對，我記得了，你，每次坐你旁邊│
│                                                                │只要朋友敬你，我都要拿起來喝，乾杯，乾杯，沒有，我要先進去看一下，因為我剛剛已經│
│                                                                │答應幹部了，我要問一下幹部，這樣比較不會不好意思。                              │
│                                                                │許：哪一個幹部。                                                                │
│                                                                │楊：我不曉得。                                                                  │
│                                                                │許：你那個，『謝總』喔，『謝總』，你電話給我，我打電話給他。                    │
│                                                                │楊：『謝總』，我跟你講，我現在不曉得，因為我現在進去，啊，那不是『謝總』客人吧，│
│                                                                │我要先問一下是哪個幹部的客人，因為是會計打電話給我的。                          │
│                                                                │許：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │楊：這樣我比較不會說不好意思，你懂意思嗎。                                      │
│                                                                │許：你要替我省錢呀。                                                            │
│                                                                │楊：不是啦，也不是這個意思啦，我是說我至少進去公司之後，然後問會計，因為是會計打│
│                                                                │電話給我的，我跟會計說好，因為我現在要進去公司了。                              │
│                                                                │許：喔，好啦，你如果要替我省錢的話要省多一點啦。                                │
│                                                                │楊：呵呵呵呵，我如果可以，可以就是，就是change掉的時候，我再打電話跟你講一聲。  │
│                                                                │許：OK啦，OK。                                                                  │
│                                                                │楊：喔，好。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│2.   2008/02/12  14:19:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中縣太平市○○路000巷00號7樓頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○            楓之林理容KTV編│許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                 號66號小姐楊雅 │楊：喂，局長。                                                                  │
│                                                 惠             │許：可不可以過來。                                                              │
│                                                                │楊：可以呀。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：你坐車子過來喔。                                                            │
│                                                                │楊：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：那個旱溪東路和天祥街交叉口。                                                │
│                                                                │楊：旱溪東路和天祥街。                                                          │
│                                                                │許：旱溪西路，旱溪西路。                                                        │
│                                                                │楊：旱溪西路喔。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：嗯，和天祥街交叉口。                                                        │
│                                                                │楊：那是什麼、什麼店。                                                          │
│                                                                │許：你到這邊再打個…嘛，我就是在這邊嘛。                                        │
│                                                                │楊：喔，好，旱溪西路就對了。                                                    │
│                                                                │許：你就從太原路一直下來喔。                                                    │
│                                                                │楊：嗯，太原路一直下去。                                                        │
│                                                                │許：過那個，曉得嗎，那個，那個，要到，這邊有1個地下道，就過來地下道。           │
│                                                                │楊：反正就是旱溪西路和天祥路就對了。                                            │
│                                                                │許：對對對對，天祥街。                                                          │
│                                                                │楊：喔，天祥街，旱溪西路跟天祥街就對了。                                        │
│                                                                │許：OK，好。                                                                    │
│                                                                │楊：是要左轉右轉。                                                              │
│                                                                │許：沒有呀，你那個。                                                            │
│                                                                │楊：太原路跟天祥街好了，喔，我知道，好，我到的時候再打電話給你。                │
│                                                                │許：OK，好，好。                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│3.   2008/02/12  14:34:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市北屯區南京東路三段"                                                      │
│                           局長戊○○                           │水利會邀戊○○明日喝春酒                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│4.   2008/02/12  14:43:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市北屯區南京東路三段"                                                      │
│                           局長戊○○             楓之林理容KTV │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                  編號66號小姐楊│楊：喂，你等一下喔。                                                            │
│                                                  雅惠          │（楊雅惠將電話交予司機）                                                        │
│                                                                │司機：你好。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：你現在在哪裡。                                                              │
│                                                                │司機：我現在在太原山西。                                                        │
│                                                                │許：太原路和山西路。                                                            │
│                                                                │司機：嗯。                                                                      │
│                                                                │許：你太原路一直走，走過北屯路。                                                │
│                                                                │司機：嗯，對。                                                                  │
│                                                                │許：1個地下道。                                                                 │
│                                                                │司機：嗯，對。                                                                  │
│                                                                │許：喔，啊，地下道起來第1個紅綠燈右轉。                                         │
│                                                                │司機：旱溪了嘛。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：嗯，對，旱溪西街喔。                                                        │
│                                                                │司機：旱溪西路吧。                                                              │
│                                                                │許：嗯，旱溪西路。                                                              │
│                                                                │司機：嗯，對，右轉。                                                            │
│                                                                │許：旱溪西路喔。                                                                │
│                                                                │司機：右轉。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：你來到，右轉喔。                                                            │
│                                                                │司機：嗯。                                                                      │
│                                                                │許：到這個天祥街，剛好第1個紅綠燈的樣子。                                       │
│                                                                │司機：好。                                                                      │
│                                                                │許：就是那個天祥路，天祥街，天祥街。                                            │
│                                                                │司機：好。                                                                      │
│                                                                │許：…，你叫那個小姐先打個電話給我。                                            │
│                                                                │司機：好，謝謝你，我知道，好，謝謝你。                                          │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│5.   2008/02/12  14:51:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市北屯區南京東路三段"                                                      │
│                           局長戊○○             楓之林理容KTV │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                  編號66號小姐楊│楊：到天祥街了。                                                                │
│                                                  雅惠          │許：好，有沒有右轉彎，這個橋這邊右轉彎。                                        │
│                                                                │楊：有。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：看到你車子了，等一下，等一下。                                              │
│                                                                │楊：好。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│6.   2008/02/12  15:35:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中縣太平市○○路000巷00號7F"                                                 │
│                           水利署科長林榮紹                     │同事表示要林榮紹和「周課長」至河南路「3個字」，「副座」在等。                   │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│7.   2008/02/12  15:40:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段0000號8F頂"                                        │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造鄭年雅│鄭：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：你有走遠嗎。                                                                │
│                                                                │鄭：沒有，我在綏遠路。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：喔，說要10萬（元）。                                                        │
│                                                                │鄭：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：「天祥街」。                                                                │
│                                                                │鄭：好啦，好。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：你這2天再跟「鐮川」（音譯）聯絡一下，這邊電話又不能用了。                   │
│                                                                │鄭：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：沒看到了。                                                                  │
│                                                                │鄭：不是「鐮川」吧，「嘉明」（音譯）啦。                                        │
│                                                                │廉：不是啦，那個什麼。                                                          │
│                                                                │鄭：「嘉明」，好。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：「嘉明」呀，「嘉明」呀。10萬（元）你再先弄一下。                            │
│                                                                │鄭：好。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：好，謝謝。                                                                  │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│8.   2008/02/12  16:04:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市北屯區南京東路三段"                                                      │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造鄭年雅│鄭：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：你要過來嗎。                                                                │
│                                                                │鄭：我快到了啦。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：快到了喔。                                                                  │
│                                                                │鄭：對呀 。                                                                     │
│                                                                │廉：喔，好，好，這樣我等你，我。                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│9.   2008/02/12  16:06:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○0路000號8 F頂"                                                 │
│                           九龍理容KTV徐玉玲      水利署周世傑  │徐：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │周：秀秀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │徐：是。                                                                        │
│                                                                │周：恭喜喔。                                                                    │
│                                                                │徐：恭喜，恭喜發財，你好。                                                      │
│                                                                │周：什麼呀。                                                                    │
│                                                                │徐：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │周：我是誰你知道嗎。                                                            │
│                                                                │徐：你是誰。                                                                    │
│                                                                │周：你也不知道嗎，對嗎。                                                        │
│                                                                │徐：沒有啦，啊，「財叔」（台語音譯）喔。                                        │
│                                                                │周：對啦，「他們」到了沒。                                                      │
│                                                                │徐：還沒有耶。                                                                  │
│                                                                │周：他們跟我講他們在「那裡」，他們講他們在那裡，好啦，我們現在要過去啦。徐：沒有│
│                                                                │，不是，不是「財叔」。                                                          │
│                                                                │周：你在公司嗎。                                                                │
│                                                                │徐：不是，我跟你講，現在都沒小姐喔。                                            │
│                                                                │周：現在都沒有喔。                                                              │
│                                                                │徐：嗯。因為來10幾「番」都沒小姐，我先跟你報告一下。                            │
│                                                                │周：這樣就不要過去了。                                                          │
│                                                                │徐：嗯，不是我不要給你來，因為來10幾「番」喔，都沒小姐，我跟你講一下。          │
│                                                                │周：剛才說，「葉仔」他們說都過去了。                                            │
│                                                                │徐：好啦，不然他們若到了我，我再打給你好嗎。                                    │
│                                                                │周：好呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │徐：好。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│10.  2008/02/12  16:14:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆                       │廉裕隆表示在載人                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│11.  2008/02/12  16:14:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○0路000號8 F頂"                                                 │
│                           九龍理容KTV徐玉玲      水利署周世傑  │水利署河川勘測隊周世傑：新年恭喜。                                              │
│                                                                │徐：恭喜，「財叔」（音譯）。                                                    │
│                                                                │周：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │徐：「人」到了喔。                                                              │
│                                                                │周：他們到了喔。                                                                │
│                                                                │徐：嗯，我，我先把他們帶進來，你先進來，你，你要過來。                          │
│                                                                │周：我坐「阿隆」的車子，現在要出發，嗯。                                        │
│                                                                │徐：喔，好，好，好。                                                            │
│                                                                │周：你帶到哪裡去。                                                              │
│                                                                │徐：嗯，「121」。                                                               │
│                                                                │周：好。                                                                        │
│                                                                │徐：嗯。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│12.  2008/02/12  16:15:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○0路000號8 F頂"                                                 │
│                           九龍理容KTV徐玉玲      水利署周世傑  │周：喂。                                                                        │
│                           水利署壬○○                         │徐：「財叔」（台語音譯）你等一下。                                              │
│                                                                │（徐玉玲將電話交予壬○○）                                                      │
│                                                                │葉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │周：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │葉：你不是說你在等我。                                                          │
│                                                                │周：再5分鐘啦，我剛又被。                                                       │
│                                                                │葉：5分鐘。                                                                     │
│                                                                │周：你就先到。                                                                  │
│                                                                │葉：你娘，「爛鳥」（台語）咧，你說什麼話。                                      │
│                                                                │周：好啦，好啦，好啦。                                                          │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│13.  2008/02/12  16:16:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           局長戊○○             水利署周世傑  │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │周：頭仔喔。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：嗯，是。                                                                    │
│                                                                │周：在忙喔。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：沒有呀，我到了。                                                            │
│                                                                │周：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：我到了，怎麼。                                                              │
│                                                                │周：你到「阿九」那裡。                                                          │
│                                                                │許：對呀，怎麼。                                                                │
│                                                                │周：我現在。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：你呢。                                                                      │
│                                                                │周：現在，現在到了呀。                                                          │
│                                                                │許：啊，到了，你，幾號，那個了嗎。                                              │
│                                                                │周：「121」。                                                                   │
│                                                                │許：我就停。                                                                    │
│                                                                │周：「121」、「121」。                                                          │
│                                                                │許：OK，OK，好好好好。                                                          │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│14.  2008/02/12  16:22:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市北區崇德路一段57"                                                        │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造陳小姐│周世傑：再走，一直走，對否。                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：對啦，過溪過。                                                              │
│                                                                │周：對呀，走往這條路，前面塞的，喔。                                            │
│                                                                │…（與川順公司陳小姐聯繫）                                                      │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│15.  2008/02/12  16:40:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │臺中市○○區○○0路000號8 F頂                                                   │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造陳小姐│短訊：明早中華電信大約９︰２０至天祥街勘查電話線路    聯絡電話:０９３７２０２２ │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│16.  2008/02/12  16:47:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○0路000號8 F頂"                                                 │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         某男          │（與某男通聯）                                                                  │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│17.  2008/02/12  16:57:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           水利署科長林榮紹                     │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│18.  2008/02/12  16:58:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           水利署科長林榮紹                     │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│19.  2008/02/12  16:58:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           水利署科長林榮紹                     │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│20.  2008/02/12  16:59:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○路○段0號5F頂"                                               │
│                           水利署科長林榮紹                     │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│21.  2008/02/12  17:00:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市北屯區南京東路三段"                                                      │
│                           水利署科長林榮紹                     │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│22.  2008/02/12  17:06:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○0路000號8 F頂"                                                 │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         配偶          │廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │妻：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │妻：你要回來吃飯。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：喔，在唱歌，沒那麼早。                                                      │
│                                                                │妻：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │妻：喝酒嗎。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：一點點而已啦。                                                              │
│                                                                │妻：一點點也是要坐計乘車啦，一點點。                                            │
│                                                                │廉：好，好啦，好。                                                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│23.  2008/02/12  17:08:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○0路000號8 F頂"                                                 │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         世曦公司張敬廉│廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：喂，?經理喔。                                                               │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：喂，你好，我是那張敬廉喔。                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：張技師。                                                                    │
│                                                                │張：董仔有在你旁邊嗎，恭喜，恭喜。                                              │
│                                                                │廉：沒有。                                                                      │
│                                                                │張：沒有喔。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：不要緊，我，昨天那個，明天那個「三河局」說要開1個什麼。                     │
│                                                                │廉：…嗯嗯嗯。                                                                  │
│                                                                │張：竣工圖的，你知道喔，有收到喔。                                              │
│                                                                │廉：有，有。                                                                    │
│                                                                │張：有喔，不知，不知到底是內容不知要開什麼，想說是要問你，跟你請教一下。        │
│                                                                │廉：就是那個上次我們驗收的時候，他叫我們改，改那個，那些的。                    │
│                                                                │張：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：一般回來在講，因為「我們董仔」是說一般喔，改那個沒意思啦。                  │
│                                                                │張：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：因為你減低，我們做就是說我們，我們竣工圖上面標，標，就是標我們做的那個，有夠│
│                                                                │那個尺寸就可以嘛。                                                              │
│                                                                │張：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：啊，你實際量的，你就照你的驗收，驗收紀錄上面你就照你實際量的嘛。            │
│                                                                │張：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：我們董仔的意思是這樣。                                                      │
│                                                                │張：再1個問題就是說怕說有錯的地方可能會那個啦。                                 │
│                                                                │廉：沒有，沒有，有錯的那個另外。                                                │
│                                                                │張：另外喔。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：那個當然，有筆誤的地方，那個當然要改。                                      │
│                                                                │張：對呀，對呀，要改，對呀，對呀。                                              │
│                                                                │廉：有筆誤的地方，那當然要改。                                                  │
│                                                                │張：對呀，對呀，對呀，那個要改，對呀，對呀。                                    │
│                                                                │廉：那個沒有問題啦，現在他們就可能要開看看大家取得1個，協調一下這樣就對啦。     │
│                                                                │張：對呀，對呀，我是說萬一說有錯誤，我是說，我是說那種尺寸或是什麼的錯誤。      │
│                                                                │廉：對對對，有錯誤那個一定要改啦。                                              │
│                                                                │張：包括「高程」那個喔。                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：「高程」那個如果錯了就罰6倍。                                               │
│                                                                │廉：有錯的地方一定要改啦。                                                      │
│                                                                │張：你對你們的「高程」有信心嗎。                                                │
│                                                                │廉：有啦。                                                                      │
│                                                                │張：有信心喔，不過你們「阿忠」沒信心耶。                                        │
│                                                                │廉：呵呵呵。                                                                    │
│                                                                │張：呵呵，你確定。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：絕對有信心，他說沒信心呀。                                                  │
│                                                                │張：因為他那時很怕，很怕人，就是很怕人去，那種的，弄他的「高程」的啦。          │
│                                                                │廉：喔，不會啦，不會啦。                                                        │
│                                                                │張：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：那個明天當面。                                                              │
│                                                                │張：好呀，好呀。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：當面再談好嗎。                                                              │
│                                                                │張：OK，OK，好。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：明天下午3點啦。                                                             │
│                                                                │張：好好。                                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：麻煩你，謝謝，好好，BYEBYE。                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│24.  2008/02/12  17:10:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○0路000號8 F頂"                                                 │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造紀駿富│交代川順公司紀駿富準備明日15時第三河川局會議                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│25.  2008/02/12  17:48:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○0路000號8 F頂"                                                 │
│                           局長戊○○                           │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│26.  2008/02/12  18:27:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○0路000號8 F頂"                                                 │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         九龍理容KTV張 │廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                  淑惠          │張：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：你在包廂裡面。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │張：你先出來一下好嗎。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：怎麼，喂。                                                                  │
│                                                                │張：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：嗯，嗯，你說怎麼。                                                          │
│                                                                │張：啊，你先聽電話。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：我怎麼。                                                                    │
│                                                                │張：隨便你。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：你說怎麼。                                                                  │
│                                                                │張：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：你說什麼。                                                                  │
│                                                                │張：沒有，我說你可不可以方便先出來包廂一下。                                    │
│                                                                │廉：喔喔喔，好。                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│27.  2008/02/12  18:57:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○0路000號8 F頂"                                                 │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         配偶          │向妻表示還在唱歌，還沒有要出來，不知到什麼時候                                  │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│28.  2008/02/12  19:13:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○0路000號8 F頂"                                                 │
│                           局長戊○○                           │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│29.  2008/02/12  19:15:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           局長戊○○                           │邀某女改日出遊                                                                  │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│30.  2008/02/12  19:40:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │向女友表示最晚20時20分會離開                                                    │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆                       │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│31.  2008/02/12  20:05:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中縣外埔鄉00鄰○○路000號3F"                                                 │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         九龍理容KTV張 │廉裕隆向張淑惠表示到大甲了                                                      │
│                                                  淑惠          │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│32.  2008/02/12  20:17:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                           局長戊○○             楓之林理容KTV │楊：你在哪裡呀。                                                                │
│                                                  編號66號小姐楊│許：我在前面呀。                                                                │
│                                                  雅惠          │楊：前面。                                                                      │
│                                                                │許：嗯，你現在在哪邊。                                                          │
│                                                                │楊：我就是那個…這邊呀。                                                        │
│                                                                │許：不是呀，你剛才下車往前走就是呀。                                            │
│                                                                │楊：往前走。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │楊：沒看到你呀。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：不是呀，你可能走錯邊吧，來來來。                                            │
│                                                                │楊：都沒有。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：有啦，你可能走錯邊了啦。                                                    │
│                                                                │楊：哪有。                                                                      │
│                                                                │許：什麼沒有。                                                                  │
│                                                                │楊：你跑去哪邊了。                                                              │
│                                                                │許：沒有，你自己走錯邊了吧。                                                    │
│                                                                │楊：喔，喔喔喔喔。                                                              │
│                                                                │許：呵呵呵。                                                                    │
│                                                                │楊：喔，我看到。                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│33.  2008/02/12  20:35:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○0路000號8 F頂"                                                 │
│                           九龍理容KTV徐玉玲      川順營造廉裕隆│廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │徐：裕隆。                                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │徐：我秀秀啦。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │徐：抱歉，我跟你報告一下，「老闆」又要把那個小姐買到1點啦。                     │
│                                                                │廉：買到幾點。                                                                  │
│                                                                │徐：1點，再補4鐘點。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │徐：8，9，10，11，12。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │徐：9，10，11，12，1點，5個小時喔，8點到1點。                                   │
│                                                                │廉：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │徐：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：好啦，有遇到他可能會再跟我講啦。                                            │
│                                                                │徐：嗯，這樣，這樣我先幫你補起來，改天有來你再補簽就好，好嗎。                  │
│                                                                │廉：好呀，好呀。                                                                │
│                                                                │徐：喔，抱歉，抱歉。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：好，他若有講我再，好好好。                                                  │
│                                                                │徐：好，謝謝。                                                                  │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│34.  2008/02/12  20:35:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中縣大甲鎮○○路000號4F"                                                     │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         九龍理容KTV徐 │廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                  玉玲          │徐：裕隆。                                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │徐：我秀秀啦。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │徐：抱歉，我跟你報告一下，「老闆」又要把那個小姐買到1點啦。                     │
│                                                                │廉：買到幾點。                                                                  │
│                                                                │徐：1點，再補4鐘點。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │徐：8，9，10，11，12。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │徐：9，10，11，12，1點，5個小時喔，8點到1點。                                   │
│                                                                │廉：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │徐：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：好啦，有遇到他可能會再跟我講啦。                                            │
│                                                                │徐：嗯，這樣，這樣我先幫你補起來，改天有來你再補簽就好，好嗎。                  │
│                                                                │廉：好呀，好呀。                                                                │
│                                                                │徐：喔，抱歉，抱歉。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：好，他若有講我再，好好好。                                                  │
│                                                                │徐：好，謝謝。                                                                  │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│35.  2008/02/12  20:40:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           九龍理容KTV徐玉玲      局長戊○○    │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │徐：大哥。                                                                      │
│                                                                │許：怎麼樣。                                                                    │
│                                                                │徐：嗯，她後面的有補了。                                                        │
│                                                                │許：喔，這樣喔。                                                                │
│                                                                │徐：嗯，我有跟「阿隆」講。                                                      │
│                                                                │許：OK，好，好，我知道。                                                        │
│                                                                │徐：嗯，補到1點，喔。                                                           │
│                                                                │許：我知道，我知道，我知道。                                                    │
│                                                                │徐：好，謝謝，BYEBYE。                                                          │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│36.  2008/02/12  20:40:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                           局長戊○○             九龍理容KTV徐 │徐：大哥。                                                                      │
│                                                  玉玲          │許：怎麼樣。                                                                    │
│                                                                │徐：嗯，她後面的有補了。                                                        │
│                                                                │許：喔，這樣喔。                                                                │
│                                                                │徐：嗯，我有跟「阿隆」講。                                                      │
│                                                                │許：OK，好，好，我知道。                                                        │
│                                                                │徐：嗯，補到1點，喔。                                                           │
│                                                                │許：我知道，我知道，我知道。                                                    │
│                                                                │徐：好，謝謝，BYEBYE。                                                          │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│37.  2008/02/12  20:45:00  0000000000      接     000000000000  │"臺中市南屯區鎮○段000000000地號"                                               │
│                           局長戊○○                           │戊○○向妻表示在返家途中                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│38.  2008/02/12  21:09:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段00號17樓頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○             楓之林理容KTV │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                  編號66號小姐楊│楊：喂，你開回到家裡了嗎。                                                      │
│                                                  雅惠          │許：我到家了，到家了。                                                          │
│                                                                │楊：是喔，好啦，好。                                                            │
└────────────────────────────────┴────────────────────────────────────────┘

┌────────────────────────────────┬────────────────────────────────────────┐
│編號 日期        時間      監聽電話       撥/接   對方電話      │通聯內容摘要                                                                備註│
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│1.   2008/03/03  09:49:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         第三河川局鍾彥│第三河川局癸○○表示（本便道工程）3月5日驗收，尚不清楚水利署派何人驗收（? 裕隆詢│
│                                                  虎            │問2次）                                                                         │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│2.   2008/03/03  11:33:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○路○段000巷00號16F屋頂"                                        │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         幀衡公司劉禎忠│幀衡公司劉禎忠表示要和「林科長」、「世傑」去水利署附近的「小仙屋」（音譯）吃個飯│
│                                                                │，有約彭壽奇；戴沼澤要劉禎忠叫一些人出來。                                      │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│3.   2008/03/03  11:35:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○路○段000巷00號16F屋頂"                                        │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         科長林榮紹    │戴：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林榮紹：喂，嗯。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：怎麼，要「小仙屋」（音譯）喔。                                              │
│                                                                │林：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：不來「鶴園」。                                                              │
│                                                                │林：不要，那麼遠，下午我們要開會也比較方便。                                    │
│                                                                │戴：你下午要開會喔。                                                            │
│                                                                │林：不一定啦，就是，就是要在這裡等啦，別人若叫我上去開我就上去開了，現在是沒有叫│
│                                                                │    我上去開啦。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：沒開你就說沒開，我就，啊，「蔡孟元」在嗎。                                  │
│                                                                │林：「蔡孟元」他下午要開會，他怎麼可能和你去。                                  │
│                                                                │戴：下午要開會。                                                                │
│                                                                │林：下午他主角呀，他主角呀。                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：叫過來吃飯呀，幾點。                                                        │
│                                                                │林：2點的會，2點。                                                              │
│                                                                │戴：就「小仙屋」，過來那裡，叫他出來呀。                                        │
│                                                                │林：你叫他比較方，你叫他比較方便。                                              │
│                                                                │戴：你啦，你說我。                                                              │
│                                                                │林：你叫他比較方便，「242」。                                                   │
│                                                                │戴：「242」喔。                                                                 │
│                                                                │林：嗯。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│4.   2008/03/03  11:35:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號6樓"                                                │
│                           科長林榮紹             川順營造戴沼澤│戴：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林榮紹：喂，嗯。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：怎麼，要「小仙屋」（音譯）喔。                                              │
│                                                                │林：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：不來「鶴園」。                                                              │
│                                                                │林：不要，那麼遠，下午我們要開會也比較方便。                                    │
│                                                                │戴：你下午要開會喔。                                                            │
│                                                                │林：不一定啦，就是，就是要在這裡等啦，別人若叫我上去開我就上去開了，現在是沒有叫│
│                                                                │我上去開啦。                                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：沒開你就說沒開，我就，啊，「蔡孟元」在嗎。                                  │
│                                                                │林：「蔡孟元」他下午要開會，他怎麼可能和你去。                                  │
│                                                                │戴：下午要開會。                                                                │
│                                                                │林：下午他主角呀，他主角呀。                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：叫過來吃飯呀，幾點。                                                        │
│                                                                │林：2點的會，2點。                                                              │
│                                                                │戴：就「小仙屋」，過來那裡，叫他出來呀。                                        │
│                                                                │林：你叫他比較方，你叫他比較方便。                                              │
│                                                                │戴：你啦，你說我。                                                              │
│                                                                │林：你叫他比較方便，「242」。                                                   │
│                                                                │戴：「242」喔。                                                                 │
│                                                                │林：嗯。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│5.   2008/03/03  11:36:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○路○段000巷00號16F屋頂"                                        │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         水利署科長蔡孟│戴沼澤邀水利署科長蔡孟元吃飯未果                                                │
│                                                  元            │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│6.   2008/03/03  11:37:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號9樓頂"                                              │
│                           九龍酒店張淑惠         川順營造廉裕隆│廉裕隆表示和「董仔」要出去，很抱歉                                              │
│                                                                │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│7.   2008/03/03  11:38:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○路○段000巷00號16F屋頂"                                        │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         科長林榮紹    │林榮紹：喂，你好。                                                              │
│                                                                │戴：「他」說還在準備資料啦，「天生」有空嗎。                                    │
│                                                                │林：誰。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：「天生」呀。                                                                │
│                                                                │林：「天生」我有叫「周課長」請他了。                                            │
│                                                                │戴：好啦。                                                                      │
│                                                                │林：他不知道有沒有要去，我不知道。                                              │
│                                                                │戴：再叫「周課長」跟他講一下。                                                  │
│                                                                │林：對呀，對呀，對呀。                                                          │
│                                                                │戴：好。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│8.   2008/03/03  11:48:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市北屯區南京東路三段"                                                      │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         水利署周世傑  │水利署周世傑：嗯。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：科長，你稍等喔。                                                            │
│                                                                │（廉裕隆將電話交予戴沼澤）                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │周：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：請客也不叫一下。                                                            │
│                                                                │周：不是啦，你們好友啦，快點呀，我還在「工務組」。                              │
│                                                                │戴：沒有，「天生」跟「壬○○」有沒有要過來。                                    │
│                                                                │周：誰。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：「天生」跟「壬○○」呀。                                                    │
│                                                                │周：對呀，對對對對，嗯嗯                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：有嗎。                                                                      │
│                                                                │周：有呀，有呀。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：2個有啦喔。                                                                 │
│                                                                │周：嗯嗯，你要過去了喔。                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：好啦，好啦。                                                                │
│                                                                │周：好好好好。                                                                  │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│9.   2008/03/03  11:57:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○○路00號13F屋頂"                                               │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         局長戊○○    │戊○○向戴沼澤表示中午與水利署「水政組」於「阿杜」用餐，戴沼澤於「小仙」（音譯）│
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│10.  2008/03/03  11:57:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○區○○街00號6"                                                         │
│                           局長戊○○             川順營造戴沼澤│戊○○向戴沼澤表示中午與水利署「水政組」於「阿杜」用餐，戴沼澤於「小仙」（音譯）│
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│11.  2008/03/03  12:00:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"台中市○○路000號12F屋頂"                                                      │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         川順營造王莉婷│戴沼澤表示被廉裕隆載去和水利署「周課長」、「天生」吃飯                          │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│12.  2008/03/03  12:20:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號10樓"                                               │
│                           局長戊○○                           │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│13.  2008/03/03  12:35:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號14F頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○             女友戴美玲    │戴美玲向戊○○表示這間房子賣了，戊○○與人吃飯                                  │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│14.  2008/03/03  12:53:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○○0鄰○○○路00000號3樓頂"                                     │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤                       │浦騰公司黃志彰將過來                                                            │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│15.  2008/03/03  12:54:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○街000巷0弄00號4F頂"                                            │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造戴泱丞│戴泱丞要? 裕隆向戴沼澤轉達，禮拜3（3/5）派「阿樹」去開會，要於會中提出剩下的不要│
│                                                                │載了，看能不能退錢                                                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│16.  2008/03/03  12:58:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號14F頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │戊○○向女友陳玉瑛表示與人吃飯                                                  │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│17.  2008/03/03  13:24:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號14F頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○             科長林榮紹    │林：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：老林。                                                                      │
│                                                                │林：是。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：你在哪一間。                                                                │
│                                                                │林：我在「小仙屋」（音譯）。                                                    │
│                                                                │許：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：「小仙屋」。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：這樣喔，你若結束時叫「阿隆」來我這裡一下。                                  │
│                                                                │林：喔喔喔喔喔。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：我在那個，你知道啦喔。                                                      │
│                                                                │林：在。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：「阿杜」。                                                                  │
│                                                                │林：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：瞭解，瞭解。                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│18.  2008/03/03  13:24:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○路○段0000號4F頂"                                            │
│                           科長林榮紹             局長戊○○    │林：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：老林。                                                                      │
│                                                                │林：是。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：你在哪一間。                                                                │
│                                                                │林：我在「小仙屋」（音譯）。                                                    │
│                                                                │許：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：「小仙屋」。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：這樣喔，你若結束時叫「阿隆」來我這裡一下。                                  │
│                                                                │林：喔喔喔喔喔。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：我在那個，你知道啦喔。                                                      │
│                                                                │林：在。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：「阿杜」。                                                                  │
│                                                                │林：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：瞭解，瞭解。                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│19.  2008/03/03  13:51:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號10樓"                                               │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │戊○○表示等一下過去找女友陳玉瑛                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│20.  2008/03/03  13:58:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號14F頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○             川順營造戴沼澤│許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：怎麼，結束了沒有。                                                          │
│                                                                │許：那個，叫「阿隆」過來一下好嗎。                                              │
│                                                                │戴：喔，要。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：不是，不是，不是，嗯，嗯，你叫他過來，我跟他講。                            │
│                                                                │戴：好，好。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│21.  2008/03/03  13:58:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○○○○路○段000號"                                             │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         局長戊○○    │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：怎麼，結束了沒有。                                                          │
│                                                                │許：那個，叫「阿隆」過來一下好嗎。                                              │
│                                                                │戴：喔，要。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：不是，不是，不是，嗯，嗯，你叫他過來，我跟他講。                            │
│                                                                │戴：好，好。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│22.  2008/03/03  13:59:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○街000巷0弄00號4F頂"                                            │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造戴沼澤│廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：你載「林榮紹」去，他們「水政組」要解決這種問題，要講給「局長」聽，叫你去解釋│
│                                                                │，你和「林榮紹」過去，你說叫他們。                                              │
│                                                                │廉：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：他在那裡等呀。                                                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│23.  2008/03/03  13:59:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○○○○路○段000號"                                             │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         川順營造廉裕隆│廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：你載「林榮紹」去，他們「水政組」要解決這種問題，要講給「局長」聽，叫你去解釋│
│                                                                │，你和「林榮紹」過去，你說叫他們。                                              │
│                                                                │廉：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：他在那裡等呀。                                                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│24.  2008/03/03  14:23:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │林榮紹要同事李傳煒查土石採取於環評法裡的定義                                    │
│                           水利署林榮紹           水利署李傳煒  │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│25.  2008/03/03  14:24:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"台中市○區○○○00鄰○○街00號四樓頂及屋凸"                                    │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         川順營造廉裕隆│廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：你到了嗎。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：剛出發一下子，我剛才有…，還在那裡啦。                                      │
│                                                                │戴：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：還在那裡，我現在載『科長』要過去。                                          │
│                                                                │戴：對呀，看要做什麼，你要跟我講一下。                                          │
│                                                                │廉：好。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│26.  2008/03/03  14:24:00  0000000000      接      0000000000   │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號5F頂"                                               │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆          川順營造戴沼 │廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：你到了嗎。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：剛出發一下子，我剛才有…，還在那裡啦。                                      │
│                                                                │戴：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：還在那裡，我現在載『科長』要過去。                                          │
│                                                                │戴：對呀，看要做什麼，你要跟我講一下。                                          │
│                                                                │廉：好。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│27.  2008/03/03  14:30:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號14F頂"                                              │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         水利署周世傑  │廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │水利署周世傑：阿隆。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：有。                                                                        │
│                                                                │周：那個，整修沒開啦。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：店修。                                                                      │
│                                                                │周：嗯，對，我們現在來「高速公路下」，知道嗎。                                  │
│                                                                │廉：「高速公路下」。                                                            │
│                                                                │周：就「楓」啦。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：好，好，好，好，好。                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│28.  2008/03/03  14:31:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市南屯區文心路一段5"                                                       │
│                           水利署林榮紹           水利署李傳煒  │同事李傳煒告知土石採取要辦環評之條件…                                          │
│                                                                │（林榮紹電話中傳出戊○○講話、KTV歌唱聲）                                       │
│                                                                │許：因為早上，早上那個…，那個我現在。                                          │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│29.  2008/03/03  14:32:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號14F頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○             水利署周世傑  │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │水利署周世傑：頭仔喔。                                                          │
│                                                                │許：嗯，是，嗯。                                                                │
│                                                                │周：拚完了沒。                                                                  │
│                                                                │許：怎麼。                                                                      │
│                                                                │周：你不是跟「水政組」1人出10個。                                               │
│                                                                │許：對呀，對呀，對呀，對呀。                                                    │
│                                                                │周：拚完了。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：現在，現在他們大家在爽快，你沒聽到。                                        │
│                                                                │周：喔，在爽快就好。                                                            │
│                                                                │許：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │周：好。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│30.  2008/03/03  14:42:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號14F頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○             司機          │司機：喂。                                                                      │
│                                                                │許：你車子開過來。                                                              │
│                                                                │司機：好。                                                                      │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│31.  2008/03/03  14:45:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號14F頂"                                              │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造戴沼澤│戴：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：我阿隆。                                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：不是要說那個事情啦。                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：另外啦。                                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：另外啦，另外，我回去我再跟你。                                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│32.  2008/03/03  14:45:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○路○段000巷00號16F屋頂"                                        │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         川順營造廉裕隆│戴：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：我阿隆。                                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：不是要說那個事情啦。                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：另外啦。                                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：另外啦，另外，我回去我再跟你。                                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│33.  2008/03/03  14:52:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號14F頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │陳：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：喂，準備好了沒有。                                                          │
│                                                                │（斷訊）                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│34.  2008/03/03  14:52:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號14F頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │許：喂，準備好了沒有。                                                          │
│                                                                │陳：還沒，我不知道你要忙到幾點。                                                │
│                                                                │許：好啦，去準備啦。                                                            │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│35.  2008/03/03  15:37:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │陳：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：可以下來了。                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│36.  2008/03/03  15:58:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○路○段000號門診立體停車場4F頂"                               │
│                           局長戊○○             水利署周世傑  │（水利署周世傑持用劉建成行動電話與戊○○通聯）                                  │
│                                                                │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │周：頭仔喔。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：嗯，是，嗯。                                                                │
│                                                                │周：你在哪裡。                                                                  │
│                                                                │許：我現在在和人談事情。                                                        │
│                                                                │周：喔，這樣喔。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │周：我在「高速公路下」啦。                                                      │
│                                                                │許：OK，我知道，我知道。                                                        │
│                                                                │周：好。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│37.  2008/03/03  16:44:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中縣潭子鄉○○路○段000巷00號8F頂"                                           │
│                           局長戊○○             水利署周世傑  │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │周：頭仔喔。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：嗯，是。                                                                    │
│                                                                │周：在忙。                                                                      │
│                                                                │許：嗯，還在講，怎麼。                                                          │
│                                                                │周：喔，沒有啦，我就和…。                                                      │
│                                                                │許：喔，好。                                                                    │
│                                                                │周：你還在忙喔。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：對啦。                                                                      │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│38.  2008/03/03  16:46:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號14F頂"                                              │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         新旭台砂石公司│新旭台砂石公司小陳表示聯單那邊整理好了，該公司有4天沒有資料，去河川局印到3天，三│
│                                                  小陳          │河局只有電腦資料沒有聯單資料，且該公司磅單等都沒有，? 裕隆要小陳先將資料留著，另│
│                                                                │新旭台公司要領取砂石之車輛空車重量，? 裕隆要小陳撥打00000000找川順公司副總「戴泱│
│                                                                │丞」                                                                            │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│39.  2008/03/03  17:57:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號14F頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶          │許：喂，要晚點回去，要晚點回去。                                                │
│                                                                │妻：早點回來啦。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：好，好。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│40.  2008/03/03  17:58:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號14F頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶          │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│41.  2008/03/03  17:59:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號14F頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶          │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│42.  2008/03/03  17:59:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號14F頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶          │妻：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：怎麼，什麼事情。                                                            │
│                                                                │妻：你女兒很愛跟我發脾氣。                                                      │
│                                                                │許：什麼人。                                                                    │
│                                                                │妻：女兒呀。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：是怎麼樣。                                                                  │
│                                                                │妻：說學校在調查說什麼都沒帶他出去玩，別人都有，只有他沒有，他就空白紀錄，拜託你│
│                                                                │    也安排1個時間好不好，不要讓我很難做人。                                     │
│                                                                │（斷訊）                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│43.  2008/03/03  18:10:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號14F頂"                                              │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆                       │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│44.  2008/03/03  18:11:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號14F頂"                                              │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         配偶          │廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │妻：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │妻：怎麼這麼快又接了。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：喔，沒有啦，剛才這通不知道誰打的，我剛才要接。                              │
│                                                                │妻：要回來吃飯嗎。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：在唱歌。                                                                    │
│                                                                │妻：在唱歌。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │妻：在台中喔。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │妻：唱歌，剛才去唱。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：喔，下午就到現在。                                                          │
│                                                                │妻：下午到現在，還沒要走嗎。                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：半個下午啦。                                                                │
│                                                                │妻：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：半個下午啦。                                                                │
│                                                                │妻：對呀，還沒要走嗎。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：喔，愈來愈大群。                                                            │
│                                                                │妻：愈來愈大群，你就錢趕快付一付，趕快走就好了。                                │
│                                                                │廉：不是我說要走就要走。                                                        │
│                                                                │妻：你有喝酒嗎。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：一些而已啦，我等一下不要喝就好了。                                          │
│                                                                │妻：對呀，等一下不要喝喔。                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：好呀，好呀。                                                                │
│                                                                │妻：好啦。                                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：喔，好。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│45.  2008/03/03  18:12:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號14F頂"                                              │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆                       │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│46.  2008/03/03  18:24:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │林榮紹未接聽來電                                                                │
│                           水利署林榮紹                         │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│47.  2008/03/03  18:25:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"中華電信未提供"                                                                │
│                           水利署林榮紹                         │林榮紹未接聽來電                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│48.  2008/03/03  18:26:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"中華電信未提供"                                                                │
│                           水利署林榮紹                         │林榮紹未接聽來電                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│49.  2008/03/03  18:27:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"中華電信未提供"                                                                │
│                           水利署林榮紹                         │林榮紹未接聽來電                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│50.  2008/03/03  18:27:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │ 林榮紹未接聽來電                                                               │
│                           水利署林榮紹                         │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│51.  2008/03/03  18:30:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"中華電信未提供"                                                                │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造戴永恭│廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴永恭：隆仔，這隻機子是你自己的名字喔。                                        │
│                                                                │廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴永恭：隆仔喔。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：這隻是你自己的名字喔。                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：啊，另外那隻是公司的喔。                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：你離開工地了嗎。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：在，我在唱歌。                                                              │
│                                                                │戴：「老闆」有在那裡嗎。                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：沒有，沒有。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：這樣喔，你有要回去嗎。                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：有呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：有要去「老闆」那裡嗎。                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：「他們」現在這邊還沒結束耶。                                                │
│                                                                │戴：好啦，這樣不要緊啦，不然我再找他一下。                                      │
│                                                                │廉：你說那個，那個事情。                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：…大溪那個啦。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：喔，喔，有啦，有啦。「老闆」有在講。                                        │
│                                                                │戴：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：那個警方喔。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：嗯，嗯，對。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：好啦。                                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：嗯，喔，好，好。                                                            │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│52.  2008/03/03  18:47:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"中華電信未提供"                                                                │
│                           水利署林榮紹                         │林榮紹未接聽來電                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│53.  2008/03/03  19:08:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │林榮紹未接聽來電                                                                │
│                           水利署林榮紹                         │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│54.  2008/03/03  19:51:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │林榮紹未接聽來電                                                                │
│                           水利署林榮紹                         │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│55.  2008/03/03  19:52:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │林榮紹未接聽來電                                                                │
│                           水利署林榮紹                         │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│56.  2008/03/03  19:53:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │林榮紹未接聽來電                                                                │
│                           水利署林榮紹                         │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│57.  2008/03/03  20:57:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○0路000號8 F頂"                                                 │
│                           九龍酒店張淑惠         川順營造廉裕隆│張：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：我要回去了。                                                                │
│                                                                │張：喔，你喝酒喔。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：對呀，沒人跟你通報嗎。                                                      │
│                                                                │張：沒有呀。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：沒有，啊，「那個」說跟你多好，都騙你的。                                    │
│                                                                │張：你在「楓之林」喝酒喔。                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：對呀，「那個」說跟你很好。                                                  │
│                                                                │張：誰很好，我沒有，沒有接到任何消息，剛才才想說現在是幾點了，你有回去嗎。      │
│                                                                │廉：「那個」呀，那個說跟你很好「那個」呀。                                      │
│                                                                │張：「那個」是哪一個呀。                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：喔，說你姊呀。                                                              │
│                                                                │張：我姊，「淑萍」嗎。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：喔，沒有啦，沒什麼聯絡，沒可能去說這種事情啦。                              │
│                                                                │廉：在那裡說，說跟你多好。                                                      │
│                                                                │張：正經的呀，不錯呀，只是大家各忙各的呀，哪有什麼好講的，你們喝你們的酒呀，就算│
│                                                                │，就算。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：跟你一樣啦。                                                                │
│                                                                │張：跟我一樣。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：都陞官嘛。                                                                  │
│                                                                │張：說一些什麼。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：陞官啦。                                                                    │
│                                                                │張：喔，喝少一點，喔，那條事情弄到現在。                                        │
│                                                                │廉：我結束了，我還載人回去。                                                    │
│                                                                │張：你喝這樣你還要開車喔。                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：我還好你知道嗎，我還載人回去。                                              │
│                                                                │張：載男的還是載女的。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：你也幫幫忙，載女的就沒有要載他回去了。                                      │
│                                                                │張：剛在想說現在幾點了，你是去哪了，我跟你講啦，就算我最好的「作陣的」（台語）的│
│                                                                │先生啦，帶女人去睡被我看到，我也不會講啦，你，你就去玩啦。                      │
│                                                                │廉：喔，沒有啦。                                                                │
│                                                                │張：這是我們的職業道德啦。                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：沒有啦，他在那裡想很久你知道嗎。                                            │
│                                                                │張：…。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：他說喔，有看過，跟誰有來過。                                                │
│                                                                │張：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：我到那時候快6、7點，差不多7點我才跟他說找你們最好的，他說跟你最好的啦，我不 │
│                                                                │知道，我說喔，我不知道說是說跟你最好的，但是我不知道說你是不是跟他最好啦，我不知│
│                                                                │道呀，但是他就說跟你最好啦，我也不知道說他跟你最好，你不知道有沒有跟他最好，我也│
│                                                                │不知道呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │張：剛出來做小姐他幫我很多忙啦，出來做幹部也是他帶的，後來沒有跟他，比較沒有聯絡│
│                                                                │，因為我升的比較快，他升的比較慢啦，但是他現在也升上來了，對呀，比我還慢，他協理│
│                                                                │跟副總都比我還慢呀，我所以不好意思呀。                                          │
│                                                                │廉：我知道啦，我就很久很久沒去那裡了。                                          │
│                                                                │張：他有跟我說他在那間，叫我不用不好意思。                                      │
│                                                                │廉：嗯，他是拿名片說陞官了喔。                                                  │
│                                                                │張：我人很不舒服。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：你是怎麼樣。                                                                │
│                                                                │張：昨天好像喝，1點多吧，早上又起來，嗯。                                       │
│                                                                │廉：你也。                                                                      │
│                                                                │張：也很累，又喝，又弄那事情，改天又要去人家家裡洗門風，叫兄弟出來耶。          │
│                                                                │廉：沒有啦，有時候小姐喔，如果自己，剛好就好啦。                                │
│                                                                │張：你現在是開到哪裡了。                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：我剛開到你們路口。                                                          │
│                                                                │張：我等一下打給你，我先訪客一下，可能要買單吧。                                │
│                                                                │廉：OK，好。                                                                    │
│                                                                │張：好。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│58.  2008/03/03  21:07:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段0000號3F頂"                                        │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆                       │廉裕隆表示要回去了                                                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│59.  2008/03/03  21:27:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中縣外埔鄉00鄰○○路000號3F"                                                 │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         九龍理容KTV張 │廉裕隆表示要到家了                                                              │
│                                                  淑惠          │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│60.  2008/03/03  23:23:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │無人接聽                                                                        │
│                           局長戊○○                           │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│61.  2008/03/04  08:10:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │臺中市○○區○○○○街0號9樓頂                                                  │
│                           局長戊○○                           │短訊：非常謝謀                                                                  │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│62.  2008/03/04  08:19:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路00號5F"                                                      │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         水利署李明仁  │水利署李明仁表示本便道工程明日驗收，聯繫驗收事宜，李明仁明日至「天祥街」        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│63.  2008/03/04  08:48:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○街000號12F頂"                                                  │
│                           科長林榮紹             川順營造廉裕隆│廉：科長。                                                                      │
│                                                                │林：隆仔，嗯。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：麻煩，麻煩來辦公室一下好嗎。                                                │
│                                                                │廉：喔，好呀，好呀，這樣我等一下，現在我在公司。                                │
│                                                                │林：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：我等一下過去。                                                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│64.  2008/03/04  08:48:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路00號5F"                                                      │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         科長林榮紹    │廉：科長。                                                                      │
│                                                                │林：隆仔，嗯。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：麻煩，麻煩來辦公室一下好嗎。                                                │
│                                                                │廉：喔，好呀，好呀，這樣我等一下，現在我在公司。                                │
│                                                                │林：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：我等一下過去。                                                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│65.  2008/03/04  09:25:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段0000號3F頂"                                        │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         第三河川局鍾彥│第三河川局癸○○表示明日驗收水利署由李明仁驗收，會計科由第一科陳文信            │
│                                                  虎            │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│66.  2008/03/04  09:36:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○路○段00000號4F頂"                                           │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         第三河川局鍾彥│癸○○表示驗收當日川順公司技師要到場                                            │
│                                                  虎            │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│67.  2008/03/04  09:42:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號6樓"                                                │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造技師陳│明日本便道工程複驗，? 裕隆要技師陳明晉到場；陳明晉表示明日本減災工程亦查驗，且由│
│                                                  明晉          │第三河川局之簽證技師杜明星查驗，杜明星係陳明晉同學                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│68.  2008/03/04  10:09:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         第三河川局鍾彥│第三河川局癸○○轉述水利署李明仁表示AC要驗2天                                   │
│                                                  虎            │                                                                                │
└────────────────────────────────┴────────────────────────────────────────┘

┌────────────────────────────────┬────────────────────────────────────────┐
│編號 日期        時間      監聽電話       撥/接   對方電話      │通聯內容摘要                                                                備註│
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│1.   2008/03/14  10:47:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號6樓"                                                │
│                           科長林榮紹             川順營造戴沼澤│林榮紹向戴沼澤表示下午還要上1堂課                                               │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│2.   2008/03/14  11:03:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○○○鄰○○路00○0號6樓頂"                                      │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         局長戊○○    │戊○○向戴沼澤表示下午14時許「總仔」的朋友要來                                  │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│3.   2008/03/14  11:03:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○區○○街00號6"                                                         │
│                           局長戊○○             川順營造戴沼澤│戊○○向戴沼澤表示下午14時許「總仔」的朋友要來                                  │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│4. 2008/03/14 11:06:00     0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"台中市○區○○路○段00號14樓頂"                                                │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         科長林榮紹    │戴沼澤邀林榮紹出來，林榮紹表示叫?裕隆跟我講                                     │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│5.   2008/03/14  11:09:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │戴泱丞      "台中市○區○○路000號12樓頂"                                            │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         川順營造戴沼銘│戴沼銘：喂。                                                                    │
│                                                                │戴沼澤：「泱丞」沒有在那裡嗎。                                                  │
│                                                                │戴沼銘：有呀，他說要過去「天祥街」。                                            │
│                                                                │戴沼澤：啊，你那個這個，這個他的「機子」怎麼不通，為什麼。                      │
│                                                                │戴沼銘：裡面這裡都不通啦，啊，你現在，我現在你打給我，我出來外面聽呀。          │
│                                                                │戴沼澤：到底。                                                                  │
│                                                                │戴沼銘：對呀，這裡面我跟你講死角，收訊都死角，都，「機子」都放在窗門邊才聽的到呀│
│                                                                │。                                                                              │
│                                                                │戴沼澤：他的「機子」每次都不行，他現在人在裡面嗎。                              │
│                                                                │戴沼銘：在這裡呀，剛來在工地剛進來，你等一下。                                  │
│                                                                │（戴沼銘將電話交予戴泱丞）                                                      │
│                                                                │戴泱丞：喂。                                                                    │
│                                                                │戴沼澤：「彭仔」有去嗎。                                                        │
│                                                                │戴泱丞：沒有咧。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴沼澤：啊，「羅仕政」呢。                                                      │
│                                                                │戴泱丞：沒有呀，沒有呀，嗯，嗯，怎麼，我等一下要過去。                          │
│                                                                │戴沼澤：…。                                                                    │
│                                                                │戴泱丞：什麼。                                                                  │
│                                                                │戴沼澤：還是要約他們來來來吃個飯，會個議，會議一下，有什麼什麼困難，這樣大家弄那│
│                                                                │個一下。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴泱丞：嗯，好呀。                                                              │
│                                                                │戴沼澤：喔，你叫看。                                                            │
│                                                                │戴泱丞：我跟他約，他們有時候，「彭仔」有時候都有事情，要去會勘呀，我聯絡他一下。│
│                                                                │戴沼澤：我叫「長仔」來，看有什麼問題大家都提出來講啦。                          │
│                                                                │戴泱丞：好啦。                                                                  │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│6.   2008/03/14  11:12:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"台中市○區○○路000號12樓頂"                                                   │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         川順營造廉裕隆│廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：你叫「林科長」過來「天祥街」啦，看中午這樣喔。                              │
│                                                                │廉：喔，好，好。                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│7.   2008/03/14  11:12:00   0000000000     接     0000000000    │"台中市○區○○路000號12樓頂"                                                   │
│                            川順營造廉裕隆        川順營造戴沼澤│廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：你叫「林科長」過來「天祥街」啦，看中午這樣喔。                              │
│                                                                │廉：喔，好，好。                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│8.   2008/03/14  11:14:00   0000000000      接    0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號6樓"                                                │
│                            科長林榮紹            川順營造廉裕隆│林：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：科長。                                                                      │
│                                                                │林：是。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：我阿隆。                                                                    │
│                                                                │林：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：今天有走遠嗎。                                                              │
│                                                                │林：沒有。                                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：喔，要說看你中午有沒有空。                                                  │
│                                                                │林：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：要做什麼。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：「水溝邊」。                                                                │
│                                                                │林：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：喔，喔。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：這樣有啦。                                                                  │
│                                                                │林：我知道，嗯，我知道。                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：喔，好啦，好啦我，看，嗯，好，好，啊，中午，好。                            │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│9.   2008/03/14  11:16:00  0000000000     撥      0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造戴沼澤│戴：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：說有啦，要過來這裡。                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：要過來這裡啦。                                                              │
│                                                                │戴：早一點過來，啊，那個，我有叫他叫「彭仔」過來啦，跟他們那個「羅仕政」。      │
│                                                                │廉：喔，我有跟他講。                                                            │
│                                                                │戴：…。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：嗯，嗯，好啦，好啦。                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：「羅仕政」叫看看，叫「泱丞」叫，早一點過來，過來大家。                      │
│                                                                │廉：好，好，好。                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│10.  2008/03/14  11:16:00 0000000000       接     0000000000    │"台中市○區○○路000號12樓頂"                                                   │
│                          川順營造戴沼澤          川順營造廉裕隆│戴：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：說有啦，要過來這裡。                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：要過來這裡啦。                                                              │
│                                                                │戴：早一點過來，啊，那個，我有叫他叫「彭仔」過來啦，跟他們那個「羅仕政」。      │
│                                                                │廉：喔，我有跟他講。                                                            │
│                                                                │戴：…。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：嗯，嗯，好啦，好啦。                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：「羅仕政」叫看看，叫「泱丞」叫，早一點過來，過來大家。                      │
│                                                                │廉：好，好，好。                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│11.  2008/03/14  11:25:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"台中市○區○○路000號12樓頂"                                                   │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         川順營造戴泱丞│戴泱丞表示尚在聯絡第三河川局羅仕政等人                                          │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│12.  2008/03/14  11:32:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"台中市○區○○路000號12樓頂"                                                   │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         川順營造戴泱丞│戴泱丞表示第三河川局彭壽奇還在新社會勘今日沒空，戴泱丞表示與羅仕政講沒有用，羅仕│
│                                                                │政要求拍照等程式                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│13.  2008/03/14  11:48:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"台中市○區○○路000號12樓頂"                                                   │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         川順營造廉裕隆│戴沼澤要?裕隆邀戊○○下午忙完再過來                                             │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│14.  2008/03/14  11:48:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段0000號8F頂"                                        │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造戴沼澤│戴沼澤要廉裕隆邀戊○○下午忙完再過來                                            │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│15.  2008/03/14  11:49:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○區○○街00號6"                                                         │
│                           局長戊○○             川順營造廉裕隆│許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：長仔，我阿隆。                                                              │
│                                                                │許：嗯，是，嗯。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：我舅舅說你若忙完，看你有沒有空。                                            │
│                                                                │許：嗯，我差不多要2、3點以後。                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：喔，好，好，好。                                                            │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│16.  2008/03/14  12:02:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號 1F"                                                │
│                           科長林榮紹             川順營造廉裕隆│林：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：在路上。                                                                    │
│                                                                │林：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：差不多再，你差不多再多久。                                                  │
│                                                                │林：20分。                                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：20分。                                                                      │
│                                                                │林：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：這樣，這樣，這樣我在這裡等你。                                              │
│                                                                │林：嗯嗯嗯。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：喔，好。                                                                    │
│                                                                │林：嗯。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│17.  2008/03/14  12:10:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段0000號8F頂"                                        │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         女友王莉婷    │廉裕隆向王莉婷表示沒有酒                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│18.  2008/03/14  12:23:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆                       │廉裕隆表示剛要到「野店」吃飯                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│19.  2008/03/14  12:48:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○區○○路000號13樓頂"                                                   │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │女友陳玉瑛：喂。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：你在睡覺喔。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：怎麼沒有…。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：「他」呢。                                                                  │
│                                                                │許：沒有回來呀。                                                                │
│                                                                │陳：誰。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：那個，「我那個同事呀」。                                                    │
│                                                                │陳：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：對呀，他們去工地呀，去工地呀，還沒回來。                                    │
│                                                                │陳：他們要幾點才會回來。                                                        │
│                                                                │許：不曉得。                                                                    │
│                                                                │陳：不曉得喔。                                                                  │
│                                                                │許：嗯，你要出去嗎。                                                            │
│                                                                │陳：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：你有要出去嗎。                                                              │
│                                                                │陳：沒有啦，我帶他去玩。                                                        │
│                                                                │許：好啦。                                                                      │
│                                                                │陳：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │許：等他，等他回來啦。                                                          │
│                                                                │陳：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：等他回來我電話再和你聯絡啦。                                                │
│                                                                │陳：好啦，啊，你，你下午要去「拚經濟」喔。                                      │
│                                                                │許：嗯，下午有朋友要來看啦，看等事情談完以後再解決。                            │
│                                                                │陳：啊，你不是要去「拚經濟」。                                                  │
│                                                                │許：對呀，會呀，會過去。                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：又「那邊」了喔。                                                            │
│                                                                │許：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：然後「他」回來你要打給我喔。                                                │
│                                                                │許：好啦，好。                                                                  │
│                                                                │陳：先睡呀。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│20.  2008/03/14  12:58:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │楊雅惠      臺中市○區○○街00號6                                               │
│                           局長戊○○             楓之林理容KTV │短訊：﹒＋′′′＋﹒＋′′′＋﹒    ＋    ＨＯＮＥＹ    ＋    ′＋﹒ＨＯＮＥＹ﹒│
│                                                  編號66號小姐  │＋′                  〞  ａ  ａ〞情人笀          臿                            │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│21.  2008/03/14  13:04:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○區○○街00號6"                                                         │
│                           局長戊○○             楓之林理容KTV │戊○○與理容KTV女子閒聊                                                         │
│                                                  編號66號小姐  │                                                                                │
│                                                  楊雅惠        │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│22.  2008/03/14  13:21:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │台中市○○區○○路○段000巷00號16F屋頂                                          │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤                       │您有未接來電:                                                                   │
│                                                                │03/12 09:38AM來自0000000000 (0通)                                               │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│23.  2008/03/14  13:46:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○路○段0號5F頂"                                               │
│                           科長林榮紹             同事          │林榮紹向同事表示在外面辦事情                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│24.  2008/03/14  14:08:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │臺中市○區○○街00號6                                                           │
│                           局長戊○○                           │短訊：親愛的鄉親長輩兄弟姐妹, ３２２總統統大選, 是咱挽救台灣經濟繁榮進步的好希望│
│                                                                │, 懇請各位一定投票給（２號）馬英九﹒蕭萬長,賴順仁懇託您                    匙臿 │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│25.  2008/03/14  14:38:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造戴永恭│廉裕隆向戴永恭表示在「天祥街」，戴永恭叫人將過去載電視                          │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│26.  2008/03/14  14:44:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆                       │廉裕隆於「天祥街」，戴泱丞剛到，戴泱丞持用?裕隆行動電話與川順公司人員聯繫       │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│27.  2008/03/14  14:56:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆                       │廉裕隆向張淑惠表示在忙                                                          │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│28.  2008/03/14  15:00:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂                                      │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         金拿獎視聽歌唱│短訊：哈囉! 金拿獎已改名為香格里拉, 全新的裝璜, 一流的陣容定於３月１７日開始營業│
│                                                  坊陳秀月(綽號 │試賣;３月２３正式開幕,期待您的蒞臨指教  謝謝!~茀                      釿        │
│                                                  ：阿華)       │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│29.  2008/03/14  15:11:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○區○○街00號6"                                                         │
│                           局長戊○○             川順營造王莉婷│許：喂，喂。                                                                    │
│                                                                │王：喂，還多久會到「這裡」。                                                    │
│                                                                │許：我現在還有客人在這裡，我說完再那個喔。                                      │
│                                                                │王：好，再1個鐘頭。                                                             │
│                                                                │許：好好。                                                                      │
│                                                                │王：好好好。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│30.  2008/03/14  15:46:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○路○段0號5F頂"                                               │
│                           科長林榮紹             同事          │與同事聯繫                                                                      │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│31.  2008/03/14  15:48:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         配偶          │廉裕隆向妻表示在「天祥街」                                                      │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│32.  2008/03/14  15:51:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           局長戊○○                           │戊○○與苗栗縣議員聯繫陳情事項                                                  │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│33.  2008/03/14  15:54:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           局長戊○○             第三河川局張文│無人接聽                                                                        │
│                                                  榮            │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│34.  2008/03/14  15:56:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           局長戊○○             第三河川局張文│無人接聽                                                                        │
│                                                  榮            │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│35.  2008/03/14  16:03:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○路○段0號5F頂"                                               │
│                           科長林榮紹             第三河川局顏詒│（撥通前，林榮紹與川順公司人員談話）                                            │
│                                                  星            │林：…我是說喔，你要推這個「文」，要跟你們的「主任」，跟「局長」喔，寫到1個很， │
│                                                                │很。                                                                            │
│                                                                │（撥通後）                                                                      │
│                                                                │第三河川局顏詒星：喂。                                                          │
│                                                                │林：小顏喔。                                                                    │
│                                                                │顏：是，嗯，科長，嗯。                                                          │
│                                                                │林：嗯，麻煩你那個，那個「公文」喔。                                            │
│                                                                │顏：嗯嗯。                                                                      │
│                                                                │林：傳真一下好嗎。                                                              │
│                                                                │顏：傳真，我現在，但是我現在在半路你知道嗎。                                    │
│                                                                │林：半路喔。                                                                    │
│                                                                │顏：縣政府這裡要回來半路上面，這樣呀。                                          │
│                                                                │林：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │顏：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：這樣，那個公文有誰知道。                                                    │
│                                                                │顏：公文喔，我可以唸給你。                                                      │
│                                                                │林：OK。                                                                        │
│                                                                │顏：我是有帶在身上啦。                                                          │
│                                                                │林：喔喔，好呀，這樣你，你，你。                                                │
│                                                                │顏：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：給「長仔」。                                                                │
│                                                                │顏：還是等一下。                                                                │
│                                                                │林：啊，還是你要來「溝仔邊」（台語）。                                          │
│                                                                │顏：「溝仔邊」。                                                                │
│                                                                │林：「溝仔邊」呀，「溝仔邊」你知道嗎。                                          │
│                                                                │顏：我不知道耶。                                                                │
│                                                                │林：那小懶人樹種很多的太原路，太原二橋下面的「溝仔邊」呀。                      │
│                                                                │顏：太原二號橋下面「溝仔邊」。                                                  │
│                                                                │林：「阿如」你知道嗎，跟我們去那個，他們這個。                                  │
│                                                                │顏：嗯嗯。                                                                      │
│                                                                │林：嗯，喔，你現在在上面還要回來嘛喔。                                          │
│                                                                │顏：嗯嗯嗯嗯。                                                                  │
│                                                                │林：往這裡轉進來一下。                                                          │
│                                                                │顏：嗯，喔，好，好。                                                            │
│                                                                │林：好好好好好。                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│36.  2008/03/14  16:05:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○路○段0號5F頂"                                               │
│                           科長林榮紹             川順營造戴永恭│戴永恭：喂。                                                                    │
│                                                                │林：嗯，永恭，嗯。                                                              │
│                                                                │戴：科長呀，現在在哪裡。                                                        │
│                                                                │林：我，我在「溝仔邊」。                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：喔，筏子溪喔。                                                              │
│                                                                │林：「溝仔邊」啦，「溝仔邊」啦。                                                │
│                                                                │戴：「溝仔邊」喔。                                                              │
│                                                                │林：嗯嗯嗯嗯。                                                                  │
│                                                                │戴：我拿過去給你還是，還是要拿過去你家裡。                                      │
│                                                                │林：不要緊，不然你拿過來給我也好，現在幾點了。                                  │
│                                                                │戴：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：現在幾點了。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：現在4，4點，4點多了。                                                       │
│                                                                │林：4點5分喔，啊，你現在人在哪裡。                                              │
│                                                                │戴：我現在在球場，不然我現在拿過去，喔。                                        │
│                                                                │林：要拿過去我家好了。                                                          │
│                                                                │戴：拿去你家喔。                                                                │
│                                                                │林：應該，嗯，我女兒回來了。                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：不然你聯絡看看，我一邊走往你家，那個也是要往你家方向來。                    │
│                                                                │林：好好好好好好好。                                                            │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│37.  2008/03/14  16:07:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○路○段0號5F頂"                                               │
│                           科長林榮紹                           │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│38.  2008/03/14  16:09:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │林榮紹：嗯，女兒。                                                              │
│                           科長林榮紹             女兒          │女兒：怎樣。                                                                    │
│                                                                │林：你到家了嗎。                                                                │
│                                                                │女：我要到家了呀。                                                              │
│                                                                │林：嗯，等一下我叫，那個戴，「戴叔叔」送過去喔，好不好。                        │
│                                                                │女：現在嗎。                                                                    │
│                                                                │林：送去家裡呀。                                                                │
│                                                                │女：現在喔。                                                                    │
│                                                                │林：嗯，啊。                                                                    │
│                                                                │女：…。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：他還沒到啦。                                                                │
│                                                                │女：喔，好啦。                                                                  │
│                                                                │林：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │女：好。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│39.  2008/03/14  16:11:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○路○段0號5F頂"                                               │
│                           科長林榮紹             川順營造戴永恭│林榮紹表示女兒在家，要戴永恭拿過去                                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│40.  2008/03/14  16:37:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │（無人接聽，林榮紹電話傳出戊○○談話聲）                                        │
│                           科長林榮紹             第三河川局顏詒│許：…不用怕，你不認識他，又和…，甲方被修理假的，每回也那個…                  │
│                                                  星            │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│41.  2008/03/14  16:38:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           科長林榮紹             第三河川局顏詒│林：小顏。                                                                      │
│                                                  星            │第三河川局顏詒星：我現在到太原二號橋，我在橋頭這裡。                            │
│                                                                │林：哪裡呀。                                                                    │
│                                                                │顏：太原二號橋…。                                                              │
│                                                                │林：喔，現在門，門開開呀，嗯，門不要關。                                        │
│                                                                │顏：這樣喔，好，好。                                                            │
│                                                                │（戊○○於林榮紹旁談話）                                                        │
│                                                                │許：…我跟你講，契約的精神他們現在若說完全沒有辦法給你做…。                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│42.  2008/03/14  16:41:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           局長戊○○             第三河川局張文│與第三河川局甲○○聯繫苗栗縣議員陳情事項                                        │
│                                                  榮            │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│43.  2008/03/14  16:50:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           局長戊○○             委員顏沛華    │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │水利署外聘委員成功大學顏沛華：同學，嗯。                                        │
│                                                                │許：嗯，現在要過去嗎。                                                          │
│                                                                │顏：你，你待會兒會、會去嗎。                                                    │
│                                                                │許：我呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │顏：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：我會派人給你安排。                                                          │
│                                                                │顏：喔，這樣。                                                                  │
│                                                                │許：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │顏：呃。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：等一下晚一點我再、再那個啦，好不好。                                        │
│                                                                │顏：好好好好好。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：你現在過去啦喔，那我。                                                      │
│                                                                │顏：喔，我現在過去，我現在過去。                                                │
│                                                                │許：嗯，你現在過去，我叫人過去給你那個安排。                                    │
│                                                                │顏：喔，好，好。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：OK，OK。                                                                    │
│                                                                │顏：謝謝。                                                                      │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│44.  2008/03/14  16:52:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：那個，那個現在我們「顏同學」要過去喔。                                      │
│                                                                │陳：多久到。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：多久到。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：不敢什麼。                                                                  │
│                                                                │陳：還要多久到。                                                                │
│                                                                │許：他現在要過去，可能差不多10分鐘左右喔。                                      │
│                                                                │陳：就到「那邊」了。                                                            │
│                                                                │許：嗯嗯嗯。                                                                    │
│                                                                │陳：你說「那裡」，我已經給他弄1個OK了。                                         │
│                                                                │許：什麼弄1個OK。                                                               │
│                                                                │陳：就是。                                                                      │
│                                                                │許：你就給他排好就好呀。                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：我知道，我知道啦。                                                          │
│                                                                │許：對啦。                                                                      │
│                                                                │陳：好，OK。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：你去跟他排好啦。                                                            │
│                                                                │陳：他1個人而已嗎。                                                             │
│                                                                │許：嗯嗯嗯嗯。                                                                  │
│                                                                │陳：OK，好好，我安排，好。                                                      │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│45.  2008/03/14  16:55:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市北屯區南京東路三段"                                                      │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：嗯，怎麼。                                                                  │
│                                                                │陳：你跟「顏大哥」喔，打電話跟他講，說他到的時候找1個「淑萍」（音譯）。         │
│                                                                │許：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：「淑萍阿母」，你跟他講一下，啊，因為我差不多半個鐘頭才會到。                │
│                                                                │許：拜託，你實在喔，好，好啦，好啦。                                            │
│                                                                │陳：說叫他找「淑萍」喔。                                                        │
│                                                                │許：好。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：我應該「發落」（台語），都「發落」。                                        │
│                                                                │許：好。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：OK，好。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：OK，好好。                                                                  │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│46.  2008/03/14  16:56:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           局長戊○○             委員顏沛華    │顏：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：喂，同學。                                                                  │
│                                                                │顏：是。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：你到喔。                                                                    │
│                                                                │顏：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：找1個幹部叫「淑萍」（音譯）。                                               │
│                                                                │顏：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：幹部叫「淑萍」，喔，他會幫你安排好。                                        │
│                                                                │顏：好好好。                                                                    │
│                                                                │許：OK，喔。                                                                    │
│                                                                │顏：好好好。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│47.  2008/03/14  17:03:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○路○段0號5F頂"                                               │
│                           科長林榮紹             配偶          │林榮紹向配偶表示在「溝仔邊」，和「許老闆」在這裡，林榮紹表示再過去載配偶        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│48.  2008/03/14  17:06:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○路○段0號5F頂"                                               │
│                           科長林榮紹             同事          │與同事聯繫（簽退）                                                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│49.  2008/03/14  17:15:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段0000號8F頂"                                        │
│                           局長戊○○             委員顏沛華    │許：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │顏：同學，我已經到了。                                                          │
│                                                                │許：好，好，我後面跟著過去。                                                    │
│                                                                │顏：OK。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│50.  2008/03/14  17:15:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         女友王莉婷    │王莉婷要廉裕隆過來                                                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│51.  2008/03/14  17:41:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路00號7樓頂"                                                   │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │陳：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：「他」過去了嗎。                                                            │
│                                                                │陳：有呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │許：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：我們在這裡玩。                                                              │
│                                                                │許：喔，好，啊，那個有買茶葉給你，提進去還是怎麼樣。                            │
│                                                                │陳：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：茶葉啦。                                                                    │
│                                                                │陳：好呀，啊，你現在不是在拚經濟嗎。                                            │
│                                                                │許：我有要過去啦。                                                              │
│                                                                │陳：好，OK，好，好，OK。                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│52.  2008/03/14  17:41:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"台中縣太平市○○街00號7樓之1"                                                  │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         幀衡工程顧問有│無人接聽                                                                        │
│                                                  限公司劉禎忠  │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│53.  2008/03/14  17:49:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○區○○路00號12樓-10"                                                   │
│                           科長林榮紹             兒子          │林榮紹交待兒子晚餐自理，兒子表示妹妹去看棒球了                                  │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│54.  2008/03/14  17:55:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"台中市○區○○○00鄰○○○路000○0號二樓及頂樓屋凸"                            │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         幀衡工程顧問有│戴：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                  限公司劉禎忠  │劉：董仔喔，抱歉，在洗澡啦，嗯。                                                │
│                                                                │戴：啊，賺一下就就就那個喔，轉一個頭不見人。                                    │
│                                                                │劉：喔，我不知道你在哪裡坐，你在哪裡呀。                                        │
│                                                                │戴：我就在，在後面啦。                                                          │
│                                                                │劉：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：在後面，你晚上有事嗎。                                                      │
│                                                                │劉：晚上是只有想看棒球，啊，你呢。                                              │
│                                                                │戴：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │劉：你呢。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：沒有，我晚上喔。                                                            │
│                                                                │劉：嗯，嗯。                                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：我想要，現在不要說，是你來「楓仔」一下啦。                                  │
│                                                                │劉：好，「楓仔」嗎。                                                            │
│                                                                │戴：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │劉：好，好，好。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：我，我是有1個事情跟你講一下，這樣。                                         │
│                                                                │劉：好呀，好呀，好呀。                                                          │
│                                                                │戴：為什麼會走這一趟路啦喔。                                                    │
│                                                                │劉：OK。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：為什麼會叫你來啦，好嗎。                                                    │
│                                                                │劉：OK，OK，OK，好，好，這樣我。                                                │
│                                                                │戴：弄一弄再過來喔。                                                            │
│                                                                │劉：差不多，差不多20分鐘出發喔。                                                │
│                                                                │戴：嗯嗯嗯。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│55.  2008/03/14  17:56:00   0000000000      接    0000000000    │"臺中市○區○○○○○○路000號14F頂"                                            │
│                            科長林榮紹                          │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│56.  2008/03/14  18:18:00   0000000000      接    0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                            川順營造廉裕隆        女友          │廉裕隆與女友閒聊                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│57.  2008/03/14  18:31:00   0000000000      接    0000000000    │林榮紹向妻表示還沒回家，妻已行經竹南，林榮紹表示會過去載                        │
│                            科長林榮紹            配偶          │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│58.  2008/03/14  18:33:00   0000000000      接    0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○○○○○路0段00000號3樓頂"                                     │
│                            川順營造戴沼澤        配偶          │戴：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │妻：喂，你人在哪裡。                                                            │
│                                                                │戴：我和，晚上喔，和「長仔」他們那些會出來，出來吃飯一下喔。                    │
│                                                                │妻：好啦。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：喔，我等一下再回去，喔。                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│59.  2008/03/14  18:47:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │配偶表示等一下到苑裡了，林榮紹表示等一下過去配偶朋友那裡接他                    │
│                           科長林榮紹             配偶          │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│60.  2008/03/14  18:49:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造戴沼澤│廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：你還在那裡嗎。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：他們剛走。                                                                  │
│                                                                │戴：他們結束了嗎。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：你說哪裡，隔壁嗎。                                                          │
│                                                                │戴：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：隔壁應該還在那裡，還在那裡。                                                │
│                                                                │戴：還在那裡喔。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：還是你要，看要過來「楓」一下，不然他們不知道要到什麼時候，我要回去了。      │
│                                                                │廉：你要走了，啊，你車子呢。                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：不要緊呀，你說我的車子放在那裡，你把我載回去就好了。                        │
│                                                                │廉：好呀，好呀。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：這樣還是，「阿忠」也有來啦喔，喔，你跟他說，不然我，我，你跟他講一下喔。    │
│                                                                │廉：喔，「阿如」喔。                                                            │
│                                                                │戴：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：叫他車子，叫他自己回來就對啦。                                              │
│                                                                │戴：對啦，你若…。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：好，好，好，這樣我等一下再過去啦，我等一下再過去。                          │
│                                                                │戴：好。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│61.  2008/03/14  18:50:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○○0鄰○○路0段000號14樓頂"                                     │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         川順營造廉裕隆│廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：你還在那裡嗎。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：他們剛走。                                                                  │
│                                                                │戴：他們結束了嗎。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：你說哪裡，隔壁嗎。                                                          │
│                                                                │戴：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：隔壁應該還在那裡，還在那裡。                                                │
│                                                                │戴：還在那裡喔。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：還是你要，看要過來「楓」一下，不然他們不知道要到什麼時候，我要回去了。      │
│                                                                │廉：你要走了，啊，你車子呢。                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：不要緊呀，你說我的車子放在那裡，你把我載回去就好了。                        │
│                                                                │廉：好呀，好呀。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：這樣還是，「阿忠」也有來啦喔，喔，你跟他說，不然我，我，你跟他講一下喔。    │
│                                                                │廉：喔，「阿如」喔。                                                            │
│                                                                │戴：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：叫他車子，叫他自己回來就對啦。                                              │
│                                                                │戴：對啦，你若…。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：好，好，好，這樣我等一下再過去啦，我等一下再過去。                          │
│                                                                │戴：好。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│62.  2008/03/14  18:53:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○0路000號8 F頂"                                                 │
│                           九龍理容KTV張淑惠      川順營造廉裕隆│廉：我們「老闆」在你們另外那邊啦。                                              │
│                                                                │張：你說什麼。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：我們老闆。                                                                  │
│                                                                │張：你們要從這邊過就對了啦。                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：對對對。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│63.  2008/03/14  19:06:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │廉裕隆向王莉婷表示戴沼澤有打電話來、還清醒                                      │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         女友王莉婷    │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│64.  2008/03/14  19:20:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │無人接聽                                                                        │
│                           科長林榮紹             配偶          │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│65.  2008/03/14  19:21:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○街000號14F頂"                                              │
│                           科長林榮紹             配偶          │妻問林榮紹為何響那麼久都不聽                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│66.  2008/03/14  19:30:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○路○段00號之13F頂"                                           │
│                           科長林榮紹             配偶          │林榮紹表示10分鐘內會到                                                          │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│67.  2008/03/14  19:32:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○路○段000號B4"                                               │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造戴沼澤│廉裕隆向戴沼澤表示已出來載了                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│68.  2008/03/14  19:32:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○○○○○路0段00000號3樓頂"                                     │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         川順營造廉裕隆│廉裕隆向戴沼澤表示已出來載了                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│69.  2008/03/14  19:39:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號14F頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶          │戊○○要妻子去載兒子                                                            │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│70.  2008/03/14  19:50:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○○○○○路0段00000號3樓頂"                                     │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         川順營造廉裕隆│無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│71.  2008/03/14  19:51:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○○○○○路0段00000號3樓頂"                                     │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         川順營造廉裕隆│廉裕隆向戴沼澤表示已在門口了                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│72.  2008/03/14  19:51:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中縣沙鹿鎮○○○街00號2F"                                                    │
│                           科長林榮紹             配偶          │林榮紹向妻表示已到新天地了                                                      │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│73.  2008/03/14  19:54:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │戴沼澤要廉裕隆進來一下                                                          │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造戴沼澤│                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│74.  2008/03/14  19:54:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │戴沼澤要廉裕隆進來一下                                                          │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         川順營造廉裕隆│                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│75.  2008/03/14  20:17:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路00號7樓頂"                                                   │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造戴沼澤│廉裕隆向戴沼澤表示在門口等，沒有要進去                                          │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│76.  2008/03/14  20:17:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○○○○○路0段00000號3樓頂"                                     │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         川順營造廉裕隆│廉裕隆向戴沼澤表示在門口等，沒有要進去                                          │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│77.  2008/03/14  20:21:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │戴沼澤要廉裕隆來店門口載他                                                      │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造戴沼澤│                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│78.  2008/03/14  20:21:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │戴沼澤要廉裕隆來店門口載他                                                      │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         川順營造廉裕隆│                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│79.  2008/03/14  20:25:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"台中市○○路○段000號12F屋頂"                                                  │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         幀衡工程顧問有│劉：喂，喂，「董仔」，嗯。                                                      │
│                                                  限公司劉禎忠  │戴：出來外面聽一下啦。                                                          │
│                                                                │劉：好，等一下，你在哪裡。                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：我在外面啦，你來外面聽，電話拿出來外面聽，我跟你講。                        │
│                                                                │劉：你在哪裡，我現在走出來了。                                                  │
│                                                                │戴：不是啦，你那個，現在就是他們「連教授」他們要進來啦喔。                      │
│                                                                │劉：喔，好，喔喔。                                                              │
│                                                                │戴：啊，那些「女孩」就是你不要花啦，那就叫人來花的，你知道嗎。                  │
│                                                                │劉：喔，好啦，好啦，好啦。                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：你現在退1局啦，好嗎，喔。                                                   │
│                                                                │劉：好啦，好啦，好啦。                                                          │
│                                                                │戴：那一局我們自己處理啦，啊，那局讓他們去處理啦，不然「那些」又進來，從中午就去│
│                                                                │了，就2個就，對否。                                                             │
│                                                                │劉：啊，啊怎麼講。                                                              │
│                                                                │戴：社會事情就是公平的啦。                                                      │
│                                                                │劉：啊，好呀，好呀，好呀，好呀。                                                │
│                                                                │戴：自己的罪業自己擔啦，不要給別人擔，你知道嗎。                                │
│                                                                │劉：瞭解，瞭解，瞭解。                                                          │
│                                                                │戴：喔喔。                                                                      │
│                                                                │劉：OK，OK，OK，好。                                                            │
│                                                                │戴：那麼大群來再續1局，再給他切掉啦，好嗎。                                     │
│                                                                │劉：好呀，好呀，好呀。                                                          │
│                                                                │戴：喔，他們若進來之後。                                                        │
│                                                                │劉：我同樣在這裡啦，對啦，喔。                                                  │
│                                                                │戴：沒有啦，現在就完了之後喔，退1局啦，本來你替我擔，我跟你講啦，就他們那些要帶 │
│                                                                │進來了啦。                                                                      │
│                                                                │劉：好啦，好啦，好。                                                            │
│                                                                │戴：叫1個先期部隊先來，你知道嗎。                                               │
│                                                                │劉：我知道，我知道，我知道，我有看到，嗯。                                      │
│                                                                │戴：你就在那裡的再「翻攤」（台語）啦。                                          │
│                                                                │劉：我知道，我知道，我知道，我知道。                                            │
│                                                                │戴：坐不下去了就「翻攤」，這樣你知道嗎。                                        │
│                                                                │劉：瞭解，瞭解，瞭解。                                                          │
│                                                                │戴：你要靠近，你想再餘興你就去，不然不去也不要緊啦。                            │
│                                                                │劉：OK，OK，OK。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：喔，喔。                                                                    │
│                                                                │劉：瞭解，瞭解，瞭解，好，謝謝喔，好，好，OK。                                  │
│                                                                │戴：好，謝謝你啦，今天不好意思。                                                │
│                                                                │劉：謝謝啦，董仔，說這樣喔，OK，OK，OK。                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│80.  2008/03/14  21:44:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號14F頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○                           │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│81.  2008/03/14  22:15:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │戊○○向妻表示要晚點回去                                                        │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶          │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│82.  2008/03/14  23:21:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │戊○○向妻表示在路上了                                                          │
│                           局長戊○○             配偶          │                                                                                │
└────────────────────────────────┴────────────────────────────────────────┘

┌────────────────────────────────┬────────────────────────────────────────┐
│編號 日期        時間      監聽電話       撥/接   對方電話      │通聯內容摘要                                                                備註│
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│1.   2008/03/14  15:00:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂                                      │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         金拿獎視聽歌唱│短訊：哈囉! 金拿獎已改名為香格里拉, 全新的裝璜, 一流的陣容定於３月１７日開始營業│
│                                                  坊陳秀月(綽號 │試賣;３月２３正式開幕,期待您的蒞臨指教  謝謝!~茀                      釿        │
│                                                  ：阿華)       │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│2.   2008/03/17  15:10:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段0000號8F頂"                                        │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         科長林榮紹    │林：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：喂，科長，嗯。                                                              │
│                                                                │林：隆仔。                                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：抱歉，我打去0000000000。                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：嗯，抱歉。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：現在是這樣啦喔，就那個「阿華」你知道嗎。                                    │
│                                                                │廉：嗯嗯嗯。                                                                    │
│                                                                │林：嗯，今天，那個，就和「那個」，喔。                                          │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：你舅舅呢。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：在忙，在忙。                                                                │
│                                                                │林：好啦，這樣我回去再跟你講。                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：好好好。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│3.   2008/03/17  15:10:00  0000000000      接    0000000000     │"臺中市南屯區向上路二段1"                                                       │
│                           科長林榮紹            川順營造廉裕隆 │林：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：喂，科長，嗯。                                                              │
│                                                                │林：隆仔。                                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：抱歉，我打去0000000000。                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：嗯，抱歉。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：現在是這樣啦喔，就那個「阿華」你知道嗎。                                    │
│                                                                │廉：嗯嗯嗯。                                                                    │
│                                                                │林：嗯，今天，那個，就和「那個」，喔。                                          │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：你舅舅呢。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：在忙，在忙。                                                                │
│                                                                │林：好啦，這樣我回去再跟你講。                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：好好好。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│4.   2008/03/17  16:34:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市南屯區向上路二段1"                                                       │
│                           科長林榮紹             水利署林森興  │林森興：喂。                                                                    │
│                                                                │林榮紹：興仔。                                                                  │
│                                                                │林森興：喂，嗯，科長。                                                          │
│                                                                │林榮紹：這樣再拜託一下，因為要5點。                                             │
│                                                                │林森興：喔，好，OK，OK。                                                        │
│                                                                │林榮紹：我在外面。                                                              │
│                                                                │林森興：好。                                                                    │
│                                                                │林榮紹：再拜託一下。                                                            │
│                                                                │林森興：OK，OK。                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│5.   2008/03/17  16:35:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市南屯區向上路二段1"                                                       │
│                           科長林榮紹             水利署林森興  │林森興：喂。                                                                    │
│                                                                │林榮紹：興仔，我應該是8、9分啦。                                                │
│                                                                │林森興：有，我現在，我現在卡片先放桌上。                                        │
│                                                                │林榮紹：謝謝你，謝謝你，抱歉，抱歉，抱歉。                                      │
│                                                                │林森興：時間差不多的時候再。                                                    │
│                                                                │林榮紹：好。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│6.   2008/03/17  16:44:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段0000號8F頂"                                        │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         金拿獎視聽歌唱│廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                  坊陳秀月、周世│周：阿隆。                                                                      │
│                                                  傑、林榮紹    │廉：有。                                                                        │
│                                                                │周：你在哪裡。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：我在「旱溪」。                                                              │
│                                                                │周：近近的嘛，喔，我跟「林董」，「林榮紹」喔，                                  │
│                                                                │廉：我沒車子，今天就沒車子。                                                    │
│                                                                │周：叫計乘車來呀。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：…。                                                                        │
│                                                                │周：什麼，等一下，等一下，什麼，你在哪裡。                                      │
│                                                                │廉：我在「旱溪」。                                                              │
│                                                                │周：對呀，你要不要來。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：我今天不行啦，今天有事情。                                                  │
│                                                                │周：這樣喔，「董仔」，「董仔」在公司喔。                                        │
│                                                                │廉：在桌子上，在忙。                                                            │
│                                                                │周：在弄那個喔。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │周：你怎麼沒空。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：…。                                                                        │
│                                                                │周：你等一下喔，你等一下喔，來，那個，阿隆。                                    │
│                                                                │（周世傑將電話交予林榮紹）                                                      │
│                                                                │林：隆仔。                                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：有。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：你們「董仔」打牌就打牌，你們「董仔」現在打牌，他打牌想事情而已。            │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：拜託一下，這樣就對了。                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：我，嗯。                                                                    │
│                                                                │林：喔，我會跟你，我會跟「你舅舅」講。                                          │
│                                                                │廉：嗯，嗯，好呀，那個「阿華」。                                                │
│                                                                │林：「阿華」來。                                                                │
│                                                                │（林榮紹將電話交予陳秀月）                                                      │
│                                                                │陳：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：恭喜啦，恭喜啦。                                                            │
│                                                                │陳：你們何時要來啦。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：我就今天沒有，今天不行。                                                    │
│                                                                │陳：你今天不行。啊，今天呢，今天呢，今天這攤呢，今天這攤呢。                    │
│                                                                │廉：喔，2個嗎。                                                                 │
│                                                                │陳：什麼2個。                                                                   │
│                                                                │廉：幾個。                                                                      │
│                                                                │陳：1、2、3、4，4個啦，啊，現在剩2個男人啦。                                    │
│                                                                │廉：喔喔。                                                                      │
│                                                                │陳：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：你就先看多少再跟我講一下。                                                  │
│                                                                │陳：OK。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：應該會跟他講啦。                                                            │
│                                                                │陳：好啦，好啦，這樣我再處理起來。                                              │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：多少我再跟你講。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：好。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：好好好，OK。                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│7.   2008/03/17  17:31:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市南屯區向上路二段1"                                                       │
│                           科長林榮紹             第三河川局王俊│撥打第三河川局王俊清，無人接聽                                                  │
│                                                  清            │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│8.   2008/03/17  17:35:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         金拿獎視聽歌唱│廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                  坊陳秀月      │陳：喂，總共15300。                                                             │
│                                                                │廉：15300。                                                                     │
│                                                                │陳：嗯，喔，好，好。                                                            │
└────────────────────────────────┴────────────────────────────────────────┘

┌────────────────────────────────┬────────────────────────────────────────┐
│編號 日期        時間      監聽電話       撥/接   對方電話      │通聯內容摘要                                                                備註│
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│1.   2008/03/25  10:58:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市西屯區環中路三段8"                                                       │
│                           科長林榮紹             川順營造戴沼澤│林：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：嗯，出去嗎。                                                                │
│                                                                │林：沒有。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：啊。                                                                        │
│                          0000000000      接     0000000000     │林：沒有。                                                                      │
│                          川順營造廉裕隆         水利署壬○○   │戴：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                 林榮紹         │林：沒有啦。                                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：去「鶴園」一下喔。                                                          │
│                                                                │戴：…。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：叫一下喔。                                                                  │
│                                                                │戴：好。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│2.   2008/03/25  10:59:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造戴沼澤│戴沼澤要?裕隆邀水利署周世傑、江文助等人至「鶴園」                               │
│                                                                │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│3.   2008/03/25  11:02:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○區○○街00號6"                                                         │
│                           局長戊○○             川順營造廉裕隆│廉裕隆邀戊○○至「鶴園」                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│4.   2008/03/25  13:55:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○區○○街00號7"                                                         │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造戴沼澤│戴沼澤交代? 裕隆：明日水利署河海組組長「曹華平」至中水局就職局長，弄個東西過去，│
│                                                                │要可以看一點                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│5.   2008/03/25  14:27:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○區○○路000號13樓頂"                                                   │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造鄭年雅│廉裕隆交代鄭年雅送花恭賀曹華平陞官                                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│6.   2008/03/25  14:34:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"中華電信未提供"                                                                │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         水利署壬○○、│（通聯前，壬○○電話傳出壬○○與林榮紹對話）                                    │
│                                                  林榮紹        │葉：他剛剛是在哪裡，我剛沒看到他。                                              │
│                                                                │林：「阿隆」（指?裕隆）呀。                                                     │
│                                                                │葉：我知道，剛才沒看到他呀。                                                    │
│                                                                │（通聯後）                                                                      │
│                                                                │葉：阿隆呀。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：有。                                                                        │
│                                                                │（壬○○電話傳出林榮紹談話聲）                                                  │
│                                                                │林：簽個名。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │葉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │葉：那個，我們在那個什麼。                                                      │
│                                                                │（壬○○電話傳出林榮紹談話聲）                                                  │
│                                                                │林：這間什麼。                                                                  │
│                                                                │葉：河南路的那間。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：新的那間喔。                                                                │
│                                                                │葉：我不知道…，啊，「香格里拉」，現在到了。                                    │
│                                                                │廉：新的，新的那間。                                                            │
│                                                                │葉：嗯，「金拿獎」（指金拿獎理容KTV，金拿獎理容KTV改名為香格里拉理容KTV），嗯， │
│                                                                │對。                                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：喔，你們剛到喔。                                                            │
│                                                                │葉：嗯，現在才到。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：喔，好啦，好啦，我回來「天祥街」，我要到了，等一下再講。                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│7.   2008/03/25  15:23:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         水利署壬○○  │廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │葉：不要啦，抱歉啦。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：副座。                                                                      │
│                                                                │葉：好啦，好啦，抱歉啦。                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：喂。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│8.   2008/03/25  15:26:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段0000號8F頂"                                        │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         川順營造戴永恭│廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：嗯，嗯。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：我回來這裡啦，「他」「打」說在「河南路底」。                                │
│                                                                │戴：「河南路底」就「金拿獎」（香格里拉理容KTV改名前為金拿獎），我現在還在忙耶， │
│                                                                │看要不要先那個。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：好啦，不然就等一下再看看，他們過去一下子，我就回到，快回到這裡了，他們才在「│
│                                                                │打」。                                                                          │
│                                                                │戴：你們實在處理事情是這樣，好啦，喔。                                          │
│                                                                │廉：好，好。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│9.   2008/03/25  16:38:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         水利署壬○○  │廉：喂，喂。                                                                    │
│                                                                │葉：隆哥。                                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：副座。                                                                      │
│                                                                │葉：你幹嘛，你在哪裡。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：剛有人來辦公室，我先回來這邊，有人來這邊找我。                              │
│                                                                │葉：你跟你的「老董」報告，我們這1攤可以處理嗎。                                 │
│                                                                │廉：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │葉：在「那個」，啊。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │葉：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：你們3個嘛。                                                                 │
│                                                                │葉：你不在，啊。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：好啦，好啦。                                                                │
│                                                                │葉：我說我們這一攤可以處理嗎，跟他報告一下。                                    │
│                                                                │廉：好啦，好啦，我等一下，等一下跟…，好啦，我打電話。                          │
│                                                                │葉：可以嗎。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：我等一下，我等一下打電話給他。                                              │
│                                                                │葉：好。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：好好好。                                                                    │
│                                                                │葉：謝謝你。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│10.  2008/03/25  16:49:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中縣太平市○○路000巷00號7樓頂"                                              │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         香格里拉理容  │（通聯前，廉裕隆與旁人對話）                                                    │
│                                                  KTV陳秀月     │廉：沒有啦，我沒有要過去。                                                      │
│                                                                │（通聯後）                                                                      │
│                                                                │陳秀月：喂，阿隆。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：有人在你們那裡。                                                            │
│                                                                │陳：林榮紹。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：2個還是3個。                                                                │
│                                                                │陳：3個。                                                                       │
│                                                                │廉：3個。                                                                       │
│                                                                │陳：買單了，「7千1」。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：…。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：「7千1」，嗯。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：OK了嗎。                                                                    │
│                                                                │陳：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │廉：好啦，好啦。                                                                │
│                                                                │陳：好。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│11.  2008/03/25  17:17:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○○○○路○段000○0號16樓頂"                                    │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         水利署壬○○  │（林榮紹持用壬○○電話與廉裕隆通聯）                                            │
│                                                                │廉：「副座」，副座。                                                            │
│                                                                │林：喂，隆仔。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：有。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：「副座」現在在「楓」啦。                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：有那個嗎，「你舅舅」都不接他電話，這樣也不對啦。                            │
│                                                                │廉：沒有啦，沒有啦，放在充電啦，放在充電啦，我看放在那裡充電啦。                │
│                                                                │林：啊，進去可以嗎。                                                            │
│                                                                │廉：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：「楓」呀，「楓」進去可以嗎。                                                │
│                                                                │廉：嗯，有人在裡面啦。                                                          │
│                                                                │林：誰。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │林：誰，誰在裡面。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：你們，你們「連」，和「老闆」。                                              │
│                                                                │林：在裡面喔。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：嗯嗯嗯。                                                                    │
│                                                                │林：喔，好啦。                                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：喔，好。                                                                    │
│                                                                │林：好啦，我瞭解。                                                              │
└────────────────────────────────┴────────────────────────────────────────┘

┌────────────────────────────────┬────────────────────────────────────────┐
│編號 日期        時間      監聽電話       撥/接   對方電話      │通聯內容摘要                                                                備註│
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│1.   2008/04/08  13:23:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │（本減災工程監工徐崧清持用戴泱丞行動電話與徐玉玲通聯）                          │
│                           九龍理容KTV徐玉玲      第三河川局徐崧│徐玉玲：阿丞。                                                                  │
│                                                  清            │徐崧清：「仲麟」（指徐崧清自稱『仲麟』，徐崧清改名前為徐仲麟）啦。              │
│                                                                │徐玉玲：嗯。                                                                    │
│                                                                │徐崧清：你，你還在睡喔。                                                        │
│                                                                │徐玉玲：沒有啦，我起來了，怎麼。                                                │
│                                                                │徐崧清：你起來了喔，沒有啦，那個「主任」要去你那裡啦。                          │
│                                                                │徐玉玲：幾點。                                                                  │
│                                                                │徐崧清：差不多幾點喔，你先準備一下啦，我，可能等一下啦，等一下啦。              │
│                                                                │徐玉玲：好啦，你若要出發再打給我。                                              │
│                                                                │徐崧清：喔，好呀，好呀，好。                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│2.   2008/04/08  13:51:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路00號"                                                        │
│                           九龍理容KTV徐玉玲      陳玉瑛        │徐玉玲：喂，美女。                                                              │
│                                                                │陳玉瑛：喂，阿母。                                                              │
│                                                                │徐：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：昨天去你那裡玩得很開心。                                                    │
│                                                                │徐：開心就好呀。                                                                │
│                                                                │陳：…。                                                                        │
│                                                                │徐：沒有啦，沒有啦，其實我跟你講「大哥」根本就不會給我請好不好。                │
│                                                                │陳：我知道啦，我是說喔，給你這樣喝，給你這樣陪我們大家很不好意思。              │
│                                                                │徐：不會啦，因為昨天比較後來喔，客人都買單買好了，所以我也比較閒了。            │
│                                                                │陳：你很OK的，我跟你講喔，等一下我還要出去喔，不一定瘋瘋的還去你那裡喔。        │
│                                                                │徐：我跟你講，要來之前先打給我，因為喔。                                        │
│                                                                │陳：像昨天那樣對不對。                                                          │
│                                                                │徐：不是，不是，不是，因為剛剛「川順」喔，「阿脫普」他第2個兒子「戴泱丞」啦，和 │
│                                                                │「三」、他們公司的人現在在吃飯。                                                │
│                                                                │陳：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │徐：剛才「我弟弟」有打給我，說他們要來，會不會來，會不會來，他們在說有說要來啦，│
│                                                                │我說好，你確定要出發前打給我啦。                                                │
│                                                                │陳：嗯嗯嗯。                                                                    │
│                                                                │徐：嗯，我是怕說「大哥」不知道有沒有方便碰到啦。                                │
│                                                                │陳：這樣我跟你說好嗎。                                                          │
│                                                                │徐：不要緊，你再和「大哥」講看看。                                              │
│                                                                │陳：這樣我說給你聽喔。                                                          │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│3.   2008/04/08  14:18:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路00號"                                                        │
│                           九龍理容KTV徐玉玲      川順公司戴泱丞│徐：阿丞。                                                                      │
│                                                  彭壽奇        │戴泱丞：我們要過去了耶。                                                        │
│                                                                │徐：好，我也要出門了，你從哪裡出發。                                            │
│                                                                │（戴泱丞行動電話傳出彭壽奇談話）                                                │
│                                                                │彭：約3點啦，我們都3點。                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：約2、3點啦。                                                                │
│                                                                │（戴泱丞行動電話傳出彭壽奇談話）                                                │
│                                                                │彭：3點啦。                                                                     │
│                                                                │徐：好，好，好。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：你，「69」和「197」呀。                                                     │
│                                                                │徐：「69」、「197」喔。                                                         │
│                                                                │戴：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │徐：你，多久，你幾個人。                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：我們，5、6個啦。                                                            │
│                                                                │徐：好，好，好，好。                                                            │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│4.   2008/04/08  14:25:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路000○00號12F"                                                │
│                           九龍理容KTV徐玉玲      九龍理容KTV編 │交代九龍理容KTV編號197號小姐早點過來，客人找                                    │
│                                                  號197號小姐   │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│5.   2008/04/08  15:02:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂                                                │
│                           九龍理容KTV徐玉玲      陳玉瑛        │短訊：他們到了！                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│6.   2008/04/08  15:05:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○0路000號8 F頂"                                                 │
│                           九龍理容KTV徐玉玲      川順公司戴泱丞│戴泱丞：喂，喂。                                                                │
│                                                                │徐：他們到了喔。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：好，好。                                                                    │
│                                                                │徐：「131」。                                                                   │
│                                                                │戴：好。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│7.   2008/04/08  15:38:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           九龍理容KTV徐玉玲      陳玉瑛        │徐玉玲：喂。                                                                    │
│                                                                │陳玉瑛：喂。                                                                    │
│                                                                │徐：嗯，你講。                                                                  │
│                                                                │陳：我跟你講，我現在還在家裡，「大哥」早一點過來，他去看工地喔，大概還要再，應該│
│                                                                │1個鐘頭以內就會來載我了，到時候我們跟他講好，就說你有打給我，說你有打給我喔。   │
│                                                                │徐：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：你說誰在那裡。                                                              │
│                                                                │徐：「彭仔」啦。                                                                │
│                                                                │陳：「彭仔」。                                                                  │
│                                                                │徐：「彭壽奇」呀，跟他很好呀，跟他也很熟呀。                                    │
│                                                                │陳：我就跟他說那個「彭壽奇」還有「阿脫普」的兒子有沒有喔。                      │
│                                                                │徐：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：在那裡喔，我問看看他要不要過去這樣。                                        │
│                                                                │徐：還有跟「我弟弟」啦，這樣子啦，就是，都是，應該，我是覺得應該都是自己人啦。  │
│                                                                │陳：被看到會不會亂講話。                                                        │
│                                                                │徐：不會啦，你放心啦，他是，其實他在辦公室也是滿低調的啦，你放心啦，他很知道利害│
│                                                                │關係啦。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：好，這樣，我跟你講，這樣我會跟他講。                                        │
│                                                                │徐：你問看看他的意思啦。                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：我知道，我知道。                                                            │
│                                                                │徐：不勉強啦，不要勉強他啦。                                                    │
│                                                                │陳：怎麼樣我再打給你。                                                          │
│                                                                │徐：好，OK。                                                                    │
│                                                                │陳：好。                                                                        │
└────────────────────────────────┴────────────────────────────────────────┘

┌────────────────────────────────┬────────────────────────────────────────┐
│編號 日期        時間      監聽電話       撥/接   對方電話      │通聯內容摘要                                                                備註│
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│1.   2008/01/07  09:43:00  0000000000             0000000000    │戴沼銘：喂。                                                                    │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤  撥     川順營造戴沼銘│戴沼澤：沼銘，那個叫做「箱型」、「箱型籠」喔。                                  │
│                                                                │戴沼銘：嘿。                                                                    │
│                                                                │戴沼澤：「箱型籠」實際跟他們2間拿，拿多少？                                     │
│                                                                │戴沼銘：那個，那個…什麼，那個「信亮」3萬米嘛，啊，總共是8萬、84280米嘛!        │
│                                                                │戴沼澤：8萬4千喔？                                                              │
│                                                                │戴沼銘：嘿。                                                                    │
│                                                                │戴沼澤：喔，好啦。                                                              │
│                                                                │戴沼銘：黑阿，阿我們，阿總共不足那個，現在就要叫「治水」補1萬，11700米出來。    │
│                                                                │戴沼澤：不足！                                                                  │
│                                                                │戴沼銘：嘿，數量不足要叫他補出來，要叫他開發票，不知道要開嗎？！                │
│                                                                │戴沼澤：阿…不足！                                                              │
│                                                                │戴沼銘：叫他開11700米的數量出來。                                               │
│                                                                │戴沼澤：喔，那不要緊啦，那不要緊啦，不會啦，不會啦，那不會啦。                  │
│                                                                │戴沼銘：要開嗎？                                                                │
│                                                                │戴沼澤：要啦。沒有啦，那不要緊啦，那我們調的問題而已啦。                        │
│                                                                │戴沼銘：不用開不要緊喔。                                                        │
│                                                                │戴沼澤：那調的問題，那跟那個沒關係啦，黑呀。                                    │
│                                                                │戴沼銘：喔，好呀。                                                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│2.   2008/01/07  09:45:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │鄭年雅：喂。                                                                    │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         川順營造鄭年雅│戴：你，那款的，「治水的」喔，「治水的」部分，叫那個「箱型籠」可能要多開的樣子，│
│                                                                │阿若沒有，數量要多開啦。                                                        │
│                                                                │鄭：數量要多開喔？                                                              │
│                                                                │戴：黑啦，你若，不然你就減少、減少金額，用數量也可以，還是、還是用，他若可以、可│
│                                                                │以開，看他們的報表，他們的稅金要怎麼算，就儘量方便開11000米啦。                 │
│                                                                │鄭：現在算要多…多11000米就對了。                                               │
│                                                                │戴：的金額，黑啦，阿他的看他的用要怎麼算，他的會用稅金要怎麼算啦。              │
│                                                                │鄭：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：黑啦。                                                                      │
│                                                                │鄭：喔！好，好。                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│3.   2008/01/07  10:49:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │短訊：請告知董事長他要多開立治水發票８１元＊５﹒２＊１１０００數量４６3萬發票電 │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         治水公司股東  │話中他不方便講稅額幾﹪李國忠甀                                                  │
│                                                  李國忠        │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│4.   2008/01/08  11:54:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │川順營造紀俊富：喂。                                                            │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         川順營造紀駿富│戴：小紀，你在天祥街嗎。                                                        │
│                                                                │紀：黑呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：那時候怎麼估的數量和、和「世曦」的怎麼不合，那個「蛇籠」的部分是怎樣？      │
│                                                                │紀：「蛇籠」的部分？                                                            │
│                                                                │戴：黑，不是都我們估給他的嗎？                                                  │
│                                                                │紀：對呀。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：阿起先怎麼說是9萬，9萬9，現在我們變9萬5嘛厚？                               │
│                                                                │紀：沒有啦，阿你還有的扣掉的呀，那是第1次變更的數量，那是變更的數量，阿但是我們 │
│                                                                │現在有的變更那時沒做，還是什麼，那都要扣掉呀。                                  │
│                                                                │戴：喔，算有的，有的沒做到的部分。                                              │
│                                                                │紀：對對對，黑呀，黑呀。黑。                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：喔，啊，現在他們那些要快、快、快，他們說那些變更的都還沒出來呀。            │
│                                                                │紀：對呀，阿他們今日，應該今日他們會送出去啦，我早上有跟「張技師」講電話了。    │
│                                                                │戴：對，應該不用弄那個，看怎麼樣喔。                                            │
│                                                                │紀：黑。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：要照我們，我們現在做1份就好了喔。                                           │
│                                                                │紀：黑。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：要快過去遵行共同的，同樣的那個…                                            │
│                                                                │紀：對呀，對呀。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：不然他那麼多他繳不出來啦。                                                  │
│                                                                │紀：黑阿，啊我們現在就是我們資料都給他們了呀，啊他們現在就是就我們的就送出去這樣│
│                                                                │呀。                                                                            │
│                                                                │戴：黑啦！                                                                      │
│                                                                │紀：黑。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：啊我們的就是現場的喔，還1個現有的要要驗收的喔。                             │
│                                                                │紀：對，對。                                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：要對…對喔好啦！                                                            │
│                                                                │紀：嘿嘿…有阿！                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：對好才有辦法驗收啦！                                                        │
│                                                                │紀：黑呀，黑呀。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：現有的東西，數字歸數字，在裡面攪在裡面算呀。                                │
│                                                                │紀：嘿，對呀。                                                                  │
│                                                                │戴：現有的部分就是要分，我跟你講就是說，現有部分，厚！未修復的部分喔。          │
│                                                                │紀：黑。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：阿那個…，這個就是日後驗收的依據阿。                                        │
│                                                                │紀：對呀，黑呀，那圖，圖上我們都有標示出來了。                                  │
│                                                                │戴：黑呀，喔。                                                                  │
│                                                                │紀：黑呀，黑呀。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：好，不然這個趕快給他處理處理，看怎麼樣再趕一下。                            │
│                                                                │紀：好…嘿嘿，好，好。                                                          │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│5.   2008/01/11  20:47:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │李：喂，董仔。                                                                  │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         治水公司股東  │戴：你現在在哪裡？                                                              │
│                                                  李國忠        │李：我那個，在那個～，烏日。                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：在烏日做什麼，明天要選舉，你有要回去選嗎？                                  │
│                                                                │李：要呀，要回去呀。                                                            │
│                                                                │戴：啊…。你那個，對不對？                                                      │
│                                                                │李：嘿，要回去選舉呀。哈哈…                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：你們那個「治水」都沒消沒息，是到底要做什麼，不然也回我一下說不要還是要，這樣│
│                                                                │就好了。                                                                        │
│                                                                │李：我，這個問題厚我沒參與哩，我也沒問內，要問「長腳」的耶。                    │
│                                                                │戴：要跟不要，這樣就好呀，對不對？你沒參與要叫誰參與？                          │
│                                                                │李：我回去我再問他看看，好不好？                                                │
│                                                                │戴：要跟不要，這樣就好了嘛！                                                    │
│                                                                │李：黑啦，我明天回去再問他看看啦！                                              │
│                                                                │戴：對呀，不要也不要緊呀，我也沒有…。                                          │
│                                                                │李：我知道，我知道，我知道，嘿！我回去，我明天回去再問他看看，好不好？阿你有要回│
│                                                                │來選嗎？                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：嘿，阿我又沒有麻將可以打，我就不大想回去了。                                │
│                                                                │李：這樣喔！明天選舉可能比較沒空啦！喔？                                        │
│                                                                │戴：選舉哪有什麼沒空，選舉就蓋一下就閒閒了，哪有什麼沒空！                      │
│                                                                │李：呦！我是，明天應該是晚一點才會回去，我明天一些事情弄一弄。                  │
│                                                                │戴：恩，好啦。                                                                  │
│                                                                │李：黑呀。厚！                                                                  │
│                                                                │戴：好啦。好啦。                                                                │
│                                                                │李：好好…。                                                                    │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│6.   2008/01/14  11:47:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │治水公司李國忠：喂，董仔。                                                      │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         治水公司股東  │戴：在哪裡？                                                                    │
│                                                  李國忠        │李：沒有，我…還在弄發票耶。                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：哼！就叫他換一換就好了。                                                    │
│                                                                │李：沒有，我要趕快拿上來給你們呀，不然那個要申報呀。                            │
│                                                                │戴：對呀，阿你那些就是快拿過來恩！                                              │
│                                                                │李：嘿！我要下午了啦。                                                          │
│                                                                │戴：阿，你現在在哪裡？                                                          │
│                                                                │李：沒有啦，我…還在那個阿，在大甲。                                            │
│                                                                │戴：喔～沒有，我是這個…阿做「級配」哩啦！                                      │
│                                                                │李：喔，碎石級配那個喔？                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：黑阿！                                                                      │
│                                                                │李：不要緊啦，你看3輛算起來看多少呀，沒有差呀，黑呀！                           │
│                                                                │戴：沒有啦，我現在是車子的部分啦喔，阿你的工的部分啦，阿我預定要1米算起來剛好差 │
│                                                                │多少這樣呀喔，總是要有1個…，也要有1個標準呀，不能說要…你…那邊也要…，要有機械│
│                                                                │啦，要有那些東西。                                                              │
│                                                                │李：嘿。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：我跟你解釋一下啦。                                                          │
│                                                                │李：喔，好啦，好，不要緊，好…。謝謝。                                          │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│7.   2008/01/14  19:26:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │治水公司李國忠：董仔。                                                          │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         治水公司股東  │戴：你明天就9點到「天祥街」，我就算到給你滿意啦。                               │
│                                                  李國忠        │李：哪，哪裡的？                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：之前的級配我絕對算到給你滿意，太好康也沒有啦，阿但是一定你會滿意啦！        │
│                                                                │李：沒有啦，董仔，沒有啦，我中午有過去啦，我本來是要跟你問問那個，那個哪裡，那個│
│                                                                │發票的事情啦，阿到底要多少數量啦。呵呵…                                        │
│                                                                │戴：不是啦，我跟你講，你的發票先解決，我的過完年再來解決也不要緊啦。            │
│                                                                │李：嘿嘿…。                                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：喔？                                                                        │
│                                                                │李：好啦，不要緊啦。黑阿，喔！                                                  │
│                                                                │戴：阿你的，之前級配你就來「天祥街」找我，跟你算到給你感覺阿，對故鄉實在有夠…  │
│                                                                │李：不會啦，董仔，我知道啦，你的人不錯啦！                                      │
│                                                                │戴：阿你們那些知道我心裡在想什麼嗎？                                            │
│                                                                │李：他們沒有這樣想，我不知道內。                                                │
│                                                                │戴：反正他們大家好像我整盤要端走一樣耶，你們若…，不好看啦，我若退掉，一樣不好看│
│                                                                │啦，不然你，4、50萬給我就好了，我就退退掉了。                                   │
│                                                                │李：黑，不會啦，不要緊，明天來再講好不好？喔？                                  │
│                                                                │戴：好呀…，對否，都沒跟我說這些事情，我要，你們要吃我還是要給我吃這樣啦。      │
│                                                                │李：嘿…。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：啊，留的人一定有飯吃啦。                                                    │
│                                                                │李：嘿嘿，對啦，黑呀。                                                          │
│                                                                │戴：喔？                                                                        │
│                                                                │李：好…。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：喔！                                                                        │
│                                                                │李：好！謝謝！好…。                                                            │
│                                                                │戴：喔！                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│8.   2008/01/17  09:26:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │李：喂，董仔。                                                                  │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         治水公司股東  │戴：阿跑去哪裡？                                                                │
│                                                  李國忠        │李：沒有阿，我等一下要過來找「林壽昌」（音譯）。                                │
│                                                                │戴：等一下要過去，喔！                                                          │
│                                                                │李：嘿，有跟他約時間啦。阿對啦，董仔，我，我那本來要拿過去給你，我下禮拜我再拿過│
│                                                                │去好嗎？我這幾天有事情把它，把這邊公司一些事情處理。                            │
│                                                                │戴：什麼東西？                                                                  │
│                                                                │李：發票啦！                                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：喔，喔，不要緊啦。那個不…                                                  │
│                                                                │李：我下禮拜拿過去，阿再那個，禮拜天喔，禮拜天中午說要吃尾牙啦，要在那個以前有沒│
│                                                                │有「銀銅」他們舊家那裡啦！                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：舊家？                                                                      │
│                                                                │李：黑呀，在「長腳」再進去那裡有沒有？                                          │
│                                                                │戴：喔喔喔。                                                                    │
│                                                                │李：喔之前你去1次那裡，禮拜天，要禮拜天中午啦。                                 │
│                                                                │戴：阿在那裡叫人家辦喔？                                                        │
│                                                                │李：黑呀，他說要在那裡，要叫人家辦，算…要順便跟他老爸做生日啦。                │
│                                                                │戴：喔！是喔！                                                                  │
│                                                                │李：呵呵呵…黑阿！禮拜天中午啦！                                                │
│                                                                │戴：這樣喔？！                                                                  │
│                                                                │李：黑阿！                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：恩…我以為說，要去，我是要，我今天是要去大甲啦。                            │
│                                                                │李：嘿嘿嘿。                                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：這樣啦。                                                                    │
│                                                                │李：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：阿我才在問說，你們上次那事情喔。                                            │
│                                                                │李：黑。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：看看月底、年底，快快橋會議，大家講喔一講看行不行！                          │
│                                                                │李：黑！對啦！這是要會議一下，我這陣子就在給它追這些帳，要先把它追回來，追回來要│
│                                                                │做一次統計咩！統計起來我再看庫存多少！我就知道他們一年度做多少，賺多少了啦！    │
│                                                                │戴：對呀！現在多少沒多少另外一個喔，一個大原則跟這款的是一個細部啦！            │
│                                                                │李：嘿嘿。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：大原則就是說，你們如果有打算大家有一個，開個會有一個共識，這再另外這款的喔，│
│                                                                │下去橋喔。                                                                      │
│                                                                │李：黑。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：阿共識以後喔，看是要改，不要改，還是說要回復原狀，照原狀走，阿原狀走有的要、│
│                                                                │不要喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │李：黑。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：做一個解決這樣喔！                                                          │
│                                                                │李：哇災！哇災！黑。                                                            │
│                                                                │戴：要縮小還是要擴大！喔！                                                      │
│                                                                │李：嘿嘿…。                                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：阿阿，還是要維持現狀，還是要怎樣，這樣才，才有一個原則啦！                  │
│                                                                │李：黑。好…                                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：喔？                                                                        │
│                                                                │李：好阿！                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：…方向而已嘛！（聲音重疊不清楚）                                            │
│                                                                │李：好…我跟他們講一下。                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：黑啦！                                                                      │
│                                                                │李：叫他們大家開會一下。討，做一個討論。                                        │
│                                                                │戴：要縮小，還是要擴大！喔！                                                    │
│                                                                │李：嘿嘿。好…                                                                  │
│                                                                │戴：黑啦！喔。                                                                  │
│                                                                │李：好…。                                                                      │
└────────────────────────────────┴────────────────────────────────────────┘

┌────────────────────────────────┬────────────────────────────────────────┐
│編號 日期        時間      監聽電話       撥/接   對方電話      │通聯內容摘要                                                                備註│
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│1.   2008/01/14  11:14:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○路○段000巷00號16F屋頂"                                        │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         水利署科長林榮│戴沼澤邀林榮紹過來「天祥街」                                                    │
│                                                  紹            │                                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│2.   2008/01/14  11:26:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"未提供"                                                                        │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         第三河川局彭壽│第三河川局彭壽奇：喂。                                                          │
│                                                  奇            │戴：喂，彭主任喔。                                                              │
│                                                                │彭：嗯，怎麼樣。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：我董仔。                                                                    │
│                                                                │彭：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：嗯，在哪裡。                                                                │
│                                                                │彭：我在辦公廳。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：喔，啊，要進去「工地」嗎。                                                  │
│                                                                │彭：工地，好呀。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：還是，還是，不然到「天祥街」來啦，我一些事情跟你跟你研究看看一下，看可行性否│
│                                                                │。                                                                              │
│                                                                │彭：喔，這樣要工地好了，來工地。                                                │
│                                                                │戴：要工地喔。                                                                  │
│                                                                │彭：嗯，嗯。                                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：不過等林榮紹，我順便要給他、給他、給他、給他、給他、跟他撟一下，撟一下，撟一│
│                                                                │下我們這個角度。                                                                │
│                                                                │彭：好呀，好呀，好呀，看怎麼樣，約幾點。                                        │
│                                                                │戴：…這樣，不然我們來吃飯一下，不然來「野店」吃啦。                            │
│                                                                │彭：好，好，好。                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│3.   2008/01/14  11:27:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○路○段000巷00號16F屋頂"                                        │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         水利署科長林榮│林：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                  紹            │戴：中午我有叫「彭壽奇」來「野店」啦。                                          │
│                                                                │林：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：來「野店」啦。                                                              │
│                                                                │林：喔，我知，嗯。                                                              │
│                                                                │戴：嗯，出來沒，出來了嗎。                                                      │
│                                                                │林：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：出來，好，好。                                                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│4.   2008/01/14  11:27:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號 1F"                                                │
│                           水利署科長林榮         川順營造戴沼澤│林：喂。                                                                        │
│                           紹                                   │戴：中午我有叫「彭壽奇」來「野店」啦。                                          │
│                                                                │林：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：來「野店」啦。                                                              │
│                                                                │林：喔，我知，嗯。                                                              │
│                                                                │戴：嗯，出來沒，出來了嗎。                                                      │
│                                                                │林：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：出來，好，好。                                                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│5.   2008/01/14  11:29:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"台中市○○區○○路○段000巷00號16F屋頂"                                        │
│                           川順營造戴沼澤         川順營造戴泱丞│川順營造頭汴坑工務所女職員：喂，川順，喂。                                      │
│                                                                │戴沼澤：喂。                                                                    │
│                                                                │女：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴沼澤：「副總」有在那裡嗎。                                                    │
│                                                                │ 女：喔，等一下喔，「副總」電話喔。                                             │
│                                                                │戴泱丞：喂。                                                                    │
│                                                                │戴沼澤：你把那張圖喔，那張我說現在要、要，用那個、那個、那個「鋼柵」那個部分那段│
│                                                                │的那圖喔，看要拿過來給我還是怎麼，我叫「彭壽奇」往這裡過來，我跟他們研究看看。  │
│                                                                │戴泱丞：好呀，好。                                                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│6.   2008/01/14  19:31:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○0路000號8 F頂"                                                 │
│                           九龍理容KTV張淑惠      川順營造廉裕隆│張淑惠：喂。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：很怕被你處理。                                                              │
│                                                                │張：你要回去了，對不對。                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：嗯，我要趕快回去。                                                          │
│                                                                │張：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │廉：我很怕被你處理，我要趕快回去。                                              │
│                                                                │張：好呀，回去呀。「忠哥」他們來，和「彭大哥」啦。                              │
│                                                                │廉：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：「忠哥」來啦。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：又過去了。                                                                  │
│                                                                │張：對呀，他說不能跟任何人說他來。                                              │
│                                                                │廉：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：他說不能跟任何人說他來。                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：啊，我不是人。                                                              │
│                                                                │張：你又不會跟他講，跟我也沒有關係。                                            │
│                                                                │廉：他自己，還是。                                                              │
│                                                                │張：跟「彭大哥」，姓「彭的」。                                                  │
│                                                                │廉：我知道，我知道，嗯，嗯，又在追了。                                          │
│                                                                │張：對呀。啊，人家9點要下班說，你要回去了，要好好跟你處理說。人家今天9點就下班說│
│                                                                │。                                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：不早一點講。                                                                │
│                                                                │張：你要回家了。                                                                │
│                                                                │廉：不早一點講。                                                                │
│                                                                │張：我要怎麼跟你講，叫你…，下班就下班了呀，我想說你去那裡最少坐2個鐘頭，…。   │
│                                                                │廉：晚上10點還要來說。                                                          │
│                                                                │張：要豬屎。人家9點下班說，我想說你去那裡最少坐2個鐘頭，我要跟你講，我說你今天最│
│                                                                │好喝醉，…來看看。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：我下午我就不要去，我知道他們一定，整群一定又跑去，我才問你說是不是去「你們那│
│                                                                │裡」，我想說會去你們那裡。                                                      │
│                                                                │張：他現在和「彭大哥」2個進來呀，說不能和任何人說他來呀。                       │
│                                                                │廉：嗯，又在追了呀。                                                            │
│                                                                │張：你開到哪裡了。                                                              │
│                                                                │廉：我載我們「董仔」回來了。                                                    │
│                                                                │張：公司喔。                                                                    │
│                                                                │廉：公司。                                                                      │
│                                                                │張：這樣我要去追酒了。                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：你不要再追了。                                                              │
│                                                                │張：不要，我這時間本來就想追酒…，好啦，你回家啦，我要去追酒了。                │
│                                                                │廉：好啦。                                                                      │
│                                                                │張：好啦，好啦，知道了，BYEBYE。                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│7.   2008/01/14  19:38:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○0路000號8 F頂"                                                 │
│                           九龍理容KTV徐玉玲      川順營造戴泱丞│戴泱丞：喂。                                                                    │
│                                                                │徐：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │徐：親愛的。                                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：親愛的，怎麼樣。                                                            │
│                                                                │徐：那個。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴：…我有收到呀。                                                              │
│                                                                │徐：我知道啦。那個誰找你啦，那個「澎湖來的朋友」啦，「澎湖來的朋友」找你。      │
│                                                                │戴：啊，他跟我們裡面的人去嗎。                                                  │
│                                                                │徐：嗯，他跟「忠哥」。                                                          │
│                                                                │戴：嗯，好呀，啊，我們「老仔」，「那個」走了。                                  │
│                                                                │徐：沒有來。                                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：喔，這樣喔。                                                                │
│                                                                │徐：對。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：好啦。                                                                      │
│                                                                │徐：只有他們2個。                                                               │
│                                                                │戴：好啦，好啦。                                                                │
│                                                                │徐：「澎湖來的朋友」這樣知道啦喔。                                              │
│                                                                │戴：好，好啦，好啦。                                                            │
│                                                                │徐：喔，喔，好，好，好。                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：好。                                                                        │
│                                                                │徐：「他」叫我跟你打的啦喔。                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：好啦，好啦。                                                                │
│                                                                │徐：好，BYEBYE。                                                                │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│8.   2008/01/14  20:10:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○0路000號8 F頂"                                                 │
│                           九龍理容KTV徐玉玲      川順營造戴泱丞│徐：哈囉。                                                                      │
│                                                                │戴泱丞：你1張開初1還是初2的，啊。                                               │
│                                                                │徐：你說什麼。                                                                  │
│                                                                │戴：有1張開初1還是初2的啦。                                                     │
│                                                                │徐：喔，不要緊，不然你走出來好不好。                                            │
│                                                                │戴：好啦。                                                                      │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│9.   2008/01/14  20:35:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○0路000號8 F頂"                                                 │
│                           九龍理容KTV徐玉玲      營造公司張啟晃│（彭壽奇持用徐玉玲行動電話與張啟晃通聯）                                        │
│                           第三河川局彭壽奇                     │營造公司張啟晃：喂。                                                            │
│                                                                │徐玉玲：胖嘟嘟。                                                                │
│                                                                │張：胖嘟嘟，在減肥了啦。                                                        │
│                                                                │徐：減肥，早就該減了，肚子那麼大，能看嗎。                                      │
│                                                                │張：快生了啦。                                                                  │
│                                                                │徐：明天有要給「楓之林」請尾牙嗎。                                              │
│                                                                │張：明天喔，明天我在新竹吃尾牙耶。                                              │
│                                                                │徐：這樣禮拜4來給我請喔。                                                       │
│                                                                │張：我一定去你那裡。                                                            │
│                                                                │徐：因為有1個「澎湖來的朋友」，我有跟他講，他說好。                             │
│                                                                │張：有遇到我「澎湖的朋友」嗎。                                                  │
│                                                                │徐：有呀，他現在在我旁邊呀。                                                    │
│                                                                │張：好。                                                                        │
│                                                                │徐：你等一下，我叫他跟你講，你等一下喔。                                        │
│                                                                │張：好。                                                                        │
│                                                                │（徐玉玲將電話交予彭壽奇，徐玉玲背景有KTV音樂）                                 │
│                                                                │彭：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │張：大仔，你不要殺了我。                                                        │
│                                                                │彭：你不來我要殺了你。                                                          │
│                                                                │張：我一定去，我一定去。                                                        │
│                                                                │彭：嗯，17號。                                                                  │
│                                                                │張：17號。                                                                      │
│                                                                │彭：好好好，你要來載我。                                                        │
│                                                                │張：我會挺著大肚子去啦。                                                        │
│                                                                │彭：挺著大肚子，為什麼。                                                        │
│                                                                │張：「秀秀」講的，我肚子愈來愈大，好。                                          │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│10.  2008/01/14  20:59:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○0路000號8 F頂"                                                 │
│                           九龍理容KTV徐玉玲                    │聯繫「103」包廂事宜                                                             │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│11.  2008/01/14  21:13:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │臺中市○○區○○0路000號8 F頂                                                   │
│                           九龍理容KTV徐玉玲                    │短訊：妳有吃飯嗎？請妳吃火錀                                                    │
└────────────────────────────────┴────────────────────────────────────────┘
┌────────────────────────────────┬────────────────────────────────────────┐
│編號 日期        時間      監聽電話       撥/接   對方電話      │通聯內容摘要                                                                備註│
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│1.   2007/10/01  13:07:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺北縣新店市○○路0000000號10樓頂"                                             │
│                           局長戊○○             女友戴美玲    │女友戴美玲約戊○○外出，戊○○結束立法院開會返台中                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│2.   2007/10/01  14:07:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"苗栗縣後龍鎮○○○○○路000巷0號10樓頂"                                        │
│                           局長戊○○             女友戴美玲    │戴：你差不多幾點會到台中。                                                      │
│                                                                │許：差不多40分鐘至50分鐘。                                                      │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│3.   2007/10/01  14:32:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中縣外埔鄉○○○段00000地號"                                                 │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │向女友表示明天看完工地後，3、4點再過去                                          │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│4.   2007/10/01  15:01:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段00號17樓頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○             女友戴美玲    │戊○○向女友表示再5分鐘到女友住處                                               │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│5.   2007/10/01  15:15:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中縣東勢鎮○○○○○路000○0號"                                              │
│                           川順營造廉裕隆         科長林榮紹    │林榮紹：隆仔，怎麼樣？                                                          │
│                                                                │廉：我回來到新社了。                                                            │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│6.   2007/10/01  16:14:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號19樓頂"                                             │
│                           局長戊○○                           │某男表示等戊○○有空時過去找戊○○                                              │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│7.   2007/10/01  16:59:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○                           │無人接聽                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│8.   2007/10/01  17:00:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號2樓頂"                                              │
│                           九龍理容KTV戴美玲      戴美玲之子    │（九龍理容KTV戴美玲持用戊○○手機打給小孩，戴美玲背景有KTV歌唱聲、女子嘻鬧聲）  │
│                                                                │戴：喂，你到家了嗎。                                                            │
│                                                                │子：喂，媽媽。                                                                  │
│                                                                │戴：你到家了。                                                                  │
│                                                                │子：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：奶奶有幫你用東西嗎。                                                        │
│                                                                │子：還沒回來。                                                                  │
│                                                                │戴：是喔，好啦，我用那個。                                                      │
│                                                                │子：喂，媽媽你在哪裡。                                                          │
│                                                                │戴：我現在在公司。                                                              │
│                                                                │子：喔，媽，這是誰電話。                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：這是「局長」呀。                                                            │
│                                                                │子：喔，媽你什麼時候會回來。                                                    │
│                                                                │戴：我現在跟他們在唱歌，在錢櫃唱歌。                                            │
│                                                                │子：那你什麼時候會回來。                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：媽媽今天有工作呀。                                                          │
│                                                                │子：媽，你不要喝酒喔。                                                          │
│                                                                │戴：我不是有留紙條給你。                                                        │
│                                                                │子：對啊，我有看到，媽，你不要喝酒喔。                                          │
│                                                                │戴：好。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│9.   2007/10/01  17:47:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路00號5F"                                                      │
│                           局長戊○○             九龍理容KTV徐 │徐：嗯，大哥。                                                                  │
│                                                  玉玲          │許：那個，我出來了，你幫我處理好。                                              │
│                                                                │徐：你走出去了喔。                                                              │
│                                                                │許：嗯嗯嗯。                                                                    │
│                                                                │徐：你已經離開了喔。                                                            │
│                                                                │許：是，嗯。                                                                    │
│                                                                │徐：啊，你現在呢，他的部分是。                                                  │
│                                                                │許：整個，整個，21人，21人。                                                    │
│                                                                │徐：放著就對了嗎？                                                              │
│                                                                │許：沒有，我有跟那個講了，跟「劉仔」講了。                                      │
│                                                                │徐：我瞭解，OK，好好好。                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│10.  2007/10/01  19:11:00  0000000000      撥     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號5樓頂"                                              │
│                           九龍理容KTV戴美玲      戴美玲之子    │（戴美玲持用戊○○行動電話與小孩通聯）                                          │
│                                                                │子：喂。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴美玲：寶貝，你在幹嘛。                                                        │
│                                                                │子：媽媽，我在吃水果。                                                          │
│                                                                │戴：啊。                                                                        │
│                                                                │子：我在吃水果。                                                                │
│                                                                │戴：你在吃水果喔，是喔。                                                        │
│                                                                │子：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：啊，阿嬤有幫你用。                                                          │
│                                                                │子：有。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：阿嬤有沒有很龜毛，沒有吧。                                                  │
│                                                                │子：不會，他要回來了。                                                          │
│                                                                │戴：好。                                                                        │
│                                                                │子：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：有用那個呀，我現在吃飯，用那個「局長老大」電話。                            │
│                                                                │子：那你怎麼沒有帶手機。                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：我手機在「公司」。                                                          │
│                                                                │子：喔。                                                                        │
│                                                                │戴：好啦，好，BYEBYE，好，BYEBYE。                                              │
│                                                                │子：BYEBYE。                                                                    │
└────────────────────────────────┴────────────────────────────────────────┘

┌────────────────────────────────┬────────────────────────────────────────┐
│編號 日期        時間      監聽電話       撥/接   對方電話      │通聯內容摘要                                                                備註│
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│1.   2007/11/26  14:38:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○區○○路0段000○0號5樓頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○             水利署河川勘測│水利署河川勘測隊周世傑：他們在「第九」。                                        │
│                                                  隊周世傑      │許：嗯。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│2.   2007/11/26  15:43:00  0000000000      接     0000000000    │"臺中市○○區○○路○段000號14F頂"                                              │
│                           局長戊○○             水利署河川勘測│（水利署河川勘測隊周世傑持用九龍理容KTV羅秀雲行動電話與戊○○通聯）             │
│                                                  隊周世傑      │周：「頭仔」。                                                                  │
│                                                                │許：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │周：你知道喔。                                                                  │
│                                                                │許：嗯，我知道。                                                                │
│                                                                │周：好。                                                                        │
│                                                                │許：晚一點，我晚一點，還在辦事情。                                              │
│                                                                │周：好。                                                                        │
├────────────────────────────────┼────────────────────────────────────────┤
│3.   2007/11/26  16:58:00  0000000000       接    0000000000    │陳：有聽到嗎。                                                                  │
│                           局長戊○○             女友陳玉瑛    │許：有。你怎麼樣。                                                              │
│                                                                │陳：我知道，聽你聲音知道你人在外面了，                                          │
│                                                                │許：嗯，對，對，對。                                                            │
│                                                                │陳：我知道了。                                                                  │
│                                                                │許：嗯。                                                                        │
│                                                                │陳：在「阿九」的樣子喔。                                                        │
│                                                                │許：什麼。                                                                      │
│                                                                │陳：在「阿九」喔。                                                              │
│                                                                │許：在「阿九」。                                                                │
│                                                                │陳：在「阿九」喔。                                                              │
│                                                                │許：嗯，沒有錯。                                                                │
│                                                                │陳：好，OK，好啦，不講了喔，好，BYEBYE。                                        │
└────────────────────────────────┴────────────────────────────────────────┘